SPORT CHALET INC CORRESP, filed Apr 30, 2008: A correspondence can be sent as a document with another submission type or can be sent as a separate submission.

By
U.S. Mail and EDGAR
April
30,
2008
Jennifer
Thompson
Accounting
Branch Chief
United
States Securities and Exchange Commission
Division
of Corporation Finance
100
F
Street, N.E.
Mail
Stop
3561
Washington,
D.C. 20549
| RE: |
Sport
Chalet, Inc.
|
Form
10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended April 1, 2007
Filed
June 13, 2007
Form
10-Q for the Fiscal Quarter Ended December 30, 2007
Filed
February 12, 2008
File
No. 0-20736
Dear
Ms.
Thompson:
This
letter sets forth the response of Sport Chalet, Inc. (the “Company”) to the
comments in your letter dated March 25, 2008 relating to the Company’s Annual
Report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended April 1, 2007 (the “Form 10-K”)
filed by the Company with the Securities and Exchange Commission (the
“Commission”) on June 13, 2007 and Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q for the
quarterly period ended December 30, 2007 (the “Form 10-Q”) filed by the Company
with the Commission on February 12, 2008.
We
understand the purpose of your review, and appreciate your comments.
In response
to your comments, the Company submits the following responses for the
Staff’s
consideration. The Company requested and was granted an extension in
the due
date of our response to April 30, 2008. For your convenience, we have
reprinted
the Staff’s original comments, followed by the Company’s response.
One
Sport
Chalet Drive, La Canada, CA 91011 ● Phone: 818-949-5300 Fax:
818-949-5301
www.sportchalet.com
● Publicly traded on NASDAQ: SPCHA, SPCHB
Form
10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended April 1, 2007
Management’s
Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of
Operations
Results
of Operations, page 20
| 1. |
In
future filings, to the extent material, please discuss the impact
of gift
card breakage on your result of operations. While the amounts of
breakage
recognized are often immaterial to net sales, the impact can be material
to operating and/or net income since breakage typically has no directly
associated costs. Accordingly, it appears the changes in breakage
between
periods presented in your filing had a material impact on your results
of
operations, especially when considering your fiscal 2006 operating
and net
income excluding the effects of your
recapitalization.
|
Response
to Comment 1:
Over
the
course of the past three years we have not specifically discussed the impact
of
our gift card breakage as we believe the amount of breakage has not been
material to our net sales and our income from operations. This belief is based
on the fact that gift card issuance and redemption are daily activities in
our
stores and our ability to sell those gift cards and receive the breakage income
only occurs because we operate those stores and is therefore inseparable from
that business and the costs associated with operating our retail stores. In
our
view, to address every element of revenue associated with our retail stores
of
the magnitude of amount of breakage revenue in our Management’s Discussion and
Analysis would hinder the reader’s ability to focus on important trends, risks
and conditions that we are trying to describe. The table below shows the amount
of breakage recognized in each of the last three years with gross profit and
selling, general and administrative expense (“SG&A”) as a percent of net
sales, as reported and after adjusting for breakage, as well as breakage as
a
percent of net sales and income from operations. Based upon this analysis,
we do
not believe the impact of gift card breakage is material to warrant a separate
discussion in our financial statements for the prior three years; however,
we do
monitor these ratios and should they become material we will include gift card
breakage in future discussions.
|
Fiscal
year
|
||||||||||
|
(in
thousands)
|
2007
|
2006
|
2005
|
|||||||
|
Revenue
from breakage
|
532
|
397
|
263
|
|||||||
|
Net
sales
|
388,209
|
343,204
|
309,090
|
|||||||
|
Net
sales reduced by breakage
|
387,677
|
342,807
|
308,827
|
|||||||
|
Gross
profit % of sales as reported
|
30.9
|
%
|
30.9
|
%
|
30.9
|
%
|
||||
|
Gross
profit % without breakage
|
31.0
|
%
|
30.9
|
%
|
31.0
|
%
|
||||
|
SG&A
% of sales as reported
|
27.8
|
%
|
27.1
|
%
|
27.5
|
%
|
||||
|
Gross
profit % without breakage
|
27.8
|
%
|
27.1
|
%
|
27.6
|
%
|
||||
|
Breakage
revenue as % of net sales
|
0.1
|
%
|
0.1
|
%
|
0.1
|
%
|
||||
|
Breakage
revenue as % of income
|
4.3
|
%
|
3.0
|
%
|
2.5
|
%
|
||||
| (a) |
Amounts
for 2006 are shown excluding the effects of the
recapitalization.
|
Liquidity
and Capital Resources, page 25
| 2. |
To
the extent that payments made for maintenance, utilities, and property
taxes on your leased properties are material, please include a footnote
below the contractual obligations table to indicate that the lease
obligation amounts presented do not include these additional obligations.
Please consider disclosing amounts paid in prior years for these
items in
order to provide a context for the reader to understand the impact
of
these charges on your total lease obligations. See Item 303(a)(5)
of
Regulation S-K and footnote 46 to SEC Release No. 33-8350. Please
also
ensure your table complies with the format provided in Item 303(a)(5),
including presentation of a total column by maturity
date.
|
Response
to Comment 2:
In
future
filings a footnote regarding the exclusion of taxes, insurance and other related
expenses will be added to the table and the table format will be changed to
comply with the format provided in Item 303(a)(5). As of April 1, 2007, the
table would have been presented as shown below.
|
Payment
due by period
|
||||||||||||||||
|
Contractual
Obligations
|
Total
|
Less
than 1 year
|
1-3
years
|
3-5
years
|
More
than 5 years
|
|||||||||||
|
Operating
Leases (a)
|
$
|
280,629,092
|
$
|
29,812,296
|
$
|
64,066,206
|
$
|
59,348,550
|
$
|
127,402,040
|
||||||
|
Employment
Contracts
|
1,356,000
|
169,500
|
339,000
|
339,000
|
508,500
|
|||||||||||
|
Total
Contractual Obligations
|
281,985.092
|
29,981,796
|
64,405,206
|
59,687,550
|
127,910,540
|
|||||||||||
| (a) |
Amounts
include the direct lease obligations. Other obligations required
by the
lease agreements such as contingent rent based on sales, common area
maintenance, property taxes and insurance are not fixed amounts and
are
therefore not included. The amount of the excluded expenses are;
$8,451,816, $7,190,168 and $7,372,261 for the fiscal years 2007,
2006 and
2005, respectively.
|
Critical
Accounting Policies and Use of Estimates, page 27
| 3. |
In
future filings, please revise the discussion of your critical accounting
policies to focus on the assumptions and uncertainties that underlie
your
critical accounting estimates. Please also quantify, where material,
and
provide an analysis of the impact of critical accounting estimates
on your
financial position and results of
operations for the periods presented, including the effects of changes
in
critical accounting
estimates between periods. In addition, please include a qualitative
and
quantitative
analysis of the sensitivity of reported results to changes in your
assumptions,
judgments, and estimates, including the likelihood of obtaining
materially
different results if different assumptions were applied. For example,
please
expand your inventory valuation disclosures to more specifically
discuss
the significant
estimates involved in your inventory accounting and supplement your
discussion
by providing quantitative analysis. Please consider disclosing further
information
about your cost-to-retail ratio, markups and markup cancellations,
|
markdowns
and markdown cancellations, promotional price changes, shrinkage,
and
valuation adjustments. Please also disclose the reasons underlying any
adjustments
and material changes between periods and provide sensitivity analyses
showing
the impact on your statements of operations given a specified change in the
parameters
of your estimates. Please refer to SEC Release No. 33-8350.
Response
to Comment 3:
In
future
filings, we intend to provide the following revised disclosure related to
“Critical Accounting Policies and Use of Estimates.” Note that for most of the
information below, we used fiscal 2007 and prior two years to show the revised
wording; in some cases the circumstances have changed and revised wording
expected to be used for the fiscal year 2008 annual report was used. Significant
changes are underlined.
Our
consolidated financial statements are prepared in accordance with accounting
principles accepted in the United States. In connection with the preparation
of
our financial statements, we are required to make assumptions and estimates
about future events, and apply judgments that affect the reported amounts of
assets, liabilities, revenue, expenses and the related disclosures. We base
our
assumptions, estimates and judgments on historical experience, current trends
and other factors that management believes to be relevant at the time our
consolidated financial statements are prepared. On a regular basis, management
reviews the accounting policies, assumptions, estimates and judgments to ensure
that our financial statements are presented fairly and in accordance with
accounting principles generally accepted in the United States. However, because
future events and their effects cannot be determined with certainty, actual
results could differ from our assumptions and estimates, and such differences
could be material.
Our
significant accounting policies are discussed in Note 2, Summary
of Significant Accounting Policies,
of the
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements, included in Item 8, Financial
Statements and Supplementary Data,
of this
Annual Report on Form 10-K. Management believes that the following
accounting estimates are the most critical to aid in fully understanding and
evaluating our reported financial results, and they require management’s most
difficult, subjective or complex judgments, resulting from the need to make
estimates about the effect of matters that are inherently uncertain. Management
has reviewed these critical accounting estimates and related disclosures with
the Audit Committee of our Board.
Inventory
Valuation.
Merchandise inventories are stated at the lower of cost (first-in, first-out
“FIFO” basis determined by the retail method of accounting) or market. We
consider cost to include direct cost of merchandise and inbound freight, plus
internal costs associated with merchandise procurement, storage and handling.
The retail method is widely used in the retail industry due to its practicality.
Under the retail method, cost is determined by applying a calculated
cost-to-retail ratio across groupings of similar items, known as departments.
As
a result, the retail method results in an averaging of inventory costs across
similar items within a department. The cost-to-retail ratio is applied to ending
inventory at its current owned retail valuation to determine the cost of ending
inventory on a department basis. Current owned retail represents the retail
price for which merchandise is offered for sale on a regular basis reduced
for
any permanent or clearance markdowns. As a result, the retail method normally
results in an inventory valuation that is lower than a traditional FIFO cost
basis.
Inherent
in the retail method calculation are certain significant management judgments
and estimates including initial mark-up, markdowns and shrinkage, which can
significantly impact the owned retail and, therefore, the ending inventory
valuation at cost. Specifically, the failure to take permanent or clearance
markdowns on a timely basis can result in an overstatement of carrying cost
under the retail method. Management believes that its application of the retail
method reasonably states inventory at the lower of cost or market.
We
regularly review aged and excess inventories to determine if the carrying value
of such inventories exceeds market value. A reserve is recorded to reduce the
carrying value to market value as necessary. A determination of market value
requires estimates and judgment based on our historical markdown experience
and
anticipated markdowns based on future merchandising and advertising plans,
seasonal considerations, expected business trends and other
factors.
We
have not made any material changes in the accounting methodology used to
establish our inventory valuation or the related markdown or inventory loss
reserves during the past three fiscal years. We do not believe there is a
reasonable likelihood that there will be a material change in the future
estimates or assumptions we use to calculate our inventory. However, if
estimates regarding consumer demand are inaccurate or our ability to maintain
our cost complement percentages for certain products changes in an unforeseen
manner, we may be exposed to losses or gains that could be material. A 10%
difference in cost complement percentages at April 1, 2007, would have affected
net earnings by approximately $5.0 million in fiscal 2007. Additionally, a
10%
change in our reserve for slow moving inventories would not be material to
the
Company’s financial statements for the past three years.
Revenue
Recognition.
Sales
are recognized upon the purchase by customers at our retail store locations,
less merchandise returned by customers. Revenue from gift cards, gift
certificates and store merchandise credits is recognized at the time of
redemption. We generally accept returns up to 30 days from the date of
purchase with a sales receipt or proof of purchase. Typically refunds are in
the
same form of payment originally received from the customer. We accommodate
customers who do not have a receipt or proof of purchase by offering an exchange
or store credit. When available we track the original sale date with each return
and provide a reserve for projected merchandise returns based on this historical
experience. As the reserve for merchandise returns is based on estimates, the
actual returns could differ from the reserve, which could impact sales.
We
have not made any material changes in the accounting methodology used to
recognize revenue during the past three fiscal years. We do not believe there
is
a reasonable likelihood that there will be a material change in the estimates
we
use to reserve for returns. Additionally, we believe that a 10% change in our
reserves for merchandise returns would not be material to the Company’s
financial statements for the past three years.
We
have
recently implemented a customer loyalty program, Action Pass, which allows
members to earn points for each purchase completed at our stores. Points earned
enable members to receive a certificate that may be redeemed on future
purchases. The value of points earned are included in accrued expenses and
recorded as a reduction in sales at the time the points are earned, based on
the
retail value of points that are projected to be redeemed. A
10%
change in our customer loyalty program liability at April 1, 2007, would not
have been material to the Company’s financial statements.
Gift
Card/Certificate Redemption. We
offer
our customers the option of purchasing gift cards and, in the past, gift
certificates which may be used toward the future purchase of our products.
Revenue from gift cards, gift certificates and store merchandise credits (the
“Gift Cards”) is recognized at the time of redemption. The
Gift
Cards have no expiration dates. We record unredeemed Gift Cards as a liability
until the point of redemption.
Our
historical experience indicates that not all issued Gift Cards are redeemed
(the
“Breakage”). Based upon over five years of redemption data, approximately 90% of
Gift Cards are redeemed within the year after issuance, and approximately 95%
are redeemed within 36 months of the date of issuance, after which redemption
activity is negligible. Accordingly, we recognize Breakage as revenue by
periodically decreasing the carrying value of the Gift Card liability by
approximately 5% of the aggregate amount. A
10%
change in our breakage estimates at April 1, 2007, would not have been material
to the Company’s financial statements.
We
recognize Breakage at the time of redemption of Gift Cards. The revenue from
Breakage is included in the income statement line item net sales and amounted
to
approximately $532,000, $397,000 and $263,000 for fiscal years 2007, 2006 and
2005, respectively.
Self-insurance.
Property, general liability and workers' compensation insurance coverage is
self-insured for various levels. When
estimating our self-insured liabilities, we consider a number of factors,
including historical claims experience, demographic factors, severity factors
and valuations provided by independent third-party actuaries.
Self-insurance accruals include claims filed, as well as estimates of claims
incurred but not yet reported based on historical trends.
We
have not made any material changes in the accounting methodology used to
establish our self-insured liabilities during the past three fiscal years.
We do
not believe there is a reasonable likelihood that there will be a material
change in the estimates or assumptions we use to calculate our self-insured
liabilities. However, if actual results are not consistent with our estimates
or
assumptions, we may be exposed to losses or gains that could be material. A
10%
change in our self-insured accruals at April 1, 2007, would not have been
material to the Company’s financial statements.
Impairment
of Long-Lived Assets. We
account for long-lived assets in accordance with the provisions of Statement
of
Financial Accounting Standards (“SFAS”) No. 144, “Accounting for the Impairment
or Disposal of Long-Lived Assets.” We review long-lived assets for impairment
whenever events or changes in circumstances indicate that the carrying amount
of
an asset may not be recoverable. Recoverability of assets to be held and used
is
determined by a comparison of the carrying amount of an asset to future
undiscounted net cash flows expected to be generated by the asset. If such
assets are considered impaired, the impairment recognized is measured by
comparing projected individual store discounted cash flow to the asset carrying
values. Declines in projected store cash flow could result in the impairment
of
assets.
Our
impairment loss calculations contain uncertainties because they require
management to make assumptions and to apply judgment to estimate future cash
flows and asset fair values, including forecasting useful lives of the assets
and selecting the discount rate that reflects the risk inherent in future cash
flows. We have not made any material changes in our impairment loss assessment
methodology during the past three fiscal years. We do not believe there is
a
reasonable likelihood that there will be a material change in the estimates
or
assumptions we use to calculate long-lived asset impairment losses. However,
if
actual results are not consistent with our estimates and assumptions used in
estimating future cash flows and asset fair values, we may be exposed to losses
that could be material. Using the impairment evaluation methodology described
herein, we recorded long-lived asset impairment charges totaling $__ million,
in
the aggregate, during fiscal 2008. The carrying value of property and equipment
was approximately $__ million as of March 30, 2008
Accounting
for Income Taxes.
As part
of the process of preparing the consolidated financial statements, income taxes
are estimated for each of the jurisdictions in which we operate. This process
involves estimating actual current tax exposure together with assessing
temporary differences resulting from differing treatment of items for tax and
accounting purposes. These differences result in deferred tax assets and
liabilities, which are included within the balance sheet. The likelihood that
deferred tax assets will be
recovered
from future taxable income is assessed, recognizing that future taxable income
may give rise to new deferred tax assets. To the extent that future recovery
is
not likely, a valuation allowance would be established. To the extent that
a
valuation allowance is established or increased, an expense will be included
within the tax provision in the income statement.
Significant
management judgment is required in determining the provision for income taxes,
deferred tax assets and liabilities and any valuation allowance recorded against
net deferred tax assets. Based on our history of operating earnings, no
valuation allowance has been recorded as of April 1, 2007. In the event that
actual results differ from these estimates, or these estimates are adjusted
in
future periods, a valuation allowance may need to be established, which could
impact our financial position and results of operations.
Provisions
for income taxes are based on numerous factors that are subject to audit by
the
Internal Revenue Service and the tax authorities in the various jurisdictions
in
which we do business.
Although
management believes that the judgments and estimates discussed herein are
reasonable, actual results could differ, and we may be exposed to losses or
gains that could be material.
To
the
extent we prevail in matters for which reserves have been established, or are
required to pay amounts in excess of our reserves, our effective income tax
rate
in a given financial statement period could be materially affected. An
unfavorable tax settlement would require use of our cash and would result in
an
increase in our effective income tax rate in the period of resolution. A
favorable tax settlement would be recognized as a reduction in our effective
income tax rate in the period of resolution.
Stock-Based
Compensation.
Prior
to the April 1, 2006 adoption of the Financial Accounting Standards Board
(“FASB”) Statement No. 123(R), “Share-Based Payment” (“SFAS 123R”), the
Company accounted for stock-based compensation using the intrinsic value method
prescribed in Accounting Principles Board Opinion (“APB”) No. 25,
“Accounting for Stock Issued to Employees,” and related interpretations. As
permitted by SFAS No. 123, “Accounting for Stock-Based Compensation” (“SFAS
123”), stock-based compensation was included as a pro forma disclosure in the
notes to the consolidated financial statements. Effective April 1, 2006, the
Company adopted the fair value recognition provisions of SFAS 123R, using the
modified-prospective transition method. Under this transition method,
stock-based compensation expense was recognized in the consolidated financial
statements for granted, modified or settled stock options. The provisions of
SFAS 123R apply to new stock options and stock options outstanding, but not
yet
vested, on the effective date of April 1, 2006. Results for prior periods have
not been restated, as provided for under the modified-prospective transition
method. Total stock-based compensation expense recognized for the 2007 fiscal
year was $166,178 before income taxes, and the related tax benefit was $67,711.
On March 31, 2006 we accelerated the vesting of options to purchase an aggregate
of 209,514 shares of Class A Common Stock and 29,931 shares of Class B Common
Stock. The purpose of accelerating the vesting of the options is to reduce
the
non-cash compensation expense that we otherwise would be required to recognize.
We
do
not believe there is a reasonable likelihood that there will be a material
change in the future estimates or assumptions we use to determine stock-based
compensation expense. A 10% change in our stock-based compensation expense
for
the year ended April 1, 2007, would have been material to our financial
statements for fiscal 2007.
Controls
and Procedures, page 31
| 4. |
We
advise you that your definition of disclosure controls and procedures
is
incomplete.
Please revise future filings to indicate that disclosure controls
and
procedures
are designed to ensure that information required to be disclosed
in the
reports
you file or submit to the SEC under the Exchange Act
is:
|
|
·
|
recorded,
processed, summarized and reported within the time periods specified
in
the Commission’s rules and forms;
and
|
|
·
|
accumulated
and communicated to your management, including your principal executive
and principal financial officer, to allow timely decisions regarding
required disclosure.
|
See
Exchange Act Rule 13a-15(e) and 15d-15(e)
Response
to Comment 4:
In
future
filings, we intend to indicate that disclosure controls and procedures are
designed to ensure that information required to be disclosed in reports the
Company files or submits to the Commission under the Exchange Act
is:
|
·
|
recorded,
processed, summarized and reported within the time period specified
in the
Commission’s rules and forms; and
|
|
·
|
accumulated
and communicated to our management, including our principal executive
and
principal financial officer, to allow timely decisions regarding
required
disclosure.
|
We
intend
to provide the following disclosure as Item 9A of our Annual Report on Form
10-K
for the fiscal year ended March 30, 2008. The following disclosure has been
marked to show the changes from the disclosure contained in Item 4 of our
Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q for the quarterly period ended December 30,
2007.
ITEM
9A.
CONTROLS AND PROCEDURES
Our
Chief
Executive Officer, Craig Levra, and Chief Financial Officer, Howard Kaminsky,
with the participation of our management, evaluated the effectiveness of the
Company’s disclosure controls and procedures pursuant to Exchange Act Rule
13a-15(e). Based upon that evaluation, the Chief Executive Officer and the
Chief
Financial Officer concluded that, as
a
result of the material weakness described below, the Company’s disclosure
controls and procedures are not effective, at the reasonable assurance level
as
of the end of the period covered by this report, to ensure that information
required to be disclosed in this report is:
|
·
|
recorded,
processed, summarized and reported within the time period specified in the
Commission’s rules and forms; and
|
|
·
|
accumulated
and communicated to our management, including our principal executive
and
principal financial officer, to allow timely decisions regarding
required
disclosure.
|
In
October 2006, we selected an enterprise resource management system (the "ERP
System") from SAP to replace our existing merchandise and financial information
systems. Over the next eighteen
months,
we were in the process of implementing this system, including testing the system
in a controlled environment, training our personnel in the use of the system
and
documenting and testing the control environment in preparation for compliance
with Section 404 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002. Our planned “go-live” date
for the new system was October 1, 2007. However, we encountered delays in,
among
other things, integrating the ERP System with our existing "best of breed"
merchandise planning system. As a result of such delays we elected to postpone
implementation of the ERP System until after the end of the fiscal year
ended March 30, 2008 as we did not believe it would be prudent to implement
the
new system so close to our fiscal year-end. We
implemented the ERP System on March 31, 2008
Pursuant
to Section 404 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, our management is required
to
assess the effectiveness of our internal control over financial reporting as
of
the end of each fiscal year beginning with fiscal 2008. We have made a
substantial investment to ensure that the ERP System will provide effective
internal control over financial reporting, and we have evaluated our controls
that are not intended to change with the implementation of the ERP System.
Because we initially anticipated that the “go-live” date of the ERP System would
be prior to March 30, 2008, we did not, however, fully evaluate the
effectiveness of the existing controls that were to be replaced by the ERP
System. With the delay in implementing the ERP System, we did not have
sufficient time to fully document, test and remediate (where applicable) those
controls that we previously planned to replace prior to March 30, 2008. As
a
result, we believe our inability to fully test the legacy system or the ERP
System as required by Section 404 results in a material weakness in our internal
control over financial reporting and results in an ineffective assessment of
our
control environment.
We
have
assessed the risk of financial misstatements in this Annual
Report on Form 10-K
that
might result from the existing information system, including a review of
compensating controls. Based on our review, we believe that the information
contained in this periodic report fairly presents, in all material respects,
the
financial condition and results of operations of the Company as of, and for,
the
periods presented in such report.
Notwithstanding
the foregoing, there can be no assurance that we will be successful in
implementing, documenting,
testing or remediating (when applicable)
the ERP
System before the end of the first quarter of fiscal 2009 ending June 29, 2008
or at all, that we will not discover material weaknesses in our internal control
over financial reporting, or that we will be able to remediate any such
weakness. Furthermore, if we discover a material weakness, corrective action
may
be time-consuming, costly and further divert the attention of management. The
disclosure of a material weakness, even if quickly remedied, could reduce the
market's confidence in the Company’s financial statements, and harm its stock
price, especially if a restatement of financial statements for past periods
were
to be necessary. See "Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial
Condition and Results of Operations - Risk Factors - We are replacing our legacy
merchandise and financial systems. Changes to our systems may disrupt our supply
chain operations and have a material adverse impact on our business and results
of operations." and "- Implementing Section 404 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of
2002 will be expensive, time-consuming and require significant management
attention, and may not be successful."
There
were no changes in the Company's internal controls over financial reporting,
identified by the Chief Executive Officer or the Chief Financial Officer that
occurred during the period covered by this report that have materially affected,
or are reasonably likely to materially affect, the Company’s internal control
over financial reporting.
Consolidated
Statements of Cash Flows, page 39
| 5. |
Please
clarify why for each fiscal year you have reflected the entire amount
of
tax benefits
related to the exercise of stock options as financing activity inflows.
Please note
that the tax benefits upon exercise are operating inflows to the
extent
that they do
not exceed the related deferred tax asset and excess tax
benefits are recognized as
financing inflows. See paragraphs 68, 81, and A94-96 of SFAS
123(R).
|
Response
to Comment 5:
All
stock
options exercised over the prior three-year period have been related to pre-
SFAS 123(R) option issuances. Accordingly, the cash retained as a result of
the
excess tax benefits relating to the share-based payments to the employees are
presented in the statement of cash flows as a financing cash inflow. It should
be noted the calculation of excess tax benefit that is presented as a financing
cash flow was performed on an option-by-option basis.
Notes
to the Consolidated Financial Statements
Note
2. Summary of Significant Accounting Policies
Revenue
Recognition, page 43
| 6. |
You
disclose that the value of loyalty points earned are included in
accrued
expenses
and recorded as a reduction in sales at the time the points are earned,
based
on the retail value of points that are projected to be redeemed.
Please
clarify if
your accounting policy is to defer a portion of the revenue for customer
transactions
earning the rewards until those rewards are redeemed or to accrue
for
the
cost of the awards, through a reduction of sales with no subsequent
reversal of that
sales reduction, as they are earned by customers. Please provide
us with
the illustrative
journal entries you use to record the initial accrual of the awards
and at
their
redemption. If you defer a portion of the revenue transactions earning
the awards
until the rewards are redeemed, please tell us where on your statements
of
operations
you classify the cost of free product distributed to customers at
the
redemption
date. Lastly, please quantify for us the loyalty program accrual
as of
each
balance sheet date presented in your filing and the amount of loyalty
program expenses
and/or sales reductions reflected on each statement of operations
presented.
|
Response
to Comment 6:
Our
customer loyalty program, Action Pass, allows members to earn points for each
purchase completed at our stores. Currently customers earn one point for every
dollar spent and receive a $10 certificate to be used for future purchases
upon
reaching 300 points. The current value of a point to a customer is approximately
3.3 cents. Once, the certificates are issued they expire after 90 days.
Customers with no activity for six months lose their points. We retain the
right
to modify or terminate the program at any time which could mean customers losing
all outstanding points.
The
liability for points is recorded as a reduction of sales at the time the points
are earned, based on the retail value of points that are projected to be
redeemed. Our accounting policy is to defer a portion of the revenue for
customer transactions earning the rewards until those rewards are redeemed.
The
projection is based on our history of certificate redemption and the expiration
of points. Based on eight quarters of data that we have tracked since we began
a
pilot program in January 2006, we see that most of the breakage comes from
certificates issued which have 90 day expiration dates. The expiration of points
after six months of inactivity represents a small amount of breakage; however,
this could change over time as the program matures. Approximately 40% of points
earned either expire or the certificates issued go unredeemed and thus sales
with a corresponding liability are recorded for approximately 2 cents per $100
of Action Pass member sales.
Illustrative
Journal Entries
The
following series of journal entries reflects an individual customer and the
assumption of a $400 sale, the issuance of a certificate based upon points
earned, a second assumed $100 sale in which the certificate issued is
redeemed.
A
$400
purchase would earn the customer 400 points with a value to the customer of
$13.33 (400 times 3.3 cents per point). In addition to the normal cost of sales
and inventory entries the following would be recorded:
|
Debit
cash
|
$
|
400.00
|
|||||
|
Credit
sales
|
$
|
386.67
|
($400.00-$13.33
|
)
|
|||
|
Credit
accrued expense
|
$
|
13.33
|
|||||
As
a
result of this transaction, the customer is issued a $10 certificate for having
reached 300 points
Carrying
the individual customer’s transaction further, we have assumed the customer
returns to the store and makes a $100 purchase, in which the $10 certificate
is
redeemed. In addition to the normal cost of sales and inventory entries the
following would be recorded:
To
record
sale and redeem certificate:
|
Debit
cash
|
$
|
90.00
|
||
|
Debit
accrued expense
|
$
|
10.00
|
||
|
Credit
sales
|
$
|
100.00
|
To
accrue
additional points on the $100 sale:
|
Debit
sales
|
$
|
3.33
|
($100.00
times 3.3 cents
|
)
|
|||
|
Credit
accrued expense
|
$
|
3.33
|
|||||
At
this
time for this customer we have 200 points remaining ($100 for the first sale
and
$100 from the subsequent sale) which is shown as $6.66 in accrued expense.
This
liability remains until
the
customer spends an additional $100 to reach the 300 point threshold required
for
the $10 certificate. The entries are summarized as follows:
|
Accrued
Expense
|
||||||||||||||||
|
Individual
Customer:
|
Cash
|
Point
$ Value
|
Certificates
|
Sales
|
Points
|
|||||||||||
|
$400
sale
|
$
|
400.00
|
$
|
(13.33
|
)
|
$
|
$
(386.67
|
)
|
400
|
|||||||
|
Mail
certificate
|
10.00
|
(10.00
|
)
|
(300
|
)
|
|||||||||||
|
$100
sale
|
90.00
|
10.00
|
(100.00
|
)
|
||||||||||||
|
Additional
points
|
-
|
(3.33
|
)
|
-
|
$
|
3.33
|
100
|
|||||||||
|
Totals
|
$
|
490.00
|
$
|
(6.66
|
)
|
$
|
-
|
$
|
(483.34
|
)
|
200
|
|||||
Based
on
our transaction history, some customers do not reach the $300 threshold to
obtain a certificate or after obtaining the certificate allow it to expire.
Additional entries are recorded for breakage as each point is accrued. The
breakage entries, although based on individual transactions like the one above,
are best understood in the aggregate. The following entries would be recorded
assuming there is $100,000 in aggregate member sales during the period, there
was a $120,000 accrued expense liability which consisted of $200,000 in point
value (approximately 6 million points) less $80,000 in estimated breakage from
the end of the prior period and of the $200,000, $50,000 (1.5 million points)
either expired from reaching six months of no activity or the certificates
issued expired. Also to keep it simple no members redeemed any certificates
in
the period.
To
record
sales:
|
Debit
cash
|
$
|
100,000
|
|||||
|
Credit
sales
|
$
|
96,670
|
($100,000.00-$3,333
|
)
|
|||
|
Credit
accrued expense
|
$
|
3,333
|
|||||
To
record
estimated breakage on sales:
|
Debit
accrued expense
|
$
|
1,332
|
($3,333*40
|
%)
|
|||
|
Credit
sales
|
$
|
1,332
|
|||||
To
record
the expiration of points or certificates:
|
Debit
accrued expense (point value)
|
$
|
50,000
|
||
|
Credit
accrued expense (breakage)
|
$
|
50,000
|
At
this
time for we have 4.4 million points remaining for an accrued expense liability
of $121,998 of which $153,330 is the value of the points less $31,332 in
estimated breakage. The entries are summarized as follows:
|
Aggregate
Transactions:
|
Cash
|
Point
$ Value or Certificates
|
Breakage
|
Sales
|
Points
|
|||||||||||
|
Beginning
balance
|
$
|
(200,000
|
)
|
$
|
80,000
|
6,000,000
|
||||||||||
|
$100,000
in sales
|
$
|
100,000
|
(3,330
|
)
|
$
|
(96,670
|
)
|
(96,670
|
)
|
|||||||
|
Estimated
breakage
|
1,332
|
(1,332
|
)
|
|||||||||||||
|
Expired
points/certificates
|
50,000
|
(50,000
|
)
|
(1,500,000
|
)
|
|||||||||||
|
Totals
|
$
|
100,000
|
$
|
(153,330
|
)
|
$
|
31,332
|
$
|
(98,002
|
)
|
4,403,330
|
|||||
The
liability for each balance sheet date was $192,034, $34,000 and zero for the
respective fiscal years ending in 2007, 2006 and 2005. The reduction of sales
was $1,100,329, $149,667 and zero for the respective fiscal years ending in
2007, 2006 and 2005.
Vendor
Allowances, page 44
| 7. |
With
respect to the volume rebates you receive from vendors, please tell
us and
disclose
whether you record the rebates as progress is made toward earning
them
or
whether they are only recognized upon achievement of milestones.
If you
record
the rebates as progress is made toward earning them, please confirm
that
significant
adjustments to expected cash rebates or refunds were unnecessary
in the
past.
Please see paragraphs 7-9 of EITF
02-16.
|
Response
to Comment 7:
The
Company’s rebates, other than for reimbursed advertising costs, have
historically been immaterial, generally less than $100,000 during any past
fiscal year, and these rebates are recognized as a reduction of cost of sales
when received. Should the amounts become material in the future we would
considered the guidance of EITF 02-16 and these rebates would be recognized
as a
reduction of cost of sales if we believe the rebate being offered by the vendor
is probable of being earned and we can reasonably estimate the amount of the
rebate. In future filings, we will revise our disclosure of Vendor Allowances
in
Note 2 to read:
Vendor
allowances include consideration received from vendors, such as volume rebates
and cooperative advertising funds. Vendor
rebates other than for cooperative advertising are immaterial and accounted
for
when received. The
majority of this consideration is based on contract terms. Amounts that
represent the reimbursement of costs incurred for advertising are recorded
as a
reduction of the related expense in the period incurred. Amounts expected to
be
received from vendors relating to the purchase of merchandise are recognized
as
a reduction of cost of goods sold as the merchandise is sold.
Advertising
Costs, page 44
| 8. |
We
believe that you should disclose the amounts of cooperative advertising
funds netted
against advertising expenses for each period presented to meet the
disclosure objectives
of paragraph 49.c. of SOP 93-7. Please do so in future
filings.
|
Response
to Comment 8:
We
have
reviewed the disclosure requirements of paragraph 49.c. of SOP 93-7 and in
future filings, we will revise our disclosure of Advertising Costs in Note
2 to
read:
Advertising
Costs
Advertising
costs are expensed as incurred. Advertising expense, net of vendor
reimbursement, amounted to $9,601,644, $8,166,267 and $7,923,512 for fiscal
years 2007, 2006 and 2005, respectively. The
amount of vendor reimbursements amounted to $5,081,169, $4,383,349 and
$4,048,998 for fiscal years 2007, 2006 and 2005,
respectively.
Earnings
Per Share, page 45
| 9. |
Page
29 of your proxy statement filed on September 1, 2005 indicates that
“the
holder of
each share of Class A Common Stock will be entitled to receive a
cash
dividend equal
to 110% of any regular cash dividend paid with respect to a share
of Class
B Common
Stock.” Since your two classes of common stock have different dividend
rates,
it appears that you should present your EPS measures using the two-class
method
described in EITF 03-6 and paragraphs 60 and 61 of SFAS 128. Please
either
revise
your filing to present both your basic and diluted EPS using the
two-class
method,
or otherwise tell us why you believe your current presentation complies
with GAAP.
Cite the applicable authoritative GAAP guidance in your response.
As
required
by paragraph 4 of SFAS 129, please also expand your disclosures to
describe the
pertinent rights and privileges of your Class A and B common
stock.
|
Response
to Comment 9:
In
response to your comment above, we have reviewed EITF 03-06 and paragraphs
60
and 61 of SFAS 128. In addition, we have read the 2006 speech at the AICPA
National Conference on Current SEC and PCAOB Developments given by Cathy Cole,
Associate Chief Accountant of the Office of the Chief Accountant. After
additional consideration and consultation, we came to believe that the
particular facts in this case justified a different answer from a strict
application of EITF Issue 03-6. We believe that the EITF consensus was generally
written in the context of classes of participating securities that do not
control the company and that applying the EITF guidance would not produce the
most transparent reporting. Below, the Company provides disclosures of the
factors it considered in determining that its methodology was appropriate.
Although
we have two classes of stock, in which Class A Stock has a preferential dividend
of 110% of the Class B Stock dividend, we believe the results of applying the
two class method is not meaningful to our presentation of earnings per share
and
creates confusion in our presentation of earnings per share. We have considered
the following in our assessment of the application of the two class
method:
|
·
|
Class
A shares represent 88% of our total common stock outstanding and
management, excluding the founder, holds only 1% of those shares.
Class B
shares represent 12% of our total common stock outstanding and management,
excluding the founder, hold 61% of those shares.
|
|
·
|
The
intent of the recapitalization transaction was to create value shares
(Class A) and controls shares (Class B) in order that holders of
the Class
B shares could control any matter presented to the
shareholders.
|
|
·
|
The
Class A and Class B shares effectively trade in the market at a similar
price which is driven by the Class A shares as they are the only
class
which has an active market in which they trade. Since our fiscal
year
following the recapitalization, to date, Class A shares trade at
3.4 times
the volume of Class B shares.
|
|
·
|
As
a result of the recapitalization transaction, the amounts of Class
B
shares that can be issued in the future are limited by Nasdaq Rule
4351
and the Company has no intention to issue additional Class B shares.
All
stock option grants since the recapitalization have been Class A
shares.
|
|
·
|
As
disclosed in our Form 10-K, the Company has never paid a cash dividend
and
has no plans to pay a cash dividend for the foreseeable future as
our
intent is to use earnings to fund store expansion for many years
to come.
Also in the event that the Company would be sold or merged with another
Company, the Class A and Class B shares would be treated the
same.
|
In
the
table below we have applied the two class method to our fiscal year end 2007
operating results.
| (Based on FY 2007, Average Diluted Shares and Dollars in 000's) | ||||||||||||||||||||||
|
#
Shares
|
%
to Total
|
Allocation
of Undistributed Earnings Based on Dividend Preference
|
Allocation
of Undistributed Earnings Based on Shares Only
|
Difference
in Allocation of Undistributed Earnings
|
EPS
Based on Dividend Preference
|
EPS
Based on Shares Only
|
||||||||||||||||
|
Class
A Common
|
12,546
|
88
|
%
|
$
|
6,286
|
$
|
6,214
|
$
|
72
|
$
|
0.50
|
$
|
0.50
|
|||||||||
|
Class
B Common
|
1,787
|
12
|
%
|
$
|
814
|
$
|
885
|
-$72
|
$
|
0.46
|
$
|
0.50
|
||||||||||
|
14,333
|
100
|
%
|
$
|
7,099
|
$
|
7,099
|
$
|
0
|
||||||||||||||
|
Class
B Common, excluding management
|
561
|
4
|
%
|
$
|
256
|
$
|
278
|
-$22
|
||||||||||||||
As
can be
seen in the calculation, if we allocate undistributed earnings based upon the
dividend preference proscribed in the two class method versus an allocation
based upon the number of shares, Class A shares receive an additional allocation
of $72,000 or approximately 1% of undistributed earnings. This additional
allocation to Class A shares would result in an earning per share number that
is
identical to the previously reported combined earnings per share calculation.
The reduction in the undistributed earnings to the Class B shares would reduce
reported earnings per share for this particular class to $0.46 or a 9% change
from the reported number. Given the limited trading of the Class B shares and
the significant amount of shares held by management and other insiders, we
do
not believe this reduction in earnings per share is material nor is it
meaningful to the individual investor. In fact, we believe this dual
presentation of earnings per share would be confusing and consequently less
transparent to the investor.
As
stated
in Cathy Cole’s speech, “The SEC staff believes that the EITF consensus was
generally written in the context of classes of participating securities that
do
not control the company…”
We
believe the application of the two class method to our Class B shares which
control of the Company would cause confusion to the investor as to why there
is
an additional allocation and create exhaustive explanations to investors each
time that earnings per share is presented. In our opinion, this is not
transparent to the reader nor is it material to our earnings per share
presentation.
In
the
future we will expand our disclosure of our common stock in the Notes to the
Consolidated Financial Statements, “Note 1. Description of Business and
Recapitalization Plan” as follows with changes underlined:
In
the
second quarter of fiscal 2006, the Company’s Board of Directors approved a
recapitalization plan designed to facilitate the orderly transition of control
from the Company’s founder (the “Founder”) to certain members of management and
to increase financial flexibility for the Company and its stockholders. The
recapitalization plan transferred a portion of the Founder’s ownership to Craig
Levra, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, and Howard Kaminsky, Executive
Vice
President - Finance, Chief Financial Officer and Secretary, and allowed current
stockholders to retain existing ownership and voting interests.
The
recapitalization established two classes of common stock and was effected
through a reclassification of each outstanding share of Common Stock into 0.25
share of Class B Common Stock. The reclassification was followed by a
non-taxable stock dividend of seven shares of Class A Common Stock for each
one
outstanding share of Class B Common Stock. Each share of Class B Common Stock
entitles the holder to one vote, and each share of Class A Common Stock entitles
the holder to 1/20th of one vote.
The
recapitalization doubled the total number of shares outstanding and, therefore,
had the same impact on earnings per share as a 2-for-1 stock split. However,
the
establishment of dual classes of common stock did not affect the relative voting
or equity interests of existing stockholders since the reclassification of
Common Stock and issuance of a stock dividend affected each stockholder in
proportion to the number of shares previously owned. The Class A Common Stock
and the Class B Common Stock will generally vote on all matters as a single
class. The holders of the Class A Common Stock and Class B Common Stock will
vote as a separate class on any reverse stock split which results in holders
of
more than 5% of such class being converted into fractional shares. The holders
of Class A Common Stock, voting as a separate class, are also entitled to elect
one director, and the affirmative vote of the holders of a majority of the
shares of Class A Common Stock, voting as a separate class, will be required
to
amend certain provisions of the Company's Certificate of Incorporation. The
recapitalization plan also included certain protection features for holders
of
Class A Common Stock in an effort to ensure parity in the trading of the two
classes of common stock
Each
share of Class A Common Stock and each share of Class B Common Stock
shall have identical rights with respect to dividends and distributions;
provided, however, that the holder of each share of Class A Common Stock shall
be entitled to receive a regular cash dividend equal to 110% of any regular
cash
dividend paid with respect to a share of Class B Common Stock; and provided,
further, that dividends or other distributions payable on the Common Stock
in
shares of Common Stock shall be made to all holders of Common Stock and may
be
made only as follows: (i) in shares of Class A Common Stock to the
record holders of Class A Common Stock and to the record holders of
Class B Common Stock, (ii) in shares of Class A Common Stock to
the record holders of Class A Common Stock and in shares of Class B
Common Stock to the record holders of Class B Common Stock solely in
connection with a proportionate dividend to effectuate a split of the Common
Stock, or (iii) in any other authorized class or series of capital
stock to the holders of both classes of Common Stock.
In
addition we will expand our disclosure of the earnings per share calculation
in
the Notes to the Consolidated Financial Statements, “Note 2. Summary of
Significant Accounting Policies, Earnings Per Share” as shown below with changes
underlined:
Earnings
per share has been computed in accordance with Statement of Financial Accounting
Standard No. 128, “Earnings Per Share” (“EPS”). Basic EPS equals net income
divided by the number of weighted average common shares. Diluted EPS includes
potentially dilutive securities such as stock options and convertible
securities. The
Company does not utilize the two-class method to report its earnings per share.
The two-class method is an earnings allocation formula that determines earnings
per share for each class of common stock according to participation rights
in
undistributed earnings. Our recapitalization plan provided that Class A Common
Stock shall be entitled to receive a regular cash dividend equal to 110% of
any
regular cash dividend paid with respect to a share of Class B Common Stock,
which could result in the two-class method of computing earnings per share.
However the application of this method would result in an immaterial change
in
earnings per share and is therefore not presented.
Form
10-Q for the Fiscal Quarter Ended December 30, 2007
Note
4. Impairment of Long-lived Assets, page 8
10.
We
note that you recorded a $2.1 million impairment charge during the quarterly
period ended December 30, 2007 related to certain underperforming California
stores and have the following comments:
|
·
|
Please
provide us with further information about the circumstances that
led to
this impairment and the timing of this charge, including how long
these
stores have been open and why an impairment charge was not necessary
in
prior periods.
|
|
·
|
Please
tell us how you determined that no other stores were
impaired.
|
|
·
|
Please
expand your Critical Accounting Policy concerning impairment of long-lived
assets to provide more detail consistent with the guidance in Section
V of
SEC Release No. 33-8350, including quantifying the impact of reasonably
likely changes in your impairment testing assumptions. Please show
us what
this expanded disclosure will look
like.
|
Response
to Comment 10:
On
a
quarterly basis, we perform an analysis of impairment for all of our stores
based upon a review of each store’s contribution to profit. For stores that do
not provide a contribution to profit, we assess the store’s performance without
consideration of depreciation and advertising which is only considered at the
incremental level. Incremental advertising is based on an assumption that the
Company will continue to advertise in a given market (if there is more than
one
store within that market) at the same level regardless as to whether one store
is removed from that market; therefore, for impairment purposes only the store
specific advertising is considered in the analysis, such as local newspaper
and
Action Pass emails. Also similar to advertising, corporate overhead was removed
as we cannot distinguish any component of overhead to a specific store.
Generally we exclude new stores from the analysis; however, in certain
circumstances, we may continue to assess the impairment of a new store if the
actual store sales are significantly below budget and the lack of sales volume
appears to be more than temporary due to overall economic conditions.
Cash
flow
is projected over the remaining term of the lease. There are many assumptions
that drive a long-term forecast of each store; however, sales is the primary
factor and each individual store’s facts and circumstances were used as well as
references to similar stores’ history to determine sales growth over time. We
assess the sensitivity of sales to the entire calculation. For instance, a
store
would not be impaired with achievable sales increases if we had reason to
believe the increases were reasonable; however, if uncharacteristically large
increases in sales would result in a store not being impaired, we utilized
a
more reasonable sales number. Since sales can fluctuate significantly over
time
and have an impact on most other line items of the operating statement, these
types of expense were either held constant in dollars or were based on sales
for
projection purposes, utilizing historical information from similar stores.
Inflation was not considered.
During
the quarter ended December 30, 2007, we reviewed all stores that did not have
a
contribution to profit for fiscal 2007, most of which were budgeted to be
profitable during the fiscal year 2008, for changes in circumstances that might
indicate impairment. Upon completion of our undiscounted cash flow analysis,
it
was determined that two stores were impaired. Both stores were opened in the
third quarter of fiscal 2007. As these stores now had a prior year sales figure
to compare and we had been open for the second Holiday season, we could
determine there was no sales growth from their first year numbers, something
that is unusual for new stores. We believe the circumstances that led to the
impairment were the result of the deteriorating economic conditions in the
state
of California and the Company’s inability to meet its forecasted sales in these
locations. This quarter was the first quarter we could determine the lack of
growth in sales. Based upon our analysis and the procedures that we perform
on a
quarterly basis, we believe these are the only two locations that are
impaired.
In
future
filings, we will expand our disclosures in accordance with SEC Release No.
33-8350 to read as shown in “Response to Comment 3” above.
We
appreciate the Staff’s comments and find them very helpful in enhancing our
disclosures. We understand that the Company is responsible for the adequacy
and
accuracy of the disclosure in the Company’s filings; that the Staff’s comments
or changes to discourse in response to the Staff comments do not foreclose
the
Commission from taking any action with respond to the filings; and that the
Company may not assert Staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated
by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United
States.
Please
note that a copy of this response letter has been filed on EDGAR. If you have
any additional comments after reviewing my responses, please contact me at
(818)
949-5386.
Sincerely,
\s\
Howard Kaminsky
Howard
Kaminsky,
Executive
Vice President,
Chief
Financial Officer and Secretary