Riley Exploration Permian, Inc. CORRESP, filed May 21, 2008: filename1.htm
Tengasco, Inc.
10215 Technology Drive, Suite 301
Knoxville, TN 37932-4307
865.675.1554
865.675.1621 (facsimile)
May 21,
2008
Mr. Karl Hiller, Branch Chief, Division of Corporation Finance
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
100 F Street, N.E.
Washington, D. C. 20549 VIA EDGAR FILING
Re:
Tengasco, Inc. Form 10-Q for the Quarter Ended September 30, 2007
File No. 1-15555
Dear Mr. Hiller:
This letter sets our position as discussed in the recent telephone conversation with you
and others in your offices concerning the accounting treatment of the September 17, 2007
transaction between Tengasco, Inc. and Hoactzin Partners, LP consisting of a ten well
drilling program, net profits interest in methane project, and contingent exchange
agreement of methane net profits interest for preferred stock. For reference in this
letter, this will be referred to as the “Hoactzin Agreement”.
Our position is that we must follow FIN 45 "Guarantor's Accounting and Disclosure
Requirements for Guarantees, Including Indirect Guarantees of Indebtedness of Others" with
regard to the Hoactzin Agreement. Paragraph 7(d) of Financial Interpretation No. 45, carves
out from liability recognition (but not from disclosure requirements) the Hoactzin
Agreement. The substance of 7(d) reads as follows: “7. The following types of
guarantees are not subject to the initial recognition and initial measurement provisions of
this Interpretation but are subject to its disclosure requirements: … d. A guarantee
for which the guarantor’s obligation would be reported as an equity item (rather than
a liability) under generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP).” We believe there
can be no disagreement that the “guarantee” here in the form of (contingently
issuable) preferred stock (not mandatorily redeemable) would be reported as an equity item
not a liability.
The
Company's position is that the fair value of the “guarantee” aspect of the
transaction was immaterial at inception, that the “guarantee”' provision was
entered into fairly late in the negotiations, was proffered as a incentive by the Company
to effectuate the transaction, and according to management's analysis which in this related
party-transaction was available to all parties would have been of no additional value in
almost all scenarios considered. The Company proposes to disclose this circumstance, as is
called for in the disclosure requirements of FIN 45 - which calls for disclosing "(a) the
nature of the guarantee, including the approximate term of the guarantee, how the guarantee
arose and the events or circumstances that would require the guarantor to perform under the
guarantee … .”
In future
financial statements the Company proposes to include a policy note regarding its policy of
following FIN 45 relating to guarantees. As we have recently done in our Form 10-Q for the
period ending March 31, 2008, the Company has clarified our disclosure to conform to these
requirements . The Company has disclosed the FIN 45 elements of: (a) the nature of the
guarantee, including the approximate term of the guarantee, how the guarantee arose; (b)
the maximum potential amount of future payments under the guarantee; (c) the carrying
amount of the liability, if any, for the guarantor’s obligations under the guarantee;
and (d) the nature and extent of any recourse provisions or available collateral that would
enable the guarantor to recover the amounts paid under the guarantee. Incidentally, this
disclosure was also included in our Form 10-K for the year ending December 31, 2007
in form previously submitted to you in response to your desire to see additional
disclosure. See Item 13, “Certain Relationships and Related Transactions, and
Director Independence”, which expressly incorporates by reference the “Certain
Items” in the Company’s Proxy Statement for Annual Shareholder’s Meeting.
The incorporated “Certain Items” section of the Proxy Statement appears at
pages 23-27 of the Proxy Statement and concludes at page 27 with the statement that
“As a result, the Company believes it is highly unlikely that any obligation to issue
preferred stock will arise under the terms of this agreement at any time in the
future.” In that our first quarter 2008 10-Q and the 2007 10-K now includes this
disclosure as indicated in your previous correspondence we believe there is little
practical utility in amending the 3rd quarter 2007 Form 10-Q as has been
suggested in your recent letters to us.
The Company believes that the Hoactzin Agreement need not be divided into separate parts
for the purpose of allocating a portion of the amount paid for the drilling program to the
methane project. Doing so would only allocate from one class of asset to another, and such
an allocation to the methane project would under any scenario have an immaterial effect on
the financial presentation.
We believe this fully addresses and properly resolves all matters raised in the recent
telephone conversation. Should you have any further requirement please let us know and the
basis for the position taken so that we may properly respond so that these matters may be
concluded.
Very truly yours,
TENGASCO,
INC.
BY:
s/Jeffrey R. Bailey
JEFFREY R. BAILEY, Chief Executive Officer