s6y FEDERAL HOME LOAN MORTGAGE CORP 10-K

FEDERAL HOME LOAN MORTGAGE CORP 10-K, filed Feb 13, 2020: IDEA: XBRL DOCUMENT

Mortgage Loans and Loan Loss Reserves
12 Months Ended
Dec. 31, 2019
SEC Schedule, 12-29, Real Estate Companies, Investment in Mortgage Loans on Real Estate [Abstract]  
MORTGAGE LOANS AND LOAN LOSS RESERVES
Mortgage Loans and Allowance for Credit Losses
The table below provides details of the loans on our consolidated balance sheets as of December 31, 2019 and December 31, 2018.
Table 4.1 - Mortgage Loans
 
 
December 31, 2019
 
December 31, 2018
(In millions)
 
Held by Freddie Mac
Held by
consolidated
trusts
Total
 
Held by Freddie Mac
Held by
consolidated
trusts
Total
Held-for-sale:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Single-family
 

$18,543


$—


$18,543

 

$20,946


$—


$20,946

Multifamily
 
18,954

—

18,954

 
23,959

—

23,959

Total UPB
 
37,497

—

37,497

 
44,905

—

44,905

Cost basis and fair value adjustments, net
 
(2,209
)
—

(2,209
)
 
(3,283
)
—

(3,283
)
   Total held-for-sale loans, net
 
35,288

—

35,288

 
41,622

—

41,622

Held-for-investment:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Single-family
 
35,324

1,902,958

1,938,282

 
35,885

1,814,008

1,849,893

Multifamily
 
10,831

6,642

17,473

 
10,828

4,220

15,048

Total UPB
 
46,155

1,909,600

1,955,755

 
46,713

1,818,228

1,864,941

Cost basis adjustments
 
(183
)
33,574

33,391

 
(1,198
)
27,752

26,554

Allowance for loan losses
 
(1,583
)
(2,651
)
(4,234
)
 
(3,009
)
(3,130
)
(6,139
)
   Total held-for-investment loans, net
 
44,389

1,940,523

1,984,912

 
42,506

1,842,850

1,885,356

Total loans, net
 

$79,677


$1,940,523


$2,020,200

 

$84,128


$1,842,850


$1,926,978


We apply fair value hedge accounting to certain single-family mortgage loans. The fair value hedge accounting related loan basis adjustments are included in the table above.
We own both single-family loans, which are secured by one to four unit residential properties, and multifamily loans, which are secured by properties with five or more residential rental units. Our single-family loans are predominantly first lien, fixed-rate loans secured by the borrower's primary residence.
Upon acquisition, we classify a loan as either held-for-investment or held-for-sale. Loans that we have the ability and intent to hold for the foreseeable future are classified as held-for-investment. Loans that we intend to securitize using an entity we will consolidate are classified as held-for-investment both prior to and subsequent to their securitization. Otherwise, they will be classified as held-for-sale. Held-for-investment loans are reported on our consolidated balance sheets at their outstanding UPB, net of deferred fees and other cost basis adjustments (including unamortized premiums and discounts, upfront fees, commitment-related derivative basis adjustments, and other pricing adjustments).
Loans not classified as held-for-investment are classified as held-for-sale. Held-for-sale loans are reported at lower-of-cost-or-fair-value on our consolidated balance sheets, unless the fair value option is elected. Any excess of a held-for-sale loan's cost over its fair value is recognized as a valuation allowance in investment gains (losses), net on our consolidated statements of comprehensive income, with changes in this valuation allowance also being recorded in investment gains (losses), net. Premiums, discounts, and other cost basis adjustments (including lower-of-cost-or-fair-value adjustments) on single-family loans classified as held-for-sale are deferred and not amortized. We elected the fair value option for certain multifamily loans that we intend to securitize and sell to investors. Therefore, these multifamily loans are measured at fair value on a recurring basis, with subsequent gains or losses related to changes in fair value reported in investment gains (losses), net on our consolidated statements of comprehensive income.
Cash flows related to loans originally classified as held-for-investment are classified as either investing activities (e.g., principal repayments) or operating activities (e.g., interest payments received from borrowers included within net income (loss)). Cash flows related to loans originally classified as held-for-sale are classified as operating activities.
The table below provides details of the UPB of loans we purchased, reclassified from held-for-investment to held-for-sale, and sold.

Table 4.2 - Loans Purchased, Reclassified from Held-for-Investment to Held-for-Sale, and Sold
(In billions)
 
2019
2018
2017
Single-family:
 
 
 
 
Purchases
 
 
 
 
  Held-for-investment loans
 

$451.2


$307.7


$343.0

Reclassified from held-for-investment to held-for-sale (1)
 
13.6

21.7

26.2

Sale of held-for-sale loans(2)
 
13.1

10.2

8.7

Multifamily:
 
 
 
 
Purchases
 
 
 
 
  Held-for-investment loans
 
9.5

5.0

5.3

  Held-for-sale loans
 
65.3

70.3

64.6

Reclassified from held-for-investment to held-for-sale (1)
 
1.9

1.8

1.6

Sale of held-for-sale loans(3)
 
71.3

68.1

61.9

(1)
We reclassify loans from held-for-investment to held-for-sale when we no longer have the intent or ability to hold for the foreseeable future. For additional information regarding the fair value of our loans classified as held-for-sale, see Note 15.
(2)
Our sales of single-family loans reflect the sale of seasoned single-family loans. The sale of seasoned single-family mortgage loans is part of our strategy to mitigate and reduce our holdings of less liquid assets.
(3)
Our sales of multifamily loans occur primarily through the issuance of multifamily K Certificates and SB Certificates. See Note 3 for more information on our K Certificates and SB Certificates.
Interest Income
We recognize interest income on an accrual basis except when we believe the collection of principal and interest in full is not reasonably assured, which generally occurs when a loan is three monthly payments or more past due, unless the loan is well secured and in the process of collection based upon an individual loan assessment. A loan is considered past due if a full payment of principal and interest is not received within one month of its due date.
Cost basis adjustments on held-for-investment loans are amortized into interest income over the contractual lives of the loans using the effective interest method.
A non-accrual loan may be returned to accrual status when the collectability of principal and interest in full is reasonably assured. For single-family loans, we determine that collectability is reasonably assured generally when the loan has become current. For multifamily loans, the collectability of principal and interest is considered reasonably assured based on an analysis of the factors specific to the loan being assessed. Upon a loan's return to accrual status, all previously reversed interest income is recognized and amortization of any basis adjustments into interest income is resumed.
Credit Quality
Single-Family
The current LTV ratio is one key factor we consider when estimating our allowance for credit losses for single-family loans. As current LTV ratios increase, the borrower's equity in the home decreases, which may negatively affect the borrower's ability to refinance (outside of the Enhanced Relief Refinance program) or to sell the property for an amount at or above the balance of the outstanding loan.
A second-lien loan also reduces the borrower's equity in the home, and has a similar negative effect on the borrower's ability to refinance or sell the property for an amount at or above the combined balances of the first and second loans. However, borrowers are free to obtain second-lien financing after origination, and we are not entitled to receive notification when a borrower does so. For further information about concentrations of risk associated with our single-family and multifamily loans, see Note 14.
The table below presents the recorded investment of single-family held-for-investment loans by current LTV ratios. Our current LTV ratios are estimates based on available data through the end of each respective period presented.



Table 4.3 - Recorded Investment of Single-Family Held-for-Investment Loans by Current LTV Ratios
 
 
As of December 31, 2019
 
As of December 31, 2018
 
 
Current LTV Ratio
Total
 
Current LTV Ratio
Total
(In millions)
 
 ≤ 80
> 80 to 100
> 100(1)
 
≤ 80
> 80 to 100
> 100(1)
20- and 30-year or more, amortizing fixed-rate
 

$1,405,562


$267,752


$3,954


$1,677,268

 

$1,336,310


$214,703


$6,654


$1,557,667

15-year amortizing fixed-rate
 
236,837

6,797

89

243,723

 
251,152

4,522

157

255,831

Adjustable-rate
 
35,478

1,425

6

36,909

 
42,117

1,883

7

44,007

Alt-A, interest-only, and option ARM
 
12,668

901

188

13,757

 
16,498

1,903

559

18,960

Total single-family loans
 

$1,690,545


$276,875


$4,237


$1,971,657

 

$1,646,077


$223,011


$7,377


$1,876,465

 
(1)
The serious delinquency rate for the total of single-family held-for-investment mortgage loans with current LTV ratios in excess of 100% was 4.51% and 7.24% as of December 31, 2019 and December 31, 2018, respectively.
For reporting purposes:
n
Loans within the Alt-A category continue to be presented in that category following modification, even though the borrower may have provided full documentation of assets and income to complete the modification and
n
Loans within the option ARM category continue to be presented in that category following modification, even though the modified loan no longer provides for optional payment provisions.
Multifamily
The table below presents the recorded investment in our multifamily held-for-investment loans, by credit quality indicator based on available data through the end of each period presented. These indicators involve significant management judgment.
Table 4.4 - Recorded Investment of Multifamily Held-for-Investment Loans by Credit Quality Indicator
(In millions)
 
As of December 31, 2019
As of December 31, 2018
Credit risk profile by internally assigned grade:(1)
 
 
 
Pass
 

$17,227


$14,648

Special mention
 
141

201

Substandard
 
121

181

Doubtful
 
—

—

Total
 

$17,489


$15,030

(1)
A loan categorized as: "Pass" is current and adequately protected by the current financial strength and debt service capacity of the borrower; "Special mention" has administrative issues that may affect future repayment prospects but does not have current credit weaknesses; "Substandard" has a weakness that jeopardizes the timely full repayment; and "Doubtful" has a weakness that makes collection or liquidation in full highly questionable and improbable based on existing conditions.
Mortgage Loan Performance
The following tables present the recorded investment of our single-family and multifamily loans, held-for-investment, by payment status.
Table 4.5 - Recorded Investment of Held-for-Investment Loans by Payment Status
 
 
As of December 31, 2019
(In millions)
 
Current
One
Month
Past Due
Two
Months
Past Due
Three Months or
More Past Due,
or in Foreclosure(1)
Total
Non-accrual
Single-family:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
20- and 30-year or more, amortizing fixed-rate
 

$1,653,113


$15,481


$3,326


$5,348


$1,677,268


$5,822

15-year amortizing fixed-rate
 
242,177

1,131

175

240

243,723

252

Adjustable-rate
 
36,537

238

45

89

36,909

104

Alt-A, interest-only, and option ARM
 
12,690

489

161

417

13,757

205

   Total single-family
 
1,944,517

17,339

3,707

6,094

1,971,657

6,383

   Total multifamily
 
17,489

—

—

—

17,489

13

Total single-family and multifamily
 

$1,962,006


$17,339


$3,707


$6,094


$1,989,146


$6,396

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
As of December 31, 2018
(In millions)
 
Current
One
Month
Past Due
Two
Months
Past Due
Three Months or
More Past Due,
or in Foreclosure
(1)
Total
Non-accrual
Single-family:
 






20- and 30-year or more, amortizing fixed-rate
 

$1,532,499


$14,683


$3,602


$6,883


$1,557,667


$6,881

15-year amortizing fixed-rate
 
254,376

1,021

171

263

255,831

263

Adjustable-rate
 
43,549

287

58

113

44,007

113

Alt-A, interest-only, and option ARM
 
16,975

793

327

865

18,960

864

   Total single-family
 
1,847,399

16,784

4,158

8,124

1,876,465

8,121

   Total multifamily
 
15,030

—

—

—

15,030

17

Total single-family and multifamily
 

$1,862,429


$16,784


$4,158


$8,124


$1,891,495


$8,138

(1)
Includes $1.8 billion and $2.9 billion of loans that were in the process of foreclosure as of December 31, 2019 and December 31, 2018, respectively.
We have the option to purchase specified loans, including certain delinquent loans, from consolidated trusts at a purchase price equal to the current UPB of the loan, less any outstanding advances of principal that have been previously distributed. However, in order to maintain alignment with Fannie Mae under the Single Security Initiative, FHFA requires us to purchase loans out of consolidated trusts if they are delinquent for 120 days, and we have the option to purchase sooner under certain circumstances (e.g. imminent default and seller breaches of representations and warranties). Our practice generally has been to purchase loans from consolidated trusts when the loans have been delinquent for 120 days or more.
When we purchase loans from consolidated trusts, we record an extinguishment of the corresponding portion of the debt securities of the consolidated trusts and we reclassify the loans from mortgage loans held-for-investment by consolidated trusts to mortgage loans held-for-investment by Freddie Mac. We purchased $5.6 billion and $7.8 billion in UPB of loans from consolidated trusts (or purchased delinquent loans associated with other mortgage-related guarantees) during the years ended December 31, 2019 and December 31, 2018, respectively.
The table below summarizes the delinquency rates of loans within our single-family credit guarantee and multifamily mortgage portfolios.
Table 4.6 - Delinquency Rates
(Dollars in millions)
 
December 31, 2019
December 31, 2018
Single-family:
 
 
 
Non-credit-enhanced portfolio:
 
 
 
Serious delinquency rate
 
0.70
%
0.83
%
Total number of seriously delinquent loans
 
42,485

51,197

Credit-enhanced portfolio:(1)
 
 
 
Primary mortgage insurance:
 
 
 
   Serious delinquency rate
 
0.79
%
0.86
%
   Total number of seriously delinquent loans
 
15,261

15,287

Other credit protection:(2)
 
 
 
   Serious delinquency rate
 
0.40
%
0.31
%
   Total number of seriously delinquent loans
 
18,143

12,920

Total single-family
 
 
 
Serious delinquency rate
 
0.63
%
0.69
%
Total number of seriously delinquent loans
 
70,162

75,649

Multifamily (3)
 
 
 
Non-credit-enhanced portfolio:
 
 
 
Delinquency rate
 
—
%
—
%
UPB of delinquent loans
 

$2


$2

Credit-enhanced portfolio:
 
 
 
Delinquency rate
 
0.09
%
0.01
%
UPB of delinquent loans
 

$244


$28

Total multifamily
 
 
 
Delinquency rate
 
0.08
%
0.01
%
UPB of delinquent loans
 

$246


$30

(1)
The credit-enhanced categories are not mutually exclusive, as a single loan may be covered by both primary mortgage insurance and other credit protection.
(2)
Consists of single-family loans covered by financial arrangements (other than primary mortgage insurance) that are designed to reduce our credit risk exposure. See Note 6 for additional information on our credit enhancements.
(3)
Multifamily delinquency performance is based on the UPB of loans that are two monthly payments or more past due or those in the process of foreclosure.
We continue to implement a number of initiatives to refinance and modify single-family loans. As part of these initiatives, we pay various incentives to servicers and borrowers. HAMP ended in December 2016 and HARP ended in December 2018. The relief refinance program has been replaced with the Enhanced Relief Refinance program, which became available in January 2019 for loans originated on or after October 1, 2017. This program provides liquidity for borrowers who are current on their mortgages but are unable to refinance because their LTV ratios exceed our standard refinance limits.
Allowance for Credit Losses
The allowance for credit losses represents estimates of probable incurred credit losses which we recognize by recording a charge to the provision for credit losses on our consolidated statements of comprehensive income. The allowance for credit losses includes:
n
Our allowance for loan losses, which pertains to all single-family and multifamily loans classified as held-for-investment on our consolidated balance sheets and
n
Our reserve for guarantee losses, which pertains to our guarantees to unconsolidated securitization trusts and other mortgage-related guarantees.
A significant number of unsecuritized single-family loans on our consolidated balance sheets include seriously delinquent and TDR loans that we previously purchased from consolidated trusts. These seriously delinquent and TDR loans historically have a higher associated allowance for loan losses than loans that remain in consolidated trusts.
The table below summarizes changes in our allowance for credit losses.
Table 4.7 - Details of Allowance for Credit Losses

 
Year Ended December 31,
 
 
2019

2018
 
2017
 
 
Allowance for Loan Losses
 Reserve  for
Guarantee
Losses
Total

Allowance for Loan Losses
 Reserve  for
Guarantee
Losses
Total
 
Allowance for Loan Losses
 Reserve  for
Guarantee
Losses
Total
 (In millions)
 
Held by Freddie Mac
Held By
Consolidated
Trusts

Held by Freddie Mac
Held By
Consolidated
Trusts
 
Held by Freddie Mac
Held By
Consolidated
Trusts
Single-family:
 









 
 
 
 
 
Beginning
balance
 

$3,003


$3,127


$46


$6,176



$5,251


$3,680


$48


$8,979

 

$10,443


$2,968


$52


$13,463

Provision (benefit) for credit losses
 
(684
)
(70
)
5

(749
)

(861
)
145

4

(712
)
 
(1,447
)
1,350

—

(97
)
Charge-offs
 
(1,676
)
(56
)
(5
)
(1,737
)

(2,823
)
(56
)
(6
)
(2,885
)
 
(4,939
)
(108
)
(4
)
(5,051
)
Recoveries
 
439

13

—

452


467

8

—

475

 
419

6

—

425

Transfers,
net
(1)
 
372

(372
)
—

—


676

(676
)
—

—

 
540

(540
)
—

—

Other (2)
 
122

4

—

126

 
293

26

—

319

 
235

4

—

239

Ending
balance
 

$1,576


$2,646


$46


$4,268



$3,003


$3,127


$46


$6,176

 

$5,251


$3,680


$48


$8,979

Multifamily:
 









 
 
 
 
 
Beginning
balance
 

$6


$3


$6


$15



$28


$7


$9


$44

 

$18


$2


$15


$35

Provision (benefit) for credit losses
 
2

1

—

3


(23
)
—

(1
)
(24
)
 
15

4

(6
)
13

Charge-offs
 
—

—

—

—


(6
)
—

(2
)
(8
)
 
(4
)
—

—

(4
)
Recoveries
 
—

—

—

—


3

—

—

3

 
—

—

—

—

Transfers,
net
(1)
 
(1
)
1

—

—


4

(4
)
—

—

 
(1
)
1

—

—

Other (2)
 
—

—

—

—

 
—

—

—

—

 
—

—

—

—

Ending
balance
 

$7


$5


$6


$18



$6


$3


$6


$15

 

$28


$7


$9


$44

Total:
 









 
 
 
 
 
Beginning
balance
 

$3,009


$3,130


$52


$6,191



$5,279


$3,687


$57


$9,023

 

$10,461


$2,970


$67


$13,498

Provision (benefit) for credit losses
 
(682
)
(69
)
5

(746
)

(884
)
145

3

(736
)
 
(1,432
)
1,354

(6
)
(84
)
Charge-offs
 
(1,676
)
(56
)
(5
)
(1,737
)

(2,829
)
(56
)
(8
)
(2,893
)
 
(4,943
)
(108
)
(4
)
(5,055
)
Recoveries
 
439

13

—

452


470

8

—

478

 
419

6

—

425

Transfers,
net
(1)
 
371

(371
)
—

—


680

(680
)
—

—

 
539

(539
)
—

—

Other (2)
 
122

4

—

126

 
293

26

—

319

 
235

4

—

239

Ending
balance
 

$1,583


$2,651


$52


$4,286



$3,009


$3,130


$52


$6,191

 

$5,279


$3,687


$57


$9,023

(1)
Relates to removal of delinquent loans from consolidated trusts and resecuritization after such removal. 
(2)
Primarily includes capitalization of past due interest on modified loans.
A significant number of unsecuritized single-family loans on our consolidated balance sheets are individually evaluated for impairment while substantially all single-family loans held by our consolidated trusts are collectively evaluated for impairment. The ending balance of the allowance for loan losses associated with our held-for-investment unsecuritized loans represented approximately 3.4%, 6.6%, and 7.8%of the recorded investment in such loans at December 31, 2019, December 31, 2018, and December 31, 2017, respectively, and a substantial portion of the allowance associated with these loans represented interest rate concessions provided to borrowers as part of loan modifications. The ending balance of the allowance for loan losses associated with loans held by our consolidated trusts represented approximately 0.1%, 0.2%, and 0.2% of the recorded investment in such loans as of December 31, 2019, December 31, 2018, and December 31, 2017, respectively.
The table below presents our allowance for loan losses and our recorded investment in loans, held-for-investment, by impairment evaluation methodology.
Table 4.8 - Net Investment in Loans
 
 
December 31, 2019
 
December 31, 2018
(In millions)
 
Single-family
Multifamily
Total
 
Single-family
Multifamily
Total
Recorded investment:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Collectively evaluated
 

$1,936,208


$17,408


$1,953,616

 

$1,830,044


$14,945


$1,844,989

Individually evaluated
 
35,449

81

35,530

 
46,421

85

46,506

Total recorded investment
 
1,971,657

17,489

1,989,146

 
1,876,465

15,030

1,891,495

Ending balance of the allowance for loan losses:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Collectively evaluated
 
(1,350
)
(12
)
(1,362
)
 
(1,761
)
(9
)
(1,770
)
Individually evaluated
 
(2,872
)
—

(2,872
)
 
(4,369
)
—

(4,369
)
Total ending balance of the allowance
 
(4,222
)
(12
)
(4,234
)
 
(6,130
)
(9
)
(6,139
)
Net investment in loans
 

$1,967,435


$17,477


$1,984,912

 

$1,870,335


$15,021


$1,885,356


Allowance for Loan Losses Determined on a Collective Basis
Single-Family Loans
We estimate allowance for loan losses on homogeneous pools of single-family loans using a model that evaluates a variety of factors affecting collectability. We review the outputs of this model by considering qualitative factors such as macroeconomic and other factors to see whether the model outputs are consistent with our expectations. Management adjustments may be necessary to take into consideration external factors and current economic events that have occurred but that are not yet reflected in the factors used to derive the model outputs. Significant judgment is exercised in making these adjustments. The homogeneous pools of single-family loans are determined based on common underlying characteristics, including current LTV ratios, trends in home prices, loan product type, and geographic region.
We rely upon third-parties to service our loans. At loan delivery, the seller provides us with loan data, which includes characteristics and underwriting information. Each subsequent month, the servicers provide us with monthly loan level servicing data, including delinquency and loss information.
Our single-family allowance for loan losses default models produce estimates based on 12 months of loan level performance data, which includes a history of delinquency, foreclosures, foreclosure alternatives, and modifications. Our allowance for loan losses estimate includes projections of:
n
Loss mitigation activities when a loss is incurred, including loan modifications for troubled borrowers and the incidence of redefault we have experienced on similar loans that have completed a loan modification and
n
Defaults we believe are likely to occur as a result of loss events that have occurred through the respective balance sheet date.
These projections are based on our recent historical experience and current business practices and require significant management judgment. We validate and update our models and factors to capture changes in actual loss experience, as well as the effects of changes in underwriting practices and in our loss mitigation strategies. In determining our allowance for loan losses, we also consider macroeconomic and other factors that affect the quality of the loans underlying our portfolio, including regional housing trends, applicable home price indices, unemployment and employment dislocation trends, the effects of changes in government policies and programs, consumer credit statistics, and the extent of third-party insurance.
Our single-family allowance for loan losses severity is based on actual REO dispositions, short sales, and third-party sales that incorporate the most recent:
n
Twelve months of sales experience realized on our distressed property dispositions and
n
Twelve months of pre-foreclosure expenses on our distressed properties, including REO, short sales, and third-party sales.
Our single-family allowance for loan losses severity estimate also captures expectations about recoveries from the collateral and attached credit enhancements, such as primary mortgage insurance. We use historical trends in home prices in our single-family allowance for loan losses process, primarily through the use of current LTV ratios in our default models and through the use of recent home price sales experience in our severity estimate. However, we do not use a forecast of trends in home prices in our single-family allowance for loan losses process.
For loans where foreclosure is probable, we measure impairment based upon an estimate of the fair value of the underlying collateral less estimated disposition costs. Our estimate also considers the effect of historical home price changes on borrower behavior.
We apply proceeds from attached credit enhancements (e.g., primary mortgage insurance) entered into contemporaneously with, and in contemplation of, a guarantee or loan purchase transaction as a recovery of our recorded investment in a charged-off loan, up to the amount of loss recognized as a charge-off. Proceeds received in excess of our recorded investment in loans are recorded as a decrease to REO operations expense on our consolidated statements of comprehensive income. We record benefits related to freestanding credit enhancements based on actual losses (e.g., ACIS insurance policies) when realization of our claims is deemed probable and a loss has been recognized on the covered loans. We record benefits for our debt with embedded credit enhancements for which we have not elected the fair value option (e.g., certain STACR debt notes and certain senior subordinate securitization structures) when the realized loss event occurs. We generally record repurchase recoveries on a cash basis due to the uncertainty of the timing and amount of collections of such recoveries. See Note 6 for additional information on credit enhancements.
Multifamily Loans
Multifamily loans evaluated collectively for impairment are aggregated into book year vintage portfolios. Potential impairment related to these portfolios is measured by benchmarking published historical commercial loan performance data to those vintages based upon available economic data related to multifamily real estate, including apartment vacancy and rental rates.
Allowance for Loan Losses Determined on an Individual Basis
We consider a loan to be impaired when, based on current information, it is probable that we will not receive all amounts due (including both principal and interest) in accordance with the contractual terms of the original loan agreement.
Single-family loans individually evaluated for impairment include TDRs, as well as loans acquired under our financial guarantees with deteriorated credit quality prior to 2010. Multifamily loans individually evaluated for impairment include TDRs, loans three monthly payments or more past due, and loans that are impaired based on management judgment.
Impaired Loans
The tables below present the UPB, recorded investment, the related allowance for loan losses, average recorded investment, and interest income recognized for individually impaired loans.
Table 4.9 - Individually Impaired Loans
 
 
Balance at December 31, 2019
 
Balance at December 31, 2018
(In millions)
 
UPB
Recorded
Investment
Associated
Allowance
 
UPB
Recorded
Investment
Associated
Allowance
Single-family:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
With no allowance recorded: (1)
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
20- and 30-year or more, amortizing fixed-rate
 

$2,431


$1,927

N/A

 

$3,335


$2,666

N/A

15-year amortizing fixed-rate
 
21

20

N/A

 
23

22

N/A

Adjustable-rate
 
169

169

N/A

 
227

226

N/A

Alt-A, interest-only, and option ARM
 
847

727

N/A

 
1,286

1,083

N/A

   Total with no allowance recorded
 
3,468

2,843

N/A

 
4,871

3,997

N/A

With an allowance recorded: (2)
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
20- and 30-year or more, amortizing fixed-rate
 
28,824

28,667

(2,416
)
 
37,579

36,959

(3,660
)
15-year amortizing fixed-rate
 
616

625

(13
)
 
703

713

(19
)
Adjustable-rate
 
131

130

(7
)
 
164

162

(8
)
Alt-A, interest-only, and option ARM
 
3,315

3,184

(436
)
 
4,867

4,590

(682
)
   Total with an allowance recorded
 
32,886

32,606

(2,872
)
 
43,313

42,424

(4,369
)
Combined single-family:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
20- and 30-year or more, amortizing fixed-rate
 
31,255

30,594

(2,416
)
 
40,914

39,625

(3,660
)
15-year amortizing fixed-rate
 
637

645

(13
)
 
726

735

(19
)
Adjustable-rate
 
300

299

(7
)
 
391

388

(8
)
Alt-A, interest-only, and option ARM
 
4,162

3,911

(436
)
 
6,153

5,673

(682
)
   Total single-family
 
36,354

35,449

(2,872
)
 
48,184

46,421

(4,369
)
Multifamily :
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
With no allowance recorded (1)
 
86

81

N/A

 
89

82

N/A

With an allowance recorded
 
—

—

—

 
3

3

—

   Total multifamily
 
86

81

—

 
92

85

—

Total single-family and multifamily
 

$36,440


$35,530


($2,872
)
 

$48,276


$46,506


($4,369
)
Referenced footnotes are included after the next table.
 
 
Year Ended December 31,
 
 
2019
 
2018
 
2017
(In millions)
 
Average Recorded Investment
Interest Income Recognized
Interest Income Recognized on Cash Basis(3)
 
Average
Recorded
Investment
Interest
Income
Recognized
Interest Income Recognized on Cash Basis(3)
 
Average
Recorded
Investment
Interest
Income
Recognized
Interest Income Recognized on Cash Basis(3)
Single-family:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
With no allowance
recorded: (1)
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
20- and 30-year or more, amortizing
fixed-rate
 

$2,450


$262


$7

 

$3,236


$346


$16

 

$3,556


$399


$16

15-year amortizing
 fixed-rate
 
20

1

—

 
21

3

—

 
25

1

—

Adjustable rate
 
200

11

—

 
248

12

1

 
292

11

—

Alt-A, interest-only, and option ARM
 
891

66

1

 
1,264

88

4

 
1,471

110

5

   Total with no allowance
   recorded
 
3,561

340

8

 
4,769

449

21

 
5,344

521

21

With an allowance
recorded: (2)
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
20- and 30-year or more, amortizing
fixed-rate
 
32,960

1,805

156

 
44,055

2,156

274

 
44,057

2,513

248

15-year amortizing
fixed-rate
 
653

22

4

 
798

28

9

 
599

32

6

Adjustable rate
 
135

6

2

 
197

6

3

 
261

9

3

Alt-A, interest-only, and option ARM
 
3,917

226

20

 
5,953

273

30

 
7,366

378

33

   Total with an allowance
   recorded
 
37,665

2,059

182

 
51,003

2,463

316

 
52,283

2,932

290

Combined single-family:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
20- and 30-year or more, amortizing
fixed-rate
 
35,410

2,067

163

 
47,291

2,502

290

 
47,613

2,912

264

15-year amortizing fixed-rate
 
673

23

4

 
819

31

9

 
624

33

6

Adjustable rate
 
335

17

2

 
445

18

4

 
553

20

3

Alt-A, interest-only, and option ARM
 
4,808

292

21

 
7,217

361

34

 
8,837

488

38

   Total single-family
 
41,226

2,399

190

 
55,772

2,912

337

 
57,627

3,453

311

Multifamily:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
With no allowance
recorded (1)
 
83

5

1

 
131

6

2

 
286

9

3

With an allowance
recorded
 
—

—

—

 
3

—

—

 
45

1

1

   Total multifamily
 
83

5

1

 
134

6

2

 
331

10

4

Total single-family and multifamily
 

$41,309


$2,404


$191

 

$55,906


$2,918


$339

 

$57,958


$3,463


$315

(1)
Individually impaired loans with no allowance primarily represent those loans for which the collateral value is sufficiently in excess of the loan balance to result in recovery of the entire recorded investment if the property were foreclosed upon or otherwise subject to disposition.
(2)
Consists primarily of loans classified as TDRs.
(3)
Consists of income recognized during the period related to loans on non-accrual status.
Troubled Debt Restructurings
A modification to the contractual terms of a loan that results in granting a concession to a borrower experiencing financial difficulties is considered a TDR. A concession is deemed granted when, as a result of the restructuring, we do not expect to collect all amounts due, including interest accrued, at the original contractual interest rate. As appropriate, we also consider other qualitative factors in determining whether a concession is deemed granted, including whether the borrower's modified interest rate is consistent with that of a non-troubled borrower. We do not consider restructurings that result in an insignificant delay in payment to be a concession. We generally consider a delay in monthly amortizing payments of three months or less to be insignificant. A concession typically includes one or more of the following being granted to the borrower:
n
A trial period where the expected permanent modification will change our expectation of collecting all amounts due at the original contract rate;
n
A delay in payment that is more than insignificant;
n
A reduction in the contractual interest rate;
n
Interest forbearance for a period of time that is more than insignificant or forgiveness of accrued but uncollected interest amounts;
n
Principal forbearance that is more than insignificant; and
n
Discharge of the borrower's obligation in Chapter 7 bankruptcy.
The table below presents the volume of single-family and multifamily loans that were newly classified as TDRs during the years ended December 31, 2019, December 31, 2018, and December 31, 2017, based on the original product category of the loan before the loan was classified as a TDR. Loans classified as a TDR in one period may be subject to further action (such as a modification or remodification) in a subsequent period. In such cases, the subsequent action would not be reflected in the table below since the loan would already have been classified as a TDR.
Table 4.10 - TDR Activity
 
 
Year Ended December 31,
 
 
2019
 
2018
 
2017
(Dollars in millions)
 
Number of 
Loans
Post-TDR
Recorded
Investment
 
Number of 
Loans
Post-TDR
Recorded
Investment
 
Number of 
Loans
Post-TDR
Recorded
Investment
Single-family: (1)
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
20- and 30-year or more, amortizing fixed-rate
 
25,924


$4,331

 
43,742


$7,084

 
33,745


$4,818

15-year amortizing fixed-rate
 
3,018

296

 
5,944

584

 
4,569

356

Adjustable-rate
 
529

86

 
902

140

 
892

128

Alt-A, interest-only, and option ARM
 
1,523

219

 
2,602

432

 
2,784

495

Total single-family
 
30,994

4,932

 
53,190

8,240

 
41,990

5,797

Multifamily
 
—


$—

 
1


$15

 
1


$—

(1)
The pre-TDR recorded investment for single-family loans initially classified as TDR during the years ended December 31, 2019, December 31, 2018, and December 31, 2017 was $4.9 billion, $8.3 billion, and $5.8 billion, respectively.
The table below presents the volume of our TDR modifications that experienced payment defaults (i.e., loans that became two months delinquent or completed a loss event) during the applicable periods and had completed a modification during the year preceding the payment default. The table presents loans based on their original product category before modification and includes loans that were reclassified from held-for-investment to held-for-sale after TDR modifications.
Table 4.11 - Payment Defaults of Completed TDR Modifications
 
 
Year Ended December 31,
 
 
 
 
2019
 
2018
 
2017
(Dollars in millions)
 
Number of Loans
Post-TDR
Recorded
Investment
 
Number of Loans
Post-TDR
Recorded
Investment
 
Number of Loans
Post-TDR
Recorded
Investment
Single-family:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
20- and 30-year or more, amortizing fixed-rate
 
13,428


$1,702

 
13,548


$1,847

 
13,973


$2,231

15-year amortizing fixed-rate
 
451

36

 
565

44

 
720

57

Adjustable-rate
 
132

15

 
176

25

 
225

33

Alt-A, interest-only, and option ARM
 
871

129

 
1,178

199

 
1,254

253

Total single-family
 
14,882

1,882

 
15,467

2,115

 
16,172

2,574

Multifamily
 
—


$—

 
—


$—

 
—


$—


In addition to modifications, loans may be classified as TDRs as a result of other loss mitigation activities (i.e., repayment plans, forbearance agreements, or trial period modifications). During the years ended December 31, 2019, December 31, 2018, and December 31, 2017, 5,158, 8,488, and 7,090, respectively, of such loans (with a post-TDR recorded investment of $0.6 billion, $1.0 billion, and $0.9 billion, respectively) experienced a payment default within a year after the loss mitigation activity occurred.

Single-Family Loans
Impairment of a single-family loan having undergone a TDR is generally measured as the excess of our recorded investment in the loan over the present value of the expected future cash flows, discounted at the loan's effective interest rate for fixed-rate loans, or at the loan's effective interest rate prior to the restructuring for ARM loans. Our expectation of future cash flows incorporates, among other items, an estimated probability of default which is based on a number of market factors as well as the characteristics of the loan, such as past due status. Subsequent to the restructuring date, interest income is recognized at the modified interest rate, subject to our non-accrual policy as discussed in Interest Income above, with all other changes in the present value of expected future cash flows being recognized as a component of the provision for credit losses on our consolidated statements of comprehensive income. If we determine that foreclosure on the underlying collateral is probable, we measure impairment based upon the fair value of the collateral, as reduced by estimated disposition costs and adjusted for estimated proceeds from primary mortgage insurance and similar sources.
Of the single-family loan modifications that were classified as TDRs during 2019, 2018, and 2017 respectively:
n
9%, 12%, and 37% involved interest rate reductions and, in certain cases, term extensions;
n
23%, 24%, and 14% involved principal forbearance in addition to interest rate reductions and, in certain cases, term extensions;
n
The average term extension was 180, 132, and 176 months; and
n
The average interest rate reduction was 0.1%, 0.2%, and 0.6%.
Substantially all of our completed single-family loan modifications classified as a TDR during 2019 resulted in a modified loan with a fixed interest rate. However, many of these fixed-rate loans include provisions for the reduced interest rates to remain fixed for the first five years of the modification and then increase at a rate of up to one percent per year until the interest rate has been adjusted to the market rate that was in effect at the time of the modification.
Multifamily Loans
Multifamily impaired loans include TDRs, loans three monthly payments or more past due, and loans that are deemed impaired based on management judgment. Factors considered by management in determining whether a loan is impaired include the underlying property's operating performance as represented by its current DSCR, available credit enhancements, current LTV ratio, management of the underlying property, and the property's geographic location.
Multifamily loans are generally measured individually for impairment based on the fair value of the underlying collateral, as reduced by estimated disposition costs, as the repayment of these loans is generally provided from the cash flows of the underlying collateral and any associated credit enhancement. Except for cases of fraud and certain other types of borrower defaults, most multifamily loans are non-recourse to the borrower. As a result, the cash flows of the underlying property (including any associated credit enhancements) serve as the source of funds for repayment of the loan. Interest income recognition on multifamily impaired loans is subject to our non-accrual policy as discussed in Interest Income above.
The assessment as to whether a multifamily loan restructuring is considered a TDR contemplates the unique facts and circumstances of each loan. This assessment considers qualitative factors such as whether the borrower's modified interest rate is consistent with that of a non-troubled borrower having a similar credit profile at the time of modification. In certain cases, for maturing loans we may provide short-term loan extensions of up to one year with no changes to the effective borrowing rate. In other cases, we may make more significant modifications of terms for borrowers experiencing financial difficulty, such as reducing the interest rate, extending the maturity for longer than one year, providing principal forbearance, or some combination of these terms.
Loan Reclassifications
On January 1, 2017, we elected a new accounting policy for loan reclassifications from held-for-investment to held-for-sale. Under the new policy, when we reclassify (transfer) a loan from held-for-investment to held-for-sale, we charge off the entire difference between the loan's recorded investment and its fair value if the loan has a history of credit-related issues. If the charge-off amount exceeds the existing allowance for loan losses amount, an additional provision for credit losses is recorded. Any declines in loan fair value after the date of transfer will be recognized as a valuation allowance, with an offset recorded to investment gains (losses), net. This new policy election was applied prospectively, as it was not practical to apply it retrospectively.
The new policy election did not affect our net income; however, it affected where the loan reclassifications from held-for-investment to held-for-sale were recorded on our consolidated statements of comprehensive income. Prior to the policy change, upon a loan reclassification from held-for-investment to held-for-sale, we reversed the related allowance for loan losses to the benefit (provision) for credit losses, recorded a valuation allowance for any difference between the loan's recorded investment and its fair value to investment gains (losses). Under the new policy, benefit (provision) for credit losses is the only line item affected when a transfer occurs.
Non-Cash Investing and Financing Activities
During the years ended December 31, 2019, December 31, 2018, and December 31, 2017, we acquired $238.4 billion, $164.0 billion, and $229.2 billion, respectively, of loans held-for-investment in exchange for the issuance of debt securities of consolidated trusts in guarantor swap transactions. We received approximately $47.4 billion, $25.6 billion, and $35.9 billion of loans from sellers in guarantor swap transactions during the years ended December 31, 2019, December 31, 2018, and December 31, 2017, respectively, and $2.6 billion and $0.2 billion of loans from sellers in cash execution transactions during the years ended December 31, 2019 and December 31, 2018, respectively, to satisfy advances to lenders that were recorded in other assets on our consolidated balance sheets.
In addition, we acquired REO properties through foreclosure sales or by deed in lieu of foreclosure. These acquisitions represent non-cash transfers. During the years ended December 31, 2019, December 31, 2018, and December 31, 2017, we had transfers of $0.8 billion, $1.0 billion, and $1.1 billion, respectively, from loans to REO.