s6y Telemar Norte Leste S.A. SC TO-C

Telemar Norte Leste S.A. SC TO-C, filed Jul 8, 2008: VALUATION REPORT

April 23, 2008
Valuation Report
Tele Norte Celular
Participações
S.A.
IMPORTANT DISCLAIMER: This document is a free translation only. Due to the complexities of language
translation, translations are not always precise. The original document was prepared in Portuguese and in case of
any divergence, discrepancy or difference between this version and the Portuguese version, the Portuguese
version shall prevail. The Portuguese version is the only valid and complete version and shall prevail for any and
all purposes.  The Translation was made by persons whose native language is not English, therefore there is no
warranty as to the accuracy, reliability or completeness of any information translated and no one should rely on the
accuracy, reliability or completeness of such information.  There is no assurance as to the accuracy, reliability or
completeness of the translation.  Any person reading this translation and relying on it should do so at his or her
own risk.


1
Disclaimer
This
valuation
report
is
for
informational
purposes
only
and
is
not
an
offer
to
purchase
or
a
solicitation
of
an
offer
to
sell
any
shares
of
Tele
Norte
Celular
Participações
S.A.
("TNCP").
The
tender
offer
for
the
outstanding
common
shares
of
TNCP
referred
to
in
this
valuation
report
has
not
commenced.
Any
offer
to
purchase
or
solicitation
of
an
offer
to
sell
any
common
shares
of
TNCP
from
any
person
resident
in
the
United
States
will
be
made
only
pursuant
to
an
offer
to
purchase
and
related
materials
that
Telemar
Norte
Leste
S.A.
("Telemar")
intends
to
file
with
the
U.S.
Securities
and
Exchange
Commission
(the
"Commission")
upon
commencement
of
the
tender
offer.
Holders
of
common
shares
of
TNCP
should
read
carefully
the
offer
to
purchase
and
the
other
documents
relating
to
the
tender
offer
when
they
become
available
and
prior
to
making
any
decisions
with
respect
to
the
tender
offer
because
these
documents
will
contain
important
information
about
the
tender
offer,
including
the
terms
and
conditions
of
the
tender
offer.
Following
the
filing
with
the
Commission
of
the
offer
to
purchase
and
the
other
documents
relating
to
the
tender
offer,
holders
of
common
shares
of
TNCP
will
be
able
to
obtain
the
filed
documents
free
of
charge
at
the
Commission's
website
at
www.sec.gov,
from
Telemar
or
from
TNCP.


2
Index
1. Executive summary
3
2. Information about the evaluator
8
3. Market and company description
15
4. Valuation of Tele Norte Celular
18
4.1. Financial and operational highlights
19
4.2. Economic value
23
4.3. Book value of the shareholders’
equity
30
4.4. Weighted average share price on the BOVESPA
32
Appendix
A.
Analysis
of
historical
spreads
between
ON
and
PN
shares
36
Appendix B. Valuation criterion
39
Appendix C. Terms and definitions used in the valuation report
41
Appendix
D.
Calculation
of
the
NPV
of
holding
expenses
43
Appendix E. Additional information and disclaimers
45


3
1. Executive summary
*
*
*
*
*
*


4
Tele Norte Celular
-
Valuation summary
Economic value based on the multiples of comparable companies
methodology
Source: Financial statements of Tele Norte Celular
and Credit Suisse. Base date: December 31, 2007.
(1) For further information on the value breakdown between different classes of shares of Tele Norte Celular
and Amazônia
Celular, see pages 28 and 29 of this report.
(2) For further information on the applied calculation methodology, see Appendix B of this report.
(3) “TMAC”
refers to Amazônia
Celular
S.A. The revenue from the reversal of ICMS tax in 2007 amounting to R$26.6mn was excluded for the purpose of this analysis, since it was
extraordinary and a non-recurring event. Adjusted EBITDA includes statutory interest and
contributions, since they are operating expenses.
(4) The value of Tele Norte Celular
holding was calculated based on its ownership stake in TMAC, a controlled company responsible for the operating activities.
(5) Net present value of TNCP holding operating expenses. For more information, see Appendix D of this report.
(6)
Source:
Tele
Norte
Celular
(Tele
Norte
Celular
did
not
have
any
treasury
shares
as
of
December
31,
2007).
R$ mn, except when otherwise indicated
Banco
de
Investimentos
Credit
Suisse
(Brasil)
S.A.
(“Credit
Suisse”
or
“CS”)
has
been
retained
by
Telemar
Norte
Leste
S.A.
(“Telemar”)
to
prepare
this
valuation
report
(“Valuation
Report”)
for
the
purpose
of
the
public
mandatory
tender
offer
(“Mandatory
TO”)
for
the
common
shares
of
Tele
Norte
Celular
Participações
S.A.
(“Tele
Norte
Celular”
or
“TNCP”),
as
described
in
Article
2
(III)
of
CVM
Instruction
No.
361/02
and
in
Article
254-A
of
Law
No.
6404/76.
Based
on
the
economic
value
criterion
and
multiples
of
comparable
companies
methodology,
the
value
range
per
common
and
preferred
share
issued
by
Tele
Norte
Celular
is
demonstrated
below:
(1)
(2)
Credit
Suisse
applied
the
economic
value
criterion
based
on
multiples
of
comparable
companies
to
calculate
the
value
of
the
shares
issued
by
Tele
Norte
Celular
+ 4.88%
-
4.65%
TMAC Adjusted EBITDA 2007
(3)
R$ 116.8
x EV/EBITDA Multiple
5.55x
= TMAC enterprise value
648.5
(-) TMAC net debt (12/31/2007)
226.6
= TMAC total equity value
421.9
Value per
share
. PN shares
114.0
$31.50
. Controlling ON shares
282.3
138.41
. Minority ON shares
25.7
110.73
TMAC shares owned by TNCP
Shares
% of share
class
. PN shares ('000)
2,374.2
65.63%
. ON shares ('000)
2,039.3
89.78%
= TNCP enterprise value
(4)
357.1
(-) NPV of TNCP holding expenses
(5)
11.4
(-) TNCP net debt (12/31/2007)
9.8
= TNCP total equity value
335.9
. PN shares
116.6
. ON shares
219.3
Number of PN shares ('000)
(6)
4,209.2
Number of ON shares ('000)
(6)
2,492.5
Total number of shares ('000)
(6)
6,701.7
PN (R$/share)
(1)
R$ 26.42
R$ 27.71
R$ 29.06
ON controlling (R$/share)
(1)
92.81
97.34
102.09
ON minority (R$/share)
(1)
74.25
77.87
81.67


5
Tele Norte Celular
-
Valuation summary (cont’d)
Weighted average price of shares listed on the BOVESPA
Source:
Economática,
as
of
April
23,
2008.
(1)
Material
Fact
dated
August
2,
2007
regarding
the
acquisition
by
Vivo
Participações
S.A.
of
shares
of
TNCP
owned
by
Telpart
Participações
S.A.
(2)
Source:
Tele
Norte
Celular
(Tele
Norte
Celular
did
not
have
any
treasury
share
as
of
December
31,
2007).
R$ per share
Based
on
the
weighted
average
price
of
the
shares
issued
by
Tele
Norte
Celular
listed
on
the
BOVESPA,
the
price
range
of
common
and
preferred
shares
issued
by
Tele
Norte
Celular
is
demonstrated
below:
ON
PN
12-month
period
prior
to
the
release
of
the
Material
Fact
(1)
08/01/2006 -
08/01/2007
R$ 50.95
R$ 19.61
Number of shares ('000)
(2)
2,492.5
4,209.2
Market capitalization (R$ mn)
127.0
82.5
Value per share weighted by the amount of shares of each class
R$ 50.95
R$ 19.61
Period between the release of the Material Fact and the date of the valuation report
08/02/2007 -
04/23/2008
R$ 72.24
R$ 25.43
Number of shares ('000)
(2)
2,492.5
4,209.2
Market capitalization (R$ mn)
180.1
107.0
Value per share weighted by the amount of shares of each class
R$ 72.24
R$ 25.43
90-day period between 01/24/08 and 04/23/08
01/24/2008 -
04/23/2008
R$ 76.40
R$ 27.58
Number of shares ('000)
(2)
2,492.5
4,209.2
Market capitalization (R$ mn)
190.4
116.1
Value per share weighted by the amount of shares of each class
R$ 76.40
R$ 27.58


6
Tele Norte Celular
-
Valuation summary (cont’d)
Book value of the shareholders’
equity per share
R$ mn, except when otherwise indicated
Source: Financial statements of Tele Norte Celular. Base date: December 31, 2007.
(1)
Source:
Tele
Norte
Celular
(Tele
Norte
Celular
did
not
have
any
treasury
share
as
of
December
31,
2007).
Based on the book value of the shareholders’
equity per share methodology, the value of common and preferred
shares issued by Tele Norte Celular
is R$13.15
12/31/2007
Total assets
R$ 529.21
(-) Total liabilities
409.3
(-) Minority interests
31.8
= Shareholders' equity
88.1
Total number of shares ('000)
(1)
6,702
R$/share PN and/or ON
13.15


7
Tele Norte Celular
-
Valuation summary (cont’d)
Comparative analysis of value ranges
R$ per share
Weighted average price
Economic value
Book
value
of
the
shareholders’
equity
per
share
ON
PN
Period from 08/01/2006 to 08/01/2007
Period from 08/02/2007 to 04/23/2008
Period from 01/24/2008 to 04/23/2008
ON controlling
ON minority
R$ 26.42
R$ 27.58
R$ 25.43
R$ 13.15
R$ 19.61
R$ 29.06
According to Schedule III, IX, “e”
of CVM Instruction No 361/02, CS presents a comparative chart with the
amounts calculated for common and preferred shares issued by Tele Norte Celular
R$ 74.25
R$ 92.81
R$ 13.15
R$ 102.09
R$ 81.67
R$ 50.95
R$ 72.24
R$ 76.40


8
2. Information about the evaluator
*
*
*
*
*
*


9
Qualifications of the evaluator
As
established
in
CVM
Instruction
No.
361/02,
CS
presents
its
qualifications
below.
CS
has
acted
as
an
advisor
in
important
mergers
and
acquisitions
in
the
Brazilian
market:
Advisory
services
in
mergers
and
acquisitions
Companies
that
operate
in
the
segment
of
Tele
Norte
Celular
(Telecom)
Telemar
(2008):
Advisory
services
to
Telemar
Norte
Leste
in
the
acquisition
of
Brasil
Telecom
Participações
/
Brasil
Telecom
Telecom
Itália
(2007):
Advisory
services
to
Telecom
Itália
in
the
sale
of
its
stake
in
Solpart
Participações
to
a
group
of
investors
TIM
(2006):
Advisory
services
to
TIM
in
the
merger
of
shares
of
TIM
Celular
by
TIM
Participações
Telesp
Celular
(2003):
Advisory
services
to
Telesp
Celular
in
the
acquisition
of
Tele
Centro
Oeste
Celular
Other
relevant
credentials
in
mergers
and
acquisitions
Public
companies
Bovespa
(2008):
Advisory
services
to
Bovespa
Holding
in
its
merger
with
Bolsa
de
Mercadorias
&
Futuros
-
BM&F
MMX
(2008):
Advisory
services
to
MMX
in
the
sale
of
MMX
Minas-Rio
and
MMX
Amapá
to
Anglo
American
Eleva
(2007):
Advisory
services
to
Perdigão
in
the
acquisition
of
Eleva
MMX
(2007):
Advisory
services
to
MMX
and
Centennial
Asset
in
the
sale
of
50%
of
the
capital
of
MMX
Minas-Rio
to
Anglo
American
Submarino
(2006):
Advisory
services
to
Submarino
in
the
merger
between
Submarino
and
Americanas.com
CVRD
(2006):
Advisory
services
to
CVRD
in
the
takeover
bid
for
Inco
International
Paper
(2006):
Advisory
services
to
IP
in
the
sale
of
Inpacel
to
Stora
Enso
Dufry
(2006):
Advisory
services
in
the
acquisition
of
80%
of
Brasif
and
Eurotrade
ALL
(2006):
Advisory
services
to
ALL
in
the
acquisition
of
Brasil
Ferrovias
and
Novoeste
Brasil
Bunge
Fertilizantes
(2006):
Advisory
services
to
Bunge
Fertilizantes
in
its
sale
to
Fosfertil
Acesita
(2005):
Advisory
services
to
Previ
and
Petros
in
the
exercise
of
its
put
option
against
Arcelor
do
Brasil,
whereby
they
sold
25%
of
the
voting
capital
of
Acesita
Usiminas
(2005):
Advisory
services
in
the
exchange
of
its
stake
in
Siderar
and
Sidor
for
a
stake
of
16%
in
the
total
capital
of
Ternium
CCR
(2003):
Advisory
services
to
Andrade
Gutierrez,
Brisa,
Camargo
Corrêa
in
the
acquisition
of
Odebrecht’s
stake
in
CCR
Private
companies
J.
Mendes
(2008):
Advisory
services
to
Mineração
J.
Mendes
in
its
sale
to
Usiminas
Magnesita
(2007):
Advisory
services
in
the
sale
of
Magnesita
to
GP
Investimentos
Grupo
Dedini
Agro
(2007):
Advisory
services
in
the
sale
of
Dedini
to
Abengoa
Bioenergy
Note:
The
term
“advisory”
includes
the
following
services:
structuring
of
the
transaction,
assistance
on
data
gathering,
financial
and
economic
valuations
and
advisory
on
the
negotiation
between
the
parties.


10
Qualifications of the evaluator (cont’d)
Qualification
of
the
professionals
responsible
for
the
Valuation
Report:
Marco Gonçalves
Responsible for Mergers and Acquisitions, Investment Banking
José
Olympio
Pereira
Managing Director, Head of the Investment Banking Division in Brazil
José
Olympio
Pereira is responsible for the investment banking division of Credit Suisse in Brazil
Before joining CS, José
Olympio
was co-responsible for the investment banking division in Latin America
and responsible for this division in Brazil at
Citigroup Global Markets between February 2001 and May 2004. He was also responsible for Donaldson, Lufkin & Jenrette in Brazil between February 1998
and December 2000. He worked for 13 years at Banco
de Investimentos
Garantia, where he occupied several positions, including his latest position as
responsible for the corporate finance area. During his career, José
Olympio
was responsible for a large number of relevant mergers and acquisitions, as well
as for various equity and debt offerings in the Brazilian and international markets
José
Olympio
has a degree in Civil Engineering from Pontifícia
Universidade
Católica
in Rio de Janeiro and a masters’
degree in Business from Harvard
Business School
Marco Gonçalves
is responsible for mergers and acquisitions of the investment banking division of Credit Suisse in Brazil
Before joining CS, Marco Gonçalves
worked at ABN Amro
Bank, Deustche
Bank and BNP Paribas both in Brazil and in New York. Marco Gonçalves
has
over 13 years of experience in investment banking, and has provided advisory services to various clients in mergers and acquisitions in a number of sectors
Marco Gonçalves
has a Mechanical Engineering degree from the Federal University
of Santa Catarina
and a specialization course in Finance from the New
York University


11
Qualifications of the evaluator (cont’d)
Qualification
of
the
professionals
responsible
for
the
Valuation
Report:
Edwyn Neves
Analyst, Investment Banking
Bruno Amaral
Associate, Investment Banking
Bruno Amaral is an associate of the investment banking division of Credit Suisse in Brazil
Bruno Amaral has been a part of the Credit Suisse team since February 2005. Before joining Credit Suisse, Bruno worked in the investment banking division
of Citigroup Global Markets (ex-Salomon Smith Barney) in São Paulo and New York, and in the mergers and acquisition division of BNP Paribas in São
Paulo and Paris. He has over 8 years of experience in investment
banks and has already worked on various mergers and acquisitions, as well as equity and
debt offerings in various sectors in Brazil, Latin America and Europe
Bruno
Amaral
has
a
degree
in
Economics
from
the
Universidade
de
São
Paulo
Edwyn Neves is part of the execution team of the investment banking division of Credit Suisse in Brazil
Before joining Credit Suisse in April 2007, Edwyn Neves worked at the private equity firm Advent International. During his career, Edwyn Neves worked in
several capital market transactions and mergers and acquisitions
in various sectors
Edwyn
Neves
has
a
degree
in
Business
from
the
School
of
Business
of
Fundação
Getúlio
Vargas
(São
Paulo)


12
Evaluator’s representations
As established in CVM Instruction No. 361/02, CS represents that:
1.
The
table
below
summarizes
the
quantity
of
securities
issued
by
Tele
Norte
Celular
that
CS,
as
well
as
other
entities
linked
to
it,
hold
or
own
under
their
administration,
based
on
data
as
of
April
23,
2008
2.
There is no conflict of interest that reduces the independence needed to perform its duties in connection with
the preparation of this Valuation Report.
3.
It
has
no
direct
or
indirect
interest
in
Tele
Norte
Celular,
Telemar
or
in
the
Mandatory
TO,
and
there
is
no
other
relevant
circumstance
that
may
be
considered
a
conflict
of
interest;
the
controlling
shareholder
or
managers
of
Tele
Norte
Celular
and
Telemar
have
not
directed,
limited,
hindered
or
performed
any
act
that
adversely
affected
or
may
have
adversely
affected
the
access
to,
use
or
knowledge
of
information,
assets,
documents
or
work
methodologies
relevant
for
the
quality
of
the
respective
conclusions;
the
controlling
shareholders
of
the
companies
and
their
managers
have
not
determined
the
methodologies
used
in
this
Valuation
Report;
there
is
no
existing
or
potential
conflict
or
pooling
of
interests
with
the
controlling
shareholder
of
Telemar,
or
with
their
minority
shareholder(s)
or,
with
respect
to
Tele
Norte
Celular,
its
respective
partners,
or
in
connection
with
the
Mandatory
TO
4.
The
combined
cost
of
this
Valuation
Report
and
of
the
valuation
report
of
Amazônia
Celular
S.A.
(“Amazônia
Celular”
or
“TMAC”),
paid
by
Telemar,
is
R$1,244,428.57
5.
CS
will
receive
the
equivalent
amount
in
Reais
of
US$450,000.00
as
commission
for
structuring
the
public
mandatory
tender
offers
and
public
voluntary
tender
offers
for
the
acquisition
of
shares
of
Amazônia
Celular
and
Tele
Norte
Celular
Entity
Observation
Type of
Security
Ticker
Number
of Shares
% of Total
Capital
Credit Suisse "Próprio" Fundo de Investimento de Ações
Investment fund under administration of CS
conglomerate companies
Shares
TNCP4
2,860
0.0486%
Credit Suisse International
Affiliate
Shares
TNCP4
27,540
0.4677%


13
Evaluator’s representations (cont’d)
6.
Credit
Suisse
(Brasil)
S.A.
Corretora
de
Títulos
e
Valores
Mobiliários,
a
wholly-owned
subsidiary
of
CS,
will
act
as
an
intermediary
institution
in
the
Mandatory
TO,
as
per
CVM
Instruction
No.
361/02,
and
will
receive
the
following
compensation:
0.35%
of
the
total
gross
amount
disbursed
in
connection
with
the
acquisition
of
shares
under
the
mandatory
public
tender
offers
for
common
shares
of
Amazônia
Celular
and
Tele
Norte
Celular;
and
0.70%
of
the
total
gross
amount
disbursed
in
connection
with
the
acquisition
of
shares
under
the
voluntary
public
tender
offers
for
shares
of
Amazônia
Celular
and
Tele
Norte
Celular
7.
On
December
28,
2007
it
received
R$19,052.42
as
reimbursement
of
expenses
incurred
in
the
provision
of
advisory
services
to
Telemar
in
connection
with
the
process
of
sale
of
the
shares
issued
by
Tele
Norte
Celular
owned
by
Telpart
Participações
S.A.
8.
On
December
21,
2007
it
received
R$963,177.69
for
the
1st
installment
of
the
engagement
commission
to
act
as
exclusive
financial
advisor
in
connection
with
the
merger
or
direct
or
indirect
acquisition
of
shares
issued
by
Brasil
Telecom
S.A.
and
Brasil
Telecom
Participações
S.A.
9.
On
January
8,
2008
it
received
R$1,888,217.14
for
the
2nd
installment
of
the
engagement
commission
to
act
as
exclusive
financial
advisor
in
connection
with
the
merger
or
direct
or
indirect
acquisition
of
shares
issued
by
Brasil
Telecom
S.A.
and
Brasil
Telecom
Participações
S.A.
10.
It
has
been
retained
by
Telemar
to
prepare
a
valuation
report
on
Amazônia
Celular
in
the
context
of
the
mandatory
tender
offer
and
the
voluntary
tender
offer
for
acquisition
of
shares
of
Amazônia
Celular,
as
explained
previously
in
item
5
11.
It
received
from
Telemar,
in
the
12
months
prior
to
the
Mandatory
TO
registration
request,
R$2,870,447.25
as
remuneration
for
the
provision
of
any
consultancy,
valuation,
auditing
and
related
services,
as
explained
previously
in
items
7,
8
and
9
12.
It
has
not
received
from
Tele
Norte
Celular,
in
the
12
months
prior
to
the
Mandatory
TO
registration
request,
any
remuneration
for
the
provision
of
any
consultancy,
valuation,
auditing
and
related
services


14
Evaluator’s representations (cont’d)
13.
This Valuation Report presents:
I.
Information about the shares issued by Tele Norte Celular, including the ownership structure;
II.
The valuation criterion based on economic value using the multiples of comparable companies
methodology;
III.
Description
of
the
methodologies
applied
in
the
valuation
of
the
shares
issued
by
Tele
Norte
Celular
using
market
prices
and
book
value
of
the
shareholders’
equity
criteria;
and
IV.
Tables with data used in the calculation of values.
14.
In addition to the information required in article 8, paragraph 3 of CVM Instruction No. 361/02, this Valuation
Report provides additional information aimed at supplementing the analysis presented herein and
supporting the conclusion on the calculated value of the shares of Tele Norte Celular
15.
In
compliance
with
article
8
(V)
(b)
of
CVM
Instruction
No.
361/02,
Credit
Suisse
represents
that,
among
the
valuation
criteria
presented
in
this
document,
it
believes
the
methodology
of
economic
value
using
multiples
of
comparable
companies,
as
per
item
XII
(c),
2,
of
schedule
III
of
CVM
Instruction
No.
361/02,
to
be
the
most
appropriate
for
determining
the
value
range
of
the
shares
issued
by
Tele
Norte
Celular
16.
CS
internal
process
for
the
approval
of
the
Valuation
Report
involves
the
following
stages:
I.
Discussion
about
the
methodology
and
assumptions
to
be
applied
in
the
valuation
with
the
team
involved
in
the
operation;
and
II.
After
preparation
and
revision
of
the
report
by
the
team
involved,
the
report
is
submitted
for
the
analysis
of
an
internal
bank
committee,
composed
of
the
bank’s
CEO,
the
director
of
the
investment
banking
division,
legal
counsel
and
other
members
of
the
committee,
and
others
responsible
for
the
departments
involved
in
the
transaction


15
3. Market and company description
*
*
*
*
*
*


16
Summary of the market in which Tele Norte Celular
operates
Tele
Norte
Celular
operates
in
the
States
of
Maranhão,
Pará,
Amazonas,
Roraima
and
Amapá,
in
the
North
and
Northeast
regions
of
Brazil,
covering
an
area
of
3,534mn
square
kilometers
–
about
41%
of
the
Brazilian
territory
Market
Market overview
Global market
The number of mobile phones in the world increased from 2.7bn to
3.3bn between 2006 and 2007, which corresponds to a penetration rate
of approximately 1 mobile phone for each 2 inhabitants
In 2007, Brazil consolidated itself as the fifth largest mobile phone
market in the world, with around 121mn mobile phones
Brazilian market
The number of mobile phones operating in Brazil was 121mn in 2007,
posting growth of 21% versus the previous year, when accesses totaled
100mn
Therefore, the mobile phone density in Brazil advanced ten percentage
points, reaching 63.6 units per 100 inhabitants
GSM
is
the
most
popular
technology,
with
market
share
of
78.5%
in
2007.
The
CDMA
technology
accounts
for
17.3%
of
accesses
in
operation,
followed
by
TDMA,
with
4.3%
The prepaid segment posted slight growth versus 2006, ending 2007
with 80.6% of the total (97.5mn users)
Postpaid plan users, accounting for 19.4% of the market, totaled
23.4mn consumers
Main global mobile phone markets
2004
2005
2006
2007
(In millions of phones)
China
335
393
461
547
USA
181
208
233
253
India
48
76
149
234
Russia
74
126
152
173
Brazil
66
86
100
121
Japan
91
95
100
105
Source: Teleco.
3,741
4,827
5,445
6,993
29%
13%
28%
2004
2005
2006
2007
Mobile
Growth %
Source: Anatel.
Growth in the number of mobile phones in the region
(in millions of phones)
States in which Amazônia Celular operates
State
Mobiles
(‘000)
Prepaid
-
Density
(1)
Pará
3,104
89.5%
42.5
Maranhão
1,763
88.0%
28.0
Amazonas
1,727
86.2%
50.3
Amapá
349
87.7%
54.0
Roraima
205
82.3%
48.8
Average Brazil
80.8%
64.5
Source: Anatel; values as of January 2008.
(1) Mobile phones per 100 inhabitants.


17
Tele Norte Celular
Participações S.A.
Description of Tele Norte Celular
Company
description
Tele
Norte
Celular
Participações
S.A.
is
a
holding
company
which
owns
89.78%
of
the
voting
capital
and
74.95%
of
the
total
capital
of
Amazônia
Celular
Through
Amazônia
Celular,
Tele
Norte
Celular
provides
mobile
phone
services
in
an
area
spanning
over
3.5mn
square
kilometers,
which
corresponds
to
41%
of
the
Brazilian
territory.
The
region
has
low
population
density:
4.9
inhabitants
per
square
meter,
which
means
that
17.3mn
people
reside
in
the
region
Four
operators
provide
Personal
Mobile
Services
in
the
region,
three
of
which
offer
GSM
technology
and
one
of
which
offers
CDMA
technology.
Amazônia
Celular
is
the
only
operator
that
offers
GSM/EDGE
and
TDMA
technologies
Performance in 2007
Through
Amazônia
Celular,
Tele
Norte
Celular
ended
2007
with
1,416,620
clients,
an
increase
of
17.0%
versus
2006,
reversing
the
downward
trend
of
the
two
previous
years.
At
the
end
of
the
period,
the
prepaid
segment
accounted
for
85.0%
of
the
customer
base
and
the
postpaid
segment
accounted
for
15.0%
thereof
The
Company’s
market
share
in
2007
was
20.3%,
1.9
percentage
point
lower
than
in
2006,
but
this
decline
was
much
smoother
than
the
3.5
percentage
point
decline
observed
between
2005
and
2006
Despite
this,
the
company
achieved
net
sales
of
799
thousand
new
phones,
growing
by
20%
yoy
The
consolidated
annual
churn
rate
stood
at
40.4%,
14.5
percentage
points
lower
than
in
the
previous
year
Ownership structure
Source: Tele Norte Celular.
Company overview
Telemar
Norte Leste
S.A.
Free
float
Market share
Source: Teleco; values as of January 2008.
18.7%
17.9%
18.7%
33.3%
22.4%
29.2%
21.5%
37.8%
34.2%
49.6%
34.1%
33.3%
35.0%
32.4%
28.0%
17.9%
27.3%
8.6%
PA
MA
AM
AP
RR
Amazônia
Vivo
Tim
Oi
Total
19.3%
ON
51.9%
PN
0.1%
Total
80.7%
ON
48.1%
PN        99.1%


18
4. Valuation of Tele Norte Celular
*
*
*
*
*
*


19
4. Valuation of Tele Norte Celular
4.1. Financial and operational highlights
*
*
*
*
*


20
Main financial highlights
Historical consolidated balance sheet
Source: Financial statements of Tele Norte Celular.
R$ mn
2005
2006
2007
2005
2006
2007
Loans and financing
58.3
241.1
80.9
Suppliers
117.1
138.3
83.7
Cash and financial investments
65.7
51.4
44.8
Taxes payable
7.2
6.6
8.2
Accounts receivable
88.8
104.9
81.3
Dividends payable
4.0
0.8
3.3
Recoverable taxes
20.3
22.0
18.2
Provisions
15.0
12.4
10.6
Inventory
11.5
10.5
9.7
Hedge operations
35.9
17.4
7.4
Other current assets
9.9
5.1
4.4
Other obligations
4.9
5.6
23.9
Current assets
196.1
193.9
158.4
Current liabilities
242.5
422.3
218.1
Loans and financing
190.0
0.0
70.9
Provisions
7.9
54.6
30.5
Intercompany loans
5.2
13.2
26.1
Deferred income taxes
68.5
82.1
82.1
Hedge operations
11.0
22.4
45.8
Other recoverable taxes
9.9
8.6
6.4
Pension plan
1.7
2.1
2.3
Intercompany credits
0.0
0.0
0.0
Others
16.9
13.2
15.7
Other long-term assets
15.6
4.2
5.7
Minority interest
55.8
30.2
31.8
Long-term assets
93.9
94.9
94.2
Long-term liabilities
288.4
135.6
223.0
Investments
0.1
0.1
0.1
Paid-in capital
84.9
84.9
84.9
PP&E
357.8
300.6
238.7
Profit reserves
76.5
5.9
0.2
Intangible
62.2
56.4
37.9
Retained earnings
17.8
(2.8)
3.1
Fixed assets
420.0
357.0
276.6
Shareholders' equity
179.1
88.0
88.1
Total assets
710.1
645.9
529.2
Total liabilities and shareholders’ equity
710.1
645.9
529.2


21
Main financial highlights (cont’d)
Consolidated historical income statement
Source: Financial statements of Tele Norte Celular.
(1)
The
ICMS
tax
provision
expense
of
R$46.3mn
incurred
in
2006
and
the
revenue
from
the
reversal
of
this
tax
in
2007
amounting
to
R$26.6mn
were
excluded
for
the
purpose
of
this
analysis,
since
they
are
extraordinary
and
non-recurring
events.
Adjusted
EBITDA
includes
statutory
interest
and
contributions,
since
they
are
operating
expenses,
and
Tele
Norte
Celular
holding
expenses.
R$ mn
2005
2006
2007
Net revenues
R$ 432.0
R$ 436.3
R$ 486.7
. Services
390.0
385.0
462.6
. Phones
42.0
51.2
24.1
Growth %
(13.4%)
1.0%
11.6%
Gross profit
176.8
137.1
169.5
Margin %
40.9%
31.4%
34.8%
Adjusted EBITDA
(1)
124.6
83.0
115.7
Margin %
28.9%
19.0%
23.8%
Depreciation and amortization
(112.7)
(116.0)
(109.9)
EBIT
11.9
(79.3)
34.7
Margin %
2.8%
(18.2%)
7.1%
Financial revenue (expense), net
(26.3)
(55.3)
(28.4)
Net income
(42.4)
(76.1)
3.2
Margin %
(9.8%)
(17.4%)
0.7%


22
Main operational highlights
Operational indicators
Source: Financial statements of Tele Norte Celular.
2005
2006
2007
Number of subscribers -
year-end (‘000)
1,238
1,211
1,417
Growth %
8.4%
(2.2%)
17.0%
Annual average number of subscribers (‘000)
1,190
1,224
1,314
Growth %
n.a.
2.9%
7.3%
Gross client additions
629
666
725
Growth %
n.a.
5.9%
8.9%
Churn rate
(1)
48.1%
54.9%
40.4%
Postpaid
32.8%
25.1%
24.7%
Prepaid
-
52.8%
62.4%
43.6%
Average service revenue per subscriber
(2)
24.1
25.2
29.1
Postpaid
72.4
76.9
89.3
Prepaid
9.6
12.3
17.1
CAPU
(3)
158.0
122.0
138.0
(1) Deactivations in the year / average between the number of clients at the beginning and at the end of the year.
(2) Net revenues from services in the year / average between the number of clients at the beginning and at the end of the year.
(3) Sum of marketing and sales expenses, commissions, subsidies to phones, FISTEL fee / number of gross activations in the period.


23
4. Valuation of Tele Norte Celular
4.2. Economic value
*
*
*
*
*
*


24
Description of comparable companies
Tele Norte Celular’s
valuation according to an analysis of multiples of comparable companies
used as reference Brazilian and international comparable companies with greater similarities and
outstanding position in the sector in which they operate
Brazilian comparable companies
Telesp:
Operates
a
local
fixed
telephone
line
in
the
State
of
São
Paulo
and
provides
Internet
services
GVT:
Offers
products
and
solutions
for
conventional
fixed
telephone
lines,
data
transmission
services
to
companies,
Internet
services
(broadband
and
ISP),
and
VoIP
services
Vivo:
Provides
mobile
phone
services
via
the
GSM,
CDMA
and
TDM
systems
TIM:
Offers
mobile
phone
services
in
the
entire
Brazilian
territory
via
the
GSM
system
Brasil
Telecom:
Offers
fixed
line
and
mobile
telephone
operations,
data
and
voice
transmission
services
and
domestic
and
international
long-distance
calls,
data
center,
free
Internet,
broadband
and
dial-up
access
Telemar:
Provides
fixed
and
mobile
telephone
services,
data
communication,
Internet
and
paid-TV
Foreign
comparable
companies
America
Móvil:
Provides
mobile
communication
services
in
Latin
America
via
the
GSM
system
Telmex:
Provides
local
and
long-distance
fixed
line
telephone
services
in
Mexico,
and
Internet
and
data
transmission
services
in
Brazil,
Argentina,
Chile,
Colombia
and
Peru.
It
also
offers
paid-TV
services
in
Brazil
and
telecommunication
services
in
Ecuador
Credit Suisse believes it is reasonable to take the group of companies above as a parameter for calculation of
multiples, since (i) a significant part of their revenues comes from similar activities to those provided by Tele
Norte Celular
/ Amazônia
Celular
and/or (ii) these companies operate in the telecom market in Brazil or Latin
America


25
Description of comparable companies (cont’d)
Summary of 2007 financial information:
The above table shows the comparability among the selected companies, since the revenues of each of them
derive from telecommunication services similar to those performed by Tele Norte Celular
/ Amazônia
Celular
Net Revenues
Wireless
Wireline
Other
(in R$ million)
Wireline
Telmex
-
18,537
4,765
14,249
6,425
2,395
Telesp
(1)
-
16,949
4,235
6,401
2,363
1,993
GVT
-
854
127
358
59
566
Wireless
América
Móvil
47,699
-
8,103
23,335
10,493
6,160
Vivo Participações
11,089
-
1,403
3,013
(99)
1,919
TIM Participações
11,421
-
1,021
2,918
76
1,933
Integrated
Telemar
(2)
4,436
20,717
3,523
6,442
2,358
2,328
Brasil
Telecom
(3)
2,024
11,204
2,769
3,797
671
1,399
Tele Norte Celular
463
-
24
116
3
28
Source: Companies.
(1) Gross revenues breakdown. Total net revenues of R$14,728 million.
(2) Gross revenues breakdown. Total net revenues of R$17,584 milion.
(3) Gross revenues breakdown. Total net revenues of R$11,059 milion.
EBITDA
Net Income
CAPEX


26
Multiples of comparable companies
(In local currency, in millions)
Net
Market
Enterprise
Debt
Capitalization
(2)
Value
(3)
2007
2008
Selected Companies
Wireline
Telmex
(4)
1,081.5
86,709
377,610
464,319
5.81x
5.72x
Telesp
(5)
11.7
2,733
21,550
24,283
3.79x
3.75x
GVT
(5)
19.9
110
4,520
4,630
13.46x
9.35x
Average
7.69x
6.27x
Median
5.81x
5.72x
Wireless
America Móvil
(4)
5,021.1
92,730
1,174,787
1,267,517
9.68x
8.47x
Vivo Participações
(5)
61.6
2,579
16,310
18,889
6.27x
5.06x
TIM Participações
(5)
39.9
973
14,483
15,457
5.30x
4.36x
Average
7.08x
5.96x
Median
6.27x
5.06x
Integrated
Brasil
Telecom
(5)
136.3
478
15,813
16,291
4.21x
4.01x
Telemar
(5)
139.5
2,735
22,777
25,512
3.96x
3.83x
Average
4.08x
3.92x
Median
4.08x
3.92x
Total median
5.55x
4.71x
(1) Local currency in millions. It includes equity turnover of all classes of shares and, if applicable, ADRs.
(2) Average share price in the 30-day period ended on 04/23/08.
(3) Enterprise value = net debt + market capitalization.
(4) In Mexican Pesos.
(5) In Brazilian Reais.
Note: The market capitalization of the Brazilian companies was calculated considering the prices and amounts of ON and PN shares, except for GVT which has ON shares only.
Note:
,
For
the
purpose
of
calculating
the
multiplesthe,
net
debt
of
Brasil
Telecom
Participações
and
Tele
Norte
Leste
Participações
was
calculated
adding
the
net
debt
of
the
controlling
company
to
the
net
debt
of
the
operating
company
(proportional
to
the
ownership
stake
that
the
holding
company
has
in
the
operating
company).
Source: Bloomberg and companies' financial statements. Updated as of 04/23/08.
Company
Daily average equity
turnover
(1)
Enterprise value / EBITDA


27
Economic value -
multiples of comparable companies
According
to
the
economic
value
criterion
based
on
multiples
of
comparable
companies
methodology,
the
value
range
per
preferred
and
ordinary
share
issued
by
Tele
Norte
Celular
is
demonstrated
below:
(1)
Economic value based on multiples of comparable
companies methodology
Source: Financial statements of Tele Norte Celular
and Credit Suisse.
(1) For further information on the value breakdown among the different classes of shares of Tele Norte Celular
and Amazônia
Celular, see pages 28 and 29 of this report.
(2) Tele Norte Celular
did not have any treasury shares on December 31, 2007.
(3) “TMAC”
refers to Amazônia
Celular
S.A. The revenue from the reversal of ICMS tax in 2007 amounting to R$26.6mn was excluded for the purpose of this analysis, since it is
extraordinary and a non-recurring event. Adjusted EBITDA includes statutory interest and
contributions, since they are operating expenses.
(4) The value of Tele Norte Celular
holding was calculated based on its ownership stake in TMAC, a controlled company responsible for the operating activities.
(5) Net present value of TNCP holding operating expenses. For more information, see Appendix D of this report.
R$ mn, except per share data
+ 4.88%
-
4.65%
Net debt breakdown
R$ mn
TMAC
TNCP
12/31/2007
12/31/2007
Loans and financing
R$ 76.0
R$ 5.0
Dividends payable
–
3.3
Hedge operations
4.9
2.5
Reverse shares split
–
14.0
Short term debt
80.9
24.8
Loans and financing
70.9
–
Provisions
30.5
–
Intercompany debt
26.2
0.1
Hedge operations
45.8
–
Pension plan
2.3
–
Long term debt
175.6
0.1
Total gross debt
256.5
24.9
Cash and financial investments
29.9
15.0
Intercompany credits
–
0.1
Cash and financial investments
29.9
15.1
Net debt
226.6
9.8
TMAC Adjusted EBITDA 2007
(3)
R$ 116.8
x EV/EBITDA Multiple
5.55x
= TMAC enterprise value
648.5
(-) TMAC net debt (12/31/2007)
226.6
= TMAC total equity value
421.9
Value per
share
. PN shares
114.0
$31.50
. Controlling ON shares
282.3
138.41
. Minority ON shares
25.7
110.73
TMAC shares owned by TNCP
Shares
% of share
class
. PN shares ('000)
2,374.2
65.63%
. ON shares ('000)
2,039.3
89.78%
= TNCP enterprise value
(4)
357.1
(-) NPV of TNCP holding expenses
(5)
11.4
(-) TNCP net debt (12/31/2007)
9.8
= TNCP total equity value
335.9
. PN shares
116.6
. ON shares
219.3
Number of PN shares ('000)
(2)
4,209.2
Number of ON shares ('000)
(2)
2,492.5
Total number of shares ('000)
(2)
6,701.7
PN (R$/share)
(1)
R$ 26.42
R$ 27.71
R$ 29.06
ON controlling (R$/share)
(1)
92.81
97.34
102.09
ON minority (R$/share)
(1)
74.25
77.87
81.67


28
Amazônia
Celular
-
Value breakdown among PNs,
ON minority and ON controlling shares
1.
The
total
value
of
shares
reflects
Amazônia
Celular’s
equity
value
2.
The
value
of
ON
controlling
shares
reflects
the
control
premium
of
25.0%
on
ON
minority
shares,
in
line
with
the
implicit
premium
defined
in
the
Brazilian
Corporate
Law
(1)
3.
The
value
of
ON
minority
shares
reflects
a
historic
spread
(90
days)
of
251.5%
on
PN
shares,
as
per
appendix
A
4.
The
value
of
PN
shares
reflects
the
remaining
value
of
the
shares
after
the
distributions
under
“2”
and
“3”
1. Total equity value
421.9
Total number of shares (millions)
5.9
Price per share
71.65
2. Equity value of ON controlling shares
282.3
Number of ON controlling shares (millions)
2.0
Price per ON controlling share
R$ 138.41
3. Equity value of ON minority shares
25.7
Number of ON minority shares (millions)
0.2
Price per ON minority share (control ON x 80%)
R$ 110.73
4. Equity value of PN shares
114.0
Number of PN shares (millions)
3.6
Price per PN share
R$ 31.50
The
shares
issued
by
Tele
Norte
Celular,
as
is
the
case
for
other
companies
traded
on
Bovespa,
are
negotiated
in
different
price
levels
according
to
their
specific
class
and
type.
This
differentiation
is
due
to
specific
rights
and
characteristics
attributed
to
each
share
class
and
type.
Therefore,
it
is
justified
to
have
specific
valuations
of
each
class
and
type
of
share
according
to
an
objectively
verifiable
criterion
(as
per
interpretation
of
CVM
“Parecer
de
Orientação”
No
34
of
08/18/2006)
deemed
to
be
adequate.
The
distribution
of
the
total
equity
value
among
ON
controlling,
ON
minority
and
PN
shares
issued
by
Tele
Norte
Celular
was
done
according
to
the
following
criteria:
(1)
As
stated
in
Article
254-A
of
Law
6.404
from
12/15/1976
(Brazilian
Corporate
Law),
the
sale
of
the
control
of
a
public
company
triggers
an
obligatory
tag
along
offer
to
the
minority
shareholders
on
a
price
of
at
least
80%
of
the
acquisition
price
per
common
share
of
the
controlling
block.
Therefore,
the
implicit
control
premium
is
(1/
80%
-
1
=
25%).


29
Tele Norte Celular
-
Value breakdown among
PNs, ON minority and ON controlling shares
1.
Total
value
of
the
shares
reflects
the
economic
value
of
the
shares
of
Tele
Norte
Celular
2.
Value
of
the
ON
controlling
shares
reflects
the
control
premium
of
25.0%
over
minority
common
shares,
consistent
with
the
implicit
premium
defined
by
Brazilian
Corporate
Law
(2)
3.
The
value
of
ON
minority
shares
reflects
a
historic
spread
(90
days)
of
181.0%
on
PN
shares,
as
per
appendix
A
4.
Value
of
the
PN
shares
reflects
the
remaining
value
of
the
shares
after
distributions
in
“2”
and
“3”
The
shares
issued
by
Tele
Norte
Celular,
as
is
the
case
for
other
companies
traded
on
Bovespa,
are
negotiated
in
different
price
levels
according
to
their
specific
class
and
type.
This
differentiation
is
due
to
specific
rights
and
characteristics
attributed
to
each
share
class
and
type.
Therefore,
it
is
justified
to
have
specific
valuations
of
each
class
and
type
of
share
according
to
an
objectively
verifiable
criterion
(as
per
interpretation
of
CVM
“Parecer
de
Orientação”
No
34
of
08/18/2006)
deemed
to
be
adequate.
The
distribution
of
the
total
equity
value
among
ON
controlling,
ON
minority
and
PN
shares
issued
by
Tele
Norte
Celular
was
done
according
to
the
following
criteria:
(1)
For
further
information
on
the
methodology
used,
see
Appendix
D
of
this
Report.
(2)
As
stated
in
Article
254-A
of
Law
6.404
from
12/15/1976
(Brazilian
Corporate
Law),
the
sale
of
control
of
a
public
company
triggers
an
obligatory
tag
along
offer
to
the
minority
shareholders
on
a
price
of
at
least
80%
of
the
acquisition
price
per
common
share
of
the
controlling
block.
Therefore,
the
implicit
control
premium
is
(1/
80%
-
1
=
25%).
Value of ownership stake in TMAC
357.1
(-) TNCP net debt
9.8
(-) NPV of TNCP holding expenses
(1)
11.4
1. TNCP equity value
335.9
Total number of shares (millions)
6.7
Price per share
50.12
2. Equity value of ON controlling shares
125.8
Number of ON controlling shares (millions)
1.3
Price per ON controlling share
R$ 97.34
3. Equity value of ON minority shares
93.4
Number of ON minority shares (millions)
1.2
Price per ON minority share (control ON x 80%)
R$ 77.87
4. Equity value of PN shares
116.6
Number of PN shares (millions)
4.2
Price per PN share
R$ 27.71


30
4. Valuation of Tele Norte Celular
4.3. Book value of the shareholders’
equity
*
*
*
*
*
*


31
Book value of the shareholder’s equity
Based on the book value of the shareholders’
equity criterion, the value per share of Tele Norte Celular
is R$13.15
Book value of the shareholders’
equity
Source:
Financial
statements
of
Tele
Norte
Celular.
(1)
Tele
Norte
Celular
did
not
have
any
treasury
shares
as
of
December
31,
2007.
R$ mn, except price per share
Total assets
R$ 529.21
(-) Total liabilities
409.3
(-) Minority interests
31.8
= Shareholders' equity
88.1
Total number of shares ('000)
(1)
6,702
R$/share PN and/or ON
13.15
12/31/2007


32
4. Valuation of Tele Norte Celular
4.4. Weighted average share price on the BOVESPA
*
*
*
*
*
*


33
TNCP3
Weighted average price of the shares on the BOVESPA
Price of common shares of Tele Norte Celular
(TNCP3) on the BOVESPA
Weighted average between 08/01/2006 and 08/01/2007: R$50.95
Weighted average between 08/02/2007 and 04/23/2008: R$72.24
Source:
Economática
as
of
April
23,
2008.
0
2,000,000
4,000,000
6,000,000
8,000,000
10,000,000
12,000,000
14,000,000
16,000,000
18,000,000
20,000,000
aug-06
sep-06
oct-06nov-06dec-06
jan-07
feb-07
apr-07may-07jun-07
jul-07
aug-07sep-07
oct-07dec-07
jan-08
feb-08
mar-08
apr-08
-
10.00
20.00
30.00
40.00
50.00
60.00
70.00
80.00
90.00
100.00
110.00
Equity turnover
Price (R$/share)


34
TNCP4
Weighted average price of the shares on the BOVESPA
Weighted average between 08/01/2006 and 08/01/2007: R$19.61
Weighted average between 08/02/2007 and 04/23/2008: R$25.43
Price of PN shares of Tele Norte Celular
(TNCP4) on the BOVESPA
0
2,000,000
4,000,000
6,000,000
8,000,000
10,000,000
12,000,000
14,000,000
-
5.00
10.00
15.00
20.00
25.00
30.00
35.00
Equity turnover
Price (R$/share)
aug-06sep-06
oct-06nov-06dec-06
jan-07
feb-07
apr-07may-07jun-07
jul-07
aug-07sep-07
oct-07dec-07
jan-08
feb-08
mar-08
apr-08
Source:
Economática
as
of
April
23,
2008.


35
Market value of the shares
Based
on
the
weighted
average
price
of
the
shares
issued
by
Tele
Norte
Celular
listed
on
the
BOVESPA,
the
price
range
of
common
and
preferred
shares
issued
by
Tele
Norte
Celular
is
demonstrated
below:
Weighted average price of the shares on the BOVESPA
Source:
Economática
as
of
April
23,
2008.
(1)
Material
Fact
from
August
2,
2007
related
to
the
acquisition
by
Vivo
Participações
S.A.
of
the
shares
of
TNCP
owned
by
Telpart
Participações
S.A.
(2)
Source:
Tele
Norte
Celular
(Tele
Norte
Celular
did
not
have
any
treasury
shares
on
December
31,
2007).
R$ per share
ON
PN
12-month period prior to the release of the Material Fact
(1)
08/01/2006 -
08/01/2007
R$ 50.95
R$ 19.61
Number of shares ('000)
(2)
2,492.5
4,209.2
Market capitalization (R$ mn)
127.0
82.5
Value per share weighted by the amount of shares of each class
R$ 50.95
R$ 19.61
Period between the release of the Material Fact and the date of the valuation report
08/02/2007 -
04/23/2008
R$ 72.24
R$ 25.43
Number of shares ('000)
(2)
2,492.5
4,209.2
Market capitalization (R$ mn)
180.1
107.0
Value per share weighted by the amount of shares of each class
R$ 72.24
R$ 25.43
90-day period between 01/24/08 and 04/23/08
01/24/2008 -
04/23/2008
R$ 76.40
R$ 27.58
Number of shares ('000)
(2)
2,492.5
4,209.2
Market capitalization (R$ mn)
190.4
116.1
Value per share weighted by the amount of shares of each class
R$ 76.40
R$ 27.58


36
Appendix A. Analysis of the historical spreads
between ON and PN shares
*
*
*
*
*


37
Amazônia
Celular
-
Analysis of historical spreads
between ON and PN
shares
Historical spreads between ON and PN
shares of Amazônia
Celular
Source: Economática, as of April 23, 2008.
Days prior to the relevant fact from
August 2, 2007
(Average prices of TMAC3 /
Average prices of TMAC11) -1
30 days
291.7%
60 days
284.2%
90 days
251.5%
180 days
233.4%
1 year
166.0%


38
Tele Norte Celular
-
Analysis of historical spreads
between ON and PN
shares
Historical spreads between ON and PN
shares of Tele Norte Celular
Days prior to the Material Fact from
August 2, 2007
(Average prices of TNCP3 /
Average prices of TNCP4) -1
30 days
141.6%
60 days
168.1%
90 days
181.0%
180 days
191.4%
1 year
159.7%
Source: Economática, as of April 23, 2008.


39
Appendix B. Valuation criterion
*
*
*
*
*
*


40
Valuation methodology
Multiples of comparable companies
CS valued Tele Norte Celular
using multiples of comparable listed companies with similar
operational and financial characteristics
Once the universe of comparable companies is chosen, the implicit enterprise value and the value of
the shares of the company being valued is calculated by multiplying their operational variables (e.g.,
net profit, EBITDA) by the respective multiples of the universe of comparable companies
The key element in the analysis of comparable companies is to identify the companies that are most
comparable and relevant
-
A good comparable company is one that has operational and financial characteristics similar to
those of the company being valued
-
Examples of operational characteristics: operating sector, products, distribution channels, markets,
clients, seasonality and cyclicality
-
Examples
of
financial
characteristics:
size,
leverage,
shareholders’
base,
growth
and
margins
CS applied the economic value criterion using multiples of comparable companies for the following reasons:
i.
The
companies
listed
on
pages
24
to
26
of
this
Valuation
Report
have
similar
operational
and
financial
characteristics
to
those
Tele
Norte
Celular
and
Amazônia
Celular
and;
ii.
The
shares
of
those
companies
have
adequate
liquidity
and
are
covered
by
several
research
departments
of
investment
banks,
and
thus
their
prices
appropriately
reflect
growth
perspectives,
profitability
and
risks
inherent
to
companies
in
the
same
sector
as
Tele
Norte
Celular
and
Amazônia
Celular


41
Appendix C. Terms and definitions used in the
valuation report
*
*
*
*
*


42
Terms and definitions used in the valuation report
ARPU:
average
revenues
per
user.
Capex:
capital
expenditures,
or
investments
in
capacity
maintenance
and/or
expansion.
CAPU:
cost
of
acquisition
per
user.
EBIT:
earnings
before
interest
and
taxes.
EBITDA:
earnings
before
interest,
taxes,
depreciation
and
amortization.
NPV:
net
present
value,
calculated
based
on
a
projected
cash
flow
and
a
certain
discount
rate.
Spread:
difference
between
prices
of
two
shares.
TMAC:
Amazônia
Celular
S.A.
TNCP:
Tele
Norte
Celular
Participações
S.A.
WACC:
weighted
average
cost
of
capital.


43
Appendix D. Calculation of the NPV of holding
expenses
*
*
*
*
*


44
Calculation of the NPV of holding expenses
(1)
Calculation
using
Gordon’s
perpetuity
growth
model.
Assumes
a
perpetuity
growth
rate
of
2.5%
in
nominal
terms,
in
U.S.
dollars.
(2)
Source:
Financial
statements
of
TNCP
and
Credit
Suisse.
(3)
Source:
Brazilian
Central
Bank
(2007
year
average)
and
Brazilian
Central
Bank
Focus
Report
(projections).
Assumptions
Expenses projections in nominal Brazilian reais
Expenses flows converted to US$ and then discounted
Base date: December 31, 2007: Present value of cash flows as of December 31, 2007
Period of projections: from 2008 to 2018
WACC in nominal terms, in US$, of 10.5%
Perpetuity growth of 2.5%
For
the
correct
application
of
the
market
multiples
of
comparable
companies
methodology
to
TNCP,
it
is
necessary
to
subtract
from
the
EBITDA
of
TMAC,
the
operating
company,
all
general
and
administrative
holding
expenses
of
TNCP,
as
this
company
does
not
have
any
own
cash
flows
other
than
the
cash
flows
received
from
its
controlling
company
in
order
to
honor
its
expenses.
The
net
present
value
of
TNCP
holding
general
and
administrative
expenses
is
demonstrated
below:
TNCP holding general and administrative expenses
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
Perpetuity
(1)
General and administrative expenses (R$ million)
(2)
(1.1)
(0.9)
(1.0)
(1.0)
(1.0)
(1.1)
(1.1)
(1.2)
(1.2)
(1.3)
(1.3)
(1.4)
(17.6)
R$/ US$ FX rate -
year average
(3)
1.95
1.74
1.80
1.86
1.90
1.94
1.96
1.99
2.02
2.05
2.08
2.11
2.11
General and administrative expenses (US$ million)
(0.6)
(0.5)
(0.5)
(0.5)
(0.5)
(0.6)
(0.6)
(0.6)
(0.6)
(0.6)
(0.6)
(0.7)
(8.3)
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
11
Multiplying factor
0%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
Discounted cash flows (US$ million)
–
(0.5)
(0.4)
(0.4)
(0.4)
(0.3)
(0.3)
(0.3)
(0.3)
(0.3)
(0.2)
(0.2)
(2.8)
WACC
10.50%
Perpetuity growth
2.50%
NPV on December 31, 2007 (US$)
(6.4)
R$/US$ FX rate on December 31, 2008
(3)
1.78
NPV on December 31, 2007 (R$)
(11.4)


45
Appendix E. Additional information and disclaimers
*
*
*
*
*
*


46
Additional information and disclaimers
The
following
information
is
important
and
must
be
carefully
and
thoroughly
read:
1.
This
Valuation
Report
has
been
prepared
for
exclusive
use
of
the
Board
of
Directors
of
Telemar,
its
shareholders
and
TNCP’s
shareholders
for
the purpose of their evaluation of the proposed Mandatory TO, and may not be used or relied upon for any other purpose. This Valuation
Report must not be used by any third party and for any other purpose without the prior written consent of CS. This Valuation Report, including
its
analyses
and
conclusions,
do
not
constitute
a
recommendation
to
any
shareholder
of
Telemar
or
Tele
Norte
Celular
or
member
of
the
Board
of Directors of Telemar
on how to vote or act in connection with any matter related to the Mandatory TO. CS will not be liable for any direct or
indirect losses or loss of profits resulting from the use of this Valuation Report. The base date used in this Valuation Report is April 23, 2008.
The base date of financial information used in this Valuation Report is December 31, 2007.
2.
In
order
to
arrive
at
the
conclusions
presented
in
this
Valuation
Report,
we
have
performed
the
following,
among
other
things:
(i)
analysis
of
the
consolidated
financial
statements
prepared
in
accordance
with
accounting
practices
adopted
in
Brazil
of
Tele
Norte
Celular
audited
by
PricewaterhouseCoopers
Auditores
Independentes
(“PWC”)
for
the
fiscal
year
ended
on
December
31,
2005
and
audited
by
Deloitte
Touche
Tohmatsu
Auditores
Independentes
(“Deloitte”)
for
the
fiscal
years
ended
on
December
31,
2006
and
2007,
(ii)
discussions
with
members
of
Telemar’s
management about the business and prospects of Tele Norte Celular; and (iii) analysis of other information, financial studies,
analyses, research and financial, economic and market criteria we deemed relevant (jointly referred to as “Information”).
3.
With
respect
to
our
work,
we
do
not
assume
any
responsibility
for
independently
investigating
any
of
the
information
referred
to
above
and
have assumed that such information was complete and accurate in all its relevant aspects. Additionally, we have not been requested to
perform, and have not performed, an independent verification of such information, or any independent verification or assessment of any assets
or liabilities (contingent or not) of Tele Norte Celular, and we have not received any such assessment and have not assessed the solvency or
fair
value
of
Tele
Norte
Celular
under
any
laws
governing
bankruptcy,
insolvency
or
similar
matters.
4.
We do not make, and will not make, either expressly or implicitly, any representation or warranty regarding any information (including financial
and
operational
forecasts
of
Tele
Norte
Celular
or
assumptions
and
estimates
on
which
such
forecasts
were
based)
used
in
the
preparation
of
this Valuation Report. Additionally, we do not assume any obligation to make, and have not made, any physical inspection of the properties or
facilities
of
Tele
Norte
Celular.
We
are
not
an
accounting
firm
and
do
not
provide
accounting
or
auditing
services
related
to
this
Valuation
Report. We are not a law firm and do not provide legal, tax or fiscal services related to this Valuation Report.


47
Additional information and disclaimers (cont’d)
5.
The
controlling
shareholders
of
Tele
Norte
Celular
and/or
Telemar
and
their
management
did
not
(i)
in
any
way
interfere
with,
restrict
or
hinder
our
access
and
our
capacity
to
obtain
and
use
the
information
necessary
to
prepare
this
Valuation
Report,
(ii)
determine
the
methodologies
used
in
the
preparation
of
the
analyses,
or
(iii)
in
any
way
restrict
our
capacity
to
arrive
at
the
conclusions
independently
presented
in
this
Valuation
Report.
6.
The
preparation
of
a
financial
analysis
is
a
complex
process
that
involves
various
decisions
on
the
most
appropriate
and
relevant
financial
analysis
methods,
and
the
application
of
these
methods.
In
order
to
arrive
at
the
conclusions
presented
in
this
Valuation
Report,
we
applied
a
qualitative
approach
to
the
analyses
and
factors
considered
by
us.
We
arrived
at
a
final
conclusion
based
on
the
results
of
the
analysis
performed
by
us
as
a
whole,
and
we
did
not
reach
individual
conclusions
based
on
or
related
to
any
of
the
factors
or
methods
of
our
analysis.
Therefore,
we
believe
our
analysis
must
be
considered
as
a
whole
and
that
the
examination
of
parts
of
our
analysis
and
specific
factors
without
considering
the
full
context
of
our
analysis
and
conclusions
may
lead
to
incomplete
and
incorrect
interpretations
of
the
processes
used
in
our
analyses
and
conclusions.
7.
This
Valuation
Report
provides
an
estimate
with
respect
to
the
value
of
the
shares
issued
by
Tele
Norte
Celular
and
does
not
evaluate
any
other
aspect
or
implication
of
the
Mandatory
TO
or
any
contract,
agreement
or
understanding
signed
in
relation
to
the
Mandatory
TO.
We
do
not
express
any
opinion
on
the
value
for
which
the
shares
related
to
the
Mandatory
TO
could
be
traded
on
any
securities
market
at
any
time.
The
results
presented
in
this
Valuation
Report
refer
exclusively
to
the
Mandatory
TO,
and
do
not
apply
to
any
other
matter
or
operation,
present
or
future,
relative
to
Tele
Norte
Celular
or
Telemar,
or
to
the
economic
group
of
which
these
companies
are
part
or
to
the
sector
in
which
they
operate.


48
Additional information and disclaimers (cont’d)
8.
Our
Valuation
Report
is
necessarily
based
on
information
provided
to
us
as
of
the
date
of
this
Valuation
Report
and
takes
into
account
economic
and
market
conditions
and
other
conditions
as
they
are
and
as
can
be
evaluated
on
this
date.
Although
future
events
and
other
developments
could
affect
the
conclusions
presented
in
this
Valuation
Report,
we
do
not
have
any
obligation
to
update,
revise,
rectify
or
revoke
this
Valuation
Report,
wholly
or
partly,
as
a
result
of
any
subsequent
development
or
for
any
other
reason.
9.
Our
analyses
deal
with
Tele
Norte
Celular
as
an
operation
independent
from
Telemar
(stand-alone
operation)
and,
thus,
do
not
include
operating,
tax
or
any
other
benefits
or
losses,
including
any
premiums,
synergies,
incremental
value
and/or
costs,
if
any,
that
Telemar
or
Tele
Norte
Celular
may
have
as
a
result
of
the
completion
of
the
Mandatory
TO,
if
consummated,
or
of
any
other
transaction.
The
evaluation
also
disregards
any
operational
and
financial
gains
or
losses
that
may
result
after
the
Mandatory
TO
due
to
a
commercial
change
in
the
business
currently
existing
between
Telemar
and
Tele
Norte
Celular.
10.
Telemar
has
agreed
to
reimburse
us
for
our
expenses
and
to
indemnify
us
and
certain
persons
related
to
us
for
certain
liabilities
and
expenses
that
may
arise
as
a
result
of
our
retained
services.


49
Additional information and disclaimers (cont’d)
11.
We
have
provided,
from
time
to
time,
in
the
past,
investment
banking
services
and
other
financial
services
to
Telemar,
its
controlling
shareholders,
subsidiaries
and
companies
under
common
control
(“Affiliates”)
for
which
we
were
remunerated,
as
mentioned
in
“Evaluator
Representations”
of
this
Valuation
Report
(for
the
purposes
of
Schedule
III,
X,
“d”,
5,
of
CVM
Instruction
No.
361/02)
and
may,
in
the
future,
provide
these
services
to
Telemar
and
Tele
Norte
Celular
and/or
their
Affiliates,
for
which
we
expect
to
be
remunerated.
We
are
a
financial
institution
that
provides
a
variety
of
financial
services
and
other
services
related
to
securities,
brokerage
and
investment
banking.
In
the
normal
course
of
our
activities,
we
may
acquire,
hold
or
sell,
on
our
behalf
or
on
the
behalf
of
our
clients,
shares,
debt
instruments
and
other
securities
and
financial
instruments
(including
bank
loans
and
other
obligations)
of
Telemar
and
Tele
Norte
Celular
and
of
any
other
companies
involved
in
the
Mandatory
TO,
as
well
as
provide
investment
banking
services
and
other
financial
services
to
these
companies
and
their
Affiliates.
Also,
the
professionals
of
our
research
departments
and
of
other
divisions
may
base
their
analyses
and
publications
on
different
operational
and
market
assumptions
and
on
different
analysis
methodologies
compared
with
those
used
in
the
preparation
of
this
Valuation
Report,
with
the
result
that
the
research
reports
and
other
publications
prepared
by
them
may
contain
different
results
and
conclusions
when
compared
with
those
herein
presented.
We
also
adopted
policies
and
procedures
to
preserve
the
independence
of
our
research
analysts,
who
may
have
different
views
from
those
of
our
investment
banking
department.
We
also
adopted
policies
and
procedures
for
preserving
the
independence
between
investment
banking
and
other
areas
and
departments
of
CS,
including
but
not
limited
to
asset
management
and
the
proprietary
desk
for
trading
shares,
debt
instruments,
securities
and
other
financial
instruments.
This
Valuation
Report
is
the
intellectual
property
of
CS.
The
financial
calculations
contained
in
this
Valuation
Report
may
not
result
in
exact
sums
due
to
rounding.
Banco
de
Investimentos
Credit
Suisse
(Brasil)
S.A.
José
Olympio Pereira
Bruno Amaral
Edwyn Neves
Marco Gonçalves
[by: /s/ Edwyn Neves]
[by: /s/ Bruno Amaral]
[by: /s/ Marco Gonçalves]
[by: /s/ José
Olympio
Pereira]


50
BANCO DE INVESTIMENTOS CREDIT SUISSE (BRASIL) S.A.
Avenida
Brigadeiro
Faria
Lima, 3064
01451-000 São Paulo, SP
+55 11 3841 6000
www.credit-suisse.com
*
*