DILLARD'S, INC. CORRESP, filed Jan 25, 2007: filename1.htm
January
25, 2007
United
States Security and Exchange Commission
Michael
Moran, Accounting Branch Chief
100
F
Street N.E.
Washington,
DC 20549-7010
Dear
Mr.
Moran:
We
are in
receipt of your letter dated January 10, 2007 regarding our Form 10-K for
the
Fiscal Year Ended January 28, 2006 and our Form 10-Q for the Fiscal Quarter
Ended October 28, 2006. Our responses to your comments are provided below.
We
have repeated each of your comments in full and the response to each comment
is
noted directly below the quoted comment. As noted in response to comment
No. 1,
we will make the changes discussed in future filings, commencing with our
10-K
for the Fiscal Year Ending February 3, 2007.
Form
10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended January 28, 2006
General
|
1.
|
Where
a comment below requests additional disclosure to be included,
please show
us in your supplemental response what your revised disclosures
will look
like. These additional disclosures should be included in your future
filings.
|
Response:
As
requested, each response relating to additional disclosures or revisions
to
disclosures is accompanied by language showing what the revisions will look
like
in future filings, using information as of the end of our 2006 fiscal year.
Such
disclosures or revisions will be made in future filings, commencing with
our
Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ending February 3, 2007.
Item
1. Business
General
|
2.
|
Please
disclose in tabular form for each period presented the amount or
percentage of total revenue or sales contributed by each class
of similar
products or services. Refer to Item 101(c)(1)(i) of Regulation
S-K.
|
Response:
We
will
include percentage of sales by major product line for each year an income
statement is presented. The disclosure will read as follows:
|
%
of Net Sales by category
|
||||||||||
|
2006
|
2005
|
2004
|
||||||||
|
Cosmetics
|
xx
|
%
|
14.7
|
%
|
14.5
|
%
|
||||
|
Apparel
|
xx
|
%
|
76.7
|
%
|
76.5
|
%
|
||||
|
Other
|
xx
|
%
|
8.6
|
%
|
9.0
|
%
|
||||
|
xx
|
%
|
100.0
|
%
|
100.0
|
%
|
|||||
Item
7. Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of
Operations
Executive
Overview
General
- Net Sales, page 13
|
3.
|
We
note that you lease to independent companies certain departments
and
classify the revenue received in net sales. Please provide us support
and
explain why you classify income from leased departments in net
sales
instead of separately stating the lease income or combining it
with other
income. See Rule 5-03 of Regulation
S-X.
|
Response:
AICPA
Technical Practice Aid 5100.16 and Rule 5-03(b)(1)(c) require income from
rentals to be included in net sales and total revenue. As such, we recorded
rental income from leased departments within net sales. Our total rental
revenue
from Leased Departments for the fiscal year ended January 28, 2006 was $8.5
million or 0.1% of total net sales and is below the 10 percent threshold
established under Rule 5-03(b) and Rule 4-02 of Regulation S-X. Thus, we
feel it
is immaterial and plan to continue to combine it with Net Sales. However,
we do
acknowledge, and we have controls to monitor, that if it were to exceed 10%
of
net sales, it would need to be disclosed as a separate line item of Net
Sales.
General
- Service Charge, Interest and Other Income, page 13
|
4.
|
Please
tell us what factors you considered in supporting your determination
that
equity income from your joint ventures is appropriately included
as
operating income. Include in your explanation how your business
is
operated largely through these equity investees and how
the joint ventures are integral to your operations. Also tell us
whether
you continue to
do business in the Yuma Mall after the sale of your interest in
the joint
venture. In this regard
we would envision that your presentation of equity in earnings
from joint
ventures would
be below operating expenses and above operating income on your
consolidated statements of operations. In addition, please expand
your
financial statement footnote disclosure to address the basis for
your
presentation clarifying why equity in earnings from joint ventures
within
operating income is appropriate given your specific facts and
circumstances. We may have further comment. See Rule 5-03 of Regulation
S-X
|
Response:
We
respectfully submit to the staff that our Statements of Operations do not
include a subtotal for operating income. Further, in our previous response
letter to the staff, in September 2003, we discussed our classification of
our
joint venture income. We have reviewed SEC Regulation S-X, Rule 5-03(b)(13),
which indicates that the investor’s equity in earnings of an unconsolidated
subsidiary and/or 50 percent or less owned person (i.e. an equity method
investee) should be shown after the investor’s income tax provision, and before
income or loss from continuing operations. However, Rule 5-03(b)(13) also
states, “If justified by the circumstances, this item may be presented in a
different position and a different manner.” We include our joint venture income
in Other Income and thus a part of our operations because our joint ventures
are
an integral part of our business and involve investments in malls and retailing
operations which we believe is clearly and closely related to our operations.
We
have disclosed in Note 1 of our consolidated financial statements the amount
of
earnings from joint ventures of $10.0 million, $8.7 million and $8.1 million
for
fiscal 2005, 2004 and 2003, respectively. Since we believe that our
justification is appropriate, and the joint venture income is less than 10%
of
pretax income in any year presented and we did disclose the amount to the
readers in Note 1, a separate line on the face of the statements of operations
was not considered necessary. If joint venture income exceeds 10% of pretax
income in the future, we will include the amount in a separate caption on
the
statements of operations below operating expenses and before pretax income
as we
have controls in place that would identify such.
With
regard to the portion of your comment on the Yuma Mall joint venture, prior
to
our sale of the joint venture, we owned the land, parking lot and our store
building connected to the Yuma Mall as well as a 50% interest in the Yuma
Mall.
After we sold our Joint Venture interest in the Yuma Mall, we no longer have
any
ownership or interest in the Yuma Mall joint venture but we still own and
operate the store connected to the Yuma mall.
In
accordance with the applicable rules, SX 4-08(g), if such percentages exceed
10%
in the future, we will properly disclose the summarized information as to
assets, liabilities and results of operations in our notes to the consolidated
financial statements on an individual or group basis.
Results
of Operations
2
General
|
5.
|
You
disclose that several stores were closed
and that operations were interrupted in approximately 60 stores
during
fiscal 2005 due to Hurricanes Katrina, Rita and Wilma. However,
it is not
clear from your disclosure what impact these significant events
had on
your financial performance and operating results in fiscal 2005.
Please
provide a more comprehensive discussion of the impact that these
hurricanes had on your sales, expenses, and overall results of
operations
during fiscal 2005. Disclose if your insurance coverage includes
business
interruption for recovery of loss sales for stores closed. Explain
the
nature
of the $29.7 million hurricane insurance recovery gain and how
it relates
to the loss
of sales in store operations. Please clarify to us if the $29.7
million
gain is in addition
to the $26.7 million of insurance proceeds received in 2005 for
the
construction of
stores damaged due to the hurricane season. Refer to Item 303(a)(3)
of
Regulation S-K.
|
Response:
The
$29.7 million gain on recovery was related to gains on amounts received from
the
insurance company for inventory losses. This amount is comprised of the amounts
received from the insurance company in excess of the carrying value of the
inventory destroyed. The total proceeds received from the insurance company
for
the destruction of inventory are separately disclosed in operating activities
in
the consolidated statements of cash flows.
The
$26.7
million amount disclosed as “proceeds from hurricane insurance” in the investing
activities of the consolidated statements of cash flows represents amounts
received for reimbursement in order to restore the damaged stores to their
preexisting condition. It is in addition to the amounts received for inventory
losses.
We
are
not able to determine with any degree of certainty the impact Hurricanes
Wilma,
Rita and Katrina had on our operations due to the numerous assumptions that
would have to be made and certain information is not available. The following
factors impacted our ability to provide this information:
|
1)
|
While
some stores were closed for various periods of time after the Hurricanes,
once these stores opened, sales increased significantly from previous
periods. ,We are not able to determine whether the increase in
sales the
days following the reopening of the stores were new business, same
business or an effort of make up sales for the days the stores
were closed
because of the hurricanes.
|
|
2)
|
For
the stores closed longer than a few days and still closed; we are
not able
to make a reasonable assumption as to what the sales for those
stores
would have been if the Hurricanes had not
occurred.
|
|
3)
|
There
was a migration of people from the regions affected by the Hurricanes
to
adjacent areas of the country where we have a substantial presence.
We
experienced some sales increases in these adjacent areas, but we
are not
able to assess how much of the sales was new business and how much
was due
to the migration of the affected
people.
|
We
will
add the following to our disclosure that was on page 17 of our Form 10-K
for the
Fiscal Year Ended January 28, 2006:
Our
insurance coverage did not include business interruption but did include
a
provision for reimbursement of the loss of inventory in excess of the carrying
value of the inventory. Our insurance coverage also covered losses sustained
on
damaged stores and we are entitled to receive money for reimbursement of
costs
incurred to restore the damaged stores to their preexisting condition. Not
all
of the insurance money has been received for costs incurred on damaged stores
affected by the Hurricanes but the Company will receive these amounts once
all
repairs are completed and all the proofs of claims are filed with the insurance
carrier.
Sales,
pages 16-17
3
|
6.
|
We
note that during each period presented you opened several new stores.
It
is important that
investors understand the impact new store operations had on sales
during
each period.
Please quantify and disclose in dollars the amount of sales attributable
to new stores opened for all periods presented. Refer to Item 303(a)(3)
of
Regulation S-K.
|
Response:
In
fiscal
2005 we opened 9 new stores which represent less than 3% of our total stores
outstanding and net sales from these new stores represent approximately 1%
of
Total Net Sales for the Company. As such we do not feel it is material or
meaningful to the users of our financial statements to disclose it separately.
We will continue to monitor new store sales and will disclose these in the
future if they become material.
|
7.
|
You
disclose that sales remained flat during fiscal 2005 with declines
for the
last two fiscal years in several product categories such as ready
to wear,
children's clothing and furniture. However, investors are not able
to
determine if the declines in these areas reflect
a pattern which will continue to impact your operating results.
Please
disclose if you
expect these current sales trends to continue in future periods
as
required
by Item 303(a)(3)
of Regulation S-K.
|
Response:
We
are
not able to determine with any amount of certainty, whether or not current
trends in sales will continue in future periods. We do disclose numerous
risk
factors that may affect our operating results in our 10-K on pages 3-4.
Liquidity
and Capital Resources, page 21
|
8.
|
You
disclose that operating cash inflows also include finance charges
paid on
receivables prior to the sale, revenue and reimbursements from
GE. Please
tell us and revise your disclosure to more clearly explain the
impact your
new marketing agreement with GE will have on cash flows and your
liquidity
position in future periods. Disclose how the arrangement with GE
has
increased and/or decreased your annual cash
flows.
|
Response:
The
Company will include the following in its future filings:
In
November 2004 the Company sold substantially all of the assets of its private
label credit card business to GE for $1.1 billion, thus increasing the Company’s
liquidity. In connection with the sale the Company and GE have entered into
a
long-term marketing and servicing alliance that provides for certain payments
to
be made by GE to the Company, including a revenue sharing and marketing
reimbursement. The cash flows that the Company receives under this alliance
have
been greater than the net cash flows provided by the Company’s credit business
prior to its sale to GE due to quicker cash receipts. Although the Company
received cash of approximately $XX and $105 million from GE in fiscal 2006
and
2005, the Company is currently not able to project the future impact the
marketing and servicing alliance will have on future cash flows and our future
liquidity position.
Consolidated
Financial Statements
Notes
to Consolidated Financial Statements
Note
1. Description of Business and Summary of Significant Accounting
Policies
General
|
9.
|
You
disclose in Item 1 - Business section on page 2 that you provide
certain
customer loyalty programs and discounts to reward new and existing
credit
card customer. Please disclose your accounting policy for the cost
of the
benefits and discounts you offer customers under these special
programs.
Refer to EITF 00-22.
|
Response:
We
respectfully submit to the staff on page 2 of our Form 10-K filed for the
Fiscal
Year Ended January 28, 2006 we actually stated the following:
4
GE
has
created various loyalty programs that reward customers for frequency and
volume
of proprietary charge card usage.
Since
we
do not provide customer loyalty programs EITF 00-22 is not applicable.
|
10.
|
Please
disclose your accounting policy for recognizing income from leased
departments, including the basis for commissions collected, if
any, on
lease department sales. Refer to SAB Topic 8:A for
guidance.
|
Response:
The
Company will include in our revenue recognition accounting policy that leased
department income is included in net sales.
Net
Sales
- The Company recognizes revenue at the “point of sale.” Allowance for sales
returns are recorded as a component of net sales in the period in which the
related sales are recorded. Commissions earned on sales generated by licensed
departments are included as a component of retail sales.
Goodwill,
page F-10
|
11.
|
Please
disclose when you perform your annual test of goodwill for impairment.
Reference
is made to paragraph 26 of SFAS
142.
|
Response:
We
will
revise our disclosure to add the following sentence:
The
Company tests for goodwill impairment annually as of the last day of the
fourth
quarter.
Vendor
Allowances, page F-11
Advertising,
page F-11
|
12.
|
We
note that you receive cash or credit allowances from merchandise
vendors
in connection with your purchase of their products and certain
cooperative
advertising and marketing
programs. In this regard, please revise your disclosure to clarify
your
basis for and the specific timing for your recognition of vendor
allowances as a reduction of the cost of your purchase. Please
confirm
that vendor allowances are not recorded until earned. If you record
any
vendor allowances upon receipt, please explain your basis for doing
so.
Please also disclose the amount of
cooperative advertising reimbursements netted against gross advertising
expense. We believe you should also include in your revised disclosures
the following additional
information:
|
|
·
|
the
number of vendors and the length of time of the
agreements;
|
|
·
|
the
terms and conditions of the
agreements;
|
|
·
|
a
statement that management would continue to incur the same level
of
advertising
expenditures even if vendors discontinued their
support;
|
|
·
|
in
management's discussion and analysis the impact that vendor allowances
received have on your results of operations in terms of generating
additional revenues; and
|
|
·
|
the
dollar amount of the excess that you recorded in cost of
sales.
|
Refer
to
EITF 02-16 and paragraph 49 of SOP 93-7 relating to gross advertising
costs.
5
Response:
Vendor
allowances received are recorded when earned and there are no instances we
have
encountered when the income effect of vendor allowances would be recorded
upon
actual receipt of cash. See our proposed revised disclosure below which includes
a discussion clarifying the basis for and the specific timing for our
recognition of vendor allowances as a reduction to cost purchases.
Vendor
Allowances
The
Company receives concessions from its vendors through a variety of programs
and
arrangements, including co-operative advertising and markdown reimbursement
programs. The Company has agreements in place with each vendor setting forth
the
specific conditions for each allowance or payment. These agreements range
in
periods from a few days to up to a year. If the payment is a reimbursement
for
costs incurred, it is offset against those related costs; otherwise, it is
treated as a reduction to the cost of the merchandise.
For
cooperative advertising programs, the Company generally offsets the allowances
against the related advertising expense when incurred. Many of these programs
require proof-of-advertising to be provided to the vendor to support the
reimbursement of the incurred cost. Programs that do not require
proof-of-advertising are monitored to ensure that the allowance provided
by each
vendor is a reimbursement of costs incurred to advertise for that particular
vendor. If the allowance exceeds the advertising costs incurred on a
vendor-specific basis, then the excess allowance from the vendor is recorded
as
a reduction of merchandise cost for that vendor. Total cooperative advertising
reimbursements we received for fiscal 2006, 2005 and 2004 were $XX.X
million,$57.8 million and $58.3million respectively.
Markdown
reimbursements are credited directly to cost of purchased merchandise in
the
period earned according to the agreement with the vendor.
The
accounting policies described above are in compliance with Emerging Issues
Task
Force 02-16 “Accounting by a Customer (Including a Reseller) for Certain
Considerations Received from a Vendor.”
In
regard
to your request for additional information, we will address each one
individually.
The
number of vendors and the length of time of the arrangements - we will disclose
a statement regarding the length of time of the arrangements. See the revised
disclosure above. We do not feel that the number of vendors the Company does
business with is relevant information that would be useful to the users of
our
financial statements. Further the approximate number of vendors changes often
as
we add vendors and discontinue doing business with others.
The
terms
and conditions of the agreements - this will vary and we will add a statement
to
that affect in our disclosure. See above.
A
statement that management would continue to incur the same level of advertising
expenditures even if vendors discontinued their support - this is difficult
for
management to determine. Advertising support is the basis for our advertising
programs and there has been a long-standing industry practice to receive
such
support from vendors. There is no expectation whatsoever that such support
will
disappear. We will add this as a risk factor and it will say the
following:
We
receive vendor advertising allowances that are a strategic part of our
advertising program. If vendor advertising allowances were substantially
reduced
or eliminated, we would likely consider other methods of advertising as well
as
the volume and frequency of our product advertising, which could
increase/decrease our expenditures and/or revenue.
In
management’s discussion and analysis the impact that vendor allowances received
have on our results of operations in terms of generating additional revenue
-
vendor allowances related to advertising costs do impact revenue but to what
extent we are currently not able to determine. Further, there is no way to
track
the revenue received as a result of a customer seeing an advertisement. We
will
add the following disclosure in our MD&A:
6
If
vendor advertising allowances were substantially reduced or eliminated, the
Company would likely consider other methods of advertising as well as the
volume
and frequency of our product advertising, which could increase or decrease
our
expenditures.
Similarly,
we are not able to assess the impact of vendor advertising allowances on
creating additional revenues, as such allowances do not directly generate
revenue for our stores.
The
dollar amount of the excess that you recorded in costs of sales - See our
proposed new disclosure above. The Retail Inventory Method allocates this
reduction of cost purchases between Cost of Goods Sold and Ending Inventory
based upon the cost complement.
Insurance
Accruals, page F-11
|
13.
|
You
have identified insurance accruals as critical accounting policy
that
involves significant
estimates each accounting period. Please revise your disclosure
to include
the stop loss limits for your catastrophic claims. Please also
disclose
the amounts you have accrued
at each balance sheet date, the changes
from
period to period as a result of charges
to expense, utilization of the amounts reserved and any other significant
adjustments along with the reasons for significant
changes.
|
Response:
Our
current liability portion of our insurance accrual is less than 5% of total
current liabilities and our long term liability portion of our insurance
accruals is less than 5% of total long term liabilities and thus under rule
5-02(20) and rule 5-02(24) we do not feel we need to revise our disclosure
to
include such amounts. Further, we do not feel it is significant to the readers
to include the stop loss limits, the changes from period to period as a result
of charges to expense, utilization of the amounts reserved and any other
significant adjustments along with the reasons for significant
fluctuations.
Revenue
Recognition, page F-11
|
14.
|
Please
revise your accounting policy for gift cards to indicate whether
they have
an expiration date. Further, please tell us and revise your disclosure
to
clarify the amortization of ". . . any remaining unused portion
of the
liability. . ." If this portion is the
actual remaining liability, please disclose at what point in time
you
begin to amortize the
liability. If the remaining unused portion of the
liability represents your estimate of the
amount expected to go unused that is being recognized over the
period of
performance as the remaining gift cards are redeemed, please revise
to
clarify that fact. Please also disclose for all periods presented
your
remaining liability for amounts due customers on gift cards
purchased.
|
Response:
Our
current liability portion of our amounts due customers on gift cards purchased
is less than 5% of total current liabilities and our long term liability
portion
of our amounts due customers on gift cards purchased is less than 5% of total
long term liabilities and thus under rule 5-02(20) and rule 5-02(24) we do
not
feel we need to revise our disclosure to include such amounts. We will revise
our disclosure for our gift card accounting policy and disclose separately
the
following:
Gift
Card Revenue Recognition
At
the time gift cards are sold, no revenue is recognized; rather, a liability
is
established for the face amount of the card. The liability is relieved and
revenue is recognized when gift cards are redeemed for merchandise and for
estimated breakage. The Company uses a homogeneous pool to recognize gift
card
breakage and will recognize income over the period when the likelihood of
the
gift card being redeemed is remote and the Company determines that it does
not
have a legal obligation
to remit the value of unredeemed gift cards to the relevant jurisdiction
as
abandoned property. The Company determined gift card breakage income based
upon
historical redemption patterns. At that time, the Company will recognize
breakage income over the performance period for those gift cards (i.e. 60
months).
7
CONFIDENTIAL
TREATMENT REQUESTED BY DILLARD’S, INC.
Note
2. Disposition of Credit Card Receivables, page F-13
|
15.
|
You
disclose that under the terms of your long-term marketing agreement
with
GE relating to your private label credit card business that new
accounts
and related balances generated are owned by GE. According to your
disclosure on page 20, it appears that you received in fiscal 2005
income
from the GE marketing and servicing alliance of $105 million. Please
explain to us how this arrangement operates and why new accounts
opened
and transferred to GE are not considered sales as defined under
SFAS 140.
Tell us
what consideration you receive from GE for new accounts opened
under the
marketing agreement and provide us with the basis in GAAP for your
accounting treatment of these transactions.
Explain to us the major components of the $105 million received
from GE in
2005, including the amount related new accounts opened under your
marketing agreement with them. Refer to paragraph 9 of SFAS
140.
|
Response:
The
Company sold its credit card business to GE on November 1, 2004. GE has owned
and controlled the accounts receivable since such date. GE is responsible
for
all aspects of credit underwriting and servicing for these accounts receivable.
Similar to transactions with other third party credit card issuers, the Company
accepts these GE credit cards as a mode of payment in its stores and GE
reimburses the Company daily for the sales transactions incurred on the GE
credit cards.
Subsequent
to November 2004, the Company accounts for theses transactions similar to
any
trade receivable or receivable from a third party credit card (i.e. Visa).
We
respectfully submit to the staff that paragraph 9 of SFAS 140 is not applicable
since we do not transfer any assets and our GE transactions are similar to
any
third party credit card company (i.e. Visa).
The
Company and GE entered into a marketing and servicing agreement covering
these
accounts receivable. The agreement provides for certain payments to be made
by
GE to the Company. During fiscal 2005, the Company received the following
payments under the agreement:
The
Company acknowledges that:
|
1.
|
We
are responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosures
in the
filing.
|
|
2.
|
Staff
comments or changes to disclosure in response to staff comments
do not
foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to
the
filing.
|
| 3. |
The
Company may not assert this action as a defense in any proceeding
initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities
laws of the United States.
|
Sincerely,
James
I.
Freeman
Senior
Vice President, Chief Financial Officer
8