Coronado Global Resources Inc. 10-K, filed Feb 21, 2023: EX-96.2
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves for the
Buchanan Mine Complex in Accordance with
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K 1300 as of December 31, 2022
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
February 2023
Prepared for:
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
100 Bill Baker Way
Beckley, West Virginia 25801
Prepared by:
MARSHALL MILLER & ASSOCIATES, INC.
582 Industrial Park Road
Bluefield, Virginia 24605
www.mma1.com
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
2
Statement of Use and Preparation
This Technical Report Summary (
TRS
) was prepared by
Marshall Miller & Associates, Inc.
(
MM&A
)
Coronado Global Resources Inc. (
Coronado
)
and its affiliated
and subsidiary companies and advisors. Copies or references to information in this report
may not be used without the written permission of Coronado.
This report provides a statement of coal resources and coal reserves for Coronado, as
defined under the
Australasian Code for Reporting of Exploration Results, Mineral
Resources and Ore Reserves
(
JORC Code
) as well as under Subpart 1300 of Regulation S-K
(Regulation S-K 1300) promulgated by
the
United States Securities and Exchange Commission
(
SEC
)
.
Australasian Code for Public Reporting of Technical Assessments and Valuations of
Mineral Assets
(
VALMIN Code
).
The statement is based on information provided by Coronado and reviewed by
Qualified
Persons
QPs
) who are full-time employees of MM&A.
As noted above, this report is a “Public Report” for the purposes of the VALMIN Code.
However, in accordance with paragraph 12.1 of the VALMIN Code, it is noted that this
report is not a “Valuation of Mineral Assets” and it also does not comply with the following
requirements that apply to “Technical Assessments” (as defined in the VALMIN Code):
This report does not include a determination of the status of tenure (as required by
paragraph 7.2 of the VALMIN Code) on the basis that tenure was separately reviewed by
Coronado’s legal advisors.
This report does not include separate commentary on the reasonableness and quality of the
Resources and Reserves estimates and the basis on which they have been reported (as
required by paragraph 7.3 of the VALMIN Code). MM&A did not consider that this was
appropriate in circumstances where MM&A was engaged for the specific purpose of
preparing those estimates. However, MM&A notes that, in accordance with its usual
practice, a separate team of MM&A employees undertook a peer review of this report and
confirmed that both the process followed by the authors of this report and the estimates
prepared were reasonable and comply with the requirements of the JORC Code.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
3
The information in this TRS related to coal resources and reserves is based on, and fairly
represents, information compiled by the QPs. At the time of reporting, MM&A’s QPs have
sufficient experience relevant to the style of mineralization and type of deposit under
consideration and to the activity they are undertaking to qualify as a QP as defined by
Regulation S-K 1300 and the JORC Code. Each QP consents to the inclusion in this report of
the matters based on their information in the form and context in which it appears.
Marshall Miller & Associates, Inc. (
MM&A
)
contained in this report dated December 31, 2022, relating to estimates of coal resources
and coal reserves controlled by Coronado.
Qualified Person:
/s/ Marshall Miller & Associates, Inc.
Date:
February 15, 2023
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
4
Table of Contents
1
Executive Summary ................................................................ ................................ ................1
1.1
Property Description ......................................................................................................... 1
1.2
Ownership ......................................................................................................................... 2
1.3
Geology .............................................................................................................................. 2
1.4
Exploration Status ............................................................................................................. 2
1.5
Operations and Development ........................................................................................... 3
1.6
Mineral Resource .............................................................................................................. 3
1.7
Mineral Reserve ................................................................................................................ 3
1.8
Capital Summary ............................................................................................................... 4
1.9
Operating Costs ................................................................................................................. 5
1.10
Economic Evaluation ......................................................................................................... 6
1.10.1
Discounted Cash Flow Analysis ........................................................................... 8
1.10.2
Sensitivity Analysis .............................................................................................. 9
1.11
Permitting .......................................................................................................................... 9
1.12
Conclusion and Recommendations ................................................................................... 9
2
Introduction ................................ ................................ ................................ ......................... 10
2.1
Registrant and Terms of Reference ................................................................................. 10
2.2
Information Sources ........................................................................................................ 10
2.3
Personal Inspections ....................................................................................................... 11
3
Property Description ................................ ................................ ................................ ............ 12
3.1
Location ........................................................................................................................... 12
3.2
Titles, Claims or Leases .................................................................................................... 12
3.3
Mineral Rights ................................................................................................................. 12
3.4
Encumbrances ................................................................................................................. 13
3.5
Other Risks....................................................................................................................... 13
4
Accessibility, Climate, Local Resources, Infrastructure and Physiography .............................. 13
4.1
Topography, Elevation, and Vegetation .......................................................................... 13
4.2
Access and Transport ...................................................................................................... 13
4.3
Proximity to Population Centers ..................................................................................... 14
4.4
Climate and Length of Operating Season ........................................................................ 14
4.5
Infrastructure .................................................................................................................. 14
5
History ................................................................ ................................ ................................ . 15
5.1
Previous Operation .......................................................................................................... 15
5.2
Previous Exploration ....................................................................................................... 15
6
Geological Setting, Mineralization and Deposit ................................................................ ..... 15
6.1
Regional, Local and Property Geology ............................................................................ 15
6.2
Mineralization ................................................................................................................. 16
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
5
6.3
Deposits ........................................................................................................................... 16
7
Exploration................................ ................................ ................................ ........................... 17
7.1
Nature and Extent of Exploration ................................................................................... 17
7.2
Non-Drilling Procedures and Parameters ....................................................................... 19
7.3
Drilling Procedures .......................................................................................................... 20
7.4
Hydrology ........................................................................................................................ 20
7.5
Geotechnical Data ........................................................................................................... 20
8
Sample Preparation, Analyses and Security ................................ ................................ .......... 21
8.1
Prior to Sending to the Lab .............................................................................................. 21
8.2
Lab Procedures ................................................................................................................ 21
9
Data Verification ................................ ................................ ................................ .................. 22
9.1
Procedures of Qualified Person ...................................................................................... 22
9.2
Limitations ....................................................................................................................... 22
9.3
Opinion of Qualified Person ............................................................................................ 22
10
Mineral Processing and Metallurgical Testing ................................ ................................ ....... 22
10.1
Testing Procedures .......................................................................................................... 22
10.2
Relationship of Tests to the Whole ................................................................................. 23
10.3
Lab Information ............................................................................................................... 23
10.4
Relevant Results .............................................................................................................. 24
11
Mineral Resource Estimates ................................ ................................ ................................ . 24
11.1
Assumptions, Parameters and Methodology.................................................................. 24
11.1.1
Geostatistical Analysis for Classification ........................................................... 26
11.2
Qualified Person’s Estimates ........................................................................................... 28
11.3
Resources Exclusive of Reserves ..................................................................................... 29
11.3.1
Initial Economic Assessment ............................................................................. 29
11.4
Qualified Person’s Opinion .............................................................................................. 30
12
Mineral Reserve Estimates ................................ ................................ ................................ ... 30
12.1
Assumptions, Parameters and Methodology.................................................................. 30
12.2
Qualified Person’s Estimates ........................................................................................... 32
12.3
Qualified Person’s Opinion .............................................................................................. 33
13
Mining Methods ................................ ................................ ................................ ................... 33
13.1
Geotech and Hydrology ................................................................................................... 33
13.2
Production Rates ............................................................................................................. 34
13.3
Mining Related Requirements ........................................................................................ 35
13.4
Required Equipment and Personnel ............................................................................... 35
14
Processing and Recovery Methods ................................ ................................ ........................ 36
14.1
Description or Flowsheet ................................................................................................ 36
14.2
Requirements for Energy, Water, Material and Personnel ............................................ 36
15
Infrastructure ................................ ................................ ................................ ....................... 36
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
6
16
Market Studies ................................ ................................ ................................ ..................... 37
16.1
Market Description .......................................................................................................... 37
16.2
Price Forecasts ................................................................................................................. 38
16.3
Contract Requirements ................................................................................................... 38
17
Environmental Studies, Permitting and Plans, Negotiations or Agreements with Local
Individuals ................................ ................................ ................................ ................... 39
17.1
Results of Studies ............................................................................................................ 39
17.2
Requirements and Plans for Waste Disposal .................................................................. 39
17.3
Permit Requirements and Status .................................................................................... 39
17.4
Local Plans, Negotiations or Agreements ....................................................................... 40
17.5
Mine Closure Plans .......................................................................................................... 40
17.6
Qualified Person’s Opinion .............................................................................................. 41
18
Capital and Operating Costs ................................ ................................ ................................ .. 41
18.1
Capital Cost Estimate....................................................................................................... 41
18.2
Operating Cost Estimate ................................................................................................. 42
19
Economic Analysis ................................................................ ................................ ................ 43
19.1
Assumptions, Parameters and Methods ......................................................................... 43
19.2
Results ............................................................................................................................. 45
19.3
Sensitivity ........................................................................................................................ 47
20
Adjacent Properties ................................ ................................ ................................ .............. 48
20.1
Information Used ............................................................................................................ 48
21
Other Relevant Data and Information ................................................................ ................... 48
22
Interpretation and Conclusions ................................ ................................ ............................. 49
22.1
Conclusion ....................................................................................................................... 49
22.2
Risk Factors ...................................................................................................................... 49
22.2.1
Governing Assumptions .................................................................................... 50
22.2.2
Limitations ......................................................................................................... 50
22.2.3
Methodology ..................................................................................................... 50
22.2.4
Development of the Risk Matrix ....................................................................... 51
22.2.5
Categorization of Risk Levels and Color Code Convention ............................... 53
22.2.6
Description of the Coal Property ...................................................................... 53
22.2.7
Summary of Residual Risk Ratings .................................................................... 53
22.2.8
Risk Factors........................................................................................................ 54
23
Recommendations ................................ ................................ ................................ ............... 60
24
References ................................ ................................ ................................ ........................... 60
25
Reliance on Information Provided by the Registrant ................................ ............................. 60
F
IGURES
(
IN
R
EPORT
)
Figure 1-1: Coronado Buchanan Mine Complex Property Location Map ........................................... 2
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
7
Figure 1-2: CAPEX ................................................................................................................................ 5
Figure 1-3: OPEX .................................................................................................................................. 6
Figure 1-4: Sensitivity of NPV .............................................................................................................. 9
Figure 6-1: Buchanan Stratigraphic Column ..................................................................................... 16
Figure 7-1: Buchanan Cross-Section, A1 – A2 .................................................................................... 18
Figure 7-2: Buchanan Cross-Section, B1 – B2 .................................................................................... 19
Figure 11-1: Histogram of the Total Seam Thickness for the Pocahontas No. 3 Seam Present in the
Buchanan Mine Complex ................................................................................................ 26
Figure 11-2: Scatter plot of the Total Seam Thickness for the Pocahontas No. 3 Seam Present in
the Buchanan Mine Complex ......................................................................................... 26
Figure 11-3: Variogram of the Total Seam Thickness for the Pocahontas No. 3 Seam Present in the
Buchanan Mine Complex ................................................................................................ 27
Figure 11-4: Result of DHSA for the Pocahontas No. 3 Seam Present in the Buchanan Mine
Complex .......................................................................................................................... 28
Figure 11-5: Results of Initial Economic Assessment ........................................................................ 30
Figure 15-1: Buchanan Surface Facilities .......................................................................................... 37
Figure 18-1: CAPEX ............................................................................................................................ 41
Figure 19-1: Cash Costs per Tonne ................................................................................................... 45
Figure 19-2: Sensitivity of NPV .......................................................................................................... 48
T
ABLES
(
IN
R
EPORT
)
Table 1-1: Coal Resources Summary as of December 31, 2022 ......................................................... 3
Table 1-2: Coal Summary (ROM (Moist)) as of December 31, 2022 ................................................... 4
Table 1-3: Coal Reserves Summary (Marketable Sales Basis) as of December 31, 2022 ................... 4
Table 1-4: Life-of-Mine Tonnage, P&L before Tax, and EBITDA ......................................................... 7
Table 1-5: Project Cash Flow Summary (000) ..................................................................................... 7
Table 2-1: Information Provided to MM&A by Coronado ................................................................ 11
Table 11-1: General Reserve and Resource Criteria ......................................................................... 25
Table 11-2: DHSA Results Summary for Radius from a Central Point .............................................. 28
Table 11-3: Coal Resources Summary as of December 31, 2022 ..................................................... 29
Table 11-4: Results of Initial Economic Assessment ......................................................................... 30
Table 12-1: Coal ROM (Moist) Summary as of December 31, 2022 ................................................. 32
Table 12-2: Coal Reserves Summary (Marketable Sales Basis) as of December 31, 2022 ............... 33
Table 13-1: Summary of Production by Year (Tonnes x 1,000) ........................................................ 35
Table 16-1: Quality Specifications by Product .................................................................................. 38
Table 17-1: Buchanan Mining Permit ............................................................................................... 40
Table 18-1: Estimated Coal Production Taxes and Sales Costs ......................................................... 43
Table 18-2: Buchanan Mine Operating Costs ................................................................................... 43
Table 19-1: Life-of-Mine Tonnage, P&L before Tax, and EBITDA ..................................................... 45
Table 19-2: Summary of Buchanan Key Financial Performance Metrics (2023-2030) ..................... 46
Table 19-3: Project Cash Flow Summary (000) ................................................................................. 47
Table 22-1: Probability Level Table ................................................................................................... 51
Table 22-2: Consequence Level Table ............................................................................................... 52
Table 22-3: Risk Matrix ..................................................................................................................... 53
Table 22-4: Risk Assessment Matrix ................................................................................................. 54
Table 22-5: Geological and Coal Resource Risk Assessment (Risks 1 and 2) .................................... 55
Table 22-6: Environmental (Risks 3 and 4) ....................................................................................... 56
Table 22-7: Regulatory Requirements (Risk 5) ................................................................................. 56
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
8
Table 22-8: Market and Transportation (Risk 6) ............................................................................... 57
Table 22-9: Market and Transportation (Risk 7) ............................................................................... 57
Table 22-10: Methane Management (Risk 8) ................................................................................... 58
Table 22-11: Mine Fires (Risk 9) ........................................................................................................ 58
Table 22-12: Availability of Supplies and Equipment (Risk 10) ......................................................... 59
Table 22-13: Labor – Work Stoppage (Risk 11) ................................................................................. 59
Table 22-14: Labor – Retirement (Risk 12) ....................................................................................... 60
Table 25-1: Information from Registran t Relied Upon by MM&A ................................................... 60
Appendices
A .......................................................................................................................... MM&A Qualifications
B ...................................................................................................................................................... Map
C ................................................................................................................................ Glossary of Terms
D ..................................................... Initial Economic Assessment for Resources Exclusive of Reserves
E ......................................................................................................................................... JORC Table 1
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
1
1
Executive Summary
1.1
Property Description
Coronado Global Resources Inc. (
Coronado
)
authorized
Marshall Miller & Associates, Inc.
(
MM&A
)
to prepare this Technical Report Summary (
TRS
) of its controlled coal resources and
reserves located at the
Buchanan Division (
Buchanan
)
Virginia (the
Property
). An updated TRS was prepared in February 2023 due to material
differences in the key financial modifying factors including coal sales price assumptions, operating
costs and capital costs from December 31, 2021 to December 31, 2022. Coal sales price
assumptions are discussed in
are discussed in
Sections 18 and 19
and coal reserves for Coronado, as defined under the
Australasian Code for Reporting of
Exploration Results, Mineral Resources and Ore Reserves
(
JORC Code
) as well as under Subpart
1300 of Regulation S-K (Regulation S-K 1300) promulgated by the
United States Securities and
Exchange Commission (
SEC
)
.
Australasian
Code for Public Reporting of Technical Assessments and Valuations of Mineral Assets
(
VALMIN
Code
).
Coal resources and coal reserves are herein reported in imperial units of measurement and are
rounded to millions of metric tonnes (
Mt
).
The Buchanan No. 1 Mine Complex is located in Buchanan County in southwest Virginia. The
Property is 24 kilometers northwest of the town of Richlands, Virginia and 65.9 kilometers
southeast of Pikeville, Kentucky. The nearest major population centers are Lexington, Kentucky
(290 kilometers northwest) and Roanoke, Virginia (153 kilometers northeast) (see
Figure 1-1
). The
Property is composed of approximately 33,577 total hectares, of which 25,852 are leased or
subleased from private landholders under approximately 150 individual coal lease tracts, and
7,725 hectares are owned by Coronado. Subject to Coronado’s exercising its renewal rights
thereunder, all the leases expire upon exhaustion of the relevant coal reserves, which is expected
to occur in 2044.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
2
Figure 1-1: Coronado Buchanan Mine Complex Property Location Map
1.2
Ownership
The Property was formerly controlled by
Consolidation Coal Company (
CONSOL
)
. Mine
development was started by CONSOL in 1983 and longwall production began in 1987. Coronado
acquired the Buchanan Mine from CONSOL in March 2016.
1.3
Geology
Operations at the Buchanan Mine Complex extract the Pocahontas No. 3 coal bed by longwall
mining methods. Strata of economic interest for this TRS are of the Pennsylvanian-age
Pocahontas Formation and the subject Pocahontas No. 3 seam is the principal coal seam of that
formation. Due to the high value of this low-volatile coking coal, it has been extensively mined in
the region. The seam is situated below drainage throughout the Property and is accessed by
existing mine shafts.
1.4
Exploration Status
The Property has been extensively explored, largely by drilling using continuous coring methods,
rotary drilling but also by obtaining coal measurements at mine exposures, ongoing drilling
associated with degas activities, and by downhole geophysical methods. The majority of the data
was acquired or generated by previous owners of the Property. These sources comprise the
primary data used in the evaluation of the coal resources and coal reserves on the Property.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
3
MM&A examined the data available for the evaluation and incorporated all pertinent information
into this TRS. Where data appeared to be anomalous or not representative, that data was
excluded from the digital databases and subsequent processing by MM&A.
Ongoing exploration has been carried out by Coronado since acquiring the Buchanan Mine. The
exploration data acquired by Coronado has been consistent with past drilling activities.
1.5
Operations and Development
Due to its coal reserve and seam characteristics, the Buchanan No. 1 Mine operates using the
longwall method. The model was therefore generated with longwall-mining constraints in mind
for Buchanan’s underground resources. The mine produces coal that is suitable for the low-
volatile metallurgical coal markets.
The Buchanan No. 1 Mine in Buchanan County, Virginia, is the only active longwall mine currently
being operated by Coronado.
Coronado currently operates a coal preparation plant at Buchanan. The Buchanan Plant operates
at a feed rate of approximately 1,270 raw tonnes per hour (
tph)
. Processes are typical of those
used in the coal industry and are in use at adjacent coal processing plants.
1.6
Mineral Resource
Mineral resources, representing in-situ coal from a portion of which reserves are derived, are
presented below. A coal resource estimate, summarized in
Table 1-1
, was prepared as of
December 31, 2022, for property controlled by Coronado.
Table 1-1: Coal Resources Summary as of December 31, 2022
Coal Resource (Dry Tonnes, In Situ, Mt)
Resource Quality (Dry)
Area
Measured
Indicated
Inferred
Total
Ash%
Sulfur%
VM%
Inclusive of Reserves
158.0
10.2
0.0
168.2
25
0.7
16
Exclusive of Reserves
33.9
5.9
0.0
39.8
Total 12/31/2022
191.9
16.1
0.0
208.0
Note 2: Coal resources are reported on a dry basis. Surface moisture and inherent moisture are excluded.
Note 3: The Property contains 39.8 Mt of dry, in-place measured and indicated coal resources exclusive of reserves as of December 31, 2022.
1.7
Mineral Reserve
Reserve tonnage estimates provided herein report coal reserves derived from the in-situ resource
tons presented in
Table 1-1
, and not in addition to coal resources. Proven and probable coal
reserves were derived from the defined coal resource considering relevant mining, processing,
infrastructure, economic (including estimates of capital, revenue, and cost), marketing, legal,
environmental, socio-economic and regulatory factors. The Resource estimate has been used as
the basis for this Reserve calculation, which utilizes a reasonable preliminary feasibility study, a
life-of-mine (
LOM
) mine plan and practical recovery factors. Production modeling was completed
with an effective start date of October 1, 2022. Additions and depletion have been used to bring
the Reserve estimate forward to December 31, 2022.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
4
Factors that would typically preclude conversion of a coal resource to coal reserve, include the
following: inferred resource classification; absence of coal quality; poor mine recovery; lack of
access; geological encumbrances associated with overlying and underlying strata; seam thinning;
structural complication; and insufficient exploration have all been considered. Reserve
consideration excludes those portions of the resource area which exhibit the aforementioned-
geological and operational encumbrances.
Coal reserves are presented on a run-of-mine (
ROM
) basis in
Table 1-2
. Proven and probable coal
reserves were derived from the defined in-situ coal resource considering relevant processing,
economic (including technical estimates of capital, revenue, and cost), marketing, legal,
environmental, socioeconomic, and regulatory factors. The proven and probable coal reserves on
the Property are summarized below in
Table 1-3
.
Table 1-2: Coal Summary (ROM (Moist)) as of December 31, 2022
Demonstrated Coal Reserves (Mt, Moist ROM)
Quality (Dry)
By Reliability Category
By Mining Type
By Control Type
Area /
Mine
Proven
Probable
Total
Surface
UG
Owned
Leased
Subleased
Ash
Sulfur
Vol
Buchanan
144.9
8.7
153.6
0.0
153.6
21.7
127.9
4.0
42
0.7
12
Table 1-3: Coal Reserves Summary (Marketable Sales Basis) as of December 31, 2022
Demonstrated Coal Reserves (Wet Tons, Washed or Direct Shipped, Mt)
Quality (Dry Basis)
By Reliability Category
By Mining Type
By Control Type
Area / Mine
Proven
Probable
Total
Surface
UG
Owned
Leased
Subleased
Ash%
Sulfur%
VM%
Buchanan Mine Complex
87.5
5.4
92.9
0.0
92.9
14.4
75.9
2.6
6
0.7
19
surface and inherent moisture is modeled at 6-percent. Actual product moisture is dependent upon multiple geological factors, operational
factors, and product contract specifications and can exceed 8-percent. As such, the modeled moisture values provide a level of conservatism
for reserve reporting.
In summary, Coronado controls a total of 92.9 Mt (moist basis) of marketable coal reserves, at
Buchanan, as of December 31, 2022. Of that total, 94 percent are proven, and 6 percent are
probable. There are 14.4 Mt of owned coal reserves and 75.9 Mt of leased coal reserves and 2.6
Mt of subleased reserves. All the Buchanan reserves are considered suitable for the metallurgical
coal market, and all of the Buchanan reserves are assigned.
1.8
Capital Summary
Coronado provided MM&A with an inventory of operating equipment available at Buchanan.
MM&A’s capital schedules assume that major equipment rebuilds occur over the course of each
machine’s remaining assumed operating life. Replacement equipment was scheduled based on
MM&A’s experience and knowledge of mining equipment and industry standards with respect to
the useful life of such equipment. A summary of the estimated capital for the Property is provided
in
Figure 1-2
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
5
Figure 1-2: CAPEX
1.9
Operating Costs
Coronado provided historical and preliminary 5-year projections of operating costs for Buchanan
for MM&A’s review. MM&A used the historical and/or budget cost information as a reference
and developed personnel schedules for the mine and support facilities. Hourly labor rates and
salaries were based upon information contained in Coronado’s financial summaries. Fringe-
benefit costs were developed for vacation and holidays, federal and state unemployment
insurance, retirement, workers’ compensation and pneumoconiosis, casualty and life insurance,
healthcare, and bonuses. A cost factor for mine supplies was developed that relates expenditures
to mine advance rates for roof-control costs and other mine-supply costs at underground mines.
Other factors were developed for maintenance and repair costs, rentals, mine power, outside
services and other direct mining costs.
Operating costs factors were also developed for the coal preparation plant processing, refuse
handling, coal loading, property taxes, and insurance and bonding. Appropriate royalty rates were
assigned for production from leased coal lands, and sales taxes were calculated for state
severance taxes, the federal black lung excise tax, and federal and state reclamation fees.
A summary of the projected operating costs for the Property is provided in
Figure 1-3
.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
6
Figure 1-3: OPEX
1.10
Economic Evaluation
The pre-feasibility financial model prepared for this TRS was developed to test the economic
viability of the coal resource area. The results of this financial model are not intended to
represent a bankable feasibility study, required for financing of any current or future mining
operations contemplated for the Coronado properties, but are intended to establish the economic
viability of the estimated coal reserves. Cash flows are simulated on an annual basis in nominal
dollars assuming a 2% inflation rate based on projected production from the coal reserves. The
discounted cash flow analysis presented herein is based on an effective date of January 1, 2023.
On an un-levered basis, the net present value (
NPV
) of the project cash flow after taxes represents
the Enterprise Value of the project. The project cash flow, excluding debt service, is calculated by
subtracting direct and indirect operating expenses and capital expenditures from revenue. Direct
costs include labor, operating supplies, maintenance and repairs, facilities costs for materials
handling, coal preparation, refuse disposal, coal loading, reclamation and general and
administrative costs. Indirect costs include statutory and legally agreed upon fees related to direct
extraction of the mineral. The indirect costs are the federal black lung tax, federal and state
reclamation taxes, property taxes, coal production royalties, and income taxes.
Table 1-4
P&L
), and earnings before income tax, depreciation &
amortization (
EBITDA
) for Buchanan.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
7
Table 1-4: Life-of-Mine Tonnage, P&L before Tax, and EBITDA
LOM
LOM
P&L
LOM
EBITDA
Tonnes
Pre-Tax P&L
Per Tonne
EBITDA
Per Tonne
Buchanan
92,923
$4,280,077
$46.06
$6,174,578
$66.45
As shown in
Table 1-4,
Coronado consolidated operations show positive LOM P&L and LOM EBITDA of $4.3 billion and
$6.2 billion, respectively.
Coronado’s consolidated Buchanan cash flow summary in nominal dollars assuming a 2% interest
rate, excluding debt service, is shown in
Table 1-5
Table 1-5: Project Cash Flow Summary (000)
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
Total
2023
2024
2025
2026
2027
Production & Sales tonnes
92,924
3,786
3,811
4,363
4,446
5,112
Total Revenue
$14,194,747
$675,923
$544,435
$574,963
$592,283
$692,273
EBITDA
$6,174,578
$295,749
$209,789
$206,065
$217,757
$294,147
Net Income
$3,368,328
$179,131
$103,854
$91,899
$90,456
$138,196
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$5,181,846
$188,692
$200,765
$186,416
$195,463
$245,493
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(1,448,505)
$(135,766)
$(130,803)
$(111,896)
$(122,768)
$(101,557)
Net Cash Flow
$3,733,342
$52,926
$69,962
$74,520
$72,695
$143,936
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2028
2029
2030
2031
2032
2033
Production & Sales tonnes
6,242
6,462
6,200
5,444
6,226
4,814
Total Revenue
$862,187
$910,476
$890,951
$798,054
$930,819
$734,119
EBITDA
$431,599
$469,093
$445,727
$357,721
$458,785
$288,024
Net Income
$240,334
$262,860
$254,666
$197,893
$280,873
$159,996
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$339,674
$386,828
$379,000
$320,798
$362,834
$277,786
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(70,382)
$(50,228)
$(71,184)
$(59,572)
$(49,573)
$(65,133)
Net Cash Flow
$269,292
$336,600
$307,815
$261,226
$313,262
$212,653
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
8
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2034
2035
2036
2037
2038
2039
Production & Sales tonnes
6,474
6,423
5,249
3,447
3,009
2,914
Total Revenue
$1,007,101
$1,019,070
$849,433
$569,043
$506,626
$500,552
EBITDA
$501,730
$526,779
$424,763
$211,060
$168,369
$216,035
Net Income
$326,060
$344,381
$266,105
$105,424
$79,886
$116,181
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$372,442
$424,330
$368,367
$223,842
$158,704
$177,921
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(54,007)
$(69,272)
$(64,919)
$(77,383)
$(43,070)
$(35,719)
Net Cash Flow
$318,435
$355,058
$303,449
$146,459
$115,634
$142,202
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2040
2041
2042
2043
2044
2045
Production & Sales tonnes
2,093
2,254
1,703
1,714
737
-
Total Revenue
$366,649
$402,822
$309,918
$317,808
$139,240
$-
EBITDA
$108,191
$153,415
$80,892
$106,596
$2,291
$-
Net Income
$34,854
$71,326
$19,002
$46,332
$(34,676)
$(3,773)
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$119,167
$128,269
$89,128
$92,258
$24,650
$(47,861)
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(50,131)
$(46,604)
$(24,930)
$(13,606)
$-
$-
Net Cash Flow
$69,036
$81,665
$64,198
$78,652
$24,650
$(47,861)
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2046
2047
2048
2049
2050
2051
Production & Sales tonnes
-
-
-
-
-
-
Total Revenue
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
EBITDA
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
Net Income
$(1,534)
$(785)
$(403)
$(209)
$(0)
$(0)
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$(16,273)
$(8,299)
$(4,232)
$(4,317)
$-
$-
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
Net Cash Flow
$(16,273)
$(8,299)
$(4,232)
$(4,317)
$-
$-
Consolidated cash flows are driven by annual sales tonnage, which at steady-state level ranges
from a peak of 6.5 million tonnes in 2034 to a low of 0.7 million tonnes in 2044. Projected
consolidated revenue ranges from $317.8 million to $1.019 billion at a steady state. Revenue
totals $14.2 billion for the project’s life.
Consolidated cash flow from operations is positive throughout the projected operating period,
with the exception of post-production years, due to end-of-mine reclamation spending.
Consolidated cash flow from operations peaks at $424.3 million in 2035 and totals $5.2 billion over
the project’s life. Capital expenditures total $602.8 million through 2027 and $1.4 billion over the
project’s life.
1.10.1
Discounted Cash Flow Analysis
Cash flow after tax, but before debt service, generated over the life of the project was discounted
to NPV at a 10.0% discount rate, which represents Coronado’s estimate of the nominal dollar, risk
adjusted weighted average cost of capital (
WACC
) for likely market participants if the subject
reserves were offered for sale. On an un-levered basis, the NPV of the project cash flows
represents the Enterpris e Value of the project and amounts to $1.562 billion. The pre-feasibility
financial model prepared for the TRS was developed to test the economic viability of each coal
resource area. The NPV estimate was made for the purpose of confirming the economics for
classification of coal reserves and not for purposes of valuing Coronado or its Buchanan assets.
Mine plans were not optimized, and actual results of the operations may be different, but in all
cases, the mine production plan assumes the properties are under competent management.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
9
1.10.2
Sensitivity Analysis
Sensitivity of the NPV results to changes in the key drivers is presented in the chart below. The
sensitivity study shows the NPV at the 10.0% discount rate when Base Case sales prices, operating
costs, and capital costs are increased and decreased in increments of 5% within a +/- 15% range.
Figure 1-4: Sensitivity of NPV
As shown, NPV is quite sensitive to changes in sales price and operating cost estimates, and
slightly sensitive to changes in capital cost estimates.
1.11
Permitting
Coronado has obtained all mining and discharge permits to operate its mine and processing,
loadout, or related support facilities. MM&A is unaware of any obvious or current Coronado
permitting issues that are expected to prevent the issuance of future permits. Buchanan, along
with all coal producers, is subject to a level of uncertainty regarding future clean water permits
due to
United States Environmental Protection Agency
(
EPA
)
United States Fish and Wildlife
(
USFW
)
1.12
Conclusion and Recommendations
Sufficient data have been obtained through various exploration and sampling programs and
mining operations to support the geological interpretations of seam structure and thickness for
coal horizons situated on the Property. The data are of sufficient quantity and reliability to
reasonably support the coal resource and coal reserve estimates in this TRS.
The geological data and preliminary feasibility study, which consider mining plans, revenue, and
operating and capital cost estimates are sufficient to support the classification of coal reserves
provided herein.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
10
This geologic evaluation conducted in conjunction with the preliminary feasibility study concludes
that the 92.9 Mt of marketable underground coal reserves identified on the Property are
economically mineable under reasonable expectations of market prices for metallurgical coal
products, estimated operation costs, and capital expenditures.
2
Introduction
2.1
Registrant and Terms of Reference
This report was prepared for the sole use of
Coronado Global Resources Inc. (
Coronado
)
and its
affiliated and subsidiary companies and advisors. An updated TRS was prepared in February 2023
due to material differences in the key financial modifying factors including coal sales price
assumptions, operating costs and capital costs from December 31, 2021 to December 31, 2022.
Coal sales price assumptions are discussed in
and capital costs are discussed in
Sections 18 and 19
of coal resources and coal reserves for Coronado, as defined under the
Australasian Code for
Reporting of Exploration Results, Mineral Resources and Ore Reserves
(
JORC Code
) as well as
under Subpart 1300 of Regulation S-K (Regulation S-K 1300) promulgated by the
United States
Securities and Exchange Commission (
SEC
)
.
Australasian Code for Public Reporting of Technical Assessments and Valuations of Mineral
Assets
(
VALMIN Code
).
This report provides a statement of coal resources and coal reserves for Coronado at Buchanan.
Exploration results and Resource calculations were used as the basis for the mine planning and the
preliminary feasibility study completed to determine the extent and viability of the reserve.
Coal resources and coal reserves are herein reported in metric units of measurement and are
rounded to millions of metric tonnes (
Mt
).
2.2
Information Sources
This TRS is based on information provided by Coronado and reviewed by MM&A. Sources of data
and information are listed below in
Table 2-1
:
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
11
Table 2-1: Information Provided to MM&A by Coronado
Information Provided by Coronado
Report Section
Geological
Geologic data including digital databases and original source data including
geologist logs, driller’s logs, geophysical logs
9.1
Coal Quality
Database of coal quality information supplemented with original source
laboratory sheets where available
10.1
Mining
Historical productivities and manpower from operating and future Coronado
mines
13.2, 13.4
Coal Preparation
Flow sheet and other information representing current and future methods of
coal processing
14.1
Waste Disposal
Engineering data and estimates representing remaining capacities for coarse
and fine coal waste disposal
17.2
Costs
Historical and budgetary operating cost information used to derive cost drivers
for reserve financial modeling
18.2
Economic
WACC and inflation rate used in discounted cash flow analysis
19.1, 19.2, 19.3
Note: While the sources of data listed in Table 2-1 are not exhaustive, they represent a significant portion of information which supports this TRS.
MM&A reviewed the provided data and found it to be reasonable prior to incorporating it into the TRS. The TRS contains “forward-looking
information” including forecasts of productivity and annual coal production, operating and capital cost estimates, coals sales price forecasts, the
assumption that Coronado will continue to acquire necessary permits, and other assumptions. The TRS statements and conclusions are not a
guarantee of future performance and undue reliance should not be placed on them. The ability of Coronado to recover the estimated coal reserves
is dependent on multiple factors beyond the control of MM&A including, but not limited to geologic factors, mining conditions, regulatory
approvals, and changes in regulations. In all cases, the plans assume the Property is under competent management.
Coronado engaged MM&A to conduct a coal resource and reserve evaluation of the Coronado coal
properties as of September 30, 2022. Additions and depletion have been used to bring the
Resource and Reserve estimates forward to December 31, 2022, the effective date of this TRS for
Buchanan. For the evaluation, the following tasks were to be completed:
>
Conduct site visits of the mines and mine infrastructure facilities;
>
Process the information supporting the estimation of coal resources and reserves into
geological models;
>
Develop life-of-reserve mine (
LOM
) plans and financial models;
>
Hold discussions with Coronado company management; and
>
Prepare and issue a TRS providing a statement of coal resources and reserves which would
include:
-
A description of the mine and facilities.
-
A description of the evaluation process.
-
An estimation of coal resources and reserves with compliance elements as stated under the
JORC Code and the SEC Regulation S-K 1300.
2.3
Personal Inspections
MM&A is very familiar with Buchanan, having provided a variety of services in recent years, and
the QPs involved in this TRS have conducted multiple site visits.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
12
3
Property Description
3.1
Location
The Buchanan Mine Complex is located in Buchanan County in southwestern Virginia (see
Figure
1-1
) approximately 16 kilometers southeast of Grundy, which is the county seat of Buchanan
County. Surface facilities for the shaft mine are located along Garden Creek and a Norfolk
Southern (NS) rail line about 6.4 kilometers south-southeast of Oakwood, Virginia.
The Property is located on the following
United States Geological Survey (
USGS
)
Prater, Vansant, Keen Mountain, and Jewell Ridge. Current mining projections fall within the Keen
Mountain and Jewell Ridge quadrangles. The coordinate system and datum used for the model of
Buchanan No. 1 and the subsequent maps were produced in the Virginia State Plane South
system, NAD 27.
3.2
Titles, Claims or Leases
The Buchanan coal reserves are located in Buchanan and Tazewell Counties, Virginia. The
Property is composed of approximately 33,577 total hectares, of which 25,852 are leased or
subleased from private landholders under approximately 150 individual coal lease tracts, and
7,725 hectares are owned by Coronado. Subject to Coronado’s exercising its renewal rights
thereunder, all the leases expire upon exhaustion of the relevant coal reserves, which is expected
to occur in 2044. MM&A has not carried out a separate title verification for the coal property and
has not verified leases, deeds, surveys, or other property control instruments pertinent to the
subject resources. Tenure was separately reviewed by Coronado’s legal advisors. Coronado has
represented to MM&A that it controls the mining rights to the reserves as shown on its property
maps, and MM&A has accepted these as being a true and accurate depiction of the mineral rights
controlled by Coronado. The TRS assumes the Property is developed under responsible and
experienced management.
3.3
Mineral Rights
Coronado supplied property control maps to MM&A related to properties for which mineral
and/or surface property are controlled by Coronado. While MM&A accepted these
representations as being true and accurate, MM&A has no knowledge of past property boundary
disputes or other concerns, through past knowledge of the Property, that would signal concern
over future mining operations or development potential.
Property control in Appalachia can be intricate. Coal mining properties are typically composed of
numerous property tracts which are owned and/or leased from both land-holding companies and
private individuals or companies. It is common to encounter severed ownership, with different
entities or individuals controlling the surface and mineral rights. Mineral control in the region is
typically characterized by leases or ownership of larger tracts of land, with surface control
generally comprised of smaller tracts, particularly in developed areas.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
13
Legal mining rights may reflect a combination of fee or mineral ownership and fee or mineral
leases of coal lands through various surface and mineral lease agreements. There is also a
relatively small amount of area where the coal is partially owned and/or partially leased on a
limited number of individual tracts.
Control of the surface property is necessary to conduct surface mining but is not necessary to
conduct underground mining. Given that the Buchanan Mine has been active dating back to the
1980s, Coronado, and its predecessors, have a successful history of obtaining any necessary rights
and the associated permits to mine.
3.4
Encumbrances
No Title Encumbrances are known. By assignment, MM&A did not complete an independent
query related to Title Encumbrances.
3.5
Other Risks
There is always risk involved in property control. Coronado and its predecessor, CONSOL, have
both had their legal teams examine the deeds and title control in order to minimize the risk.
Historically, property control has not posed any challenges related to Buchanan’s operations.
4
Accessibility, Climate, Local Resources,
Infrastructure and Physiography
4.1
Topography, Elevation, and Vegetation
The topography of the area surrounding the Buchanan Mine Complex is typical of the Central
Appalachian Plateau being rugged and deeply dissected by v-shaped river valleys flanked by steep-
sided upland regions. Surface elevations near the mine complex range from approximately 823
meters above sea level in upland regions to approximately 579 meters at stream level. The
Property is moderately vegetated, with a mixture of hardwood and conifer forest in the temperate
broadleaf category. The Property is not situated near any major urban centers, and the
surrounding area is considered rural.
4.2
Access and Transport
General access to the Buchanan No. 1 Mine property is via a well-developed network of primary,
secondary, and unimproved roads. Highway 460 is the primary highway connecting Pike County in
Eastern Kentucky to Buchanan and Tazewell Counties in Southwestern Virginia. Numerous
secondary and unimproved roads provide direct access to the Property, some being state- and
town-maintained. These roads typically stay open throughout the year. A
Norfolk Southern (
NS
)
rail line that is located approximately 6.44 kilometers south-southeast of Oakwood, Virginia,
serves as the primary means of transport for produced coal. NS transports coal from the
Buchanan Mine Complex either to domestic customers or to the Pier 6 export terminal at Norfolk,
Virginia for overseas shipment. A small portion of production is transported via truck haul. An
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
14
extensive network of service roads to gob gas and coalbed methane (
CBM
) production wells exist
on the subject property.
4.3
Proximity to Population Centers
The Buchanan No. 1 Mine property lies near the town of Grundy in Buchanan County, Virginia
approximately 290 kilometers southeast of Lexington, Kentucky and 153 kilometers southwest of
Roanoke, Virginia. As of 2021, Buchanan County had a population of approximately 19,800
residents.
4.4
Climate and Length of Operating Season
The climate of the region is classified as humid sub-tropical with four distinct seasons: warm
summers, cold winters, and moderate fall and spring seasons. Precipitation in the region is
consistent throughout the year with the most rain falling in spring and the early months of
summer. Average yearly rainfall is 112.62 centimeters. Summer months typically begin in late
May and end in early September and range in average temperature from 49 to 84 degrees
Fahrenheit (or 9.44 to 28.89 degrees Celsius). Winters typically begin in mid to late November and
run until mid to late March with average temperatures ranging from 26 to 56 degrees Fahrenheit
(or -3.33 to 13.33 degrees Celsius). Precipitation in the winter typically comes in the form of
snowfall or as a wintery mix (sleet and snow) with severe snowfall events occurring occasionally.
Seasonal variations in climate typically do not affect underground mining in Virginia. However,
weather events could potentially negatively impact efficiency of surface and preparation plant
operations on a very limited basis and lasting less than a few days.
4.5
Infrastructure
The Buchanan No. 1 Mine Complex has sources of water, power, personnel, and supplies readily
available for use. Personnel have historically been sourced from the surrounding communities in
Buchanan, Tazewell, McDowell, and Pike counties, and have proven to be adequate in numbers to
operate the mine. As mining is common in the surrounding areas, the workforce is generally
familiar with mining practices, and many are experienced miners. Water is sourced locally from
streams that flow over Coronado-owned property. The mine also utilizes ground water from an
old abandoned mine. Electricity is sourced from
American Electric Power
AEP
)
. The service
industry in the areas surrounding the mine complex has historically provided supplies, equipment
repairs and fabrication, etc. The Coronado-owned Buchanan Preparation Plant services the mine
via a skip hoist and conveyor belt system which transports extracted coal from an underground
bunker to the surface facility. The NS rail line serves as the main means of transport from the
mine.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
15
5
History
5.1
Previous Operation
The Property was formerly controlled by
Consolidation Coal Company (
CONSOL
)
.
Mine
development was started by CONSOL in 1983 and longwall production began in 1987. Coronado
acquired the Buchanan Mine from CONSOL in March 2016.
The most productive mining of any period since 1987 has occurred since the acquisition of
Buchanan Mine by Coronado. Production history has been approximately 3.5 Mt in 2016 (in only a
9-month period), 4.9 Mt in 2017, 4.7 Mt in 2018, 4.5 Mt in 2019, 3.4 Mt in 2020, 4.4 Mt in 2021,
and 3.9 Mt in 2022.
5.2
Previous Exploration
The Property has been extensively explored by subsurface drilling efforts carried out by numerous
entities, many of which were completed prior to acquisition by Coronado. The majority of the
drilling was accomplished using vertical continuous (diamond) coring or air rotary methods.
Drill records indicate that independent contract drilling operators have typically been engaged to
carry out drilling on the Property. Geophysical logging on those properties acquired from CONSOL
was often performed by both CONSOL’s in-house logging services and outside logging firms.
MM&A, via its Geophysical Logging Systems subsidiary, has logged a significant number of the past
exploration holes and degas wells, and currently logs most of the recently drilled holes.
6
Geological Setting, Mineralization and Deposit
6.1
Regional, Local and Property Geology
The Property lies in the Central Appalachian Coal basin in the Appalachian Plateau physiographic
province.
The coal deposits in the eastern US are the oldest and most extensively developed coal deposits in
the country. The coal deposits on the Property are Carboniferous in age, being of the
Pennsylvanian system. Overall, these Carboniferous coals contain two-fifths of the US’s
bituminous coal deposits and extend over 1,448 kilometers from northern Alabama to
Pennsylvania and are part of what is known as the
Appalachian Basin
. The Appalachian Basin is
more than 402 kilometers wide and, in some portions, contains over 60 coal seams of varying
economic significance.
Seams of economic significance typically range between 0.30 meters and 1.83 meters in thickness,
with relatively little structural deformation. Regional structure is typically characterized by gently
dipping strata to the northwest at less than one percent.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
16
Seams of the Pocahontas Formation have historically been mined in the Buchanan No. 1 Mine
with the Pocahontas No. 3 seam being the principal seam in the formation. Coal from the area has
historically been sold in primarily metallurgical market s.
6.2
Mineralization
The generalized stratigraphic columnar section in
Figure 6-1
of the principal coal seams and rock formations on the Property.
Figure 6-1: Buchanan Stratigraphic Column
Note: not to scale
6.3
Deposits
The coal produced at Buchanan No. 1 is typically Low Volatile (<23% volatile matter) bituminous
coal. Due to the value of the Pocahontas No. 3 (
P3
) as a low-volatile coking coal, it has been
extensively mined in the region. The P3 seam consists of multiple benches that split and merge
across the Property, including in descending stratigraphic order:
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
17
>
P31, uppermost bench, represented in purple on
Figures 7-1
7-2
>
P32, represented in orange on
Figures 7-1
7-2
>
P33, represented in blue on
Figures 7-1
7-2
>
345, lowermost bench, represented in green on
Figures 7-1
7-2
The mineable benches within the P3 horizon consist of three principal configurations determined
by variable seam splitting characteristics present across the Property:
1.
Full-seam
; all four benches (P31, P32, P33, and 345) are included within the mineable
section. This configuration is present within the remaining North and Northwest resource
areas, as well as the upper portion of the South resource area. Refer to
Figures 7-1
7-2
below
.
2.
P31, P32, and P33 Benches
; the underlying 345 bench extends more than two feet below
the P33 bench and is no longer included within the mineable section. This configuration is
present on the South side of the Property. Refer to
Figure 7-1
3.
P32, P33, and 345 Benches
; the overlying P31 bench extends more than two feet above the
P32 bench and is no longer included within the mineable section. This configuration is
present on the Northeast side of the Property. Refer to
Figure 7-2
The full-seam bench (P3) thickness ranges from 1.22 to 3.44 meters with an average of 1.86
meters, the P31, P32, P33 bench thickness ranges from 1.22 to 2.10 meters with an average of
1.43 meters, and the P32, P33, 345 bench thickness ranges from 1.22 to 2.71 meters with an
average of 1.65 meters. The seam is situated below drainage throughout the Property and is
accessible by existing mine shafts. Floor and roof strata vary throughout the mine area with floor
strata including fireclay, claystone, shale, sandy shale, and sandstone, but primarily being fireclay
and shale. Roof strata varies throughout as well but primarily is composed of sandstone, sandy
shale, and shale.
7
Exploration
7.1
Nature and Extent of Exploration
Extensive exploration in the form of subsurface drill efforts has been carried out on the Property
by numerous entities, most of which efforts were completed prior to the acquisition by Coronado.
Diamond core, rotary, and CBM drilling are the three primary types of exploration on the Property.
Data for correlation and mining conditions are derived from core descriptions and geophysical
logging (e-logging). Coal quality analyses were also employed during the core exploration process.
A total of 4,589 core, rotary, channel samples, mine measurements, and CBM wells with
Pocahontas No. 3 seam information are found within the Coronado database, of which 1,784 data
points are located within the current mine / resource area. The location of the drilling is shown on
the maps included in
Appendix B
.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
18
The concentration of exploration varies slightly across the Property, with the proposed
underground mining areas having the highest concentration of drill holes. Drilling on the Property
is typically sufficient for delineation of potential underground mineable benches. Core logging is
typically conducted by professional geologists in cases where roof and floor strata are of particular
interest and in cases where greater resolution and geologic detail are needed.
However, much of the early drill hole data comes from simplified driller’s logs, which often lack
specific details regarding geotechnical conditions and specific geology, making correlations and
floor and roof conditions difficult to determine. Geophysical logging techniques, by contrast,
document some details useful for geologic interpretation and mining conditions, but do not
provide detailed lithologic information. Given the variability of data-gathering methods, definitive
mapping of future mining conditions may not be possible, but projections and assumptions can be
made within a reasonable degree of certainty.
Once the integrity of the database was established, stratigraphic columnar sections were
generated using cross-sectional analysis to establish or confirm coal seam correlations. Cross-
section illustrating the three mineable bench configurations are presented below in
Figure 7-1
and
Figure 7-2
.
Figure 7-1: Buchanan Cross-Section, A1 – A2
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
19
Figure 7-2: Buchanan Cross-Section, B1 – B2
Due to the extended history of exploration by various parties on the Property, a wide variety of
survey techniques exist for documentation of data point locations. Many of the older exploration
drill holes appear to have been located by survey and more recently completed drill holes are
often located by high-resolution Global Positioning System (
GPS
) units. However, some holes
appear to have been approximately located using USGS topography maps or other methods which
are less accurate. Therefore, discretion had to be used regarding the accuracy for the location and
ground surface elevation of some of these older drill holes. In instances where a drill hole location
(or associated coal seam elevations) appeared to be inconsistent with the overall structural trend
(or surface topography for surface-mineable areas), the data point was not honored for geological
modeling. Others with apparently minor variances were adjusted and then used by MM&A.
Surveying of the underground and surface mined areas has been performed by the mine operators
and/or their consulting surveyors. By assignment, MM&A did not verify the accuracy or
completeness of supplied mine maps but accepted this information as being the work of
responsible engineers and surveyors.
MM&A compiled comprehensive topographic map files by selecting the best available aerial
mapping for each area and filling any gaps with digital USGS topographic mapping.
7.2
Non-Drilling Procedures and Parameters
To supplement the core hole quality database, samples have been collected from underground
channel samples, mine stockpiles, and/or truck / train shipments.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
20
7.3
Drilling Procedures
Core drilling methods typically utilize NX-size (5.4 centimeters) or similar-sized core cylinders to
recover core samples, which can be used to delineate geologic characteristics, and for coal quality
testing and geotechnical logging. For the core holes, the geophysical logs are especially useful in
verifying the core recovery of both the coal samples (for assurance that a sample is representative
of the full seam) and of the roof and floor rock samples (for evaluating ground control
characteristics of deep mineable coal seams).
In addition to core holes, rotary-drilled holes also exist on much of the Property. Data for the
rotary drilled holes are mainly derived from downhole geophysical logs, which are used to
interpret coal and rock thickness and depth since logging of the drill cuttings is not reliable. From
time to time, geological staff at MM&A have been engaged by Coronado to interpret geophysical
logs within specific areas of interest, the results of which have been added to the Coronado
geologic database. Moreover, MM&A field geologists have conducted gas content (desorption)
testing of core samples as part of an ongoing effort to assess levels of coalbed methane gas (
CBM
)
present within the seam. Additionally, there is an ongoing active surface drilling program for
degassing the mined seam ahead of mining. The degas holes are typically logged geophysically,
and the resulting interpreted data are incorporated into the geological model. Exploratory drilling
generally requires drilling to depths of over 305 meters to penetrate the target coal seam at
Buchanan.
A wide variety of core logging techniques exist for the Property. For many of the core holes, the
primary data source is a generalized lithology description by the driller, which may be
supplemented by a more detailed core log completed by a geologist. These logs were provided to
MM&A as a geological database. MM&A geologists were not involved in the production of
original core logs but did perform a basic check of information within the provided database.
Where geophysical logs for such holes are available, they were used by MM&A geologists to verify
the coal thickness and core recovery of seams.
7.4
Hydrology
Buchanan is an active mine with no hydrologic concerns or material issues experienced in its
history. Future mining is projected to occur in areas exhibiting similar hydrogeological conditions
as past mining, including stream undermining, undermining of aquifers, and mining through
hydraulically fractured (frac’d) coalbed methane wells. Based upon the successful history of the
operation with regards to hydrogeological conditions, MM&A assumes that the operation will not
be hindered by such issues in the future.
7.5
Geotechnical Data
Mining plans for potential underground mines were developed by Coronado and modified by
MM&A to fit current property constraints. Pillar stability was tested by MM&A using the
Analysis
of Retreat Mining Pillar Stability (ARMPS
) and
Analysis of Longwall Pillar Stability (ALPS)
that were developed by the
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (
NIOSH
)
.
MM&A reviewed the results from the ARMPS and ALPS analysis and considered them in the
development of the LOM plan.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
21
8
Sample Preparation, Analyses and Security
8.1
Prior to Sending to the Lab
Most of the coal samples have been obtained from the Property by subsurface exploration using
core drilling techniques. The protocol for preparing and testing the samples has varied over time
and is not well documented for the older holes drilled on the Property. Typical core-drilling
sampling methods for coal in the United States involves drilling through the seam, removing the
core from the barrel, describing the lithology, wrapping the sample in a sealed plastic sleeve and
placing it lengthwise into a covered core box, and carefully marking hole ID and depth intervals on
each box and lid, allowing the core to be delivered to a laboratory in correct stratigraphic order,
and with original moisture content. This process has been the norm for both historical and
ongoing exploration activities at the Property.
This work is typically performed by the supervising driller, geologist, or company personnel.
Samples are most often delivered to the company by the driller after each shift or acquired by
company personnel or representatives. Most of the coal core samples were obtained by previous
or current operators on the Property. MM&A did not participate in the collection, sampling, and
analysis of the core samples. However, it is reasonable to assume, given the consistency of quality
from previous operators, that these samples were generally collected and processed under
industry best practices. This assumption is based on MM&A’s familiarity with the operating
companies and the companies used to perform the analyses.
8.2
Lab Procedures
Coal-quality testing has been performed over many years by operating companies using different
laboratories and testing regimens. Some of the samples have raw analyses and washabilities on
the full seam (with coal and rock parting layers co-mingled) and are mainly useful for
characterizing the coal quality for projected production from underground mining. Other samples
have coal and rock analyzed separately, the results of which can be utilized to forecast
underground mining quality. Care has been taken to use only those analyses that are
representative of the coal quality parameters for the appropriate mining type for each sample.
Unlike many Appalachian properties, Buchanan has interest in a single deep-mineable seam, the
Pocahontas No. 3 seam; therefore, the analyses have been conducted following a consistent
protocol.
Standard procedure upon receipt of core samples by the testing laboratory is to: 1) log the depth
and thickness of the sample; then 2) perform testing as specified by a representative of the
operating company.
Samples are analyzed in accordance with procedures defined under
ASTM International (
ASTM
)
standards including, but not limited to (not all analytical tests identified in the list below have
been run on each sample): washability (ASTM D4371); ash (ASTM D3174); sulfur (ASTM D4239);
Btu/lb. (ASTM D5865); volatile matter (ASTM D3175); Free Swell Index (
FSI
) (ASTM D720).
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
22
While not confirmed by MM&A, it is assumed that best practices and ASTM (or equivalent
standards at the time of testing) were utilized in laboratory quality testing.
9
Data Verification
9.1
Procedures of Qualified Person
MM&A reviewed the digital geologic database supplied by Coronado. The database consists of
data records, which include drill hole information for holes that lie within and adjacent to the
Property and records for numerous supplemental coal seam thickness measurements. Upon
completion of the database verification, copies of each entry were printed, and cross referenced
to the original document for verification. Once the initial integrity of the database was
established, stratigraphic columnar sections were generated using cross-sectional analysis to
establish or confirm coal-seam correlations. Geophysical logs were used wherever available to
assist in confirming the seam correlation and to verify proper seam thickness measurements and
recovery of coal samples.
After establishing and/or verifying proper seam correlation, seam data-control maps and
geological cross-sections were generated and again used to verify seam correlations and data
integrity. Once the database was fully vetted, seam thickness, base-of-seam elevation, roof and
floor lithology, and overburden maps were independently generated for use in the mine planning
process.
9.2
Limitations
As with any exploration program, localized anomalies cannot always be discovered. The greater
the density of the samples taken, the less the risk. Once an area is identified as being of interest
for inclusion in the mine plan, additional samples are taken to help reduce the risk in those specific
areas. In general, provision is made in the mine planning portion of the study to allow for
localized anomalies that are typically classed more as a nuisance than a hinderance. Longwall
production has been de-rated in thinner coal zones.
9.3
Opinion of Qualified Person
Sufficient data have been obtained through various exploration and sampling programs and
mining operations to support the geological interpretations of seam structure and thickness for
coal horizons situated on the Property. The data are of sufficient quantity and reliability to
reasonably support the coal resource and coal reserve estimates in this TRS.
10
Mineral Processing and Metallurgical Testing
10.1
Testing Procedures
Separate tabulations have been compiled for basic chemical analyses (both raw and washed
quality), petrographic data, rheological data and chlorine, ash, ultimate and sulfur analysis. The
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
23
latter two data types are not as prevalent and have been supplemented by samples collected from
mine stockpiles and either truck- or train-shipment samples.
Available coal-quality data were tabulated by resource area in a Microsoft® EXCEL workbook and
the details of that work are maintained on file at the offices of Coronado and MM&A. These
tables also provide basic statistical analyses of the coal quality data sets, including average value;
maximum and minimum values; and the number of samples available to represent each quality
parameter of the seam. Coal samples that were deemed by MM&A geologists to be
unrepresentative were not used for statistical analysis of coal quality, as documented in the
tabulations. A representative group of drill hole samples from the Property were then checked
against the original drill laboratory reports to verify accuracy and correctness.
The amount and areal extent of coal sampling for geological data is generally sufficient to
represent the quality characteristics of the coal horizons and allow for proper market placement
of the subject coal seams. For some of the coal deposits there are considerable laboratory data
from core samples that are representative of the full extent of the resource area; and for others
there are more limited data to represent the resource area. For example, in the active operations
with considerable previous mining, there may be limited quality data within some of the
remaining resource areas; however, in those cases the core sampling data can be supplemented
with operational data from mining and shipped quality samples representative of the resource
area.
10.2
Relationship of Tests to the Whole
The extensive sampling and testing procedures typically followed in the coal industry result in an
excellent correlation between samples and marketable product. Shipped analyses of the coal
from Buchanan were reviewed to verify that the coal quality and characteristics were as expected.
Buchanan has a long history of saleable production in the low-volatile metallurgical markets,
confirming exploration results. Degradation of coking coal characteristics over time is not
anticipated to be an issue.
10.3
Lab Information
As noted previously, samples are analyzed at area Laboratories that operate in accordance with
procedures defined under ASTM standards including, but not limited to the following (Note: not
all analytical tests identified in this list have been run on each sample.):
>
ASTM D 4371
>
ASTM D 3174
>
ASTM D 4239
Temperature Tube Furnace Combustion Methods
>
ASTM D 5865
>
ASTM D 3175
>
ASTM D 3176
– Standard Practice for Ultimate Analysis of Coal and Coke
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
24
>
ASTM D 3178
- Test Method for Carbon and Hydrogen in Coal and Coke
>
ASTM D 3179
-
Te
st Method for Nitrogen in Coal and Coke
>
ASTM D 720
FSI
) of Coal
>
ASTM D 5515
- Test Method for Determination of the Swelling Properties of Bituminous Coal
Using a Dilatometer (Arnu)
>
ASTM D 2639
>
ASTM D 3683
– Trace Elements in Coal and Coke Ash by the Atomic Absorption Method
>
ASTM D 1857
– Standard Test Method for Fusibility of Coal and Coke Ash
>
ASTM D 2798
– Microscopical Determination of the Reflectance of Vitrinite in a Polished
Specimen of Coal
Ultimate analysis is a process typically used which gives the composition of coal in terms of
carbon, hydrogen, nitrogen, oxygen, ash, and sulfur without regard to origin. The sum of the
carbon, hydrogen, nitrogen, sulfur, and ash are subtracted from 100 percent to calculate oxygen
percent.
Heating value or calorific value is a measure of the heat produced from a unit weight of coal. In
the United States, it is commonly expressed in British thermal units per pound (
Btu/lb.
). Other
units are kilocalories per kilogram (
Kcal/kg
) and kilojoules per gram (
KJ/g
). Heating value is
generally determined by burning a weighed coal sample, in oxygen, in a calorimeter.
10.4
Relevant Results
No critical factors have been found that would adversely affect the recovery of the Reserve.
11
Mineral Resource Estimates
MM&A independently created a geologic model to define the coal resources at Buchanan. Coal
resources were estimated as of December 31, 2022.
11.1
Assumptions, Parameters and Methodology
Geological data were imported into Carlson Mining
®
®
) geological modelling
software in the form of Microsoft
®
picks, bottom seam elevations and raw and washed coal quality. These data files were validated
prior to importing into the software. Once imported, a geologic model was created, reviewed, and
verified with a key element being a gridded model of coal seam thickness.
Resource tonnes were estimated by using the seam thickness grid based on each valid point of
observation and by defining resource confidence arcs around the points of observation. Points of
observation for Measured and Indicated confidence arcs were defined for all valid drill holes that
intersected the seam using standards deemed acceptable by MM&A based on a detailed geologic
evaluation and a statistical analysis of all drill holes within the projected reserve areas as described
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
25
in
Section 11.1.1
. The geological evaluation incorporated an analysis of seam thickness related to
depositional environments, adjacent roof and floor lithologies, and structural influences.
After validating coal seam data and establishing correlations, the thickness and elevation for
seams of economic interest were used to generate a geologic model. Due to the relative
structural simplicity of the deposits and the reasonable continuity of the tabular coal beds, the
principal geological interpretation necessary to define the geometry of the coal deposits is the
proper modeling of their thickness and elevation. Both coal thickness and quality data are
deemed by MM&A to be reasonably sufficient within the resource areas. Therefore, there is a
reasonable level of confidence in the geologic interpretations required for coal resource
determination based on the available data and the techniques applied to the data.
Table 11-1
the coal resource and reserve evaluation. These cut-off parameters have been developed by
MM&A based on its experience with the Coronado property and are typical of mining operations
in the Central Appalachian coal basin. This experience includes technical and economic
evaluations of numerous properties in the region for the purposes of determining the economic
viability of the subject coal reserves.
Table 11-1: General Reserve and Resource Criteria
Item
Parameters
Technical Notes & Exceptions*
• General Reserve Criteria
Reserve Classification
Reserve and Resource
Reliability Categories
Reserve (Proven and Probable)
Resource (Measured, Indicated and Inferred)
To better reflect geological conditions of the coal
deposits, distance between points of observation is
standard USGS (in meters), respectively, for measured
and indicated and inferred.
Effective Date of Resource Estimate
December 31, 2022
Coal resources were updated for depletion based on
information from Coronado. Effective date for coal
resources is as of December 31, 2022.
Effective Date of Reserve Estimate
December 31, 2022
Coal reserves were updated for depletion based on
information from Coronado. Effective date for coal
reserves is as of December 31, 2022.
Seam Density
Variable, dependent upon seam characteristics
(based on available drill hole quality). In the
absence of laboratory data, estimated by (1)
assuming specific gravity of 1.30 for coal and 2.25
to 2.5 for rock parting, or (2) 1280 kg/m
3
kg/m
3
• Underground-Mineable Criteria
Map Thickness
Total seam thickness
Minimum Seam Thickness
1.2 meters (locally <1.2 m for limited areas
integral to the mine plan)
Minimum Mining Thickness
1.83 meters
Minimum In-Seam Wash Recovery
40 percent
Wash Recovery Applied to Coal
Reserves
Based on average yield for drill holes within
reserve area, or in the absence of laboratory
washability data, based on estimated visual
recovery using specific gravities noted above and
95 percent yield on "clean" coal
Out-of-Seam Dilution Thickness for
Run-of-Mine Tonnes Applied to Coal
Reserves
0.05 meters
2243 kg/m³ density used for dilution tonnage estimate
Mine Barrier
61-meter distance from abandoned mines and
sealed or pillared areas.
Adjustments Applied to Coal Reserves
6 percent moisture increase; 5 percent
preparation plant inefficiency
Note: Exceptions for application of these criteria to resource and reserve estimation are made as warranted and demonstrated by either actual mining
experience or detailed data that allows for empirical evaluation of mining conditions. Final classification of coal reserve is made based on the pre-
feasibility evaluation.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
26
11.1.1
Geostatistical Analysis for Classification
MM&A completed a geostatistical analysis on drill holes within the reserve boundaries to
determine the applicability of the common United States classification system for measured and
indicated and inferred coal resources. Historically, the United States has assumed that coal within
0.4 kilometers of a point of observation represents a measured resource whereas coal between
0.4 kilometer and 1.2 kilometers from a point of observation is classified as indicated. Inferred
resources are commonly assumed to be located between 1.2 kilometers and 4.8 kilometers from a
point of observation. Per SEC regulations, only measured and indicated resources may be
considered for reserve classification, respectively as proven and probable reserves.
MM&A performed a geostatistical analysis of the Buchanan data set using the Drill Hole Spacing
Analysis (
DHSA
) method. This method attempts to quantify the uncertainty of applying a
measurement from a central location to increasingly larger square blocks and provides
recommendations for determining the distances between drill holes for measured, indicated, and
inferred resources.
To perform DHSA the data set was processed to remove any erroneous data points, clustered data
points, as well as directional trends. This was achieved through the use of histograms, as seen in
Figure 11-1
, color coded scatter plots showing the geospatial positioning of the borings,
Figure 11-
2
, and trend analysis.
Figure 11-1: Histogram of the Total Seam
Thickness for the Pocahontas No. 3 Seam Present
in the Buchanan Mine Complex
Figure 11-2: Scatter plot of the Total Seam
Thickness for the Pocahontas No. 3 Seam Present in
the Buchanan Mine Complex
Following the completion of data processing, a variogram of the data set was created,
Figure 11-3
.
The variogram plots average square difference against the separation distance between the data
pairs. The separation distance is broken up into separate bins defined by a uniform lag distance
(e.g., for a lag distance of 152 meters the bins would be 0 – 152 meters, 153 – 305 meters, etc.).
Each pair of data points that are less than one lag distance apart are reported in the first bin. If
the data pair is further apart than one lag distance but less than two lag distances apart, then the
variance is reported in the second bin. The numerical average for differences reported for each
bin is then plotted on the variogram. Care was taken to define the lag distance in such a way as to
not overestimate any nugget effect present in the data set. Lastly, modeled equations, often
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
27
spherical, gaussian, or exponential, are applied to the variogram in order to represent the data set
across a continuous spectrum.
Figure 11-3: Variogram of the Total Seam Thickness for the Pocahontas No. 3 Seam
Present in the Buchanan Mine Complex
The estimation variance is then calculated using information from the modeled variogram as well
as charts published by Journel and Huijbregts (1978). This value estimates the variance from
applying a single central measurement to increasingly larger square blocks. Care was taken to
ensure any nugget effect present was added back into the data. This process was repeated for
each test block size.
The final step of the process is to calculate the global estimation variance. In this step, the
number of square blocks that would fit inside the selected study area is determined for each block
size that was investigated in the previous step. The estimation variance is then divided by the
number of blocks that would fit inside the study area for each test block size. Following this
determination, the data is then transformed back to represent the relative error in the 95th-
percentile range.
Figure 11-4
shows the results of the DHSA performed on the Pocahontas No. 3 seam data for the
Buchanan Mine. DHSA provides hole to hole spacing values; these distances need to be converted
to radius from a central point in order to compare to the historical standards. A summary of the
radius data is shown in
Table 11-2
. DHSA prescribes that measured, indicated, and inferred drill
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
28
hole spacing be determined at the 10-percent, 20-percent, and 50-percent levels of relative error,
respectively.
Figure 11-4: Result of DHSA for the Pocahontas No. 3 Seam Present in the Buchanan Mine Complex
Table 11-2: DHSA Results Summary for Radius from a Central Point
Model:
Measured Radial Distance
(10% Relative Error)
Indicated Radial Distance
(20% Relative Error)
Inferred Radial Distance
(50% Relative Error)
(km)
(km)
(km)
Gaussian:
0.71
1.10
2.76
Spherical:
0.71
1.08
2.67
Exponential:
0.67
1.08
3.08
Comparing the results of the DHSA to the historical standards, it is evident that the historical
standards are more conservative than even the most conservative DHSA model with regards to
determining measured resources. The Exponential model recommends using a radius of 0.67
kilometers for measured resources compared to the historical value of 0.4 kilometers. With
respect to indicated resources, the DHSA falls in line closely with the historical standards. The
Exponential and Spherical models recommend using a radius 1.08 kilometers, while the Gaussian
model recommends a radius of 1.10 kilometers. These values line up closely with the historical
radius of 1.2 kilometers. These results have led the QPs to report the data following the historical
classification standards, rather than use the results of the DHSA.
11.2
Qualified Person’s Estimates
Mineral resources, representing in-situ coal from a portion of which reserves are derived, are
presented below. Based on the work described and detailed modelling of the areas considering all
the parameters defined, a coal resource estimate, summarized in
Table 11-3
, was prepared as of
December 31, 2022, for property controlled by Coronado.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
29
Table 11-3: Coal Resources Summary as of December 31, 2022
Coal Resource (Dry Tonnes, In Situ, Mt)
Resource Quality (Dry)
Area
Measured
Indicated
Inferred
Total
Ash%
Sulfur%
VM%
Inclusive of Reserves
158.0
10.2
0.0
168.2
25
0.7
16
Exclusive of Reserves
33.9
5.9
0.0
39.8
Total 12/31/2022
191.9
16.1
0.0
208.0
Note 2: Coal resources are reported on a dry basis. Surface moisture and inherent moisture are excluded.
Note 3: The Property contains 39.8 Mt of dry, in-place measured and indicated coal resources exclusive of reserves as of December 31, 2022.
11.3
Resources Exclusive of Reserves
The Property contains multiple resource blocks which were not deemed to exhibit reserve
potential at the time of the study. These resources, formally identified as resources exclusive of
reserves, are located in the Pocahontas No. 3 coal seam. Reasons which may preclude elevation
of resources to reserves include, but are not limited to:
1.
Insufficient density of drilling and/or coal quality data available at the time of this evaluation.
2.
Unfavorable economics at the PFS level, yet economics could become attractive in the future
under different market conditions.
3.
Exclusion from LOM planning by mining operator due to remaining resource blocks which are
relatively small, isolated blocks and not currently attractive from an operational perspective.
Multiple resource blocks in the active Buchanan Mine have not been considered as reserve
due to relatively small size and isolation.
11.3.1
Initial Economic Assessment
MM&A completed an initial economic assessment to determine the potential economic viability of
resources exclusive of reserves. Unlike the economic analysis presented in
Section
to test reserves, the initial economic assessment below is presented on a real basis in 2022 dollars.
MM&A applied relevant technical factors to estimate potential saleable tonnes without the
resource blocks, should the resources be extracted via deep, continuous mining methods (given
that their irregular and isolated nature
may
MM&A developed cash cost profiles for the resource blocks, including direct cash costs (labor,
supplies, roof control, maintenance and repair, power, and other); washing, trucking, materials
handling, general and administrative, and environmental costs; and indirect cash costs (royalties,
production taxes, property tax, insurance). Costs were developed based off relevant cost drivers
(per-meter, per-raw-tonne, per-clean-tonne). Additionally, MM&A estimated capital costs to
extract resources. Capital costs associated with mine development were amortized across the
resource’s potential saleable tonnages. Additional non-cash items (depreciation of equipment and
depletion) and cash costs were compared to an assumed sale price of $110 per tonne (FOB
loadout), representing the long-term average price forecast for Buchanan supplied by Coronado.
The results of the analysis are shown below and demonstrate potential profitability on a fully
loaded cost basis. Detailed summaries are shown in
Appendix D
.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
30
Table 11-4: Results of Initial Economic Assessment
Seam
Resource
Block
Direct Cash
Transportation,
Washing, Enviro,
G&A
Indirect
Non-Cash
Total Cost
Fully
Loaded P&L
P3
N, NE, NW
$58.63
$14.14
$7.52
$16.77
$97.06
$13.18
Figure 11-5: Results of Initial Economic Assessment
11.4
Qualified Person’s Opinion
While there is some level of stratigraphically controlled seam-thickness variability, the Pocahontas
No. 3 coal seam at Buchanan demonstrates reasonable thickness consistency according to the
classification system of
measured
indicated
inferred
delineated mineable regions to reflect the nature of each seam and the practicality of mining
constraints. Based on MM&A’s geostatistical analysis, it would be possible to extend the
measured arcs slightly beyond historically accepted practices due to consistent geological settings.
These results have led the QPs to report the data following the historical classification standards,
rather than use the results of the DHSA.
Based on the data review, the attendant work done to verify the data integrity and the creation of
an independent geologic model, the QPs believe this is a fair and accurate representation of the
Buchanan coal resources.
12
Mineral Reserve Estimates
12.1
Assumptions, Parameters and Methodology
Coal Reserves are classified as
proven
probable
mining, metallurgical, economic, marketing, legal, environmental, social, and governmental
factors.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
31
>
Proven Coal Reserves
adjusted for diluting materials and allowances for losses when the material is mined. It is based
on appropriate assessment and studies in consideration of and adjusted for reasonably
assumed modifying factors. These assessments demonstrate that extraction could be
reasonably justified at the time of reporting.
>
Probable Coal Reserves
in some circumstances a measured coal resource, adjusted for diluting materials and
allowances for losses when the material is mined. It is based on appropriate assessment and
studies in consideration of and adjusted for reasonably assumed modifying factors. These
assessments demonstrate that extraction could be reasonably justified at the time of reporting.
Upon completion of delineation and calculation of coal resources, MM&A generated a LOM plan
for Buchanan. The footprint of the reserve area is shown on the map in
Appendix B
. The Mine
plan was generated based on the forecast mine plan and permit plan provided by Coronado with
modifications by MM&A where necessary due to current property control limits, modifications to
geologic mapping, or other factors determined during the evaluation.
Carlson Mining software was used to generate the LOM plan for Buchanan. The mine plan was
sequenced based on productivity schedules provided by Coronado. MM&A judged the
productivity estimates and plans to be reasonable based on experience and current industry
practice.
At the Buchanan No. 1 Mine, a minimum mining height of 1.83 meters was used due to the
longwall mining method being employed. For coal seams thinner than the assigned mining height,
the difference between the coal seam height and assigned mining height consists of out-of-seam
dilution (
OSD
). Mine recovery generally varies between 40 and 60 percent for continuous mining
panels, and 100 percent for longwall. Plant recovery is a function of in-seam recovery, OSD and
plant efficiency factor, which is set at 95 percent. Typical entry width is 5.79 meters to 6.10
meters.
Raw, ROM production data outputs from LOM plan sequencing were processed into Microsoft
®
EXCEL spreadsheets and summarized on an annual basis for processing into the economic model.
Average seam densities were estimated to determine raw coal tonnes produced from the LOM
plan. Average mine recovery and wash recovery factors were applied to determine coal reserve
tonnes.
Coal reserve tonnes in this evaluation are reported at a 6.0-percent moisture basis and represent
the saleable product from the Property.
Pricing data as provided by Coronado is described in
Section 16.2
. The pricing data assumes a
weighted average domestic and international FOB-mine price of approximately $179 per metric
tonne for calendar year 2023. The weighted average price decreases to approximately $132 to
$143 per metric tonne through year 2027 and averages approximately $153 per metric tonne over
the LOM.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
32
The coal resource mapping and estimation process described in this report was used as a basis for
the coal reserve estimate. Proven and probable coal reserves were derived from the defined coal
resource considering relevant processing, economic (including technical estimates of capital,
revenue, and cost), marketing, legal, environmental, socio-economic, and regulatory factors and
are presented on a moist, recoverable basis.
As is customary in the US, the categories for proven and probable coal reserves are based on the
distances from valid points of measurement as determined by the QPs for the area under
consideration. For this evaluation, measured resource, which may convert to a proven reserve, is
based on a 0.4-kilometer radius from a valid point of observation.
Points of observation include exploration drill holes, degas holes, and mine measurements which
have been fully vetted and processed into a geologic model. The geologic model is based on seam
depositional modeling, the interrelationship of overlying and underlying strata on seam
mineability, seam thickness trends, the impact of seam structure (i.e., faulting), intra-seam
characteristics, etc. Once the geologic model was completed, a statistical analysis, described in
Section 11.1.1
selected to define Measured Resources.
Likewise, the distance between 0.4 and 1.2 of a kilometer radius was selected to define Indicated
Resources. Indicated Resources may convert to Probable Reserves.
There are no Inferred Resources (greater than a 1.2-kilometer radius from a valid point of
observation) at Buchanan.
12.2
Qualified Person’s Estimates
Reserve tonnage estimates provided herein report coal reserves derived from the in-situ resource
tonnes presented in
Table 11-3
, and not in addition to coal resources. Coal reserves are presented
on a ROM basis in
Table 12-1
. Proven and probable coal reserves were derived from the defined
coal resource considering relevant mining, processing, infrastructure, economic (including
estimates of capital, revenue, and cost), marketing, legal, environmental, socio-economic and
regulatory factors. The coal reserves, as shown in
Table 12-2
, are based on a technical evaluation
of the geology and a preliminary feasibility study of the coal deposits. The extent to which the
coal reserves may be affected by any known environmental, permitting, legal, title, socio-
economic, marketing, political, or other relevant issues has been reviewed rigorously. Similarly,
the extent to which the estimates of coal reserves may be materially affected by mining,
metallurgical, infrastructure and other relevant factors has also been considered.
Table 12-1: Coal ROM (Moist) Summary as of December 31, 2022
Demonstrated Coal Reserves (Mt, Moist ROM)
Quality (Dry)
By Reliability Category
By Mining Type
By Control Type
Area /
Mine
Proven
Probable
Total
Surface
UG
Owned
Leased
Subleased
Ash
Sulfur
Vol
Buchanan
144.9
8.7
153.6
0.0
153.6
21.7
127.9
4.0
42
0.7
12
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
33
Table 12-2: Coal Reserves Summary (Marketable Sales Basis) as of December 31, 2022
Demonstrated Coal Reserves (Wet Tons, Washed or Direct Shipped, Mt)
Quality (Dry Basis)
By Reliability Category
By Mining Type
By Control Type
Area / Mine
Proven
Probable
Total
Surface
UG
Owned
Leased
Subleased
Ash%
Sulfur%
VM%
Buchanan Mine Complex
87.5
5.4
92.9
0.0
92.9
14.4
75.9
2.6
6
0.7
19
surface and inherent moisture is modeled 6-percent. Actual product moisture is dependent upon multiple geological factors, operational
factors, and product contract specifications and can exceed 8-percent. As such, the modeled moisture values provide a level of conservatism
for reserve reporting.
As shown below, coal shipments during 2022 (primarily from the northern portion of the Property)
exhibit a year-to-date average quality comparable to quality projected from core samples (refer to
Table 12-2
>
Moisture content: 8.3%
>
Ash content: 5.8% (db)
>
Sulfur content: 0.7% (db)
>
VM content: 17% (db)
The results of this TRS define an estimated 92.9 Mt of proven and probable marketable coal
reserves. Of that total, 94 percent are proven, and 6 percent are probable. There are 14.4 Mt of
owned coal reserves and 75.9 Mt of leased coal and 2.6 Mt of subleased reserves. All the
Buchanan reserves are considered suitable for the metallurgical coal market, and all are assigned.
12.3
Qualified Person’s Opinion
The estimate of coal reserves was determined in accordance with the JORC Code along with SEC
Regulation S-K 1300.
The LOM mining plan for Buchanan was prepared to the level of preliminary feasibility. Mine
projections were prepared with a timing schedule to match production with coal seam
characteristics. Production timing was carried out from current locations to depletion of the coal
reserve area. Coal reserve estimates could be materially affected by the risk factors described in
Section 22.2
.
Based on the preliminary feasibility study and the attendant economic review, the QPs believe this
is a fair and accurate calculation of the Buchanan coal reserves.
13
Mining Methods
13.1
Geotech and Hydrology
Mining plans for potential underground mines were developed by Coronado and MM&A. Pillar
stability was tested by MM&A using the
Analysis of Retreat Mining Pillar Stability (ARMPS
) and
Analysis of Longwall Pillar Stability
(
ALPS
) programs that were developed by the
National Institute
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
34
for Occupational Safety and Health (
NIOSH
)
. MM&A reviewed the results from the ARMPS and
ALPS analysis and considered them in the development of the LOM plan.
Hydrology has not been an issue of concern at Buchanan. Based on numerous site visits to both
the surface and underground portions of the Property by the QPs, it has been determined that this
is not a significant concern. Mining of future reserves is projected to occur in areas which exhibit
similar hydrogeological characteristics as those formerly mined areas.
13.2
Production Rates
The Buchanan mine is active with six continuous mining sections and one longwall section
currently operating. Operations at Buchanan by Coronado and its predecessor have been ongoing
for many years. The mine plan and productivity expectations reflect historical performance and
efforts have been made to adjust the plan to reflect future conditions. MM&A is confident that
the mine plan is reasonably representative to provide an accurate estimation of coal reserves.
Mine development and operation have not been optimized within the TRS.
Longwall production is scheduled for approximately 295 to 312 days each year, which represents
production on Monday through Saturday with allowances for holidays and longwall moves. On
each day, the continuous mining sections and longwall produce coal on three shifts. The sections
are configured as regular sections with one continuous miner available for production on each
section. Productivity is planned at the rate of 18.2 meters to 21.3 meters of advance per shift of
operation for the continuous miner sections, and 5.79 meters to 7.32 meters per shift of longwall
retreat. A second longwall is scheduled to begin production in the first quarter of 2025.
Carlson Mining software was used by MM&A to generate mine plans for the underground
mineable coal seam. Coronado recently revised the Buchanan mine plan with an independent
headgate and tailgate for longwall panels in the South and Northeast districts. Such a change was
made to allow for an effective panel width of 982 feet, as opposed to an effective width of 688
feet used previously. The active areas in the North and East, along with the future Northwest
area, are still based on an effective panel width of approximately 688 feet. MM&A incorporated
this mine plan revision into the layout and subsequent reserve estimates contained herein. Mine
plans were sequenced based on productivity schedules provided by Coronado, which were based
on historically achieved productivity levels. All production forecasting ties assumed production
rates to geological models as constructed by MM&A’s team of geologists and mining engineers.
As shown in
Table 13-1
, the areas planned for underground production continue until 2044. Clean
coal production varies directly with coal thickness.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
35
Table 13-1: Summary of Production by Year (Tonnes x 1,000)
Mine Name
2023
2024
2025
2026
2027
2028
2029
2030
Buchanan
3,786
3,811
4,363
4,446
5,112
6,242
6,462
6,200
Mine Name
2031
2032
2033
2034
2035
2036
2037
2038
Buchanan
5,444
6,226
4,814
6,474
6,423
5,249
3,447
3,009
Mine Name
2039
2040
2041
2042
2043
2044
2045
2046
Buchanan
2,914
2,093
2,254
1,703
1,714
737
0
0
13.3
Mining Related Requirements
Although the continuous miner sections are significantly more expensive to operate on a cost-per-
tonne basis, they are necessary to open up areas of the mine for the longwall. At the time of this
study, Buchanan had 6 operating continuous miner stations that were used to develop main
entries and gate roads in preparation for the longwall. As the mine develops, this number will be
able to be reduced.
An additional requirement at Buchanan is the drilling of degas holes prior to mining. This process
was initially developed as a safety measure to extract methane from the coal seam prior to
exposure to the workforce. As such, it has been very effective.
More recently, the methane extracted has been able to be processed and sold. However,
degasifying of the coal seam will continue as a safety measure regardless.
13.4
Required Equipment and Personnel
The Buchanan Mine is currently Coronado’s only longwall operation. The longwall shearing
machine is used for extraction of coal at the production face. A chain conveyor is used to remove
coal from the longwall face for discharge onto the conveyor belt which then ultimately delivers it
to an underground storage bunker. Development for the longwall is conducted by the extraction
of coal from the production faces using continuous miners and haulage using shuttle cars to a
feeder-breaker located at the tail of the section conveyor belt. The feeder -breaker crushes large
pieces of coal and rock and regulates coal feed onto the mine conveyor. Roof-bolting machines
are used to support the roof on the development sections of the longwall mines. Roof-bolting
machines are used to install roof bolts, and battery scoops are available to clean the mine entries
and assist in delivery of mine supplies to work areas. Other supplemental equipment such as
personnel carriers, supply vehicles, etc., are also used daily.
Mine conveyors typically range in width up to 1.83 meters. Multiple belt flights are arranged in
series to deliver raw coal to the underground storage. Along the main and sub-main entries and
panels, a travel way is provided for personnel and materials by rubber-tired equipment or on rail.
The Buchanan No. 1 Mine utilizes a skip hoist in order to transport ROM coal from the
underground storage bunker to the surface where the coal may be sampled, crushed and washed
in the preparation plant and stockpiled to await shipment.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
36
Surface ventilation fans are installed as needed to provide a sufficient volume of air to ventilate
production sections, coal haulage and transport entries, battery charging stations, and
transformers in accordance with approved plans. High-voltage cables deliver power throughout
the mine where transformers reduce voltage for specific equipment requirements.
The Mine
Improvement and New Emergency Response Act of 2006
MINER Act
) requires that carbon
monoxide detection systems be installed along mine conveyor belts and that electronic two-way
tracking and communications systems be installed throughout underground mines. Water is
required to control dust at production sections and along conveyor belts, and to cool electric
motors. Water is available from nearby sources and is distributed within the mine by pipelines as
required. A total of 588 salary and hourly employees are assigned to the mine in 2023, and a total
of 672 salary and hourly employees are assigned to the mine beginning in 2025 when the second
longwall begins operation.
14
Processing and Recovery Methods
14.1
Description or Flowsheet
Coronado currently operates a coal preparation plant at Buchanan. The Buchanan Plant operates
at a feed rate of approximately 1,270 raw tonnes per hour (
tph
). Coarse material is washed in a
heavy medium vessel, the intermediate-size material is washed in heavy medium cyclones and
fine material is washed using froth flotation. These processes are supported by the requisite
screens, centrifuges, vacuum filters, sumps, pumps, and distribution systems. Processes and
equipment are typical of those used in the coal industry and are in use in nearly all plants in the
Central Appalachian Basin.
14.2
Requirements for Energy, Water, Material and Personnel
Personnel have historically been sourced from the surrounding communities in Buchanan,
Tazewell, McDowell, and Pike Counties, and have proven to be adequate in numbers to operate
the mine. As mining is common in the surrounding areas, the workforce is generally familiar with
mining practices, and many are experienced miners.
The Buchanan No. 1 Mine Complex has sources of water, power, personnel, and supplies readily
available for use. Water is sourced locally from a nearby abandoned underground mine.
Electricity is sourced from AEP. The service industry in the areas surrounding the mine complex
has historically provided supplies, equipment repairs and fabrication, etc.
15
Infrastructure
The Coronado-owned Buchanan Preparation Plant services the mine via a skip hoist and conveyor
belt system which transports extracted coal from an underground bunker to the surface facility.
The NS rail line serves as the main means of transport from the mine.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
37
As an active operation, the necessary support infrastructure for Buchanan is in place. In addition
to the plant and loadout, there are also portal facilities, including personnel access to the mine,
ventilation fans and a coal hoisting skip shaft. A map of the existing facilities in
Figure 15-1
.
Figure 15-1: Buchanan Surface Facilities
16
Market Studies
16.1
Market Description
The quality characteristics for the subject coal resources and coal reserves have been reviewed in
detail by MM&A. The drill hole data were utilized to develop average coal quality characteristics
for the mining site. These average coal quality characteristics were then utilized as the basis for
determining the various markets into which the saleable coal will likely be placed.
The projected quality specifications for the Buchanan products are as shown in
Table 16-1
.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
38
Table 16-1: Quality Specifications by Product
Buchanan
HCC
PCI
Moisture (%)
7.50
7.50
Ash (%)
5.50
6.00
Sulfur (%)
0.75
0.85
Volatile Matter (%)
18.00
18.00
Btu/lb.
N/A
14,926
Fluidity (ddpm)
130
N/A
MMR (%)
1.69
N/A
CSR
40
N/A
FSI
8.5
N/A
Note: All Specs are dry basis except Moisture and Thermal
All the mine production serves the metallurgical markets. The metallurgical coal is marketed as a
low-volatile (typically less than 23 percent volatile matter content) product.
16.2
Price Forecasts
Coronado provided MM&A with price forecasts for the Buchanan operation. Customer coal
pricing is derived from market observed forward estimates based on global economic supply and
demand analysis which is applied to mine plan sales volumes and product mix and is
supplemented with Coronado’s in-house knowledge of applicable rail transportation charges,
ocean freight charges and port charges. Concurrent with the active operation, Buchanan’s
production is assumed to enter domestic and international low volatile coking coal markets.
Pricing provided by Coronado assumes applicable quality adjustments. Pricing was provided
through calendar year 2044.
Coal price forecasts for the Buchanan products were provided by Coronado for various coal
markets in terms of US nominal dollars per metric tonne.
16.3
Contract Requirements
Some contracts are necessary for successful marketing of the coal. For Buchanan, since all mining,
preparation and marketing is done in-house, the remaining contracts required are:
>
Transportation
customers or to the Pier 6 export terminal for overseas shipment.
>
Handling
handled by annual negotiations based on projected shipments.
>
Sales
– Sales contracts are a mix of spot and contract sales. With the volatility of the market,
long-term contracts are not typically written.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
39
17
Environmental Studies, Permitting and Plans,
Negotiations or Agreements with Local Individuals
17.1
Results of Studies
MM&A completed a Limited Phase I Environmental Site Assessment (
ESA
) on the Property in April
2016 on behalf of Coronado. Coronado reports not having conducted such a study since the
MM&A study. The ESA
records, a database search of state and federal regulatory records and interviews to identify
potential recognized environmental conditions (
RECs
) that may create environmental liability for
the sites. MM&A concluded that no long-term liabilities existed at the time of the ESA.
Based on the former ESA completed by MM&A, it is the QPs’ opinion that Buchanan generally has
a record consistent with industry standards regarding compliance with applicable mining, water
quality, and environmental laws. Estimated costs for mine closure, including water quality
monitoring during site reclamation, are included in the financial models.
17.2
Requirements and Plans for Waste Disposal
Based on a study commissioned by Coronado in June 2020, the current Buchanan refuse disposal
site adjacent to the preparation plant has a capacity of 29 million cubic meters (
CM
) as currently
designed; with an additional lift (No. 11), the capacity is 37 million CM. Projected requirements
within the MM&A financial model are 28.0 million CM. Permitting for such an expansion is
anticipated to be achievable.
17.3
Permit Requirements and Status
All mining operations are subject to federal and state laws and must obtain permits to operate
mines, coal preparation and related facilities, haul roads, and other incidental surface
disturbances necessary for mining to occur. Permits generally require that the permittee post a
performance bond in an amount established by the regulatory program to provide assurance that
any disturbance or liability created during mining operations is properly restored to an approved
post-mining land use and that all regulations and requirements of the permits are fully satisfied
before the bond is returned to the permittee. Significant penalties exist for any permittee who
fails to meet the obligations of the permits including cessation of mining operations, which can
lead to potential forfeiture of the bond. Any company, and its directors, owners and officers,
which are subject to bond forfeiture can be denied future permits under the program.
1
New permits or permit revisions will occasionally be necessary to facilitate the expansion or
addition of new mining areas on the properties, such as amendments to existing permits and new
permits for mining of reserve areas. Exploration permits are also required. Property under lease
includes provisions for exploration among the terms of the lease. New or modified mining permits
are subject to a public advertisement process and comment period, and the public is provided an
1
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
40
opportunity to raise objections to any proposed mining operation. MM&A is not aware of any
specific prohibition of mining on the subject property and given sufficient time and planning,
Coronado should be able to secure new permits to maintain its planned mining operations within
the context of current regulations. Necessary permits are in place to support current production
on the Property, but future permits are required to maintain and expand production. Portions of
the Property are located near local communities. Regulations prohibit mining activities within
91.44 meters of a residential dwelling, school, church, or similar structure unless written consent
is first obtained from the owner of the structure. Where required, such consents have been
obtained where mining is proposed beyond the regulatory limits.
Coronado has obtained all mining and discharge permits to operate its mines and processing,
loadout, or related facilities. MM&A is unaware of any obvious or current Coronado permitting
issues that are expected to prevent the issuance of future permits. Buchanan, along with all coal
producers, is subject to a level of uncertainty regarding future clean water permits due to
United
States Environmental Protection Agency
(
EPA
)
and
United States Fish and Wildlife (
USFW
)
involvement with state programs.
The active Mining permit currently held by Buchanan is shown in
Table 17-1.
Table 17-1: Buchanan Mining Permit
Type
Permit ID
Permit Name
$ Bond
Current
Status
Issued Date
Expiration
Date
Hectares
NPDES No.
Coal Underground
1402152
Buchanan No. 1
Mine
$2,484,000
Active
03/08/1983
03/08/2023
334.79
VA0082152
17.4
Local Plans, Negotiations or Agreements
MM&A found no indication of agreements beyond the scope of federal or state regulations.
17.5
Mine Closure Plans
Applicable regulations require that mines be properly closed, and reclamation commenced
immediately upon abandonment. In general, site reclamation includes removal of structures,
backfilling, regrading, and revegetation of disturbed areas. Sediment control is required during
the establishment of vegetation, and bond release generally requires a minimum five-year period
of site maintenance, water sampling, and sediment control following mine completion. This
requirement is reduced to two years for certain operations involving re-mining. Reclamation of
underground mines includes closure and sealing of mine openings such as portals and shafts in
addition to the items listed above.
Estimated costs for mine closure, including water quality monitoring during site reclamation, are
included in the financial model. As with all mining companies, an accretion calculation is
performed annually so the necessary Asset Retirement Obligations (
ARO
) can be shown as a
Liability on the balance sheet.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
41
17.6
Qualified Person’s Opinion
The Buchanan Mine is an operating facility; all necessary permits for current production have been
obtained. The QPs know
obtained.
Estimated expenditures for site closure and reclamation are included in the financial model for
this site.
18
Capital and Operating Costs
18.1
Capital Cost Estimate
The production sequence selected for a property must consider the proximity of each reserve area
to coal preparation plants, river docks and railroad loading points, along with suitability of
production equipment to coal seam conditions. The in-place infrastructure was evaluated, and
any future needs were planned to a level suitable for a Preliminary Feasibility Study and included
in the Capital Forecast.
Coronado provided MM&A with an inventory of operating equipment available at Buchanan.
MM&A’s capital schedules assume that major equipment rebuilds occur over the course of each
machine’s remaining assumed operating life. Replacement equipment was scheduled based on
MM&A’s experience and knowledge of mining equipment and industry standards with respect to
the useful life of such equipment.
A summary of the estimated capital for the Property is provided in
Figure 18-2
Figure 18-1: CAPEX
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
42
18.2
Operating Cost Estimate
Coronado provided historical and a preliminary five-year projection of operating costs for MM&A’s
review. MM&A used the historical and/or budget cost information as a reference and developed a
personnel schedule for the mine. Hourly labor rates and salaries were based upon information
contained in Coronado’s financial summaries. Fringe-benefit costs were developed for vacation
and holidays, federal and state unemployment insurance, retirement, workers’ compensation and
pneumoconiosis, casualty and life insurance, healthcare, and bonuses. A cost factor for mine
supplies was developed that relates expenditures to mine advance rates for roof-control costs and
other mine-supply costs experienced at underground mines. Other factors were developed for
maintenance and repair costs, rentals, mine power, outside services and other direct mining costs.
Other cost factors were developed for coal preparation plant processing, refuse handling, coal
loading, property taxes, and insurance and bonding. Appropriate royalty rates were assigned for
production from leased coal lands, and sales taxes were calculated for state severance taxes, the
federal black lung excise tax, and federal and state reclamation fees.
Mandated Sales Related Costs such as Black Lung Excise are summarized in
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
43
Table 18-1: Estimated Coal Production Taxes and Sales Costs
Description of Tax or Sales Cost
Basis of Assessment
Cost
Federal Black Lung Excise Tax - Underground
Per Tonne
$1.21
Federal Reclamation Fees – Underground
Per Tonne
$0.13
Virginia Reclamation Tax – Underground
Per Tonne
$0.05
Virginia Severance Tax
2%
Royalties – Underground
Percentage of Revenue
4.0%
Notes:
1.
Federal black lung excise tax is paid only on coal sold domestically. MM&A assumed 45% of total
coal sales to be domestic in the economic analysis discussed below.
A summary of the projected Operating Costs is in
Table 18-2
.
Table 18-2: Buchanan Mine Operating Costs
YE
12/31
YE
12/31
YE
12/31
YE
12/31
YE
12/31
YE
12/31
YE
12/31
YE
12/31
Remaining
Total
2023
2024
2025
2026
2027
2028
2029
2030
LOM Average
ROM Production Tonnes
153.6
7.4
7.5
8.8
9.5
11.1
9.4
9.4
9.2
5.8
Yield
60.48%
50.98%
50.61%
49.81%
46.98%
46.16%
66.22%
68.89%
67.70%
64.48%
Saleable Production Tonnes
92.9
3.8
3.8
4.4
4.4
5.1
6.2
6.5
6.2
3.8
Thermal Tonnes
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Dommestic & Non-Asia
Export Met Tonnes
29.9
1.2
1.2
1.4
1.4
1.6
2.0
2.1
2.0
1.2
Export Met Tonnes
63.0
2.6
2.6
3.0
3.0
3.5
4.2
4.4
4.2
2.5
92.9
3.8
3.8
4.4
4.4
5.1
6.2
6.5
6.2
3.8
Cash Costs per Tonne:
Mining Costs
$65.99
$66.53
$66.60
$64.95
$64.94
$58.16
$51.67
$50.89
$53.95
$71.83
Processing and Transport
$8.22
$20.33
$9.40
$9.03
$9.11
$8.84
$6.32
$6.20
$6.44
$7.74
Sales Related Costs
$9.48
$9.78
$8.92
$8.04
$7.64
$8.60
$8.68
$8.84
$9.01
$10.05
G&A
$2.65
$3.79
$2.89
$2.54
$2.54
$2.27
$2.32
$2.36
$2.41
$2.70
$86.33
$100.43
$87.80
$84.55
$84.24
$77.88
$68.98
$68.30
$71.81
$92.31
19
Economic Analysis
19.1
Assumptions, Parameters and Methods
A pre-feasibility LOM plan was prepared by MM&A for the Buchanan operations. MM&A
prepared mine projections and production timing forecasts based on coal seam characteristics.
Production timing was carried out from 2023 to depletion (exhaustion) of the coal reserve areas,
which is projected for the year 2044. All costs and prices are based on 2022 nominal United States
dollars.
The Mine plan, productivity expectations and cost estimates generally reflect historical
performance by Coronado and efforts have been made to adjust plans and costs to reflect future
conditions. MM&A is confident that the mine plan and financial model are reasonably
representative to provide an accurate estimation of coal reserves.
Capital schedules were developed by MM&A for mine development, infrastructure, and on-going
capital requirements for the life of the mine. Staffing levels were prepared, and operating costs
estimated by MM&A. MM&A utilized historical cost data provided by Coronado and its own
knowledge and experience to estimate direct and indirect operating costs.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
44
The preliminary feasibility financial model, prepared for this TRS, was developed to test the
economic viability of the coal reserve area. The results of this financial model are not intended to
represent a bankable feasibility study, required for financing of any current or future mining
operations, but are intended to prove the economic viability of the estimated coal reserves. All
costs and prices are based on 2022 nominal United States dollars assuming a 2% inflation rate.
On an unlevered basis, the NPV of the project cash flows after taxes was estimated for the
purpose of classifying coal reserves. The project cash flows, excluding debt service, are calculated
by subtracting direct and indirect operating expenses and capital expenditures from revenue.
Direct costs include labor, drilling and blasting, operating supplies, maintenance and repairs,
facilities costs for materials handling, coal preparation, refuse disposal, coal loading, sampling and
analysis services, reclamation and general and administrative costs. Indirect costs include
statutory and legally agreed upon fees related to direct extraction of the mineral. The indirect
costs are the federal black lung tax, federal and state reclamation taxes, property taxes, local
transportation prior to delivery at rail or barge loading sites, coal production royalties, sales and
use taxes, income taxes and state severance taxes. Coronado’s historical costs provided a useful
reference for MM&A’s cost estimates.
Sales revenue is based on the metallurgical coal price information provided to MM&A by
Coronado.
Projected debt service is excluded from the P&L and cash flow model in order to determine
Enterprise Value.
The financial model expresses coal sales prices, operating costs, and capital expenditures in
current day dollars without adjustment for inflation. Capital expenditures and reclamation costs
are included based on engineering estimates for each mine by year. The Coronado division’s
existing allocations of administrative costs are continued in the future projections.
Coronado will pay royalties for the various current and projected operations. The royalty rates
vary by mining method and location. The royalty rates for Buchanan are estimated to be 4.0% of
the sales revenue.
The projection model also includes consolidated income tax calculations at the Coronado level,
incorporating statutory depletion calculations, as well as state income taxes, and a federal tax rate
of 21%. To the extent the mine generates net operating losses for tax purposes, the losses are
carried over to offset future taxable income. The terms “cash flows” and “project cash flows”
used in this report refer to after tax cash flows.
Consolidated cash flows are driven by annual sales tonnage, which at steady-state level ranges
from a peak of 6.5 million tonnes in 2034 to a low of 0.7 million tonnes in 2044. Projected
consolidated revenue ranges from $317.8 million to $1.019 billion at a steady state. Revenue
totals $14.2 billion for the project’s life.
Consolidated cash flow from operations is positive throughout the projected operating period,
with the exception of post-production years, due to end-of-mine reclamation spending.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
45
Consolidated cash flow from operations peaks at $424.3 million in 2035 and totals $5.2 billion over
the project’s life. Capital expenditures total $602.8 million through 2027 and $1.4 billion over the
project’s life.
Coal price forecasts for coal products were prepared by Coronado for its active operations. Such
prices were used for the revenue input into the financial model. Sales variable costs such as
production royalties and severance taxes were based upon the revenue input.
19.2
Results
The pre-feasibility financial model, prepared by MM&A for this TRS, was developed to test the
economic viability of each coal resource area. The results of this financial model are not intended
to represent a bankable feasibility study, as may be required for financing of any current or future
mining operations contemplated but are intended to prove the economic viability of the
estimated coal reserves. Optimization of the LOM plan was outside the scope of the engagement.
Figure 19-1
Table 19-1
and EBITDA for Buchanan.
Figure 19-1: Cash Costs per Tonne
As shown above, the Buchanan Mine’s average cash cost ranges between approximately $68 and
$111 per tonne for most of the operating period.
Table 19-1: Life-of-Mine Tonnage, P&L before Tax, and EBITDA
LOM
LOM
P&L
LOM
EBITDA
Tonnes
Pre-Tax P&L
Per Tonne
EBITDA
Per Tonne
Buchanan
92,923
$4,280,077
$46.06
$6,174,578
$66.45
As shown in
Table 19-1,
Coronado’s consolidated operations show positive LOM P&L and EBITDA of $4.3 billion and $6.2
billion, respectively. A summary of the key financial performance metrics projected through 2030
is provided below in
Table 19-2
.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
46
Table 19-2: Summary of Buchanan Key Financial Performance Metrics (2023-2030)
YE
12/31
YE
12/31
YE
12/31
YE
12/31
YE
12/31
YE
12/31
YE
12/31
YE
12/31
Remaining
Total
2023
2024
2025
2026
2027
2028
2029
2030
LOM Average
ROM Production Tonnes
153.6
7.4
7.5
8.8
9.5
11.1
9.4
9.4
9.2
5.8
Yield
60.48%
50.98%
50.61%
49.81%
46.98%
46.16%
66.22%
68.89%
67.70%
64.48%
Saleable Production Tonnes
92.9
3.8
3.8
4.4
4.4
5.1
6.2
6.5
6.2
3.8
Thermal Tonnes
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Domestic & Non-Asia
Export Met Tonnes
29.9
1.2
1.2
1.4
1.4
1.6
2.0
2.1
2.0
1.2
Export Met Tonnes
63.0
2.6
2.6
3.0
3.0
3.5
4.2
4.4
4.2
2.5
92.9
3.8
3.8
4.4
4.4
5.1
6.2
6.5
6.2
3.8
Cash Costs per Tonne:
Mining Costs
$65.99
$66.53
$66.60
$64.95
$64.94
$58.16
$51.67
$50.89
$53.95
$71.83
Processing and Transport
$8.22
$20.33
$9.40
$9.03
$9.11
$8.84
$6.32
$6.20
$6.44
$7.74
Sales Related Costs
$9.48
$9.78
$8.92
$8.04
$7.64
$8.60
$8.68
$8.84
$9.01
$10.05
G&A
$2.65
$3.79
$2.89
$2.54
$2.54
$2.27
$2.32
$2.36
$2.41
$2.70
$86.33
$100.43
$87.80
$84.55
$84.24
$77.88
$68.98
$68.30
$71.81
$92.31
EBITDA per Tonne
$66.45
$78.12
$55.04
$47.23
$48.98
$57.54
$69.15
$72.59
$71.90
$68.66
Expansion CapEx ($M)
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
Maintenance CapEx ($M)
$1,448.5
$135.8
$130.8
$111.9
$122.8
$101.6
$70.4
$50.2
$71.2
$46.7
$1,448.5
$135.8
$130.8
$111.9
$122.8
$101.6
$70.4
$50.2
$71.2
$46.7
After Tax Cash Flows were developed in order to calculate the NPV for this Property. The NPV is
estimated to be $1.562 billion at a discount rate of 10.0%. A summary of the Buchanan after-tax
cash flow is shown in
Table 19-3
.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
47
Table 19-3: Project Cash Flow Summary (000)
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
Total
2023
2024
2025
2026
2027
Production & Sales tonnes
92,924
3,786
3,811
4,363
4,446
5,112
Total Revenue
$14,194,747
$675,923
$544,435
$574,963
$592,283
$692,273
EBITDA
$6,174,578
$295,749
$209,789
$206,065
$217,757
$294,147
Net Income
$3,368,328
$179,131
$103,854
$91,899
$90,456
$138,196
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$5,181,846
$188,692
$200,765
$186,416
$195,463
$245,493
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(1,448,505)
$(135,766)
$(130,803)
$(111,896)
$(122,768)
$(101,557)
Net Cash Flow
$3,733,342
$52,926
$69,962
$74,520
$72,695
$143,936
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2028
2029
2030
2031
2032
2033
Production & Sales tonnes
6,242
6,462
6,200
5,444
6,226
4,814
Total Revenue
$862,187
$910,476
$890,951
$798,054
$930,819
$734,119
EBITDA
$431,599
$469,093
$445,727
$357,721
$458,785
$288,024
Net Income
$240,334
$262,860
$254,666
$197,893
$280,873
$159,996
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$339,674
$386,828
$379,000
$320,798
$362,834
$277,786
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(70,382)
$(50,228)
$(71,184)
$(59,572)
$(49,573)
$(65,133)
Net Cash Flow
$269,292
$336,600
$307,815
$261,226
$313,262
$212,653
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2034
2035
2036
2037
2038
2039
Production & Sales tonnes
6,474
6,423
5,249
3,447
3,009
2,914
Total Revenue
$1,007,101
$1,019,070
$849,433
$569,043
$506,626
$500,552
EBITDA
$501,730
$526,779
$424,763
$211,060
$168,369
$216,035
Net Income
$326,060
$344,381
$266,105
$105,424
$79,886
$116,181
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$372,442
$424,330
$368,367
$223,842
$158,704
$177,921
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(54,007)
$(69,272)
$(64,919)
$(77,383)
$(43,070)
$(35,719)
Net Cash Flow
$318,435
$355,058
$303,449
$146,459
$115,634
$142,202
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2040
2041
2042
2043
2044
2045
Production & Sales tonnes
2,093
2,254
1,703
1,714
737
-
Total Revenue
$366,649
$402,822
$309,918
$317,808
$139,240
$-
EBITDA
$108,191
$153,415
$80,892
$106,596
$2,291
$-
Net Income
$34,854
$71,326
$19,002
$46,332
$(34,676)
$(3,773)
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$119,167
$128,269
$89,128
$92,258
$24,650
$(47,861)
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$(50,131)
$(46,604)
$(24,930)
$(13,606)
$-
$-
Net Cash Flow
$69,036
$81,665
$64,198
$78,652
$24,650
$(47,861)
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
YE12/31
2046
2047
2048
2049
2050
2051
Production & Sales tonnes
-
-
-
-
-
-
Total Revenue
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
EBITDA
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
Net Income
$(1,534)
$(785)
$(403)
$(209)
$(0)
$(0)
Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities
$(16,273)
$(8,299)
$(4,232)
$(4,317)
$-
$-
Purchases of Property, Plant, and Equipment
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
$-
Net Cash Flow
$(16,273)
$(8,299)
$(4,232)
$(4,317)
$-
$-
19.3
Sensitivity
Sensitivity of the NPV results to changes in the key drivers is presented in the chart below. The
sensitivity study shows the NPV at the 10.0% discount rate when Base Case sales prices, operating
costs, and capital costs are increased and decreased in increments of 5% within a +/- 15% range.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
48
Figure 19-2: Sensitivity of NPV
As shown, NPV is quite sensitive to changes in sales price and operating cost estimates, and
slightly sensitive to changes in capital cost estimates.
20
Adjacent Properties
20.1
Information Used
No proprietary information associated with neighboring properties was used as part of this study.
21
Other Relevant Data and Information
MM&A performed a previous audit of all the properties in year 2017 for Coronado based on SEC
Industry Guide 7 standards. In addition, MM&A completed a Limited Phase I Environmental Site
Assessment (
ESA
) on the Property in 2016 on behalf of Coronado. MM&A has subsequently
conducted Joint Ore Reserve Committee (
JORC
) compliant resource and reserve assessments of
the Buchanan assets as of: (1) December 31, 2017, (2) December 31, 2020, and (3) December 31,
2021. By assignment, the JORC assessment included a preliminary feasibility level study of the
subject coal reserves, encompassing detailed mine planning and cost analysis through depletion of
Buchanan’s JORC-compliant coal reserves. MM&A utilized these former preliminary feasibility
studies as the basis of an updated study which meets those standards set forth by the SEC.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
49
22
Interpretation and Conclusions
22.1
Conclusion
Sufficient data have been obtained through various exploration and sampling programs and
mining operations to support the geological interpretations of seam structure and thickness for
coal horizons situated on the Property. The data are of sufficient quantity and reliability to
reasonably support the coal resource and coal reserve estimates in this TRS.
The geological data and preliminary feasibility study, which consider mining plans, revenue, and
operating and capital cost estimates are sufficient to support the classification of coal reserves
provided herein.
This geologic evaluation conducted in conjunction with the preliminary feasibility study is
sufficient to conclude that the 92.9 Mt of marketable underground coal reserves identified on the
Property are economically mineable under reasonable expectations of market prices for
metallurgical coal products, estimated operation costs, and capital expenditures.
22.2
Risk Factors
Risks have been identified for operational, technical and administrative subjects addressed in the
Pre-Feasibility Study. A risk matrix has been constructed to present the risk levels for all the risk
factors identified and quantified in the risk assessment process. The risk matrix and risk
assessment process are modelled according to the Australian and New Zealand Standard on Risk
Management (AS/NZS 4360).
The purpose of the characterization of the project risk components is to inform the project
stakeholders of key aspects of the Coronado projects that can be impacted by events whose
consequences can affect the success of the venture. The significance of an impacted aspect of the
operation is directly related to both the probability of occurrence and the severity of the
consequences. The initial risk for a risk factor is herein defined as the risk level after the potential
impact of the risk factor is addressed by competent and prudent management utilizing control
measures readily available. Residual risk for a risk factor is herein defined as the risk level
following application of special mitigation measures if management determines that the initial risk
level is unacceptable. Initial risk and residual risk can be quantified numerically, derived by the
product of values assigned to probability and consequence ranging from very low risk to very high
risk.
The probability and consequence parameters are subjective numerical estimates made by
practiced mine engineers and managers. Both are assigned values from 1 to 5 for which the value
1 represents the lowest probability and least consequence, and the value 5 represents the highest
probability and greatest consequence. The products, which define the Risk Level, are classified
from very low to very high.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
50
Risk Level Table (R = P x C)
Risk Level (R)
Very Low (1 to 2)
Low (3 to 5)
Moderate (6 to 11)
High (12 to 19)
Very High (20 to 25)
Risk aspects identified and evaluated during this assignment total 12. No residual risks are rated
Very High. One (1) residual risk is rated High. Seven (7) of the risk aspects could be associated
with Moderate residual risk. Four (4) of the risk aspects were attributed Low or Very Low residual
risks.
22.2.1
Governing Assumptions
The listing of the aspects is not presumed to be exhaustive. Instead that listing is presented based
on the experiences of the contributors to the TRS.
1.
The probability and consequence ratings are subjectively assigned, and it is assumed that
this subjectivity reasonably reflects the condition of the active and projected mine
operations.
2.
The Control Measures shown in the matrices presented in this chapter are not exhaustive.
They represent a condensed collection of activities that the author of the risk assessment
section has observed to be effective in coal mining scenarios.
3.
Mitigation Measures listed for each risk factor of the operation are not exhaustive. The
measures listed, however, have been observed by the author to be effective.
4.
The monetary values used in ranking the consequences are generally-accepted quantities for
the coal mining industry.
22.2.2
Limitations
The risk assessment proposed in this report is subject to the limitations of the information
currently collected, tested, and interpreted at the time of the writing of this report.
22.2.3
Methodology
The numerical quantities (i.e., risk levels) attributable to either “initial” or “residual” risks are
derived by the product of values assigned to probability and consequence ranging from very low
risk to very high risk.
R = P x C
Where:
R = Risk Level
P = Probability of Occurrence
C = Consequence of Occurrence
The Probability (P) and Consequence (C) parameters recited in the formula are subjective
numerical estimates made by practiced mine engineers and managers. Both P and C are assigned
integer values ranging from 1 to 5 for which the value 1 represents the lowest probability and
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
51
least consequence, and the value 5 represents the highest probability and greatest consequence.
The products (R = P x C) which define the Risk Level, are thereafter classified from very low to very
high.
Risk Level Table
Risk Level (R)
Very Low (1 to 2)
Low (3 to 5)
Moderate (6 to 11)
High (12 to 19)
Very High (20 to 25)
Very high initial risks are considered to be unacceptable and require corrective action well in
advance of project development. In short, measures must be applied to reduce very high initial
risks to a tolerable level.
As shown and discussed above, after taking into account the operational, technical, and
administrative actions that have been applied or are available for action when required, the
residual risk can be determined. The residual risk provides a basis for the management team to
determine if the residual risk level is acceptable or tolerable. If the risk level is determined to be
unacceptable, further actions should be considered to reduce the residual risk to acceptable or
tolerable levels to provide justificati on for continuation of the proposed operation.
22.2.4
Development of the Risk Matrix
Risks have been identified for the technical, operational, and administrative subjects addressed in
the TRS. The risk matrix and risk assessment process are modelled according to the Australian and
New Zealand Standard on Risk Management (AS/NZS 4360).
22.2.4.1
Probability Level Table
Table 22-1: Probability Level Table
Category
Probability Level (P)
1
Remote
Not likely to occur except in exceptional circumstances.
<10%
2
Unlikely
Not likely to occur; small in degree.
10 - 30%
3
Possible
Capable of occurring.
30 - 60%
4
Likely
High chance of occurring in most circumstances.
60 - 90%
5
Almost Certain
Event is expected under most circumstances; impossible to avoid.
>90%
The lowest rated probability of occurrence is assigned the value of 1 and described as remote,
with a likelihood of occurrence of less than 2 percent. Increasing values are assigned to each
higher probability of occurrence, culminating with the value of 5 assigned to incidents considered
to be almost certain to occur.
22.2.4.2
Consequence Level Table
Table 22-2
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
52
Table 22-2: Consequence Level Table
Correlation of Events in Key Elements of the Project Program to Event Severity Category
Category
Severity of
the Event
Financial Impact
of the Event
Unplanned
Loss of
Production
(Impact on
Commercial
Operations)
Events Impacting
on the Environment
Events Affecting the Program's
Social and Community
Relations
Resultant Regulatory /
Sovereign Risk
Events Affecting Occupational Health &
Safety
1
Insignificant
< USD $0.5
million
≤ 12 hours
Insignificant loss of
habitat; no
irreversible effects
on water, soil and
the environment.
Occasional nuisance impact on
travel.
-
Event recurrence avoided by corrective
action through established procedures
(Engineering, guarding, training).
2
Minor
USD $0.5 million
to $2.0 million
≤ 1 day
No significant
change to species
populations; short-
term reversible
perturbation to
ecosystem function.
Persistent nuisance impact on
travel. Transient adverse media
coverage.
-
First aid – lost time.
avoided by corrective action through
established procedures.
3
Moderate
USD $2.0 million
to $10.0 million
≤ 1 week
Appreciable change
to species
population;
medium-term (≤10
years) detriment to
ecosystem function.
Measurable impact on travel
and water/air quality.
Significant adverse media
coverage / transient public
outrage.
Uncertainty securing or
retaining essential
approval / license.
Medical Treatment –
permanent
incapacitation. Avoiding event
recurrence requires modification to
established corrective action procedures
.
Change to regulations
(tax; bonds; standards).
4
Major
USD $10.0
million to $50.0
million
1 to 2 weeks
Change to species
population
threatening
viability; long-term
(>10 years)
detriment to
ecosystem function.
Long-term, serious impact on
travel and use of water
resources; degradation of air
quality; sustained and effective
public opposition.
Suspension / long-delay
in securing essential
approval / license.
Fatality.
requires modification to established
corrective action procedures and staff
retraining.
Change to laws (tax;
bonds; standards).
5
Critical
>USD $50.0
million
>1 month
Species extinction;
irreversible damage
to ecosystem
function.
Loss of social license.
Withdraw / failure to
secure essential
approval / license.
Multiple fatalities.
Avoiding event
recurrence requires major overhaul of
policies and procedures.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
53
The lowest rated consequence is assigned the value of 1 and is described as an Insignificant
Consequence, parameters of which include non-reportable safety incidents with zero days
lost accidents, no environmental damage, loss of production or systems for less than one
week and cost of less than USD $0.5 million. Increasing values are assigned to each higher
consequence, culminating with the value of 5 assigned to critical consequences, the
parameters of which include multiple-fatality accidents, major environmental damage, and
loss of production or systems for longer than one month and cost of greater than USD $50.0
million.
Composite Risk Matrix R = P x C and Color-Code Convention
The risk level, defined as the product of probability of occurrence and consequence, ranges
in value from 1 (lowest possible risk) to 25 (maximum risk level). The values are color-coded
to facilitate identification of the highest risk aspects.
Table 22-3: Risk Matrix
P x C = R
Consequence (C)
Insignificant
Minor
Moderate
Major
Critical
1
2
3
4
5
Probability Level (P)
Remote
1
1
2
3
4
5
Unlikely
2
2
4
6
8
10
Possible
3
3
6
9
12
15
Likely
4
4
8
12
16
20
Almost
Certain
5
5
10
15
20
25
22.2.5
Categorization of Risk Levels and Color Code Convention
Very high risks are considered to be unacceptable and require corrective action. Risk
reduction measures must be applied to reduce very high risks to a tolerable level.
22.2.6
Description of the Coal Property
The Buchanan Mine Complex is located in Buchanan and Tazewell Counties, Virginia and
operates a longwall section with supporting continuous mining sections. Operations are
projected to continue in the present mode until reserves are depleted in 2044.
22.2.7
Summary of Residual Risk Ratings
Each risk factor is numbered, and a risk level for each is determined by multiplying the
assigned probability by the assigned consequence. The risk levels are plotted on a risk
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
54
matrix to provide a composite view of the Coronado risk profile. The average risk level is
7.1, which is defined as Moderate.
Table 22-4:
Risk Assessment Matrix
Consequence
Critical
>$50 MM
8,9
Major
$10-50MM
6
Moderate
$2-10 MM
11
1,2,4
3
Minor
$0.5-$2 MM
12
5
7
Low
<$0.5 MM
10
<10%
10-30%
30-60%
60-90%
>90%
Remote
Unlikely
Possible
Likely
Almost
Certain
22.2.8
Risk Factors
A high-level approach is utilized to characterize risk factors that are generally similar across
a number of the active and proposed mining operations. Risk factors that are unique to a
specific operation or are particularly noteworthy are addressed individually.
22.2.8.1
Geological and Coal Resource
Coal mining is accompanied by risk that, despite exploration efforts, mining areas will be
encountered where geological conditions render extraction of the resource to be
uneconomic, or that coal quality characteristics disqualify the product for sale into target
markets.
Offsetting the geological and coal resource risks are the massive size of the controlled
property which allows large areas to be mined in the preferred mine areas sufficiently away
from areas where coal quality and mineability may be less favorable. This flexibility,
combined with the extensive work done to define the reserve, reduces the risk at Buchanan
below that of other mine properties.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
55
Table 22-5: Geological and Coal Resource Risk Assessment (Risks 1 and 2)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation Measures
Residual Risk Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Recoverable coal
tonnes recognized to
be significantly less
than previously
estimated.
Reserve base is adequate
to serve market
commitments and respond
to opportunities for many
years. Local adverse
conditions may increase
frequency and cost of
production unit relocations.
Previous and ongoing
exploration and extensive
regional mining history
provide a high level of
confidence of coal seam
correlation, continuity of
the coal seams, and coal
resource tonnes.
3
4
12
Optimize mine plan
to increase resource
recovery; develop
mine plan to provide
readily available
alternate mining
locations to sustain
expected production
level.
2
3
6
Coal quality locally
proves to be lower
than initially
projected.
If uncontrolled, production
and sale of coal that is out
of specification can result in
rejection of deliveries,
cancellation of coal sales
agreements and damage to
reputation.
Exploration and vast
experience and history in
local coal seams provide
confidence in coal
quality; limited excursions
can be managed with
careful product
segregation and
blending.
2
5
10
Develop mine plan to
provide readily
available alternate
mining locations to
sustain expected
production level;
modify coal sales
agreements to reflect
coal quality.
2
4
8
22.2.8.2
Environmental
MM&A completed a Limited Phase I Environmental Site Assessment (
ESA
) on the Property in
April 2016 on behalf of Coronado. MM&A concluded that no long-term liabilities existed at
the time of this ESA.
Water quality and other permit requirements are subject to modification and such changes
could have a material impact on the capability of the operator to meet modified standards
or to receive new permits and modifications to existing permits. Permit protests may result
in delays or denials to permit applications.
Environmental standards and permit requirements have evolved significantly over the past
50 years and to date, mining operators and regulatory bodies have been able to adapt
successfully to evolving environmental requirements.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
56
Table 22-6: Environmental (Risks 3 and 4)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation Measures
Residual Risk
Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Environmental
performance standards
are modified in the
future.
Delays in receiving new
permits and modifications to
existing permits; cost of
testing and treatment of
water and soils
Work with regulatory
agencies to understand and
influence final standards;
implement testing,
treatment and other actions
to comply with new
standards.
3
4
12
Modify mining and
reclamation plans to
improve compliance with
new standards while
reducing cost of compliance.
3
3
9
New permits and
permit modifications
are increasingly
delayed or denied.
Interruption of production and
delayed implementation of
replacement production from
new mining areas.
Comply quickly with testing,
treatment and other actions
required; continue excellent
compliance performance
within existing permits.
2
4
8
Establish and maintain close
and constructive working
relationships with regulatory
agencies, local communities
and community action
groups. Prepare and submit
permits well in advance of
needs.
2
3
6
22.2.8.3
Regulatory Requirements
Federal and state health and safety regulatory agencies occasionally amend mine laws and
regulations. The impact is industry-wide. Mining operators and regulatory agencies have
been able to adapt successfully to evolving health and safety requirements.
Table 22-7: Regulatory Requirements (Risk 5)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Federal and state mine
safety and health
regulatory agencies
amend mine laws and
regulations.
Cost of training, materials,
supplies and equipment;
modification of mine
examination and production
procedures; modification of
mining plans.
Participate in hearings and
workshops when possible
to facilitate understanding
and implementation; work
cooperatively with agencies
and employees to facilitate
implementation of new laws
and regulations.
4
3
12
Familiarity and
experience with new
laws and regulations
results in reduced
impact to operations
and productivity and
improved supplies
and equipment
options.
4
2
8
22.2.8.4
Market and Transportation
Most of the current and future production is expected to be directed to domestic and
international metallurgical markets. Historically the metallurgical markets have been
cyclical and highly volatile.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
57
Table 22-8: Market and Transportation (Risk 6)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Volatile coal prices drop
precipitously.
Loss of revenue adversely
affects profitability; reduced
cash flow may disrupt capital
expenditures plan.
Cost control measures
implemented; capital
spending deferred.
4
5
20
High-cost operations
closed, and
employees
temporarily
furloughed.
4
4
16
Occasional delay or interruption of rail, river and terminals service may be expected. The
operator can possibly minimize the impact of delays by being a preferred customer by
fulfilling shipment obligations promptly and maintaining close working relationships.
Table 22-9: Market and Transportation (Risk 7)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Rail or river transport is
delayed; storage and
shipping access at river
and ocean terminals is
not available.
Fulfillment of coal sales
agreements delayed; limited
coal storage at mines may
increase cost of rehandling;
production may be temporarily
idled.
Provide adequate storage
capacity at mines;
coordinate continuously
with railroad and shipping
companies to respond
quickly and effectively to
changing circumstances.
5
3
15
Provide back-up
storage facility along
with personnel,
equipment and
rehandle plan to
sustain production
and fulfill sales
obligations timely.
5
2
10
22.2.8.5
Mining Plan
Occupational health and safety risks are inherent in mining operations. Comprehensive
training and retraining programs, internal safety audits and examinations, regular mine
inspections, safety meetings, along with support of trained fire brigades and mine-rescue
teams are among activities that greatly reduce accident risks. Employee health-monitoring
programs coupled with dust and noise monitoring and abatement reduce health risks to
miners.
As underground mines are developed and extended, observation of geological,
hydrogeological and geotechnical conditions leads to modification of mine plans and
procedures to enable safe work within the mine environments.
Highlighted below are selected examples of safety and external factors relevant to
Coronado operations.
22.2.8.5.1
Methane Management
Coalbed methane is present in coal operations below drainage. Often the methane
concentration in shallow coal seams is at such low levels that it can be readily managed with
frequent testing and monitoring, vigilance, and routine mine ventilation. Very high methane
concentrations may be present at greater depths, as experienced in the Pocahontas No. 3
seam at Buchanan Mine Complex in Virginia. High methane concentrations may require
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
58
degasification of the coal seam to assure safe mining. The Buchanan Mine has operated
safely for many years in one of the most intense methane environments in the United States
through careful management of coal seam degasification, gob degasification and mine-
ventilation procedures.
Table 22-10: Methane Management (Risk 8)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Methane hazard is
present in mines
operating below
drainage.
Injury or loss of life; possible
ignition of gas and mine
explosion; potential loss of
mine and equipment
temporarily or permanently;
additional mine fan, mine
power, ventilation, monitoring
and examination
requirements.
Low to moderate levels can
be managed with frequent
examinations, testing and
monitoring within the mine
ventilation system.
Excellent rock dust
maintenance minimizes
explosion propagation risk
should an ignition occur.
1
5
5
Very high-level
methane
concentrations may
require coal seam
degasification and
gob degasification if
longwall or pillar
extraction methods
are employed.
1
5
5
22.2.8.5.2
Mine Fires
Mine fires, once common at mine operations, are rare today. Most active coal miners have
not encountered a mine fire. Vastly improved mine power and equipment electrical
systems, along with safe mine practices, reduce mine fire risks. Crew training and fire
brigade support and training improve response for containment and control if a fire occurs.
Spontaneous combustion within coal mines, which is the source of most fires that occur
today, is not expected to occur at Buchanan.
Table 22-11: Mine Fires (Risk 9)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation Measures
Residual Risk Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Mine fire at underground
or surface mine
operation.
Injury or loss of life;
potential loss of mine
temporarily or
permanently; damage to
equipment and mine
infrastructure.
Inspection and
maintenance of mine
power, equipment and
mine infrastructure; good
housekeeping; frequent
examination of conveyor
belt entries; prompt
removal of accumulations
of combustible materials.
1
5
5
If spontaneous
combustion conditions
are present, enhanced
monitoring and
examination procedures
will be implemented;
mine design will
incorporate features to
facilitate isolation,
containment and
extinguishment of
spontaneous
combustion locations.
1
5
5
22.2.8.5.3
Availability of Supplies and Equipment
The industry has periodically experienced difficulty receiving timely delivery of mine
supplies and equipment. Availability issues often accompanied boom periods for coal
demand. Any future delivery of supplies and equipment delays are expected to be
temporary with limited impact on production.
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
59
Table 22-12: Availability of Supplies and Equipment (Risk 10)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Disruption of availability
for supplies and
equipment.
Temporary interruption of
production.
Force majeure provision in
coal sales agreements to
limit liability for delayed or
lost sales.
3
2
6
Work closely with
customers to assure
delayed coal
delivery rather than
cancelled sales;
monitor external
conditions and
increase inventory
of critical supplies;
accelerate delivery
of equipment when
possible.
3
1
3
22.2.8.5.4
Labor
Work stoppage due to labor protests are considered unlikely and are accompanied by
limited impact should it occur. Excellent employee relations and communications limit the
exposure to outside protesters. Loss of supervisors and skilled employees to retirement is
inevitable; the impact can be lessened with succession planning and training and
mentorship of new employees.
Table 22-13: Labor – Work Stoppage (Risk 11)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Work stoppage due to
strikes, slowdowns or
secondary boycott
activity.
Loss of production and coal
sales; damaged customer and
employee relations; reputation
loss.
Maintain excellent
employee relations and
communications; maintain
frequent customer
communications.
1
3
3
Develop plan for
employee
communications and
legal support to
minimize impact of
secondary boycott
activities.
1
3
3
the JORC Code and United States SEC Regulation S-K
Central Appalachian Coal Basin
Virginia, USA
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
60
Table 22-14: Labor – Retirement (Risk 12)
Aspect
Impact
Control Measures
Initial Risk Level
Mitigation
Measures
Residual Risk Level
P
C
R
P
C
R
Retirement of
supervisors and skilled
employees.
Loss of leadership and critical
skills to sustain high levels of
safety, maintenance and
productivity.
Monitor demographics
closely and maintain
communications with
employees who are
approaching retirement
age; maintain employee
selection and training
programs.
3
3
9
Maintain selection of
candidates and
implementation of in-
house or third-party
training for
electricians and
mechanics; develop
employee mentoring
program.
3
2
6
23
Recommendations
Coronado is continuing to work both internally and with outside assistance to further define
their resource base and to optimize the LOM plan.
24
References
Publicly available information from various state and federal agencies was used where
relevant.
25
Reliance on Information Provided by the
Registrant
A summary of the information provided by Coronado relied upon by MM&A for the
purposes of this TRS is provided in
Table 25-1
.
Table 25-1: Information from Registrant Relied Upon by MM&A
Information Provided by Coronado
Report
Section
Marketing
Long-term price forecast used in financial projections
16.2
Legal
Mineral control and surface control rights as shown on maps
3.2, 3.3
Environmental
Permit and bonding information
17.3
APPENDIX
A
MM&A QUALIFICATIONS
APPENDIX
B
MAP
APPENDIX
C
GLOSSARY OF ITEMS
Appendix C
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
3
Glossary of Abbreviations and Definitions
Abbreviation
Definition
AIPG
American Institute of Professional Geologists
ARMPS
Analysis of Retreat Mining Pillar Stability
ASTM
ASTM International
AVS
Applicant Violator System
bcm
Bank cubic meters
Btu/lb.
British Thermal Unit per pound
CAT
®
Caterpillar Inc.
C.P.G.
Certified Professional Geologist
Carlson
Carlson Mining – formerly SurvCADD
®
modeling in the Appalachian region
CFR
Code of Federal Regulations
CBM
Coalbed Methane
Coronado
Coronado Global Resources Inc.
CSR
Codes of State Rules
CSX
CSX Corporation, a rail-based freight transportation company
CTR
Contour mining
Demonstrated
reserves
Demonstrated reserves are the sum of proven and probable reserves.
DEP
Department of Environmental Protection
EBITDA
Earnings before Intere st, Taxes, Depreciation, and Amortization
EOM
End-of-mine reclamation
EPA
United States Environmental Protection Agency
ESA
Limited Phase I Environmental Site Assessment
EVR
Estimated Visual Recovery
Feasibility Study
“…comprehensive technical and economic study of the selected development
option for a mineral project, which includes detailed assessments of all
applicable modifying factors together with any other relevant operational
factors, and detailed financial analysis that are necessary to demonstrate, at
the time of reporting, that extraction is economically viable. According to the
proposed definition, the results of the study may serve as the basis for a final
decision by a proponent or financial institution to proceed with, or finance,
the development of the project. Thus, a feasibility study is more
comprehensive, with a higher degree of accuracy, and yielding results with a
higher level of confidence, than a pre-feasibility study.”
Hitachi
Hitachi Construction Machinery Co., Ltd.
HWM
Highwall mining
In situ
Its natural position; said specific of a rock, soil, or fossil when in the situation
in which was originally formed or deposited
Indicated
Resources
Indicated resources are those lying between 0.4-kilometer and 1.2-kilometer
radius from such an observation point and reported herein as in-situ mineral
resources.
Inferred Resources
Inferred resources lie more than a 1.2-kilometer radius from a valid point of
measurement but less than 4.8 kilometers from one and reported herein as
in-situ mineral resources.
JORC Code
Australasian Code for Reporting of Exploration Results, Mineral Resources and
Appendix C
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
4
Abbreviation
Definition
Ore Reserves
lb. SO
2
Pounds per sulfur dioxide per million British thermal units
LJ Hughes
LJ Hughes & Sons, Inc. - drilling Company
LOM
Life-of-mine
M&R
Maintenance and repair
M.B.A.
Master of Business Administration
Measured
Resources
Measured resources are those lying within 0.4-kilometer radius from a valid
point of measurement and reported herein as in-situ mineral resources.
MINER Act
Mine Improvement and New Emergency Response Act of 2006
Mineral Reserve
“…the economically mineable part of a Measured and/or Indicated Mineral
Resource. It includes dilution materials and allowances for losses, which occur
when the material is mined or extracted and is defined by studies at
Preliminary Feasibility or Feasibility level as appropriate that include
Modifying Factors. Such studies demonstrate that, at the time of reporting,
extraction of the mineral reserve is economically viable under reasonable
investment and marketing assumptions.”
Mineral Resource
“…a concentration or occurrence of solid material of economic interest or on
the Earth’s crust in such form, grade or quality that there are reasonable
prospects for eventual economic extraction. The location, quantity, grade,
continuity and other geological characteristics and continuity of a Mineral
Resource are known, estimated or interpreted from specific geological
evidence and knowledge, including sampling.”
MM&A
Marshall Miller & Associates, Inc.
Modifying Factors
“…considerations used to convert Mineral Resources to Mineral Reserves.
These include, but are not restricted to, mining, processing, metallurgical,
infrastructure, economic, marketing, legal, environmental compliance, plans,
negotiations, or agreements with local individuals or groups and
governmental factors.”
MRMR
Mineral Resources to Mineral Reserves
MSHA
United States Department of Labor Mine Safety and Health Administration
MSL
Mean sea level
Mt
Million metric tonnes
NAIP
National Agricultural Imagery Program
NIOSH
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
NS
Norfolk Southern Corporation, a rail-based freight transportation company
O&M
Operating and maintenance
OSD
Out-of-seam dilution
OSM
U.S. Office of Surface Mining Reclamation and Enforcement
P&L
Profit and loss before tax
P.E.
Professional Engineer
Preliminary
Feasibility Study
“…as a comprehensive study of a range of options for the technical and
economic viability of a mineral project that has advanced to a stage where a
qualified person has determined (in the case of underground mining) a
preferred mining method, or in the case of surface mining) a pit configuration,
and in all cases has determined an effective method of mineral processing and
an effective plan to sell the product. The study’s financial analysis must have
Appendix C
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
5
Abbreviation
Definition
the level of detail necessary to demonstrate, at the time of reporting, that
extraction is economically viable. In addition, as noted in the proposed
definition of a pre-feasibility study, while a pre-feasibility study is less
comprehensive and results in a lower confidence level than a feasibility study,
a pre- feasibility study is more comprehensive and results in a higher
confidence level than an initial assessment.”
Property(ies)
Bituminous coal deposits located in Buchanan and Tazewell Counties, Virginia.
QP
Qualified Person
Qualified Person
“…a person who is a mineral industry professional with at least five years of
relevant experience in the type of mineralization and type of deposit under
consideration and in the specific type of activity that person is undertaking on
behalf of the registrant. In addition, the proposed definition requires a
qualified person to be an
eligible member or licensee in good standing of a
recognized professional organization at the
time the technical report is prepared.”
Rec.
Recovery
RECs
Recognized Environmental Conditions
Resource Database
The Resource Database is established by the collection, validation, recording,
storing and processing of data and forms the foundation necessary for the
estimation of Mineral Resource and Mineral Reserve.
A quality assurance and quality control program is essential and must be
established to govern the collection of all data. In reporting, a Mineral
Resource must meet the minimum requirement of “reasonable prospects for
economic extraction”. This will require the concurrent collection and storage
of preliminary economic, mining, metallurgical, environmental, legal and
social data and other information for use in the estimation of MRMR.
The Resource Database will include both “primary” (observation and
measurement) and “interpreted” data. It is recommended that data be stored
digitally, using a documented, standard format and a reliable storage medium
that allows for easy and complete retrieval of the data.
ROM
Run-of-mine
RPO
Recognized Professional Organizations
S-K 1300
United States Securities and Exchange Commission Regulation S-K 1300
Modernization of Property Disclosures
SEC
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
SME
Society for Mining Engineers
SMCRA
Surface Mining Control and Reclamation Act of 1977 is the primary federal law
that regulates the environmental effects of coal mining in the United States.
Strip Ratio
Represented by bcm of overburden to recoverable coal tonnes
tph
tonnes per hour
TRS
Technical Report Summary
USA
United States of America
USFW
United States Fish and Wildlife
USGS
United States Geologic Survey
Appendix C
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
6
Abbreviation
Definition
VALMIN Code
Australasian Code for Public Reporting of Technical Assessments and
Valuations of Mineral Assets
Vulcan™
Vulcan™ software is a product of Maptek™, a provider of software for the
global mining industry.
APPENDIX
D
INITIAL ECONOMIC ASSESSMENT FOR RESOURCES EXCLUSIVE
OF RESERVES
APPENDIX
E
JORC TABLE 1
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
Appendix E: JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
3
Section 1 Sampling Techniques and Data
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Sampling techniques
>
Nature and quality of sampling (e.g. cut channels, random chips, or specific specialised
industry standard measurement tools appropriate to the minerals under investigation, such as
downhole gamma sondes, or handheld XRF instruments, etc.). These examples should not be
taken as limiting the broad meaning of sampling.
>
Include reference to measures taken to ensure sample representivity and the appropriate
calibration of any measurement tools or systems used.
>
Aspects of the determination of mineralisation that are Material to the Public Report. In cases
where ‘industry standard’ work has been done this would be relatively simple (e.g. ‘reverse
circulation drilling was used to obtain 1 m samples from which 3 kg was pulverised to produce
a 30 g charge for fire assay’). In other cases, more explanation may be required, such as where
there is coarse gold that has inherent sampling problems. Unusual commodities or
mineralisation types (e.g. submarine nodules) may warrant disclosure of detailed information.
>
Most of the coal samples have been obtained from the Properties by subsurface exploration using
core drilling techniques. The protocol for preparing and testing the samples has varied over time
and is not well documented for the older holes drilled on the Properties.
>
Typical USA core drilling sampling technique is for the coal core sample, once recovered from the
core barrel, to be described then wrapped in a sealed plastic sleeve and placed into a covered core
box, which is the length of the sample so that the core can be delivered to a laboratory in relatively
intact condition and with original moisture content.
>
It is reasonable to assume, given the sophistication level of the previous operators, that these
samples were generally collected and processed under industry best-practices. This assumption is
based on MM&A’s familiarity with the operating companies and the companies used to perform the
analysis.
>
Some of the drill holes were air rotary bored and no coal core samples were collected. Seam
thickness for rotary-drilled bore holes is verified by calibrated downhole gamma-density logs.
>
Coal samples that were deemed by MM&A geologists to be unrepresentative were not used for
statistical analysis of coal quality, as documented in the tabulations. A representative group of drill
hole samples from the Properties were then checked against the original drill laboratory reports to
verify accuracy and correctness.
Drilling techniques
>
Drill type (e.g. core, reverse circulation, open-hole hammer, rotary air blast, auger, Bangka,
sonic, etc.) and details (e.g. core diameter, triple or standard tube, depth of diamond tails,
face-sampling bit or other type, whether core is oriented and if so, by what method, etc.).
>
The Properties have been extensively explored by subsurface drilling efforts carried out by
numerous entities, most of which were completed prior to acquisition by Coronado. The majority of
the drilling was accomplished using vertical continuous (diamond) coring or air rotary methods.
>
Core drilling methods utilize NX-size (5.4 centimeter) or similar-sized core cylinders to recover core
samples, which can be used to delineate geologic characteristics, and for coal quality testing and
geotechnical logging.
>
Data for the rotary drilled holes is mainly derived from downhole geophysical logs, which are used to
interpret coal and rock thickness and depth since logging of the drill cuttings is not reliable.
>
Geophysical logging was performed on many of the holes, either by Geological Logging Systems (a
division of MM&A), other geophysical logging contractors, and on those properties acquired from
CONSOL geophysical logging was often performed by CONSOL’s in-house logging services.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
Appendix E: JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
4
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Drill sample recovery
>
Method of recording and assessing core and chip sample recoveries and results assessed.
>
Measures taken to maximise sample recovery and ensure representative nature of the
samples.
>
Whether a relationship exists between sample recovery and grade and whether sample bias
may have occurred due to preferential loss/gain of fine/coarse material.
>
Where available, core recovery thickness of coal samples was reconciled with the thickness
interpreted from geophysical logs.
>
Core recovery of the older coal samples lacking geophysical logs is sometimes not well-documented:
however, when the laboratory results for such holes had anomalous values, the data was
disqualified and not used.
Logging
>
Whether core and chip samples have been geologically and geotechnically logged to a level of
detail to support appropriate Mineral Resource estimation, mining studies and metallurgical
studies.
>
Whether logging is qualitative or quantitative in nature. Core (or costean, channel, etc.)
photography.
>
The total length and percentage of the relevant intersections logged.
>
A wide variety of core-logging techniques exist for the properties. For many of the core holes, the
primary data source is a generalized lithology description by the driller, in some cases supplemented
by a more detailed core log completed by a geologist.
>
The logging of core thickness and depth is quantitative. With the exception of the coal seams,
logging of rock strata type is more subjective and best considered as qualitative.
Sub-sampling
techniques and sample
preparation
>
If core, whether cut or sawn and whether quarter, half or all core taken.
>
If non-core, whether riffled, tube sampled, rotary split, etc. and whether sampled wet or dry.
>
For all sample types, the nature, quality and appropriateness of the sample preparation
technique.
>
Quality control procedures adopted for all sub-sampling stages to maximise representivity of
samples.
>
Measures taken to ensure that the sampling is representative of the in situ material collected,
including for instance results for field duplicate/second-half sampling.
>
Whether sample sizes are appropriate to the grain size of the material being sampled.
>
Typical US practice in the Appalachian Basin is that core samples for deep mineable core samples are
not sawn or subsampled (since seams are not of great thickness and the entire seam is mined and
co-mingled).
>
Oftentimes, core for surface-mineable coal seams are bench sampled separately by the various coal
and rock layers (plies).
>
MM&A has exercised diligence to use only those analyses that are representative of the coal quality
parameters for the appropriate mining type for each sample.
Quality of assay data
and laboratory tests
>
The nature, quality and appropriateness of the assaying and laboratory procedures used and
whether the technique is considered partial or total.
>
For geophysical tools, spectrometers, handheld XRF instruments, etc., the parameters used in
determining the analysis including instrument make and model, reading times, calibrations
factors applied and their derivation, etc.
>
Nature of quality control procedures adopted (e.g. standards, blanks, duplicates, external
laboratory checks) and whether acceptable levels of accuracy (i.e. lack of bias) and precision
have been established.
>
Sample analysis was typically carried out by accredited US laboratories.
>
Standard procedure upon receipt of core samples by the testing laboratory is to log the depth and
thickness of the sample, then perform testing as specified by a representative of the operating
company. Each sample is then analyzed in accordance with procedures defined under
ASTM
International (
ASTM
)
D3174); sulfur (ASTM D4239); Btu/lb. (ASTM D5865); volatile matter (ASTM D3175); Free Swell Index
(
FSI
) (ASTM D720).
>
Geophysical tools are calibrated by the logging company and where possible, validated using a
calibration hole.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
Appendix E: JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
5
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Verification of
sampling and assaying
>
The verification of significant intersections by either independent or alternative company
personnel.
>
The use of twinned holes.
>
Documentation of primary data, data entry procedures, data verification, data storage
(physical and electronic) protocols.
>
Discuss any adjustment to assay data.
>
All coal intersection data used to generate the geologic model has been cross referenced with the
lithological and geophysical logs by MM&A.
>
Laboratory quality was adjusted from dry basis to reflect the anticipated marketable product
moisture.
>
Coal quality results were verified by spot-check with laboratory analysis sheets by MM&A before
inclusion into the geologic model and use in the resource estimate.
Location of data points
>
Accuracy and quality of surveys used to locate drill holes (collar and down-hole surveys),
trenches, mine workings and other locations used in Mineral Resource estimation.
>
Specification of the grid system used.
>
Quality and adequacy of topographic control.
>
Due to the long history of exploration by various parties on the Properties, a wide variety of survey
techniques exist for documentation of data point locations. Many of the older exploration drill holes
appear to have been located by ground survey; more recently completed drill holes are often
located by high-resolution Global Positioning System (
GPS
) units.
>
Grid systems used are typically the State Plane Coordinate System pertinent to each property.
>
Topography is based on either the USGS topographic 7.5-minute quadrangle maps or on recent
aerial photogrammetry as necessary (subject to availability).
Data spacing and
distribution
>
Data spacing for reporting of Exploration Results.
>
Whether the data spacing and distribution is sufficient to establish the degree of geological
and grade continuity appropriate for the Mineral Resource and Ore Reserve estimation
procedure(s) and classifications applied.
>
Whether sample compositing has been applied.
>
Spacing and distribution of data point information may vary from seam to seam within each mining
area. The areas estimated for coal resource and coal reserve tonnes have been limited so that the
data spacing and distribution is sufficient to establish the degree of geological continuity appropriate
for the estimation and classification of the coal tonnes.
>
All of the coal resource tonnes are in the measured, indicated, and inferred categories, and all of the
coal reserve tonnes are in the proved and probable categories in accordance with the JORC Code
and SEC standards.
Orientation of data in
relation to geological
structure
>
Whether the orientation of sampling achieves unbiased sampling of possible structures and
the extent to which this is known, considering the deposit type.
>
If the relationship between the drilling orientation and the orientation of key mineralised
structures is considered to have introduced a sampling bias, this should be assessed and
reported if material.
>
Drill holes have been vertically drilled. No downhole deviation logs have been collected and it is
therefore not known if the drill holes have deviated away from vertical. Based on the relatively
shallow seam depths, any deviation is expected to be insignificant and immaterial to the geologic
characterization of the Property.
>
The dip of the coal seams is relatively minor and not a material issue for representation of seam
thickness or quality.
Sample security
The measures taken to ensure sample security.
>
Sample handling procedures employed by explorationists follow typical US protocol and should be
adequate to insure sample security.
Audits or reviews
The results of any audits or reviews of sampling techniques and data.
>
MM&A has reviewed all available geological information for the Properties in developing the
geologic model. Only that data deemed suitable has been used for the purpose of generating the
resource and reserve estimates.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
Appendix E: JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
6
Section 2 Reporting of Exploration Results
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Mineral tenement and
land tenure status
>
Type, reference name/number, location and ownership including agreements or material
issues with third parties such as joint ventures, partnerships, overriding royalties, native title
interests, historical sites, wilderness or national park and environmental settings.
>
The security of the tenure held at the time of reporting along with any known impediments to
obtaining a licence to operate in the area.
>
The Coronado coal resources are located within three of the United State of America: Virginia; West
Virginia; and Pennsylvania. Control of these Properties is governed by many hundreds of
agreements.
>
MM&A has not carried out separate title verification for the coal properties and has not verified
leases, deeds, surveys or other property control instruments pertinent to the subject resources.
>
Coronado has represented to MM&A that it controls the mining rights to the coal deposits as shown
on its property maps, and MM&A has accepted these as being a true and accurate depiction of the
mineral rights controlled by Coronado. The TRS assumes the properties are developed under
responsible and experienced management.
>
There are no known legal or environmental encumbrances that would impede development of the
subject coal reserves.
Exploration done by
other parties
>
Acknowledgment and appraisal of exploration by other parties.
>
The Properties have been extensively explored by subsurface drilling efforts carried out by
numerous entities, most of which were completed prior to acquisition by Coronado.
>
This exploration work was generally performed to prevailing US best practice standards and deemed
adequate for the purposes of this TRS.
Geology
>
Deposit type, geological setting and style of mineralisation.
>
The Coronado coal resources are located within the Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins.
>
The coal deposits are Carboniferous in age, being of the Pennsylvanian system.
>
Seam of economic significance typically range between 0.3 meters and 1.8 meters in thickness, with
relatively little structural deformation.
>
Regional structure is typically characterized by gently dipping strata to the northwest at less than
one percent.
Drill hole Information
>
A summary of all information material to the understanding of the exploration results
including a tabulation of the following information for all Material drill holes:
●
easting and northing of the drill hole collar
●
elevation or RL (Reduced Level – elevation above sea level in metres) of the drill hole
collar
●
dip and azimuth of the hole
●
down hole length and interception depth
●
hole length.
>
If the exclusion of this information is justified on the basis that the information is not Material
and this exclusion does not detract from the understanding of the report, the Competent
Person should clearly explain why this is the case.
>
MM&A reviewed and entered all pertinent data into a digital geologic database for each Coronado
property. The database consists of thousands of data records, which include drill hole and
supplemental coal seam thickness measurements from outcrop and mine exposures.
>
All drill holes in the database are provided with a collar elevation and the State Plane Coordinate
System easting and northing coordinate.
>
After MM&A confirmed proper coal seam thickness and correlation, the seam data was modelled
and compiled into coal resource maps.
>
The maps are provided in the TRS; however, a tabulation of the thousands of individual data records
is not practical to include.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
Appendix E: JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
7
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Data aggregation
methods
>
In reporting Exploration Results, weighting averaging techniques, maximum and/or minimum
grade truncations (e.g. cutting of high grades) and cut-off grades are usually Material and
should be stated.
>
Where aggregate intercepts incorporate short lengths of high grade results and longer lengths
of low grade results, the procedure used for such aggregation should be stated and some
typical examples of such aggregations should be shown in detail.
>
The assumptions used for any reporting of metal equivalent values should be clearly stated.
>
Where a coal seam has been bench sampled (typically for surface mining) the individual analyses for
the coal plies are normally weight-averaged to represent the total of recoverable coal.
>
Coal quality summary results have been documented in the TRS. Average coal quality on a per-
seam basis is used to represent the coal resources within a given mining area.
>
Average coal quality for each Coronado complex is provided in Tables 1-1, 1-2 and 1-3 of this TRS.
>
No other data aggregations methods are used.
Relationship between
mineralisation widths
and intercept lengths
>
These relationships are particularly important in the reporting of Exploration Results.
>
If the geometry of the mineralisation with respect to the drill hole angle is known, its nature
should be reported.
>
If it is not known and only the down hole lengths are reported, there should be a clear
statement to this effect (e.g. ‘down hole length, true width not known’).
>
Coal thickness values from all coal intersections and down hole geophysical logs are considered to
be vertical thicknesses. Seam dip of approximately 2.0 to 3.0 degrees has little effect on the vertical
thickness of the seam.
Diagrams
>
Appropriate maps and sections (with scales) and tabulations of intercepts should be included
for any significant discovery being reported These should include, but not be limited to a plan
view of drill hole collar locations and appropriate sectional views.
>
Diagrams and maps showing the coal seam intercepts are presented in the TRS.
Balanced reporting
>
Where comprehensive reporting of all Exploration Results is not practicable, representative
reporting of both low and high grades and/or widths should be practiced to avoid misleading
reporting of Exploration Results.
>
All of the available, qualified exploration data has been included within the tabulations, maps, and
diagrams for this TRS.
>
Both coal thickness and quality data are deemed by MM&A to be reasonably sufficient within the
resource areas. Therefore, there is a reasonable level of confidence in the geologic interpretations
required for coal resource determination based on the available data and the techniques applied to
the data.
Other substantive
exploration data
>
Other exploration data, if meaningful and material, should be reported including (but not
limited to): geological observations; geophysical survey results; geochemical survey results;
bulk samples – size and method of treatment; metallurgical test results; bulk density,
groundwater, geotechnical and rock characteristics; potential deleterious or contaminating
substances.
>
Informational material available from the U.S. Geological Survey and the respective State Surveys
was used to assist in the Resource estimate.
Further work
>
The nature and scale of planned further work (e.g. tests for lateral extensions or depth
extensions or large-scale step-out drilling).
>
Diagrams clearly highlighting the areas of possible extensions, including the main geological
interpretations and future drilling areas, provided this information is not commercially
sensitive.
>
Further work is expected to include additional exploration, geotechnical testing, coal quality
analyses, and coal property acquisition.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
Appendix E: JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
8
Section 3 Estimation and Reporting of Mineral Resources
(Criteria listed in the preceding section also apply to this section.)
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Database integrity
>
Measures taken to ensure that data has not been corrupted by, for example, transcription or
keying errors, between its initial collection and its use for Mineral Resource estimation
purposes.
>
Data validation procedures used.
>
MM&A confirmed coal seam thickness and correlations in databases used for coal deposit
modelling. Representative records were spot-checked for data entry validation.
>
Geophysical logs were used wherever available to assist in confirming the seam correlation and to
verify proper seam thickness measurements and recovery of coal samples.
Site
visits
>
Comment on any site visits undertaken by the Competent Person and the outcome of those
visits.
>
If no site visits have been undertaken indicate why this is the case.
>
MM&A is very familiar with the Properties and has conducted multiple site visits throughout the
years.
Geological
interpretation
>
Confidence in (or conversely, the uncertainty of) the geological interpretation of the mineral
deposit.
>
Nature of the data used and of any assumptions made.
>
The effect, if any, of alternative interpretations on Mineral Resource estimation.
>
The use of geology in guiding and controlling Mineral Resource estimation.
>
The factors affecting continuity both of grade and geology.
>
Due to the relative structural simplicity of the deposits and the reasonable continuity of the tabular
coal beds, the principal geological interpretation necessary to define the geometry of the coal
deposits is the proper modeling of their thickness and elevation.
>
Both coal thickness and quality data are deemed by MM&A to be reasonable within the resource
areas.
>
Therefore, there is a reasonable level of confidence in the geologic interpretations required for coal
resource determination based on the available data and the techniques applied to the data.
Dimensions
>
The extent and variability of the Mineral Resource expressed as length (along strike or
otherwise), plan width, and depth below surface to the upper and lower limits of the Mineral
Resource.
>
The subject coal resource areas mostly exist in discreet, individual deposits of highly variable
dimensions, shapes and depth below the ground surface.
>
Such factors are best depicted in the maps contained in the TRS.
>
Details of the parameters are cited within the TRS and included in the table of Cut-off Parameters
listed in Section 11.1 of the TRS.
Estimation
and
modelling techniques
>
The nature and appropriateness of the estimation technique(s) applied and key assumptions,
including treatment of extreme grade values, domaining, interpolation parameters and
maximum distance of extrapolation from data points. If a computer assisted estimation
method was chosen include a description of computer software and parameters used.
>
The availability of check estimates, previous estimates and/or mine production records and
whether the Mineral Resource estimate takes appropriate account of such data.
>
The assumptions made regarding recovery of by-products.
>
Estimation of deleterious elements or other non-grade variables of economic significance (e.g.
sulphur for acid mine drainage characterisation).
>
In the case of block model interpolation, the block size in relation to the average sample
spacing and the search employed.
>
Geological data was imported into Carlson Mining
®
®
) geological modelling
software in the form of Microsoft
®
picks, bottom seam elevations and raw and washed coal quality. These data files were validated
prior to importing into the software.
>
Once imported, a geologic model was created.
>
The geological model was verified and reviewed.
>
Resources were estimated by defining seam thickness at each point of observation and by defining
resource confidence arcs around the points of observation.
>
Points of observation for Measured and Indicated confidence arcs were defined for all drill holes
that intersected the seam.
>
As prescribed by the common United States classification system the following distances from points
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
Appendix E: JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
9
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
>
Any assumptions behind modelling of selective mining units.
>
Any assumptions about correlation between variables.
>
Description of how the geological interpretation was used to control the resource estimates.
>
Discussion of basis for using or not using grade cutting or capping.
>
The process of validation, the checking process used, the comparison of model data to drill
hole data, and use of reconciliation data if available.
of observation were used to define the corresponding Resource category arcs:
-
Inferred Resources – greater than 3,960 feet (1.2 kilometers) but less than 15,840 feet (4.8
kilometers)
-
Indicated Resources – 3,960 feet (1.2 kilometers)
-
Measured Resources – 1,320 feet (0.4 kilometers)
>
The use of the standards commonly used in the United States are appropriate and customary for
this resource jurisdiction and deposition type.
>
MM&A performed a geostatistical analysis test of the Coronado data sets using the Drill Hole
Spacing Analysis (
DHSA
) method.
>
Based on MM&A’s analysis, it would be possible to extend the measured, indicated and inferred
arcs slightly beyond historically accepted practices due to consistent geological settings. The QP’s
have elected not to extend arc distances, introducing a level of conservatism in the coal
classification.
Moisture
>
Whether the tonnages are estimated on a dry basis or with natural moisture, and the method
of determination of the moisture content.
>
Coal resource tonnes are presented on a dry, in-situ basis.
>
Reserve tonnes are presented on a moist basis at anticipated product moisture ranging from 4.0 to
6.0 percent. Moisture content based on historic analyses of shipped coal.
Cut-off Parameters
>
The basis of the adopted cut-off grade(s) or quality parameters applied.
>
The cut-off parameters were tailored for each of the Coronado properties to be in accordance with
mining/ processing capabilities and market conditions prevalent at each operation.
>
Examples include minimum recoverable coal thickness, acceptable ash content and wash recovery,
and manageable overburden to coal ratio for surface mineable coal.
>
Details of the parameters are cited within the TRS and included in the table of Cut-off Parameters
listed in Section 11.1 of this TRS.
>
These cut-off parameters have been developed by MM&A based on its experience with the
Coronado properties and other mining operations of the Central Appalachian coal basin. This
experience includes technical and economic evaluations of numerous properties in the region for
the purposes of determining the economic viability of the subject coal reserves.
Mining factors or
assumptions
>
Assumptions made regarding possible mining methods, minimum mining dimensions and
internal (or, if applicable, external) mining dilution. It is always necessary as part of the process
of determining reasonable prospects for eventual economic extraction to consider potential
mining methods, but the assumptions made regarding mining methods and parameters when
estimating Mineral Resources may not always be rigorous. Where this is the case, this should
be reported with an explanation of the basis of the mining assumptions made.
>
Mining factors such as dilution, mining and washing recovery are variable and have been applied at
the coal deposits at each operation based on site-specific characteristics.
>
Details of the factors are cited within the TRS.
>
Factors that would typically preclude conversion of a coal resource to coal reserve include the
following: inferred resource classification; absence of coal quality; poor mine recovery; lack of
access; insufficient exploration; or uncontrolled surface property for areas of proposed for surface
mining.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
Appendix E: JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
10
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
>
While such factors were used to preclude the conversion of a very limited number of coal resources
to coal reserves in this report, the extensive history of mining on the Properties would suggest that
there are reasonable prospects for eventual economic extractions of all coal resources under
favorable market conditions.
Metallurgical factors
or assumptions
>
The basis for assumptions or predictions regarding metallurgical amenability. It is always
necessary as part of the process of determining reasonable prospects for eventual economic
extraction to consider potential metallurgical methods, but the assumptions regarding
metallurgical treatment processes and parameters made when reporting Mineral Resources
may not always be rigorous. Where this is the case, this should be reported with an
explanation of the basis of the metallurgical assumptions made.
>
The products mined from coal resources controlled by Coronado can be sold into high-, mid-, and
low-volatile metallurgical coal markets because of their inherent quality characteristics.
>
Run-of-mine production is washed at the coal preparation plants as needed for quality control.
>
Coronado may blend production from multiple sources to manage ash and sulfur content along with
the rheological and petrographic characteristics of the shipped products.
Environmental factors
or assumptions
>
Assumptions made regarding possible waste and process residue disposal options. It is always
necessary as part of the process of determining reasonable prospects for eventual economic
extraction to consider the potential environmental impacts of the mining and processing
operation. While at this stage the determination of potential environmental impacts,
particularly for a greenfields project, may not always be well advanced, the status of early
consideration of these potential environmental impacts should be reported. Where these
aspects have not been considered this should be reported with an explanation of the
environmental assumptions made.
>
MM&A completed a Limited Phase I Environmental Site Assessment (ESA) on the Buchanan property
in April 2016, and on the Logan County and Greenbrier Properties in May 2017 on behalf of
Coronado. Coronado reports not having conducted such a study since the MM&A studies.
>
The ESAs completed by MM&A included a site inspection, review of historical records, a database
search of State and Federal regulatory records and interviews to identify potential recognized
environmental conditions (RECs) that may create environmental liability for the sites.
>
MM&A identified one REC at Greenbrier associated with stained soil and gravel near a fueling and
maintenance area. Coronado reported to MM&A that satisfactory clean-up efforts were completed
at Greenbrier.
>
Based on these former ESAs completed by MM&A, it is MM&A’s opinion that Coronado has a
generally typical coal industry record of compliance with applicable mining, water quality, and
environmental laws. Estimated costs for mine closure, including water quality monitoring during
site reclamation, are included in the TRS financial models.
Bulk density
>
Whether assumed or determined. If assumed, the basis for the assumptions. If determined,
the method used, whether wet or dry, the frequency of the measurements, the nature, size
and representativeness of the samples.
>
The bulk density for bulk material must have been measured by methods that adequately
account for void spaces (vugs, porosity, etc), moisture and differences between rock and
alteration zones within the deposit.
>
Discuss assumptions for bulk density estimates used in the evaluation process of the different
materials.
>
Laboratory derived seam densities measured in specific gravity were used where available. As
needed, these data were supplemented by estimated seam density values based on the relative
proportion of coal and non-coal material within the seam (typically at 1.30 and 2.25 specific gravity,
respectively).
>
Average seam density was determined for each coal deposit and used to convert coal volumes into
coal tonnage estimates.
Classification
>
The basis for the classification of the Mineral Resources into varying confidence categories.
>
Whether appropriate account has been taken of all relevant factors (i.e. relative confidence in
tonnage/grade estimations, reliability of input data, confidence in continuity of geology and
metal values, quality, quantity and distribution of the data).
>
Whether the result appropriately reflects the Competent
>
The Resource has been classified based on suitable distances from points of observations prescribed
in the common United States classification system.
>
The use of the United States standards is appropriate and customary for this resource jurisdiction
and deposition type.
>
MM&A performed a geostatistical analysis test of the Coronado data sets using the Drill Hole
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
Appendix E: JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
11
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
>
Person’s view of the deposit.
Spacing Analysis (
DHSA
) method.
>
Based on MM&A’s analysis, it would be possible to extend the measured, indicated and inferred
arcs slightly beyond historically accepted practices due to consistent geological settings. The QP’s
have elected not to extend arc distances, introducing a level of conservatism in the coal
classification.
>
All relevant factors have been accounted for and reflect the Competent Person’s view of the
deposit.
Audits or reviews
>
The results of any audits or reviews of Mineral Resource estimates.
>
MM&A completed prepared a statement of coal resources and reserves for the Properties in
accordance with the JORC Code as of December 31, 2017. MM&A also subsequently updated the
estimate of resources and reserves for depletion as of December 31, 2018, December 31, 2019,
December 31, 2020 and December 31, 2021.
>
MM&A performed a previous audit of the Properties in year 2017 for Coronado based on U.S.
Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) Industry Guide 7 and USGS Circular 891 standards.
>
Earlier audits were performed by various independent consultants for predecessors-in-title to
Coronado and at various levels of detail depending on the clients concerns and the allotted time for
completion. Previous audits and reviews defined the primary coal resource areas and estimated the
recoverable tonnes for each seam based on the expected mining methods.
>
Additionally, MM&A has performed proprietary evaluations for predecessors-in-title to Coronado,
which encompass portions of the Properties included in this TRS.
Discussion of relative
accuracy/ confidence
>
Where appropriate a statement of the relative accuracy and confidence level in the Mineral
Resource estimate using an approach or procedure deemed appropriate by the Competent
Person. For example, the application of statistical or geostatistical procedures to quantify the
relative accuracy of the resource within stated confidence limits, or, if such an approach is not
deemed appropriate, a qualitative discussion of the factors that could affect the relative
accuracy and confidence of the estimate.
>
The statement should specify whether it relates to global or local estimates, and, if local, state
the relevant tonnages, which should be relevant to technical and economic evaluation.
Documentation should include assumptions made and the procedures used.
>
These statements of relative accuracy and confidence of the estimate should be compared
with production data, where available.
>
The relative accuracy of and confidence in the coal tonnage and quality estimates provided herein
are judged to be in conformance with current industry best-practices.
>
The representation of average coal quality characteristics should be understood to represent a
reasonably representative sampling that is generally indicative of coal quality and does not
represent a statistically rigorous approach to coal quality modeling.
>
Resource estimation has been completed using standard coal estimation methods which are
deemed appropriate for this deposit.
Section 4 Estimation and Reporting of Ore Reserves
(Criteria listed in the preceding section also apply to this section.)
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Mineral Resource
estimate for
conversion to Ore
Reserves
>
Description of the Mineral Resource estimate used as a basis for the conversion to an Ore
Reserve.
>
The coal resource estimate was prepared as part of the report Coronado Global Resources Inc.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves in Accordance with JORC Code and United States SEC
Standards as of December 31, 2022 – Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins – Virginia, West
Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA – February 2023 prepared by MM&A.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
Appendix E: JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
12
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
>
The resource estimation criteria were developed by MM&A based on the capabilities of the mining
equipment used within the production model and on industry-accepted standards to assure that the
basic geologic characteristics of the coal resources are in reasonable conformity with those to be
mined and marketed by Coronado.
>
Clear statement as to whether the Mineral Resources are reported additional to, or inclusive
of, the Ore Reserves.
>
Coal resources generally are reported inclusive of the coal reserves. In some cases, resources are
reported in addition to coal reserves. Tables 1-1 and 11-3 of the TRS clearly identify resources
“inclusive of mine plan” from which coal reserves were estimated along with those resources
“exclusive of mine plan” from which no reserves were estimated.
Site visits
>
Comment on any site visits undertaken by the Competent Person and the outcome of those
visits.
>
MM&A is very familiar with the Properties and has conducted multiple site visits throughout the
years.
Study status
>
The type and level of study undertaken to enable Mineral Resources to be converted to Ore
Reserves.
>
A preliminary feasibility LOM plan was prepared by MM&A for active and proposed mines.
>
The Code requires that a study to at least Pre-Feasibility Study level has been undertaken to
convert Mineral Resources to Ore Reserves. Such studies will have been carried out and will
have determined a mine plan that is technically achievable and economically viable, and that
material Modifying Factors have been considered.
>
This geologic evaluation conducted in accordance with JORC and SEC standards and in conjunction
with the preliminary feasibility study is sufficient to conclude that the surface, highwall miner and
underground coal reserves identified on the Properties are economically mineable under reasonable
expectations of market prices for thermal and metallurgical coal products, estimated operation
costs, and capital expenditures.
>
The pre-feasibility financial models, prepared by MM&A for this TRS, was developed to test the
economic viability of each coal resource area.
>
Proved and probable coal reserve were derived from the defined in-situ coal resource considering
relevant processing, economic (including independent estimates of capital, revenue and cost,
marketing, legal, environmental, socioeconomic, and regulatory factors).
Cut-off parameters
>
The basis of the adopted cut-off grade(s) or quality parameters applied.
>
The cut-off parameters were tailored for each of the Coronado properties to be in accordance with
mining/ processing capabilities and market conditions prevalent at each operation.
>
Examples include minimum recoverable coal thickness, acceptable ash content and wash recovery,
and manageable overburden to coal ratio for surface mineable coal.
>
Details of the parameters are cited within the TRS and included in the table of Cut-off Parameters
listed in Section 11.1 of this TRS.
>
These cut-off parameters have been developed by MM&A based on its experience with the
Coronado properties and are typical of mining operations in the Central Appalachian coal basin. This
experience includes technical and economic evaluations of numerous properties in the region for
the purposes of determining the economic viability of the subject coal reserves.
Mining factors or
assumptions
>
The method and assumptions used as reported in the Pre-Feasibility or Feasibility Study to
convert the Mineral Resource to an Ore Reserve (i.e. either by application of appropriate
factors by optimisation or by preliminary or detailed design).
>
After validating coal seam data and establishing correlations, the thickness and elevation for seams
of economic interest were used to generate a geologic model.
>
A pre-feasibility LOM plan was prepared by MM&A for active and proposed mines. MM&A prepared
mine projections and production timing forecasts based on coal seam characteristics. Production
timing was carried out from 2023 to depletion (exhaustion) of the coal reserve areas.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
Appendix E: JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
13
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
>
The choice, nature and appropriateness of the selected mining method(s) and other mining
parameters including associated design issues such as pre-strip, access, etc.
>
The room-and-pillar mining method was selected to model the underground mining resources,
utilizing continuous miners for coal extraction, shuttle cars for production section haulage and roof
bolters for roof control, with the exception that the Buchanan Mine also uses longwall shearers,
armored face conveyors, and hydraulic self-advancing roof support. The resource areas located
above drainage are relatively small and often have irregular boundaries.
The Buchanan Mine in
Buchanan County, Virginia is the only active longwall mine currently being operated by Coronado.
>
The Coronado underground mining resource areas which are located above-drainage require an
access road and mine access development along the outcrop, whereas below-drainage mines are
accessed via shaft or slope based on other proposed surface infrastructure locations and/or surface
property control.
>
The surface mining method selected utilizes highly productive hydraulic shovels, front-end loaders,
large tractors and rock trucks for overburden removal. The mobile equipment spreads adapt readily
to winding coal outcrops for contour surface mining and are effective for point-removal and area
mining applications.
>
Application of highwall and auger mining units is an effective method to recover coal resources not
suitable for underground mining and under excessive cover for surface mining.
>
The assumptions made regarding geotechnical parameters (e.g. pit slopes, stope sizes, etc.),
grade control and pre-production drilling.
>
Mining plans for potential underground mines were developed by MM&A. Pillar stability was tested
by MM&A using the
Analysis of Coal Pillar Stability (ACPS
) program that was developed by the
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (
NIOSH
)
.
>
Coronado must obtain approved mining plans from
United States Department of Labor Mine Safety
and Health Administration (
MSHA
)
that define safety parameters for the highwalls developed
during contour and area mining. MM&A’s planning model does not require input of specific
highwall design parameters, but provides for timing of mining within mine plan polygons that is
representative of the operation performance attained at Central Appalachia surface mines.
>
Highwall and auger mining is conducted under highwalls designed and constructed to meet MSHA
permit requirements. To better assure highwall stability and safety during highwall coal extraction,
MSHA requires that coal fenders, or stumps, be left in place between successive cuts. Periodic
barrier pillars must be left in place as an additional safeguard. MM&A has adjusted the expected
mining recovery for highwall and auger mining resources to reflect highwall stability and safety
requirements.
>
The major assumptions made and Mineral Resource model used for pit and stope optimisation
(if appropriate).
>
Underground Mining Resources: For metallurgical resources, minimum coal seam thickness extends
down to between 0.6 and 1.2 meters and a minimum overburden (depth of cover) of 30.5 meters. A
61-meter horizontal distance is maintained from abandoned mines and sealed or pillared areas, and
a 30-meter horizontal distance is maintained from planned highwall miner panels. Mine recovery is
reduced when a rider coal seam is present within a 1.5- to 3.0-meter interval above the coal seam.
No mining is projected when the interval between overlying and underlying reserves is less than 12
meters.
>
Surface Mining Resources: For classification as a surface-mineable resource, a seam must be at least
0.3 meters in thickness as a stand-alone (principle) seam and 0.15 meters in thickness when less
than 0.8 meters from a principal seam. The maximum cumulative area mining strip ratio is generally
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
Appendix E: JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
14
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
20:1 for thermal coal and 30:1 for metallurgical coal. Some areas were assessed for their economic
viability at higher ratios, and were included as reserves if deemed economic. For contour surface
mining, a minimum of 38-meter bench is provided to support HWM.
>
HWM and Auger Mining Resources: HWM cut depth (penetration) is established at a maximum of
244 meters. The minimum mineable coal thickness is limited at 0.6 meters. For coal seams less than
0.8 meters thick, roof and/or floor characteristics must allow OSD cutting to maintain a 0.8-meter
minimum cutting height.
Auger mining cut depth is established at an average of 91 meters. The
minimum mineable coal thickness is limited at 0.5 meters.
>
The mining dilution factors used.
>
Underground Mining Reserves: The planning model assigns minimum mining heights of 1.4 to 1.8
meters for mains and panel development. At the Buchanan Mine, a minimum mining height of 1.8
meters was used due to the longwall mining method being employed. For coal seams thinner than
the assigned mining height, the difference between the coal seam height and assigned mining
height consists of OSD. In all cases a minimum of 0.05 meters of OSD was assumed, with the
exception of the Mon Valley mines, where a minimum 0.15 meters of OSD was assumed due to
weaker floor strata.
>
Surface Mining Reserves: Area mining is generally limited to a cumulative overburden ratio of 30:1
and a 15:1 ratio for contour mining. Exceptions were considered for mining of metallurgical grade
coal where deemed economical. It is assumed that careful cleaning of exposed coal pits will result in
minimal OSD.
>
HWM and Auger Mining Reserves: The mining plan assumes that the HWM cutting height is a
minimum of 76 to 99 centimeters for clearance purposes. When the coal seam is less than 76 to 99
centimeters thick, OSD assumed and included in the ROM product.
Because the auger has very
limited OSD cutting ability, it is assumed that an appropriate auger diameter will be chosen based on
the coal seam thickness and that OSD will be minimal.
>
The mining recovery factors used.
>
Underground Mining Reserves: Mine recovery generally varies between 40 and 60 percent for
continuous mining panels, and 100 percent for longwall.
>
Surface Mining Reserves: Mining recovery is 90 percent for virgin areas. Mining recovery is reduced
where second mining is projected in previously underground and auger mined areas.
>
HWM and Auger Mining Reserves: A mine recovery of 40 percent has been applied for HWM.
A
mine recovery of 35 percent has been applied for auger mining.
>
Any minimum mining widths used.
>
Underground Mining Reserves: Typical entry width is 5.8 to 6.1 meters.
>
The manner in which Inferred Mineral Resources are utilised in mining studies and the
sensitivity of the outcome to their inclusion.
>
Proved and probable coal reserve were derived from the defined in-situ coal resource considering
relevant processing, economic (including independent estimates of capital, revenue and cost,
marketing, legal, environmental, socioeconomic, and regulatory factors).
>
Mine plan LOM tonnage includes inferred coal and those areas that do not meet the minimum coal
thickness requirement for classification as reserve. Inferred coal represents approximately 0.6% of
the LOM production for Mon Valley and 0.000001% of the total LOM production for Logan. None of
this coal was included in the estimate of reserves.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
Appendix E: JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
15
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
>
The infrastructure requirements of the selected mining methods.
>
Underground Mining Resources: The continuous mining method provides for the extraction of coal
from the production faces using continuous miners (and longwall shearing machine at Buchanan)
and haulage using shuttle cars or battery haulers to a feeder-breaker located at the tail of the
section conveyor belt. The feeder-breaker crushes large pieces of coal and rock and regulates coal
feed onto the mine conveyor. A chain conveyor is used to remove coal from the longwall face at the
Buchanan Mine for placement onto the conveyor belt which is ultimately delivered to an
underground storage bunker. Roof-bolting machines are used to install roof bolts, and battery
scoops are available to clean the mine entries and assist in delivery of mine supplies to work areas.
Surface ventilation fans are installed as needed to provide a sufficient volume of air to ventilate
production sections, coal haulage and transport entries, battery charging stations, and transformers
in accordance with approved plans.
>
Coronado currently operates three coal preparation plants, one each at the Buchanan, Logan County
and Greenbrier Divisions. The Buchanan Plant operates at a feed rate of approximately 907 raw
tonnes per hour (
tph
), whereas the Saunders Plant (Logan County Division) has a nominal feed rate
of 816 tph, and the Mountaineer Plant (Greenbrier Division) operates at 544 tph.
MM&A has
included capital estimates for construction of additional coal preparation plants at the Russell
County and Mon Valley Complex for the purposes of this TRS.
>
Surface Mining Resources: The surface mining mobile equipment spreads advance the contour and
area mining pits while systematically reclaiming the trailing side of pits where coal has been
removed. The coal haul roads are extended and maintained as the pits advance. Support facilities
are maintained nearby but away from the active mining, and include storage areas for blasting
agents, fuel and lubricants, and mine supplies along with maintenance facilities and offices. Most of
the surface mine production is transported to a loading point for crushing, blending and direct-
shipment to customers.
>
HWM and Auger Resources: The HWM equipment advances along with the contour mining pits. The
rate of advance of the contour mining is governed by the advancement rate of the HWM. A diesel-
powered generator trails the highwall miner and powers the continuous mining unit. Other support
facilities are provided along with the contour mining support facilities. HWM production is all
transported by truck to the coal preparation plant for washing.
Metallurgical factors
or assumptions
>
The metallurgical process proposed and the appropriateness of that process to the style of
mineralisation.
>
Coarse material is washed in a heavy medium vessel. Intermediate-size material is washed in heavy
medium cyclones. Fine material is washed using conventional froth flotation cells.
>
Whether the metallurgical process is well-tested technology or novel in nature.
>
Processes are typical of those used in the coal industry and are in use at adjacent coal processing
plants.
>
The nature, amount and representativeness of metallurgical test work undertaken, the nature
of the metallurgical domaining applied and the corresponding metallurgical recovery factors
applied.
>
The quality characteristics for the subject coal resources and coal reserves have been reviewed in
detail by MM&A. The drill hole data were utilized to develop average coal quality characteristics
mining site. These average coal quality characteristics were then utilized as the basis for
determining the various markets into which the saleable coal will likely be placed.
>
Any assumptions or allowances made for deleterious elements.
>
No significant effects on product quality are anticipated from dilution material; float product quality
was used to model final product quality.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
Appendix E: JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
16
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
>
The existence of any bulk sample or pilot scale test work and the degree to which such
samples are considered representative of the orebody as a whole
>
No bulk sample or pilot scale work has been completed.
>
For minerals that are defined by a specification, has the ore reserve estimation been based on
the appropriate mineralogy to meet specifications?
>
Notwithstanding the complexity of the coal quality data set, the seams of the central and northern
Appalachian coalfields have a long history of providing both high-Btu thermal coals and high-, mid-
and low-volatile coking coals with favorable metallurgical properties.
Environmental
>
The status of studies of potential environmental impacts of the mining and processing
operation. Details of waste rock characterisation and the consideration of potential sites,
status of design options considered and, where applicable, the status of approvals for process
residue storage and waste dumps should be reported.
>
MM&A completed a Limited Phase I Environmental Site Assessment (
ESA
) on the Buchanan property
in April 2016, and on the Logan County and Greenbrier Properties in May 2017 on behalf of
Coronado.
>
MM&A identified one REC at Greenbrier associated with stained soil and gravel near a fueling and
maintenance area. Coronado reported to MM&A that satisfactory clean-up efforts were completed
at Greenbrier.
>
Based on these former ESAs completed by MM&A, it is MM&A’s opinion that Coronado has a
generally typical coal industry record of compliance with applicable mining, water quality, and
environmental laws. Estimated costs for mine closure, including water quality monitoring during
site reclamation, are included in the TRS financial models.
Infrastructure
>
The existence of appropriate infrastructure: availability of land for plant development, power,
water, transportation (particularly for bulk commodities), labour, accommodation; or the ease
with which the infrastructure can be provided or accessed.
>
Coronado currently operates one surface mine (Toney Fork Mine at the Logan Mine Complex);
Coronado also controls the idle Midland Surface Mine at the Greenbrier Mine Complex.
>
Coronado operates five underground mines as follows: Buchanan Mine at the Buchanan Mine
Complex; Winifrede, Eagle No. 1, Muddy Bridge and Lower War Eagle Mines in the Logan Mine
Complex; the Mountaineer #1 Mine at the Greenbrier Mine Complex is currently idle.
>
All ROM production is currently planned for either truck transportation from the mines to the
processing or shipping facilities, or in some cases there is either a current or planned mine mouth
preparation plant and barge/rail loading facility.
>
There is a network of public highways that provide serviceable coal haul routes and private, internal
roads on the Properties would be developed as may be needed. Rail service to the Properties is
most readily provided by NS and CSX
with connections to both domestic consumers and
international trans-shipment points. NS track is located across the Monongahela River from the
proposed Pangburn Hollow load-out facility. Coal would be shipped to customers via barge and rail
and sold as both metallurgical and thermal products.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
Appendix E: JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
17
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
Costs
>
The derivation of, or assumptions made, regarding projected capital costs in the study.
>
The methodology used to estimate operating costs.
>
Coronado provided historical and 5-year budget operating costs for its active mines for MM&A’s
review. MM&A used the historical and/or budget cost information as a reference and developed
personnel schedules for each mine. Hourly labor rates and salaries were based upon information
contained in Coronado’s financial summaries. Fringe benefit costs were developed for vacation and
holidays, federal and state unemployment insurance, retirement, workers’ compensation and
pneumoconiosis, casualty and life insurance, healthcare and bonuses. A cost factor for mine
supplies was developed that relates expenditures to mine advance rates for roof control costs and
other mine supply costs at underground mines. Other factors were developed for maintenance and
repair costs, rentals, mine power, outside services and other direct mining costs.
>
Surface mine direct operating costs were developed as a function of overburden ratio for repair and
maintenance supplies, diesel fuel, explosives and blasting, and miscellaneous supplies and services.
Operating costs for highwall mines are based on costs per ROM tonne estimates. Other cost factors
were developed for coal preparation plant processing, refuse handling, coal loading, trucking,
property taxes, and insurance and bonding. Appropriate royalty rates were assigned for production
from leased coal lands and sales taxes were calculated for state severance taxes, the federal black
lung excise tax, and federal and state reclamation fees.
>
Capital schedules were developed by MM&A for mine development, infrastructure, and on-going
capital requirements for the life of each projected mine.
>
Staffing levels were prepared and operating costs estimated by MM&A for each projected mine.
MM&A utilized historical cost data provided by Coronado and its own knowledge and experience to
estimate direct and indirect operating costs.
>
Allowances made for the content of deleterious elements.
>
No allowances have been made for deleterious elements; no impact to quality from deleterious
elements is anticipated.
>
The derivation of assumptions made of metal or commodity price(s), for the principal minerals
and co- products.
>
Coronado provided MM&A with price forecasts for all Properties. Customer coal pricing is derived
from market observed forward estimates based on global economic supply and demand analysis
which is applied to mine plan sales volumes and product mix and is supplemented with Coronado’s
in-house knowledge of applicable rail transportation charges, ocean freight charges and port
charges. Coal price forecasts for the various products were provided by Coronado for various coal
markets in terms of US nominal dollars per metric tonne. MM&A utilized this data for price
forecasting in financial modeling.
>
Derivation of transportation charges.
>
Coronado provided MM&A with price forecasts for all Properties. Customer coal pricing is derived
from market observed forward estimates based on global economic supply and demand analysis
which is applied to mine plan sales volumes and product mix and is supplemented with Coronado’s
in-house knowledge of applicable rail transportation charges, ocean freight charges and port
charges. Coal price forecasts for the various products were provided by Coronado for various coal
markets in terms of US nominal dollars per metric tonne. MM&A utilized this data for price
forecasting in financial modeling.
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
Appendix E: JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
18
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
>
The basis for forecasting or source of treatment and refining charges, penalties for failure to
meet specification, etc.
>
MM&A utilized historical cost data provided by Coronado and its own knowledge and experience to
estimate direct and indirect operating costs. All ROM production is currently planned for either
truck transportation from the mines to the processing or shipping facilities, or in some cases there is
either a current or planned mine mouth preparation plant and barge/rail loading facility.
>
The allowances made for royalties payable, both Government and private.
>
Appropriate royalty rates were assigned for production from leased coal lands and sales taxes were
calculated for state severance taxes, the federal black lung excise tax, and federal and state
reclamation fees.
Revenue factors
>
The derivation of, or assumptions made regarding revenue factors including head grade, metal
or commodity price(s) exchange rates, transportation and treatment charges, penalties, net
smelter returns, etc.
>
Coronado provided MM&A with price forecasts for all Properties. Customer coal pricing is derived
from market observed forward estimates based on global economic supply and demand analysis
which is applied to mine plan sales volumes and product mix and is supplemented with Coronado’s
in-house knowledge of applicable rail transportation charges, ocean freight charges and port
charges. Coal price forecasts for the various products were provided by Coronado for various coal
markets in terms of US nominal dollars per metric tonne. MM&A utilized this data for price
forecasting in financial modeling.
>
The derivation of assumptions made of metal or commodity price(s), for the principal metals,
minerals and co-products.
>
Coal sales prices as defined above. All reported reserves are on a marketable basis.
Market assessment
>
The demand, supply and stock situation for the particular commodity, consumption trends and
factors likely to affect supply and demand into the future.
>
Coronado provided MM&A with price forecasts for all Properties. Customer coal pricing is derived
from market observed forward estimates based on global economic supply and demand analysis
which is applied to mine plan sales volumes and product mix and is supplemented with Coronado’s
in-house knowledge of applicable rail transportation charges, ocean freight charges and port
charges. Coal price forecasts for the various products were provided by Coronado for various coal
markets in terms of US nominal dollars per metric tonne. MM&A utilized this data for price
forecasting in financial modeling.
>
A customer and competitor analysis along with the identification of likely market windows for
the product.
>
All of the mine production serves metallurgical and thermal markets. The metallurgical coal is
marketed as high-volatile (typically 28 percent or greater volatile matter content); mid-volatile
(typically 23- to 27-percent volatile matter content) and low-volatile (typically less than 23 percent
volatile matter content) products.
>
Raw ROM production that requires washing is currently processed through Coronado owned and
operated coal preparation plants.
>
ROM coal that does not require further processing is delivered directly to the loading points for
sizing and delivery to customers. Coronado has access to two rail-loading points serviced by the
Norfolk Southern Corporation (
NS
)
CSX Corporation (
CSX
)
.
>
Price and volume forecasts and the basis for these forecasts.
>
Carlson Mining
®
coal seams. Underground mine plans were sequenced based on productivity schedules provided by
Coronado, which were based on historically achieved productivity levels. Surface mine plans were
generated under productivity assumptions (bank cubic yard per shift) as provided by Coronado and
reviewed by MM&A, again based heavily on productivity levels achieved by Coronado. All
production forecasting ties assumed production rates to geological models as constructed
independently by MM&A’s team of geologists and mining engineers.
>
Coronado provided MM&A with price forecasts for all Properties. Customer coal pricing is derived
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
Appendix E: JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
19
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
from market observed forward estimates based on global economic supply and demand analysis
which is applied to mine plan sales volumes and product mix and is supplemented with Coronado’s
in-house knowledge of applicable rail transportation charges, ocean freight charges and port
charges. Coal price forecasts for the various products were provided by Coronado for various coal
markets in terms of US nominal dollars per metric tonne. MM&A utilized this data for price
forecasting in financial modeling.
Economic
>
The inputs to the economic analysis to produce the net present value (NPV) in the study, the
source and confidence of these economic inputs including estimated inflation, discount rate,
etc.
>
On an unlevered basis, the NPV of the project cash flows after taxes was estimated for the purpose
of classifying coal reserves. The project cash flows, excluding debt service, are calculated by
subtracting direct and indirect operating expenses and capital expenditures from revenue. Direct
costs include labor, drilling and blasting, operating supplies, maintenance and repairs, facilities costs
for materials handling, coal preparation, refuse disposal, coal loading, sampling and analysis
services, reclamation and general and administrative costs. Indirect costs include statutory and
legally agreed upon fees related to direct extraction of the mineral. The indirect costs are the
Federal black lung tax, Federal and State reclamation taxes, property taxes, local transportation
prior to delivery at rail or barge loading sites, coal production royalties, sales and use taxes, income
taxes and State severance taxes. Coronado’s historical costs provided a useful reference for MM&A’s
cost estimates.
>
Coronado provided MM&A with price forecasts for all Properties. Customer coal pricing is derived
from market observed forward estimates based on global economic supply and demand analysis
which is applied to mine plan sales volumes and product mix and is supplemented with Coronado’s
in-house knowledge of applicable rail transportation charges, ocean freight charges and port
charges. Coal price forecasts for the various products were provided by Coronado for various coal
markets in terms of US nominal dollars per metric tonne. MM&A utilized this data for price
forecasting in financial modeling.
>
All costs and prices are based on 2022 nominal United States dollars.
>
A pre-feasibility LOM plan was prepared by MM&A for active and proposed mines. MM&A prepared
mine projections and production timing forecasts based on coal seam characteristics. Production
timing was carried out from 2023 to depletion (exhaustion) of the coal reserve areas, which is
projected for the year 2100.
>
The all-mines average cash cost ranges between approximately $65 and $317 per tonne for most of
the operating period.
>
NPV ranges and sensitivity to variations in the significant assumptions and inputs.
>
An estimate of NPV at a base discount rate of 10.0% was included in Section 19 of the TRS.
>
NPV of the Buchanan, Russell, Mon Valley, Logan and Greenbrier Properties was estimated to be
$1.562 billion, $92.2 million, $168.3 million, $366.6 million and $62.7 million, respectively.
>
The sensitivity study shows the NPV at the 10.0% discount rate when Base Case sales prices,
operating costs, and capital costs are increased and decreased in increments of 5% within a +/- 15%
range.
Social
>
The status of agreements with key stakeholders and matters leading to social license to
operate.
>
Portions of the properties are located near local communities. Regulations prohibit mining activities
within 91 meters of a residential dwelling, school, church, or similar structure unless written consent
is first obtained from the owner of the structure. Where required, such consents have been
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
Appendix E: JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
20
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
obtained where mining is proposed beyond the regulatory limits.
Other
To the extent relevant, the impact of the following on the project and/or on the estimation and classification of
the Ore Reserves:
>
Any identified material naturally occurring risks.
>
No material naturally occurring risks have been identified.
>
The status of material legal agreements and marketing arrangements.
>
The Coronado coal resources are located in Buchanan, Russell and Tazewell Counties, Virginia;
Greenbrier, Logan, Boone, Wyoming and Greenbrier Counties, West Virginia; Allegheny, Washington
and Westmoreland Counties, Pennsylvania.
>
MM&A has not carried out separate title verification for the coal properties and has not verified
leases, deeds, surveys or other property control instruments pertinent to the subject resources.
>
Coronado has represented to MM&A that it controls the mining rights to the reserves as shown on
its property maps, and MM&A has accepted these as being a true and accurate depiction of the
mineral rights controlled by Coronado. The TRS assumes the properties are developed under
responsible and experienced management.
>
The status of government agreements and approvals critical to the viability of the project,
such as mineral tenement status and government and statutory approvals. There must be
reasonable grounds to expect that all necessary Government approvals will be received within
the timeframes anticipated in the Pre-Feasibility or Feasibility study. Highlight and discuss the
materiality of any unresolved matter that is dependent on a third part on which extraction of
the reserve is contingent.
>
Coronado has obtained all mining and discharge permits to operate 34 underground mines, 13
surface mines, and 18 processing, loadout or related facilities. MM&A is unaware of any obvious or
current Coronado permitting issues that are expected to prevent the issuance of future permits.
Coronado, along with all Central and Northern Appalachian basin coal producers, is subject to a level
of uncertainty regarding future clean water permits due to
United States Environmental Protection
Agency
(
EPA
)
Classification
>
The basis for the classification of the Ore Reserves into varying confidence categories.
Whether the result appropriately reflects the Competent Person’s view of the deposit. The
proportion of Probable Ore Reserves that have been derived from Measured Mineral
Resources (if any).
>
Measured and indicated resources have been converted to proved and probable reserves,
respectively.
>
None of the probable coal reserves have been derived from measured resources.
>
In a limited number of cases where there was only very limited data available to demonstrate the
metallurgical suitability of a given coal deposit, that deposit was classified as a probable reserve
instead of a proved reserve.
>
The results of this TRS define an estimated total initial ROM recoverable ore (coal) reserve estimate
of 551 million tonnes for Coronado as follows:
a)
Buchanan = 154 Mt
b)
Logan = 138 Mt
c)
Greenbrier= 12 Mt
d)
Russell = 50 Mt
e)
Mon Valley = 197 Mt
>
Coronado controls a total of 334 Mt (moist basis) of marketable coal reserves for Coronado as of
December 31, 2022 (total may not add due to rounding). Of that total, 74 percent are proved, and
26 percent are probable. Total reserves by complex are as follows:
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
Appendix E: JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
21
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
a)
Buchanan = 93 Mt
b)
Logan = 71 Mt
c)
Greenbrier= 7 Mt
d)
Russell = 30 Mt
e)
Mon Valley = 134 Mt
Audits or reviews
>
The results of any audits or reviews of Ore Reserve estimates.
>
MM&A completed prepared a statement of coal resources and reserves for the Properties in
accordance with the JORC Code as of December 31, 2017. MM&A also subsequently updated the
estimate of resources and reserves for depletion as of December 31, 2018, December 31, 2019,
December 31, 2020 and December 31, 2021.
>
MM&A performed a previous audit of the Properties in year 2017 for Coronado based on
U.S.
Securities and Exchange Commission (
SEC
)
performed by various independent consultants for predecessors-in-title to Coronado and at various
levels of detail depending on the clients concerns and the allotted time for completion. Previous
audits and reviews defined the primary coal resource areas and estimated the recoverable tonnes
for each seam based on the expected mining methods.
>
Additionally, MM&A has performed proprietary evaluations for predecessors-in-title to Coronado,
which encompass portions of the Properties included in this TRS.
Discussion of relative
accuracy/ confidence
>
Where appropriate a statement of the relative accuracy and confidence level in the Ore
Reserve estimate using an approach or procedure deemed appropriate by the Competent
Person. For example, the application of statistical or geostatistical procedures to quantify the
relative accuracy of the reserve within stated confidence limits, or, if such an approach is not
deemed appropriate, a qualitative discussion of the factors which could affect the relative
accuracy and confidence of the estimate.
>
Operations on the Properties by Coronado and its predecessors have been on-going for many years.
>
MM&A is confident that the mine plans and financial models are reasonably representative to
provide an accurate estimation of coal reserves.
>
Mine development and operation have not been optimized within the TRS.
>
The statement should specify whether it relates to global or local estimates, and, if local, state
the relevant tonnages, which should be relevant to technical and economic evaluation.
Documentation should include assumptions made and the procedures used.
>
Proved and probable coal reserve were derived from the defined in-situ coal resource considering
relevant processing, economic (including independent estimates of capital, revenue and cost),
marketing, legal, environmental, socioeconomic, and regulatory factors on a global scale as current
local data reflects the global assumptions.
>
Accuracy and confidence discussions should extend to specific discussions of any applied
Modifying Factors that may have a material impact on Ore Reserve viability, or for which there
are remaining areas of uncertainty at the current study stage.
The major risk factors for the active Coronado mines and future resource development are summarized below:
>
Mine Accidents
>
Highwall Failure. Highwall failures are likely to result in a temporary mine closure and should not
have a material impact on the mine sustainability. The risk is considered to be probable.
>
Adverse Geological Conditions. Adverse geological conditions include such conditions as faults and
sandstone washouts. The risk is considered to be probable. The impact is expected to be temporary
with little material impact on mine sustainability.
>
Environmental Risk. Numerous federal and state permits are required to operate coal mines and
mine surface facilities. Permitting rules are complex and may change over time, making compliance
difficult or impossible.
>
Water Quality. Permit requirements to fulfill Clean Water Act obligations are subject to
modification. The probability of water quality changes having a material impact on mine operations
Statement of Coal Resources and Reserves
in Accordance with SEC and the JORC Code as of December 31, 2021
Northern and Central Appalachian Coal Basins –
Virginia, West Virginia and Pennsylvania, USA
Appendix E: JORC Table 1
M
ARSHALL
M
ILLER
&
A
SSOCIATES
,
I
NC
.
22
Criteria
JORC Code explanation
Commentary
is possible. As a contemporary example, the selenium discharge issue that affects western Canadian
and Central Appalachian Basin operators has only recently emerged as a concern and its ultimate
impact has not been determined.
>
New Permits. Permit protests by environmental groups and individuals can contribute to permit
delays or denial and increase the cost of permitting and delay development. Surface mining
activities, coal refuse disposal and construction of access roads in mountainous terrain often require
storage of material in valley fills. Authority to dispose of fill material into waters of the United
States must be granted by the
United States Army Corps of Engineers (
COE
)
. COE permits are
increasingly difficult to obtain.
>
Regulatory Requirements. Adverse impact from regulatory changes is considered to be probable.
The impact will likely affect the broader industry and is not expected to result in mine closure.
>
Market Risk. Metallurgical and thermal coal markets ultimately depend upon the global steel and
thermal coal demand and are considered to be volatile. Currently, the US coal market has seen a
decline in demand for thermal coal due to thermal plant closures, as a result of new air and water
pollution regulations, and competition from other commodities used for power generation such as
natural gas. This has resulted in an overall decline in CAPP coal production. Continued regulatory
changes and declining demand could result in material changes in domestic and global coal markets.
The impact cannot be predicted at this time; however, while MM&A expects the coal reserve within
this TRS to remain economically viable throughout the life of the projected mines, the LOM financial
model is very sensitive to changes in coal sales price and therefore market risk is not insignificant.
>
Labor Risk. Work stoppage due to organized labor protests is considered to be unlikely and not
likely to lead to permanent mine closure. The mines are likely to suffer the loss of key supervisors
and skilled employees due to retirement as the workforce ages. The problem is industry-wide and
the impact is expected to be temporary and have no sustained impact on coal production.
>
Availability of Equipment and Supplies. Risk of equipment and supply availability is likely to be
temporary and should not have a sustained adverse impact on the production of coal.
>
Transportation Delay. Interruption of coal transport services by river or rail is considered to be
probable but unlikely to have a sustained impact on coal production.
>
It is recognised that this may not be possible or appropriate in all circumstances. These
statements of relative accuracy and confidence of the estimate should be compared with
production data, where available.
>
Mine plans, productivity expectations and cost estimates generally reflect historical performance
and efforts have been made to adjust plans and costs to reflect future conditions.