Dror Ortho-Design, Inc. CORRESP, filed Aug 31, 2010: filename1.htm
RICHARDSON
& PATEL LLP
10900
Wilshire Boulevard
Suite
500
Los
Angeles, CA 90024
Telephone
(310) 208-1182
Facsimile
(310) 208-1154
August
31, 2010
Mr.
Patrick Gilmore
Accounting
Branch Chief
Division
of Corporation Finance
Securities
and Exchange Commission
100 F
Street, N.E.
Washington,
DC 20549
|
Re:
|
Novint
Technologies, Inc.
|
Form 10-K/A for the Fiscal Year Ended
December 31, 2008
Filed April 23, 2009
Your File No. 000-51783
Dear Mr.
Gilmore:
On behalf
of Novint Technologies, Inc., (the “Company” or “Novint”), set forth below are
the Company’s substantive responses to the comments received from the staff
(“Staff”) of the Securities and Exchange Commission in the letter dated August
17, 2010. We have reproduced the Staff’s comments in bold type for
your convenience and have followed the comment with the Company’s
response. References in this letter to “we”, “our”, or “us” mean the
Company or its advisors, as the context may require.
Note 2 – Summary of
Significant Accounting Policies
Software Development Costs,
page F-8
|
1.
|
We
note that you have approximately $585,000 of capitalized software
development costs that you amortize ratably over the estimated life of the
product, typically 5 years. Please tell us how you determined
that a 5 year amortization period is reasonable. Additionally,
describe how you compared these costs to the net realizable value of the
product as of December 31, 2008, particularly in light of the following
factors:
|
|
|
·
|
You reported increasing losses
from operations and reported cash outflows from operation in each of the
past four years.
|
Mr.
Patrick Gilmore
Accounting
Branch Chief
Securities
and Exchange Commission
Re: Novint
Technologies, Inc.
August
31, 2010
Page
2
|
|
·
|
Your disclosure on page F-6 and
the Report of Independent Registered Public Accounting Firm indicates
there is substantial doubt about your ability to continue as a going
concern.
|
|
|
·
|
You wrote down $218,000 of your
inventory balance to net realizable value based upon your lower of cost or
market analysis.
|
Refer
to ASC 985-20-35-4.
RESPONSE:
We respectfully note the Staff's
comment. For the year ended December 31, 2008, the Company accounted for its
software development costs in accordance with FAS 86. Although in
comparing FAS 86 to ASC 985-20-35-4 the Company and its advisors noted no
differences, the Company believes referencing the ASC is inappropriate as it was
not effective for the period under review. The Company’s software
development costs that have been capitalized are all related to its haptics
technology software that drives its hardware products. As the
software is directly related to its hardware the Company believes a 5 year
estimated life is more reasonable to use than the standard 3 years for most
other software. During the year ended 2008, the Company continued its
efforts to develop and improve the hardware based upon feedback received since
the launch in mid 2007. Based upon the above reasoning, the Company
believes using a 5 year life appears reasonable for its software development
costs.
Although the Company wrote down
inventory by $218,000 to net realizable value, based upon lower of cost or
market at December 31, 2008, due to market conditions and its limited
manufacturing runs, the Company evaluated its capitalized software development
costs and determined that no impairment was necessary. While inventory is a
current asset at December 31, 2008, the Company’s software development costs
were expected to benefit future periods' revenues, not just from product sales
of its Falcon consumer devices. Overall the larger portion of the
Company’s developing revenue stream is in its special projects
offerings. The Company’s projects currently generate the majority of
its revenues. Based upon FAS 86 (ASC 985-20-35-4), the Company
understands that the total unamortized capitalized costs at December 31, 2008
are to be compared to the net realizable value of the revenue in determining if
impairment exists. The net realizable value is the estimated future
gross revenues from that product (project) reduced by the estimated future costs
of completing and disposing of that product (project).
As of the Company’s December 31, 2008
reporting period the Company considered the following:
Mr.
Patrick Gilmore
Accounting
Branch Chief
Securities
and Exchange Commission
Re: Novint
Technologies, Inc.
August
31, 2010
Page
3
The Company began selling the Falcon in
July 2007 and had limited sales since the launch, caused primarily by limited
software titles available to support the product (titles were in
development). Once the Company begins releasing AAA game titles, it
expects its sales will dramatically increase. Since the Falcon has
not had AAA game titles available since its launch, the Company did not have
adequate data to analyze for impairment as its product offerings were
continuing to develop. Should these titles be released and sales not
improve, the Company will have better supportive information to use in
determining whether or not impairment exists (related to product
sales).
In addition, although product sales
were not as high as expected, the Company’s special projects revenue
increased substantially. The Company does not believe that
associating its software development costs only with its product inventory and
revenue is appropriate. Its projects utilize the same software
development costs as its products.
As a result of the Company’s analysis
regarding both the future revenues to be generated from its products and its
increasing project revenues, both of which utilize the software development
costs, the Company believed and continues to believe that no impairment was
necessary.
Although the Company’s cash flows from
operations were negative during the year ended December 31, 2008, it does not
believe that should impact its impairment analysis. A large portion
of its operating overhead resulted from its continuing development of software
titles to be utilized by the Falcon.
The Company’s negative cash flows from
operations and other factors such as continuing losses from operations lead to
the conclusion that there was substantial doubt regarding its ability to
continue as a going concern. While the Company has generated revenues
from operations, it is an early stage technology company and as such, is reliant
upon outside sources of financing to continue the development of its
product. At the time of issuance of the financial statements, the
Company did not have sources of additional financing available to
it. The Company did not believe that the "going concern" opinion
should have impacted its analysis.
Mr.
Patrick Gilmore
Accounting
Branch Chief
Securities
and Exchange Commission
Re: Novint
Technologies, Inc.
August
31, 2010
Page
4
Intangible Assets, page
F-8
|
2.
|
We
note that you have approximately $680,000 of intangible assets, net of
accumulated amortization, consisting primarily of licensing
agreements. We further note your conclusion that no impairment
loss was required in 2008 or 2007. Please provide us with a
detailed description of each license agreement and patent making up your
intangible asset balance and include the estimated useful life, and the
gross and net amounts of each license and patent as of December 31,
2008. Additionally, please clarify how you determined that an
impairment charge was not necessary during 2008 and how you considered the
following factors in your impairment
analysis:
|
|
|
·
|
You reported increasing losses
from operations and reported cash outflows from operations in each of the
past four years.
|
|
|
·
|
Your disclosure on page F-6 and
the Report of Independent Registered Public Accounting Firm indicates
there is substantial doubt about your ability to continue as a going
concern.
|
|
|
·
|
You wrote down $218,000 of your
inventory balance to net realizable value based upon your lower of cost or
market analysis.
|
RESPONSE:
We respectfully note the Staff's
comment. Per your request for additional detail, we have attached a
detailed schedule of the Company’s licensing agreements and patents as of
December 31, 2008. The schedule for the licensing agreements includes
the date of the agreement, estimated useful life, acquisition cost (gross
balance), accumulated amortization as of December 31, 2008 and the net balance
as of December 31, 2008. The schedule for the Patents includes the
date, who the patent was filed with, description of the costs and overall
patent, gross amounts, accumulated amortization at December 31, 2008, net
balance at December 31, 2008 and the status of each as of December 31,
2008.
In regards to the Company’s decision to
not record impairment during the year ending December 31, 2008, we refer you to
the following as of the December 31, 2008 reporting period:
The $680,000 net balance as of December
31, 2008 related to the intangible assets including additions of $433,000, net
during the year ended December 31, 2008. Of the $680,000 net
balance, 63% is related to current year additions. The majority of
these intangibles are amortized over the term of the license agreement,
regardless of sales totals. These licenses are the basis for games
that will be available in the future. The development process ranges
from approximately six months to two years.
The Company did not launch its hardware
product until mid 2007 and although launched, the Company had not yet developed
the variety of games needed (in its estimation) to generate significant
sales. The costs associated with these license agreements relate to
the licensing of games to be developed for the Falcon that the Company believed
would drive a significant increase in sales. Once the license
agreements are entered, there is additional time required to develop those games
to integrate with its hardware and as a result the Company will not see the
benefits of these agreements until it launches the underlying
games. As such, there is no basis to review these costs for
impairment as there are no sales or lack there of with these games available to
base such impairment analysis.
Mr.
Patrick Gilmore
Accounting
Branch Chief
Securities
and Exchange Commission
Re: Novint
Technologies, Inc.
August
31, 2010
Page
5
The Company's cash outflows have
related to costs of being a publicly traded company and the acquisition and
development of the hardware and software with little sales
generated. Although negative operating cash flows currently and in
the past and a going concern was expressed, the Company does not believe this
impacts its review of impairment of these licenses as its sales have not been
based upon its hardware with this software support. The Company
believes once these software titles are released its sales will significantly
increase and support the decision not to impair. At the time of the
filing of its 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2008, the Company’s
development process of these game titles continued and it believed impairment of
the value was not appropriate at such an early stage of
development.
The Company’s write down of its
hardware inventory balance during the year ended December 31, 2008 was the
result of a determination that its product was not properly priced for the
current market. At the time of the filing of its 10-K for the year
ended December 31, 2008, the United States domestic economy was at its worst and
its then pricing structure would not generate significant sales. As a
result of the Company’s decision to lower its prices, the Company wrote down
inventory. The expected effect of lower hardware prices was that it
would result in increased sales of its software titles. Therefore,
the Company believed the inventory write down had no impact on the valuation or
impairment analysis of its licensing agreements. The Company believed
that lower priced hardware and the availability of AAA software titles would
generate significant sales, further supporting the net book value of these
titles.
Note 4 – Prepaid Expenses,
page F-13
|
3.
|
We
note that prepayments on your royalties comprise approximately $1,585,000
of the prepaid expenses reported on your Balance Sheet as of December 31
2008. Please describe the nature of the prepaid royalties and
how you analyzed the realizability of these prepaid royalties in light of
the following factors:
|
|
|
·
|
You reported increasing losses
from operations and reported cash outflows from operations in each of the
past four years.
|
|
|
·
|
Your disclosure on page F-6 and
the Report of Independent Registered Public Accounting Firm indicates
there is substantial doubt about your ability to continue as a going
concern.
|
Mr.
Patrick Gilmore
Accounting
Branch Chief
Securities
and Exchange Commission
Re: Novint
Technologies, Inc.
August
31, 2010
Page
6
RESPONSE:
We respectfully note the Staff’s
comment. The Company’s prepaid royalties consist of amounts paid to
software companies for the exclusive license to add haptic enabled software to
their games and sell the games for the Company’s benefit for use with its Novint
Falcon product. The agreements with these software companies are
similar to the Company’s license agreements except the license agreements are
for a specific period of time and the prepaid royalty agreements specifically
state the amounts paid are for prepaid royalties on future game sales based upon
units to be sold. Each agreement calls for a certain amount to be
paid to the software company for each game sold. The amounts prepaid
are guaranteed amounts and no further amounts are owed unless the number of
units sold exceeds that for which has already been paid. The Company
amortizes these costs based upon the number of games sold.
In regards to the realizability of
these prepaid royalties, of the $1.6 million balance as of December 31, 2008,
approximately $1.4 million or 87.5% were net additions during the year ended
December 31, 2008. The Company was only beginning to develop those
titles for release. The development process ranges from approximately
six months to two years. A majority of the current year additions
relate to one software company, who's games are considered AAA
games. The Company believed the release of those games along with the
release of games under a licensing agreement with another AAA game software
company would result in dramatically increased sales of both hardware and
software. The Company expected its increasing net losses and cash
outflows from operations would decrease once these titles were
released. As these games had not been fully developed, the Company
was unable to determine what future sales of these games would be or what impact
they would have on the sales of its Novint Falcon product. As with
its license agreements, the Company believed that once these software
titles were released its sales would significantly increase and support the
decision not to impair. At the time of the filing of its 10-K for the
year ended December 31, 2008, the Company’s development of these game titles
continued and therefore the Company determined that impairment of the value was
not appropriate at such an early stage of development.
* * * * *
You have also requested a statement
from the Company acknowledging certain matters. In response to this
request, we direct the Staff’s attention to the acknowledgment letter dated
August 31, 2010 from the Company to you signed by Tom Anderson, its
CEO.
Mr.
Patrick Gilmore
Accounting
Branch Chief
Securities
and Exchange Commission
Re: Novint
Technologies, Inc.
August
31, 2010
Page
7
We hope that the information contained
in this letter satisfactorily addresses the comments by the
Staff. Please do not hesitate to contact the undersigned by telephone
at (310) 208-1182, or by facsimile at (310) 208-1154.
|
Sincerely
yours,
|
|
|
RICHARDSON
& PATEL LLP
|
|
|
By:
|
/s/
Addison Adams
|
|
Addison
Adams
|
|
|
cc:
|
Tom
Anderson, CEO, Novint Technologies,
Inc.
|
Craig Stegeman, CPA, AJ. Robbins,
P.C.
Enclosure
Novint
Technologies, Inc.
License
Agreements
As
of Dec 31, 2008
|
Placed in
Service
Date
|
Depr
Meth/Conv
|
Life Yr Mo
|
Life
Months
|
Acquisition
Cost
|
Accumulated
Depreciation
12/31/08
|
Net Balance
12/31/08
|
||||||
|
4/11/2000
|
SL
|
12 yr 0 mo
|
144
|
30,000
|
21,875
|
8,125
|
||||||
|
5/15/2004
|
SL
|
3 yr 0 mo
|
36
|
15,000
|
15,000
|
-
|
||||||
|
12/31/2004
|
SL
|
3 yr 0 mo
|
36
|
200,000
|
200,000
|
-
|
||||||
|
11/1/2006
|
SL
|
3 yr 0 mo
|
36
|
5,000
|
3,611
|
1,389
|
||||||
|
3/31/2007
|
SL
|
4 yr 0 mo
|
36
|
10,001
|
5,834
|
4,167
|
||||||
|
4/6/2007
|
SL
|
3 yr 0 mo
|
36
|
3,000
|
1,750
|
1,250
|
||||||
|
5/25/2007
|
SL
|
3 yr 0 mo
|
36
|
20,000
|
10,556
|
9,444
|
||||||
|
5/16/2007
|
SL
|
3 yr 0 mo
|
36
|
10,000
|
5,417
|
4,583
|
||||||
|
5/10/2007
|
SL
|
3 yr 0 mo
|
36
|
4,000
|
2,222
|
1,778
|
||||||
|
4/21/2007
|
SL
|
3 yr 0 mo
|
36
|
302,000
|
167,778
|
134,222
|
||||||
|
6/15/2007
|
SL
|
3 yr 0 mo
|
36
|
3,490
|
1,745
|
1,745
|
||||||
|
12/31/2007
|
SL
|
3 yr 0 mo
|
36
|
25,000
|
8,333
|
16,667
|
||||||
|
12/31/2007
|
SL
|
3 yr 0 mo
|
36
|
15,000
|
5,000
|
10,000
|
||||||
|
5/30/2008
|
SL
|
3 yr 0 mo
|
36
|
5,000
|
972
|
4,028
|
||||||
|
5/30/2008
|
SL
|
3 yr 0 mo
|
36
|
15,000
|
2,917
|
12,083
|
||||||
|
3/31/2007
|
SL
|
3 yr 0 mo
|
36
|
41,634
|
24,286
|
17,348
|
||||||
|
3/31/2008
|
SL
|
3 yr 0 mo
|
36
|
7,000
|
1,750
|
5,250
|
||||||
|
5/6/2008
|
SL
|
3 yr 0 mo
|
36
|
10,500
|
2,333
|
8,167
|
||||||
|
6/6/2008
|
SL
|
30 months
|
30
|
500,000
|
116,667
|
383,333
|
||||||
|
5/30/2008
|
SL
|
3 yr 0 mo
|
36
|
5,000
|
972
|
4,028
|
||||||
|
6/30/2008
|
SL
|
3 yr 0 mo
|
36
|
1,418
|
236
|
1,182
|
||||||
|
8/7/2008
|
SL
|
3 yr 0 mo
|
36
|
10,500
|
1,458
|
9,042
|
||||||
|
9/30/2008
|
SL
|
3 yr 0 mo
|
36
|
7,000
|
583
|
6,417
|
||||||
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
||||||
|
Subtotal: Licensing Agreements
|
1,245,543
|
601,296
|
644,247
|
|||||||||
Novint
Technologies, Inc.
Patent
Costs
As
of Dec 31, 2008
Note:
This schedule was updated based on discussions with Gerald Grafe. The life of
the patents is 20 Years.
|
Accum Amort
|
Net balance
|
Status
|
||||||||||||||||
|
Type
|
Date
|
Num
|
Name
|
Patent Costs Memo
|
Amount
|
at 12/31/08
|
12/31/2008
|
as 12/31/08
|
Description
|
|||||||||
|
Check
|
8/14/02
|
3813
|
U.S.P.T.O
|
Anderson/Atty
Docket #
|
$824.00
|
$824.00
|
on
appeal
|
Filling
fee for US application 10/228,462; "Force Frames in
Animation"
|
||||||||||
|
Check
|
5/14/03
|
3929
|
U.S.P.T.O
|
$504.00
|
$100.80
|
$403.20
|
Issued
12/21/04
|
Fee
with office action response in 09/638,186; "Human Computer
Interface"
|
||||||||||
|
Check
|
12/3/03
|
8040
|
U.S.P.T.O
|
Patent
Filing Fee
|
$502.00
|
$502.00
|
on
appeal
|
Filing
fee for US application 10/729,574; "Human Computer interfaces
Incorporating Haptics And Path-Based Interation"
|
||||||||||
|
Check
|
12/3/03
|
8041
|
U.S.P.T.O
|
Patent
Filing Fee
|
$1,858.00
|
$1,858.00
|
$0.00
|
decided
not to file for a national patent
|
Filing
fee for PCT application PCT/US2003/038509; "Human- computer interfaces
incorporating haptics and path-based interation"
|
|||||||||
|
Check
|
2/13/04
|
8043
|
U.S.P.T.O
|
Issue
Fee for 09/649.853
|
$1,330.00
|
$315.88
|
$1,014.13
|
issued
on 4/20/04
|
Issue
fee for US application 09/649,853; patent 6,724,400; "Human- Computer
Interface Incorporating Personal and Application
Domains"
|
|||||||||
|
Check
|
2/13/04
|
8044
|
U.S.P.T.O
|
Issue
Fee for 09/690,343
|
$665.00
|
$157.94
|
$507.06
|
issued
on 4/24/04
|
Issue
fee for US application 09/690,343; patent 6,727,924; "Human- Computer
Interface including Efficient Three-Dimensional
Controls"
|
|||||||||
|
Check
|
2/13/04
|
8045
|
U.S.P.T.O
|
VOID:
Office Action Res
|
$0.00
|
$0.00
|
||||||||||||
|
Check
|
2/13/04
|
8046
|
U.S.P.T.O
|
Assignment
Recordation
|
$200.00
|
$200.00
|
$0.00
|
patent
assignment
|
USPTO
fee for recording assignment to Novint in 5 different applications ($40
per application): application 10/226,462, 09/785,696, 09/690,343,
09/638,186
|
|||||||||
|
Check
|
3/12/04
|
8049
|
U.S.P.T.O
|
Patent
Continuation on
|
$770.00
|
$770.00
|
still
pending
|
US
Patent application 10/801,756; "Human-Computer Interface Incorporating
Personal and Application Domains"
|
||||||||||
|
Check
|
3/12/04
|
8050
|
Sassan
Ma
|
Patent
Submission in C
|
$1,200.00
|
$1,200.00
|
$0.00
|
Dropped
this patent; so need to expense
|
Fees
for filling Canada national application from PCT application
PCT/US02/31536; "Coordinating Haptics with Visual Images in a
Human-Computer Interface"
|
|||||||||
|
Check
|
7/13/04
|
4207
|
U.S.P.T.O
|
09/638,186-Issue
Fee
|
$1,330.00
|
$266.00
|
$1,064.00
|
issued
on 12/21/04
|
Issue
fee for US application 09/638,186; "Human-Computer
Interface"
|
|||||||||
|
Check
|
7/13/04
|
4208
|
U.S.P.T.O
|
09/638,186-Petition
Fee
|
$1,330.00
|
$266.00
|
$1,064.00
|
issued
on 12/21/04
|
Revival
fee for US application 09/638,186; "Human-Computer
Interface"
|
|||||||||
|
Check
|
9/15/04
|
4246
|
Cassan
Ma
|
Patent
Submission in Ce
|
$221.00
|
$221.00
|
$0.00
|
We
did not continue this one; need to expense
|
Canadian
Patent App. #2461724
|
|||||||||
|
8/31/07
|
PCT
Filer
|
Patent
Application
|
$14,925.17
|
$14,925.17
|
still
pending
|
Application:
PCT/EP2006/001244 Force Dimension application to Canada, China, Europe,
and Japan
|
||||||||||||
|
8/31/07
|
PCT
Filer
|
Patent
Application
|
$15,047.13
|
$15,047.13
|
still
pending
|
Application:
PCT/EP2006/001245 Force Dimension application to Canada, China, Europe,
and Japan
|
||||||||||||
|
$40,706.30
|
$4,585.61
|
|