Dror Ortho-Design, Inc. CORRESP, filed Oct 19, 2010: filename1.htm
RICHARDSON
& PATEL LLP
10900
Wilshire Boulevard
Suite
500
Los
Angeles, CA 90024
Telephone
(310) 208-1182
Facsimile
(310) 208-1154
October
19, 2010
Mr.
Patrick Gilmore
Accounting
Branch Chief
Division
of Corporation Finance
Securities
and Exchange Commission
100 F
Street, N.E.
Washington,
DC 20549
|
Re:
|
Novint
Technologies, Inc.
|
|
|
Form
10-K/A for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2008
|
||
|
Filed
April 23, 2009
|
||
|
Your
File No. 000-51783
|
Dear Mr.
Gilmore:
On behalf
of Novint Technologies, Inc., (the “Company” or “Novint”), set forth below are
the Company’s substantive responses to the comments received from the staff
(“Staff”) of the Securities and Exchange Commission in the letter dated October
5, 2010. We have reproduced the Staff’s comments in bold type for
your convenience and have followed the comment with the Company’s
response. References in this letter to “we”, “our”, or “us” mean the
Company or its advisors, as the context may require.
Note 2 – Summary of
Significant Accounting Policies
Intangible Assets, page
F-8
|
1.
|
We
note in your response to prior comment 2 that you believe there is no
basis to review your license agreements for impairment because there are
“no sales or lack thereof with these games available to base such
impairment analysis.” Please clarify whether you tested your
intangible assets for impairment during 2008 or 2009 and provide us with
the following additional
information:
|
|
·
|
Your
response to comment 1 indicates that “overall the larger portion of [your]
developing revenue stream is in [your] special projects offerings” and
that “product sales were not as high as expected”. Tell us
whether these statements are an indication that you plan to shift your
focus toward project offerings and how these factors impact your
impairment assessment during 2008 and during the nine months ended
September 30, 2009.
|
Mr.
Patrick Gilmore
Accounting
Branch Chief
Securities
and Exchange Commission
Re: Novint
Technologies, Inc.
October
19, 2010
Page
2
|
·
|
We
note that you based your decision not to impair your intangible assets
upon your belief that once “these software titles are released [your]
sales will significantly increase.” Please provide the key
assumptions used in your analysis, including revenue and cost of sales
growth rates for the subsequent 3
years.
|
|
·
|
To
the extent that you did not test your intangible assets for impairment
during 2008 or the nine months ended September 30, 2009, please tell us
how you considered paragraph 8 of SFAS 144, particularly in light of the
fact that you determined that your hardware was not properly priced for
the current market.
|
RESPONSE:
We
respectfully note the Staff's comment. To clarify, yes the Company
did test its intangible assets for impairment for the year ended December 31,
2008 but it did not perform additional tests for the nine months ended September
30, 2009.
|
·
|
Novint
did not nor does it plan to shift its focus toward project
offerings. Its advanced products group ("APG"), which runs its
projects, is essentially a division that runs separately from its game
products group. Different employees work for the advanced
project group than those that work for the game products
group. APG was set up to be self sustaining and only completes
work on a project by project basis, with no capital infusion
required. The recent increase in revenues resulting from the
APG does not have an impact on the Company’s game products and therefore
was not considered in its impairment
analysis.
|
|
·
|
Novint
is both a hardware and software company. In general, in the gaming
industry, any company that sells hardware needs to provide strong game
support to drive their hardware sales. This is true of large console
manufacturers like Sony, Microsoft, and Nintendo, and small companies that
make game controllers, like Novint. Sony, for example, recently released a
product called Move. Even with Sony's significant budgets
towards this product, its success will depend heavily on Sony's ability to
garner additional game support. Any hardware platform in the
game industry is heavily dependent on game support. Novint has
always felt that strong game support is one of the single biggest
criteria, perhaps the single biggest criteria, in increasing its hardware
sales. With added game support, the Company felt that it would be able to
drive many more hardware sales, and generally increase its ability to sell
both in retail and online distribution channels. Increased hardware sales,
and therefore a much larger installed-base of its hardware, it felt would
in turn drive many more software game sales. The Company assumed that for
each hardware unit sold, it would sell several games, as customers who buy
any type of game hardware typically buy several games over the hardware's
lifetime, to get full enjoyment out of the hardware. The key
assumptions the Company used in developing its analysis were that with the
release of the AAA games and subsequent AAA games thereafter, it could
sell up to 50,000 hardware units over the next year after launch and that
for each hardware unit sold it would sell 4 games, or a total of 200,000
games. At a conservative average price of $20 per game, this
would be equal to $4,000,000, approximately of which half would be
attributed to those games under license agreements. This amount greatly
exceeds the unamortized value of the license agreements. The Company did
not prepare nor has it prepared revenue and costs of sales growth rates
for any point in the future other than discussed
above. Novint’s analysis was also based upon the fact only 50%
of the asset value remained as unamortized and that it believes the sales
generated after the release of the AAA games would more than cover the
unamortized cost of the licenses. Overall, the release of AAA
games represented what management believed would be a significant
transition period in the Company’s
business.
|
Mr.
Patrick Gilmore
Accounting
Branch Chief
Securities
and Exchange Commission
Re: Novint
Technologies, Inc.
October
19, 2010
Page
3
|
·
|
As
previously mentioned, Novint did test its intangible assets for impairment
for the year ended December 31, 2008 but did not test for impairment for
the period ended September 30, 2009. In considering paragraph 8
of FAS 144, the Company did not believe there were any events or changes
in circumstances that indicated the carrying value of its license
agreements may not be recoverable and therefore deemed it not necessary to
test the assets for recoverability. The fact that Novint
impaired its inventory due to its high retail price did not prove that its
license agreements were not recoverable. When a product is
launched, it takes time to determine what the market will pay for the
product. Even with its limited sales experience, the Company
knew its hardware product was overpriced. In the gaming
industry, most of the revenues earned are from game sales and not hardware
sales. Consumers are willing to pay more than $50 for one
game. Novint’s games conservatively average $20 for the AAA
titles. The Company believed and still does believe it will
sell the games once it is able to release more titles and market the
product as management would like to. The Company does not
believe the impairment of its inventory has any relation to the
recoverability of its license agreements and does not believe paragraph 8
of FAS 144 is applicable. In fact, the Company believes that by
lowering the price of its hardware product, it will sell more software,
thereby increasing its ability to recover the cost of its license
agreements.
|
Mr.
Patrick Gilmore
Accounting
Branch Chief
Securities
and Exchange Commission
Re: Novint
Technologies, Inc.
October
19, 2010
Page
4
Note 4 – Prepaid Expenses,
page F-13
|
2.
|
We
note in your response to prior comment 3 that the prepaid royalty expenses
represent guaranteed minimum payments to third party software
companies. We further note that the amortization of these
repayments is based upon the number of games sold. Please
provide us with the following additional
information:
|
|
·
|
Advise
whether the guaranteed minimum payments stipulated in your agreements are
monthly, quarterly or annual requirements. In the event that
the agreements include any such time-based guaranteed minimum payments,
tell us how you considered recognizing expense on a monthly, quarterly or
annual basis.
|
|
·
|
Confirm
whether any of the prepayments will be refunded to the extent that sales
do not reach the levels anticipated in the
agreement.
|
|
·
|
Your
disclosure on page F-13 indicates that you separate your prepaid royalty
expenses between current and long term assets. Describe how you
make the distinction in light of your lack of sales experience as well as
your consideration of Chapter 3 of Accounting Research Bulletin
43.
|
|
·
|
Confirm
that you will provide enhanced disclosure of these arrangements in future
filings, including details regarding the guaranteed payment requirements
and the existence of any potential refund options as discussed
above.
|
RESPONSE:
We
respectfully note the Staff's comments and offer you the following:
|
·
|
None
of the guaranteed minimum payments are time-based. Each
agreement calls for the guaranteed minimum payment to be paid up front and
earned royalties are to be offset against the guaranteed
minimum. If the Company sells more games than is covered by the
minimum guaranty, the Company would then be required to pay royalties
according to the agreement on a quarterly
basis.
|
|
·
|
The
guaranteed minimum amounts are non-refundable and if the Company does not
sell enough games to recoup the amounts prepaid it will not receive a
refund.
|
|
·
|
Due
to its lack of sales history, the Company does not have a clear operating
cycle and therefore in accordance with ARB 43 Chapter 3, the Company
follows the one-year rule for assets to be considered
current. The prepaid royalties the Company classified as
current are those in which it believes will be recognized in the next
year, or to more clearly state, those that are expected the Company would
have cash outflow for in the next year had it not paid them in
advance. In determining the amount for current versus long term
the Company analyzed each game individually. Based upon the
prepaid amount the Company determined how many games it would need to sell
to recover the total prepaid amount. From that it calculated
its best educated estimate of how many units of each game the Company
thought it would sell over the next twelve months taking into
consideration the release of the AAA game titles, subsequent AAA game
title releases and the lowering of the price of the
hardware. This analysis, like that of the license agreements,
was based upon the estimate used of selling up to 50,000 hardware units
over the next year after the release of the AAA games and selling up to 4
games with each hardware unit sold or 200,000 games. At a
conservative average price of $20 per game, this would be equal to
$4,000,000, approximately of which half would be attributed to those games
under prepaid royalties. This was only an estimate and it changed from
quarter to quarter in 2009 as new information came in to play and will
continue to change as actual results are revealed. The Company
expects it will recover the full amount prepaid but the timing of that
recovery and the release of each game is unknown and therefore results in
use of estimations.
|
|
·
|
In
future filings the Company confirms it will provide enhanced disclosure of
the arrangements surrounding the guaranteed payment requirements and the
existence of any potential refund options, if
any.
|
We hope that the information contained
in this letter satisfactorily addresses the comments by the
Staff. Please do not hesitate to contact the undersigned by telephone
at (310) 208-1182, or by facsimile at (310) 208-1154.
|
Sincerely
yours,
RICHARDSON & PATEL LLP
|
|||
|
|
By:
|
/s/Addison
Adams
|
|
|
Addison
Adams
|
|||
| cc: | Tom Anderson, CEO, Novint Technologies, Inc. |
|
Craig
Stegeman, CPA, AJ. Robbins, P.C.
|