Interparfums Inc CORRESP, filed Jul 23, 2009: A correspondence can be sent as a document with another submission type or can be sent as a separate submission.
Inter
Parfums, Inc.
551 Fifth
Avenue
New York,
NY 10176
July 23,
2009
United
States
Securities
and Exchange Commission
Washington,
D.C. 20549-7010
Att.: Mr.
Rufus Decker, Accounting Branch Chief
Division
of Corporation Finance
|
Re:
|
Form
10-K and Form 10-K/A for the fiscal year ended December 31,
2008
|
|
Form
10-Q for Fiscal Quarter Ended March 31, 2009
|
|
|
File No.
0-16469
|
Ladies
and Gentlemen:
This letter is written in response to
the letter dated June 17, 2009 of Mr. Rufus Decker, Accounting Branch Chief,
addressed to Mr. Russell Greenberg, the Chief Financial Officer of Inter
Parfums, Inc. (the “Staff Letter”). We have reproduced the comments from the
Staff Letter, and our responses follow each of such comments.
Comment
from Staff Letter:
FORM 10-K FOR THE YEAR ENDED
DECEMBER 31, 2008
General
|
|
1.
|
Where
a comment below requests additional disclosures or other revisions to be
made, these revisions should be included in your future filings, including
you interim filings if applicable.
|
Company response:
1. Below
are our responses to the comments set forth in the Staff Letter, which provide
the requested information, and we acknowledge that such responses will be
included in future filings.
Comment
from Staff Letter:
Item 7, Management’s
Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operation, page
29
United States
Securities and Exchange Commission
July 23, 2009
Page 2 of 13
Discussion of Critical
Accounting Policies – Equipment and Other Long-Lived Assets, page
34
2. We
have read your response to comment five from our letter dated April 30,
2009.
Please enhance your disclosures
accordingly:
|
|
·
|
It
is unclear that you evaluation for goodwill impairment follows the two
step method set forth in paragraphs 19 through 21 of SFAS
142. Please revise your disclosures to
clarify.
|
|
|
·
|
It
still remains unclear how you determine when long-lived assets should be
tested for impairment. Please disclose what types of events and
circumstances indicate impairment, and how frequently you evaluate for
these types of events and
circumstances;
|
|
|
·
|
Please
expand your discussion of the significant estimates and assumptions used
to determine estimated future cash flows and fair value. Please
disclose how you determine the applicable risk adjusted discount rate,
future sales levels and terminal values used in your discounted cash flow
projections; and
|
|
|
·
|
With
regards to the residual value of the Lanvin brand names and trademarks,
you indicated that residual value is determined by reference to
appropriate sales more robust discussion so that a reader understands the
underlying assumptions you have used to determine the Lanvin brand names
and trademark’s residual value.
|
Company response:
2. We
will modify our Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and
Results of Operations with respect to the Discussion of Critical Accounting
Policies – Equipment and Other Long-lived Assets to contain substantially the
following text:
“We
evaluate goodwill and indefinite-lived intangible assets for impairment on an
annual basis during the fourth quarter, or when events occur or circumstances
change that would more likely than not reduce the fair value of the reporting
unit below its fair value or indicating that the carrying value of an
indefinite-lived intangible asset may not be recoverable. Impairment
of goodwill is evaluated using a two step process. The first step involves a
comparison of the estimated fair value of the reporting unit to the carrying
value of that unit. If the carrying value of the reporting unit exceeds the fair
value of the reporting unit, the second step of the process involves comparison
of the implied fair value of goodwill (based on industry purchase and sale
transaction data) with its carrying value. If the carrying value of the
reporting unit’s goodwill exceeds the implied fair value of that goodwill, an
impairment loss is recognized as an amount equal to the excess.
For
indefinite-lived intangible assets, the evaluation requires a comparison of the
estimated fair value of the asset to the carrying value of the asset. If the
carrying value of an indefinite-lived intangible asset exceeds its fair value,
as generally estimated using discounted future net cash flow projections and
discounted terminal values, the carrying value of the asset would be reduced to
its fair value.
United States
Securities and Exchange Commission
July 23, 2009
Page 3 of 13
The fair
values used in our evaluation are estimated based upon discounted future cash
flow projections. The cash flow projections are based upon a number of
assumptions, including risk-adjusted discount rates, future sales levels and
future cost of goods and operating expense levels, as well as economic
conditions, changes to our business model or changes in consumer acceptance of
our products which are more subjective in nature. We believe that the
assumptions that we have made in projecting future cash flows for the
evaluations described above are reasonable. However, if future actual results do
not meet our expectations, we may be required to record an impairment charge,
the amount of which could be material to our results of operations.
Intangible
assets subject to amortization are evaluated for impairment testing whenever
events or changes in circumstances indicate that the carrying amount of an
amortizable intangible asset may not be recoverable. If impairment indicators
exist for an amortizable intangible asset, the undiscounted future cash flows
associated with the expected service potential of the asset are compared to the
carrying value of the asset. If our projection of undiscounted future cash flows
is in excess of the carrying value of the intangible asset, no impairment charge
is recorded. If our projection of undiscounted future cash flows is less than
the carrying value of the intangible asset, an impairment charge would be
recorded to reduce the intangible asset to its fair value. The cash flow
projections are based upon a number of assumptions, including future sales
levels and future cost of goods and operating expense levels, as well as
economic conditions, changes to our business model or changes in consumer
acceptance of our products which are more subjective in nature. In those cases
where we determine that the useful life of long-lived assets should be
shortened, we would depreciate the net book value in excess of the salvage value
(after testing for impairment as described above), over the revised remaining
useful life of such asset thereby increasing amortization expense.”
With respect to bullet points three and
four of comment number two, it appears that the information the staff is
requesting goes well beyond the requirements of SFAS 142 and what other
companies disclose in their 10-K filings, and as such, we believe the existing
disclosure (as modified above) complies with the applicable
requirements without the additionally requested information. In addition, some
of the information requested in bullet points three and four may be deemed
confidential, as such information could give insight to our competition
regarding our internal acquisition and disposition criteria. For the foregoing
reasons, we do not believe the information requested in bullet points three and
four should be or needs to be disclosed.
Comment
from Staff Letter:
Liquidity and Capital
Resources, page 40
|
|
3.
|
We
have read your response to comment eight from out letter dated April 30,
2009. Please tell us supplementally the nature of the material
negative covenants and why you do not believe disclosure of those specific
negative covenants are warranted.
|
United States
Securities and Exchange Commission
July 23, 2009
Page 4 of 13
Company response:
3. As
indicated in our initial response, we advised that our long term debt facilities
only contain negative covenants customarily found in such facilities. As such,
we believe they are boilerplate and not material. These negative covenants
require us to inform the lender in advance if we wished to enter into another
loan or lease agreement that would significantly increase our financial burden,
or transfer assets in excess of the original loan amounts not in the ordinary
course of business or provide funding or a third party guarantee not in the
ordinary course of business. If violated, these negative covenants would permit
the lenders to accelerate the debt if not cured within applicable grace periods.
As of March 31, 2009, long-term debt excluding its current portion aggregated
$23.8 million. Total equity and total assets aggregated $248 million and $396
million respectively. We do not believe that these covenants provide any
significant restrictions and we do not believe that disclosure of these
customary negative covenants is warranted.
Comment
from Staff Letter:
|
|
FORM 10-K/A FOR THE
YEAR ENDED DECEMBER 31, 2008
|
Item 11, Executive
Compensation, page 2
Compensation Discussion and
Analysis, page 2
Elements of Compensation,
page 3
|
|
4.
|
We
note that your compensation committee considered “individual performance,
level of responsibility, skills and experience, and other compensation
awards or arrangements” when determining the specific components of
compensation for your named executive officers. With a view
towards future disclosure, please tell us how these factors impacted the
actual compensation decisions for 2008 made by the committee for each
named executive officer. Please address each element of
compensation separately. Your response should clarify, for
example, how the committee determined both the magnitude of the bonuses
that were paid and the number of shares underlying the equity awards that
were granted.
|
Company response:
4. The
named executive officers in Item 11 have all been with the company for more than
the past ten (10) years, with Messrs. Madar and Benacin being founders of the
company in 1985. As previously disclosed, Mr. Madar for United States
operations, and Mr Benacin for European operations, each recommend executive
compensation levels for executives in the respective operating segments. In
addition, and also as previously reported, Messrs. Greenberg, the Chief
Financial Officer of the company (as well as United States operations) and
Santi, the Chief Financial Officer of European operations, also participate in
recommendations for executive compensation levels for executives in the
respective operating segments.
United States
Securities and Exchange Commission
July 23, 2009
Page 5 of 13
As
Messrs. Madar and Greenberg for United States operations, and Benacin and Santi
for European operations, are most familiar with the individual performance,
level of responsibility, skills and experience of each executive officer in
their respective segments, the committee relies upon the information provided by
such executive officers in determining individual performance, level of
responsibility, skills and experience of each executive officer. Accordingly, we
propose to make the following disclosure in Item 11, under the “General”
subsection, in substantially the following form:
“General
Our named executive officers have all
been with the company for more than the past ten (10) years, with Messrs. Madar
and Benacin being founders of the company in 1985. As previously disclosed, Mr.
Madar for United States operations, and Mr Benacin for European operations, each
recommend executive compensation levels for executives in the respective
operating segments. In addition, and also as previously reported, Messrs.
Greenberg, the Chief Financial Officer of the company (as well as United States
operations) and Santi, the Chief Financial Officer of European operations, also
participate in recommendations for executive compensation levels for executives
in the respective operating segments.
As Messrs. Madar and Greenberg for
United States operations, and Benacin and Santi for European operations, are
most familiar with the individual performance, level of responsibility, skills
and experience of each executive officer in their respective segments, the
committee relies upon the information provided by such executive officers in
determining individual performance, level of responsibility, skills and
experience of each executive officer.”
In addition, we propose to make the
following disclosure in Item 11, under the “Base Salary”, in substantially the
following form (which also incorporates our response to staff comment number
seven regarding bonus compensation):
“Base
Salary
Base salaries for executive officers
are initially determined by evaluating the responsibilities of the position held
and the experience of the individual, and by reference to the competitive market
place for executive talent. Base salaries for executive officers are reviewed on
an annual basis, and adjustments are determined by evaluating our operating
performance, the performance of each executive officer, as well as whether the
nature of the responsibilities of the executive has changed.
United States
Securities and Exchange Commission
July 23, 2009
Page 6 of 13
As stated above, as Messrs. Madar and
Greenberg for United States operations, and Benacin and Santi for European
operations, are most familiar with the individual performance, level of
responsibility, skills and experience of each executive officer in their
respective segments, the committee relies upon the information provided by such
executive officers in determining individual performance, level of
responsibility, skills and experience of each executive officer.
For executive officers of United States
operations, the bulk of their annual compensation is in base salary. However,
for executive officers of European operations base salary comprises a smaller
percentage of overall compensation.
We have paid a lower percentage of
overall compensation in the form of base salary to executive officers of
European operations for several years, principally because European operations
historically have had higher profitability than United States operations and
European operations are run differently by the chief executive officer of
European operations, Mr. Benacin, than United States operations. As the result
of this historically higher profitability, European operations have had the
ability to pay higher bonus compensation in addition to base salary. As bonus
compensation is and has historically been discretionary, no targets were set in
order to maintain flexibility. Further, if results of operations for European
operations were not satisfactory (again, no target amounts were set to maintain
flexibility), then bonus compensation, as well as overall compensation could be
lowered without otherwise affecting base salary. Finally, by keeping annual
bonus compensation at a higher percentage of overall compensation and base
salary at a lower percentage, our company benefits because the base amount for
annual salary adjustments would be smaller.
Upon the recommendation of Mr. Benacin,
the base salaries of Mr. Philippe Santi, the Chief Financial Officer of Inter
Parfums, S.A., and Mr. Frederic Garcia-Pelayo, were each increased from 192,000
euros in 2007 to 220,800 euros in 2008, a 15% increase. Likewise, Mr. Benacin’s
base compensation was increased from 192,000 euros in 2007 to 220,800 euros in
2008.
A different approach is taken for
United States operations as that segment is much smaller and profitability is
much more volatile. A more significant base salary is paid in order to attract
and retain employees with the skills and talents needed to run the operation
with a lesser emphasis placed on bonuses. Mr. Madar, the Chief
Executive Officer, did not request any increase in his base salary and
accordingly none was authorized by the committee. Mr. Madar’s base salary has
been maintained at the same level of $400,000 for the past several
years.
Upon recommendation of our Chief
Executive Officer, the committee determined to increase the base salary of Mr.
Greenberg, the Chief Financial Officer, by $30,000 from $405,000 to $435,000, a
7.4% increase. Mr. Greenberg has received the same salary increase of $30,000
for the past four years.”
United States
Securities and Exchange Commission
July 23, 2009
Page 7 of 13
In
addition, we propose to add the following disclosure in Item 11, under the
“Bonus Compensation/ Annual Incentives,” in substantially the following
form:
“We have paid a higher percentage of
overall compensation in the form of bonus compensation to executive officers of
European operations for several years, principally because European
operations historically have had higher profitability than United States
operations. As the result of this historically higher profitability, European
operations have had the ability to pay higher bonus compensation in addition to
base salary. As bonus compensation is discretionary no targets were set in order
to maintain flexibility. Further, if results of operations for European
operations were not satisfactory (again, no target amounts were set to maintain
flexibility), then bonus compensation, as well as overall compensation could be
lowered without otherwise affecting base salary. Mr. Benacin, the chief decision
maker for European operations, proposed and the committee concurred in the
payment of bonus compensation equal to approximately 70% of base salary for
executive officers of European operations. This is compared to bonus
compensation as a percentage of annual salary of 82% for 2007 for Messrs. Santi
and Garcia-Pelayo and approximately 64% for Mr. Benacin in 2007, and
approximately 87% for 2006 for Messrs. Santi and Garcia-Pelayo and 68% for Mr.
Benacin in 2006.
A different approach is taken for
United States operations as that segment is much smaller and profitability is
much more volatile. A more significant base salary is paid in order to attract
and retain employees with the skills and talents needed to run the operation
with a lesser emphasis placed on bonuses. Based upon the recommendation of the
Chief Executive Officer, Mr. Greenberg received a cash bonus of $35,000 for 2008
as compared to a cash bonus of $43,100 for 2007. In order for Mr. Madar, the
Chief Executive Officer to receive a cash bonus, United States operations has to
achieve after tax profit target. In 2008, based upon such targets, our Chief
Executive Officer did not earn any cash bonus. In 2007, based upon such targets,
our Chief Executive Officer earned a $100,000 cash bonus. The Executive
Compensation Committee has determined to use the same after tax profit target
for our company’s United States operations to calculate Mr. Madar’s bonus for
2009.”
In
addition, we propose to delete the last paragraph, and to add the following
disclosure in Item 11, under the “Bonus Compensation/ Annual Incentives,” in
substantially the following form:
“As required by French law, Inter
Parfums, SA maintains its own profit sharing plan for all French employees who
have completed three months of service, including executive officers of our
European operations other than Mr. Benacin, the Chief Executive Officer of Inter
Parfums, SA. Benefits are calculated based upon a percentage of taxable income
of Inter Parfums, S.A. and allocated to employees based upon salary. The maximum
amount payable per year per employee is 25,000 euros, or approximately
$34,792.
United States
Securities and Exchange Commission
July 23, 2009
Page 8 of 13
Calculation
of total annual benefits contribution is made according to the following
formula:
50% of
(Inter Parfums, S.A. net income, less 5% of shareholders equity without net
income for the year) times a fraction, the numerator of which is wages, and
the denominator of which is net income before tax + wages + taxes (other
than income tax) + valuation allowances + amortization expenses + interest
expenses.
Contribution to individual employees is
then made pro rata based upon their individual salaries for the
year.”
Re
Stock Options
We have
previously disclosed that as a general rule, the number of options granted is
determined by several factors, but most importantly, both individual and company
operating results for the past year, as well as past option grants to such
executives. Also as previously disclosed, we have temporarily discontinued all
option grants to purchase shares of our majority-owned, French subsidiary, Inter
Parfums, S.A. to avoid dilution of our ownership interest in Inter Parfums, S.A.
In lieu of option grants to purchase shares of our majority-owned, French
subsidiary, we have granted options to our French executive officers and
employees under the French Addendum to our stock option plan, which have a term
of 6 years and vest 4 years after the date of grant.
In
addition, we propose to add the following disclosure in Item 11, under the “Long
Term Incentives/Stock Options”, in substantially the following
form:
“Stock Options.
* *
*
In December 2008, upon the
recommendation of the company’s Chief Executive Officer, the Executive
Compensation and Stock Option Committee granted options to purchase a total of
19,000 shares of our common stock to each of Jean Madar and Philippe Benacin,
and 15,000 shares to Mr. Greenberg, all at the fair market value on the date of
grant. Option grants to Messrs Madar and Benacin are the same, as each is the
Chief Executive Officer of their respective operating segments.
During
2007 and in early 2008, upon the recommendation of the company’s Chief Executive
Officer, the Executive Compensation and Stock Option Committee granted options
to purchase a total of 42,375 shares of our common stock to each of Jean Madar
and Philippe Benacin, 22,500 shares to Mr. Greenberg, and 12,750 to each of
Messrs. Santi and Garcia-Pelayo, all at the fair market value on the date of
grant.
United States
Securities and Exchange Commission
July 23, 2009
Page 9 of 13
Option
grants made in 2008 and 2007 were reduced from the option grants made during
2006, when Messrs. Madar and Benacin received options to purchase 60,000 shares,
and Mr. Greenberg received options to purchase 37,500 shares. However, option
grants were increased for Messrs. Santi and Garcia-Pelayo who each received
options to purchase 7,500 shares as they no longer receive option grants from
Inter Parfums, S.A.”
Comment
from Staff Letter:
|
|
5.
|
Your
compensation discussion and analysis should be sufficiently precise to
identify material differences in compensation policies with respect to
individual named executive officers. Please see Section II.B1.
of Commission Release No. 33-8732A. In this regard, we note
from the summary compensation table that Mr. Benacin received “other
compensation” in the form of lodging expenses that significantly exceeded
the “other compensation” received by your other named executive
officers. With a view towards future disclosure, please provide
us with a more detailed discussion of how and why Mr. Benacin compensation
differs from that of the other named executive officers. If
policies or decision relating to a named executive officer are materially
different from the other officers, please discuss this on an
individualized basis.
|
Company response:
5. Mr.
Benacin is the Chief Executive Officer of Inter Parfums, S.A. (European
operations), as well as a founder of the company, and accordingly, there should
be some recognition of his responsibility, skills and experience, as well as the
results of the company. In view of his service to the company, Mr. Benacin has
received a housing and automobile allowance for more than the past ten (10)
years. This is a method of acknowledging his responsibility, skills and
experience, as well as the company operating results, and at the same level as
the other named executive officers of European operations. Accordingly, we
propose to add the following disclosure in substantially the following form in
the compensation discussion and analysis section.
“Other
Compensation
Mr. Benacin is the Chief Executive
Officer of Inter Parfums, S.A. (European operations), as well as a founder of
our company, and we believe we should recognize his responsibility, skills and
experience, as well as the results of the company. In view of his service to the
company, Mr. Benacin has received a housing and automobile allowance for more
than the past ten (10) years. This is a way we have differentiated him from
other executive officers of European operations, and acknowledged his
responsibility, skills and experience, as well as the company operating results,
while maintaining his base salary at the same level as Messrs. Santi and
Garcia-Pelayo, the other named executive officers of European
operations.”
United States
Securities and Exchange Commission
July 23, 2009
Page 10 of 13
Comment
from Staff Letter:
Base Salary, page
3
|
|
6.
|
We
note the base salaries were determined in part by “reference to the
competitive market place for executive talent.” With a view
towards future disclosure, please tell us how your compensation committee
defines the market place and ascertains the competitive conditions within
that market. In doing so, please clarify the extent to which
your compensation decisions are derived from or based on a comparison to
peer companies, being sure to identify the peer companies by name, or
otherwise described your methodologies for utilizing comparative
information when implementing your compensation policies or marking
specific compensation awards. To the extent any specific
elements of compensation are tied to a benchmark, please identify the
benchmark and discuss where your actual payments and awards fell with
respect to the benchmark, and to the extent that actual compensation
deviated from the benchmark, please provide an explanation of the reasons
for this deviation. Please refer to Item 402(b)(2)(xiv) of
Regulation S-K and Question 118.05 of the Compliance and Disclosure
Interpretations of the staff of the Division of Corporation Finance
concerning Item 402 of Regulation S-K, which can be found on our
website.
|
Company response:
6. The
committee views the competitive market place very broadly, which would include
executive officers from both public and privately held companies in general,
including fashion and beauty companies, but not limited to the “peer companies”
contained in the corporate performance graph contained in the Annual Report on
form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2008. Rather than tie their
determination of compensation proposals to any specific peer companies, the
members of the committee have used their business experience, judgement and
knowledge to review the executive compensation proposals recommended to them by
Messrs. Madar and Benacin for United States operations and European operations,
respectively. As such the committee did not determine the need to “benchmark”
(as such term is defined in question 118.05 Compliance and Disclosure
Interpretations of Staff of the Division of Corporation Finance) of any material
item of compensation or overall compensation. We believe the members of the
committee have extensive experience and business acumen (as discussed below) and
are well qualified in determining the appropriateness of executive compensation
levels.
United States
Securities and Exchange Commission
July 23, 2009
Page 11 of 13
Accordingly,
we propose to supplement the Compensation, Discussion and Analysis by the
addition of the following disclosure, in substantially the following
form:
“The compensation committee views the
competitive market place very broadly, which would include executive officers
from both public and privately held companies in general, including fashion and
beauty companies, but not limited to the “peer companies” contained in the
corporate performance graph contained in our Annual Report on form 10-K for the
year ended December 31, 2008. Rather than tie the compensation committee’s
determination of compensation proposals to any specific peer companies, the
members of our committee have used their business experience, judgement and
knowledge to review the executive compensation proposals recommended to them by
Mr. Madar for United States operations and Benacin for European operations. As
such, compensation committee did not determine the need to “benchmark” of any
material item of compensation or overall compensation.
The members of the compensation
committee have extensive experience and business acumen and are well qualified
in determining the appropriateness of executive compensation levels. Mr.
Heilbronn is a managing partner of a business consulting firm in the area of
mergers and acquisitions of large international companies in retail, consumer
goods and consumer services throughout the world. Mr. Levy has over thirty years
experience as an executive officer, including more than ten years as President
and Chief Executive Officer of well known cosmetic companies such as Cosmair and
Sanofi Beaute (France). Mr. Choël, the final committee member, is presently a
business consultant and advisor, who previously worked as President and Chief
Executive Officer of two divisions of LVMH Moet Hennessy Louis Vuitton S.A.,
which included such well known brands as Parfums Christian Dior, Guerlain, and
Parfums Givenchy.”
Comment
from Staff Letter:
Bonus Compensation/Annual
Incentives, page 3
|
|
7.
|
We
note your disclosure that cash bonuses for named executive officers
responsible for European operations are generally larger than the bonuses
paid to their counterparts responsible for U.S.
operations. With a view towards future disclosure, please
provide us with a materially complete analysis for the reasons for this
apparently disparate treatment. Please see Sections II.B.1. of
Commission Release No. 33-8732A. You should also explain how
your compensation committee determined the magnitude of the bonuses that
were actually paid for 2008.
|
Company response:
7. Payment
of a higher percentage of overall compensation in the form of bonus compensation
to executive officers of European operations has been consistently followed for
several years, principally because European operations historically have had
higher profitability than United States operations. As the result of this
historically higher profitability, European operations have had the ability to
pay higher bonus compensation in addition to base salary. The chief decision
maker for European operations, Mr. Benacin, initially determined and recommended
to the compensation committee, and in which the compensation committee concurs,
that payment of bonus compensation as a high percentage of base salary
(generally in the 60-90%) in lieu of a higher base salary would benefit the
company, because of the ability of European operations to pay higher bonus
compensation. As the determination of bonus compensation for European operations
is discretionary no targets were set in order to maintain flexibility. Further,
if results of operations for European operations were not satisfactory (again no
target amounts were set to maintain flexibility), then bonus compensation, as
well as overall compensation could be lowered without otherwise affecting base
salary for such executives.
United States
Securities and Exchange Commission
July 23, 2009
Page 12 of 13
A
different approach is taken for United States operations as that segment is much
smaller and profitability is much more volatile. A more significant base salary
is paid in order to attract and retain employees with the skills and talents
needed to run the operation with a lesser emphasis placed on
bonuses.
Please see our proposed disclosure in
response to Item 4, above.
Comment
from Staff Letter:
|
|
8.
|
We
note from the summary compensation table that two of your named executive
officers received non-equity incentive plan compensation. With
a view towards future disclosure, please provide us with a materially
complete analysis of these awards, including how the amounts of the awards
were determined and under what plan or plans the awards were
granted.
|
Company response:
8. We
have disclosed at pages 9-10 of the Annual report on Form 10-K/A Amendment No. 1
for the year ended December 31, 2008 (“2008 10-K/A 1”) the
following:
“Inter
Parfums, S.A. Profit Sharing Plan
As required by French law, Inter
Parfums, SA maintains its own profit sharing plan for all French employees who
have completed three months of service, including executive officers of our
European operations other than Mr. Benacin, the Chief Executive Officer of Inter
Parfums, SA. Benefits are calculated based upon a percentage of taxable income
of Inter Parfums, S.A. and allocated to employees based upon salary. The maximum
amount payable per year per employee is 25,000 euros, or approximately
$34,792.
United States
Securities and Exchange Commission
July 23, 2009
Page 13 of 13
Calculation
of total annual benefits contribution is made according to the following
formula:
50% of
(Inter Parfums, S.A. net income, less 5% of shareholders equity without net
income for the year) times a fraction, the numerator of which is wages, and
the denominator of which is net income before tax + wages + taxes (other
than income tax) + valuation allowances + amortization expenses + interest
expenses.
Contribution to individual employees is
then made pro rata based upon their individual salaries for the
year.”
We propose to add substantially the
same disclosure as set forth above as a footnote to the Summary Compensation
Table.
* * *
*
As previously requested, we acknowledge
the following:
|
|
·
|
the
company is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in
their filings;
|
|
|
·
|
staff
comments or changes to disclosure in response to staff comments do not
foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the
filing; and
|
|
|
·
|
the
company may not assert staff comments as a defense in any proceeding
initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities
laws of the United States.
|
I trust that this adequately addresses
your questions. However, if further information is required, please feel free to
contact the undersigned.
Very truly yours,
/s/ Russell Greenberg
Russell Greenberg,
Executive Vice President
and Chief financial
Officer